Lajpat v. Ashok Kumar And ORS
!
" #$% !"# $%&
' (! )* +, -!
*!
&
$&' ()$ * *)*)) '!
!
)-!(+#)
) !%#) !*&
!
*!$#) !*!&
...
)*)) + /* & ! 0 11! %
& ! !# 3! 3 % 4 & 2" * !
&& * !"# 3! $!
! !* 3 &
!5 6 *7!" 8!2 !
9 ) !* !:;*) ; 2"*!&
!
! % - *& !! -*
&!- )&& 2"*& !* 2 2"
*!
&&) * !"#3! % 4
<! !" ! % * ! * &
!5 6 *) 3 2"*!&
+ *& !! -* &!- * & !- 1&! *2 " !2 *&
9 * 3 1* *1!
0&"- !!! ! #2 1* 2
!
!2 &! "
=3& *!&
:)* +, -!
1 *!> ! *&!- !* 5 !2*3* 3 &*2 -& !7!
3! 5 !2*3 - 2 1 1&!
" -& !7!
3!3 !+ 1? !1
=3 !*!& *!&
:)* +, -! 1 &!- % * &!-
/* &!- 3!
&
*
3 - *2 *** &
!
3 = 3 !*! !! * *
3
!
3 * & !2 # 3* *5 !2*
7!*3
*!2 - &!-3! - 2"! #
!
3* /*2 13 2 &
#
5& & *
&!-3* % * * *3 2" !
* ! -& % !
6 4& 2"
*!
&& ) * !" * &!
1 3 &
!
' 3! 2"*&! & !3*+ ! &!- !" 2%
! 1*!- -! =3 ** &!-3!+ ! - 1 * * *! !&
6# @
* 2
!&
4
*&! &
)!* * 1 *#! 32 1& 7!*, -!
! 3
2 *& !;2" &"** A =3 **&! & !3 !!! ! !**&!- > 3! & #
!
* -
'! " *
3 3* 1*5 !2* )* +, -!33 !+ 1 !
-" !1" =
'! $- ? !1
! !# *
3!1 *3 *!* &3"! #3!
< *
&&!3 !! * &
*!* & 2 1!
!"3 !! =3#* #& *2 &! " *
A - *&
3&!" !
B 3 1 3!!- ! !
C**!*!&
2 2% *1!
- *& D''
C**!*& *& !! - 2 *&! !-D' C**!*& !*
*!
-! ! -* !D' C**!*& !*1
*&! !-D'
9
3 2"2 **&! &! *!!&
$!
! !
**& !3 !!! ! 7 3!#*& 3 3 *1!
&! 2 " *
3*2 1
> 2
)&& 2"* &! & 3 )&&) * !"#3! % 4
)11! *!! -#*! & *2
$!
!*& !*- "!1 *2 * *!
!2 3*1! "!! 3 1*& 2"
*!&
:
!5 6 *) B
1! !
1 * & ! ! - 2 &!!
&& *
=
* - "*!!! !E 0*!!
2 ! 3* *
* ! !#
*
1 * * &!
1 1 * : * * % * & +&
* ** & > * - **! *2! *!,* $
* *
3* !3**&! &!-#3 & !*!&
:
- *& = !*!!1 **!&
:
&&! ** ! 3* *
- ** *-"- * 2 !
1- 6 4& && ) * !"#3!*2 &!
"3*3 &! ** 2 1 > 3
B !*!- !#2 *
&!
5 !2* )* +, -!# &! #1 "-& " ? !1
C 1#) )
# !1"=
'!$- *2 A- 2"* & ! &! *- =!
"!1 **
;
! "2 1 11 -" !"22! - &! 2 "2 *&! *
!1 "
- -! /*! !# *! & * 2
*1!
$!
! * & ! !*! 2- * *
&! *2 1 2 &
!
= !1 ** **2 1 & &&1 - ""!
* 1 * & *"!@#- " * * *&!-!
"-
! !#!
33!
1"& !2 3 &
*!& !3* *3!&!
*&!
1> * % * & $!
!*& !! & *% *7 ;25 &!- ! ,-,),./,.-0,01-,
" % "
3%4
*% * ! $5),600,7 8 ,-9,0.-0,),
!"
% "
3% :#*0,),"7% 30-;<00) 8,-,30
"
% "
3%:4
3, ,8 *0,8),
" % "
3% 2= =#* #&!" **!
& 2 3
1- &
! !#3!3% 4 & 2"
*!
&& * !"#3!2 > "#&
! 5 6 * ) 2" *
: !&
2
$!
!*!&
&!
! 2-* 2 * * !
! 2 3 * !
! ! 2
1 % 2 &! &!&&! *
= 2- ** & !!
! % ! -
/* !3 !! " &&! &!!"#1" !
-! 1
= 2- ** *
3* * !0- 23 * 0*!! ! !#*& !:
*
& *** & > 3+ 2"*-! - 1 * &! !0 0 ! *&! !&
/*!!*3&" 1! 7!*, -! !&
* &! ! & #*! !#! *& *
23 *&!
2 &
=#1!
2- # 3 22"* *! 0*!!#3*
"* ! "
2% * = !*! 2- *& 3!-
2 !*!
