← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5965/2015dismissed

Ramesh Chander v. Aggarwal Sabha

2015-09-22Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih7 pages

  

      

!"# $#%&'&()

 

 !*#'++!($#, -#"&"&(#, .#,'/'

00!,1!23!4+! -#'5($#("  ) 6 7 3  77 ,#'#(") ,!&3&(0++!/+!(8 $9%!"#8

,"+#5#"&"&(#, :::

 ;+#"+#, ,#5,