! !3**!*
*
!
-! ! -* !
62 *-3 &! 2"*& /*! !#*& !
1*- *1 ! !#&! 2 " *
!"&!
)* +, -!'C635 !2*)C * !" & *!& B !*!- !#* &
*2 1!
! 1
"&!
=#* #&!" **& 2
7!
#!
!*&!
*1 *! 1* *! 3**!2
9 *& !*2 !
! *1!
&! 2 " *
*2 12
= & **&! * & !-&! 2 1 3* * *!* & % *
&!-3 !
! 2 *
1 *
6 4& && * !"#3!
! 9A 'FE /* * -" *, -!3
! 2% ! *1!
* *&!-3! !
! !* -
'* 1!&*+ 2")C65 % 3! "&!
/* &* 1!&*!*
* &!- )C@%, -!* 2 && $ -- ! *!!&!
1 ; 1 *
*;
6 4 & !9A )C@E2"%, -!#) "
&! * 3 =!& ! **!! ! + * !* 3#&! % *2 -1
< 1!& ! 2
@
) *!!& !)C4E2"*2 1A&!* 2
&! 2"' +*+!%? &)C4 )!1 *
*2 1#& " & *** & > *
#* # "
2"
!&!
)*33!!& ! * *!! 1* &1 * 3 5 *33
2"A
*# 1* 2 -+ &
3**&
1& 1*! $!
! !*!1*"* * !
2& !& !9A
C E 2- 2"
, -! 1& *2 1A&!A-
2"*
, -! 1& *!& !* 2! *** & > !
!"
!* -
/*! 1
&1#+1# ! +
*3! &2 + 1 *!*! ! = ! !** 3
, -! 1&3
!
3**&! !& !9A
') * ; 1 *! *, -!;
7 - * & "- *!!!& !**&!-! !" !*2
, -! 1& !*! - **
! +A *! ! *&!- ! A- *
A&!!***
& *&!- >
$!
!2 3*!1*" & "!
*!& ! ! !#!1*" 2! 2"2 **!
!2 3 * * & *-2 1 *1!
** &!-
) - "#2 ** * & !-&! *-2 /*! -! *!1 - ! 2* *& !*2-"2 "* *!* &
3* *-"2
/*! *
! 2 * !-
&! *2 !
* &!-& 2 / 11** &!- ! !* - !"
!!
&& *
!
B !*!- !#
2 *
!> ! 3 !*2 1 & &! **&!-!
'! 2 " *
"&! 2"
*
B-"- # "#23 * 0 3 !
* 3* "!1* 11
!
*& &
:
*!&
!5 6 *) * !" ** &!-!!> ! !
5 !2* )* +, -!
B !*!- !#
& * 5 !2* )* +, -!3 1&!
" -& !
*!
3! 2"C 12 33 !+ 1 !
-" !1"=
'!$- #? !1 #*-
2" !
"+
- *&! *
!
&! * ! !!
**&! 2
" *
- = !*!- **
*1 *&!- % * &!-
/* % &!-3! &
*
3
- *2 *** &
!
3 = !" *3 * &3 2!
!
5 !2*
7!*, -!3 !
*!!& 2 *!
/* - * % * &* 2 "-
! 2"*
/*! !#
2 **! "
- 2"*
*!& 3*- "!1
)*1#! *!
! !*
61 *
=
6 &! 1 >
- -! 2"
*
1 *& !3 3*& " 2! ** * &! * ! "
3 * )!1 - ! 2"!
!*& !** 3 &! " ! 1;* !
; &! * & !! -! 1*!1 -
#*
!%
9 *!3#&! *!**!
- !
-!&! * 2"*
3* *&! *-! - + 1% - *& !! -* &!-
= ! * * 7 ;2 5 &!- !
7;3, 3-;8 -1-,3 )837 -; 6,0,- *<0 " !
:% *4=2 3*A- 1* & ! % !
!! *& 3!
- ' !
1
&!!
&& *
! * 2 !! 3* =& " 2! * /*
! !A- *
2"* 71* ! ! % !
! * )
*
1 ! 2" * !E) * !"2 3
1 3
!
! - " !! ! 3 )
1 ! 2"
!E) * !" 2 3# &!! ! * 2 !! 3*
! *-!
! *
2
!-! 1 *
! 1! "!!
*# 3
#3 !
1! - !!1 % # & !! 2
!
1
1 3 = * #* 71* ! A!
! % !
!*
2 ! ) *2 * -& 1 !
!2 1 !&! &!
/*71* ! "* !! !1" !&! &!"
" ! !
!-& 1 2 !
2
7 3!# " *!1 !"# !! #1"
!&! &!" *-& 1 !* !
!#*71* !* A!
& 3! &&& 3! !&&! !!0*
! - 1 !
& 3!
2>
3**& 3! !
! >
! !&& $!
!*& ! 2 & "
1"#-&! &!" !!! ! 3 *-& 1 %
& 2" * !
! !# 3! 3 % 4 & 2" * !
&& * !"# 3!3* * ! " !!
A!
! % !
2"* !
*!!1 - *2 !
'! & #
1"#
"),% !"# ;7< ! C**!&+ 1E!
HE
C**!!& !2
HE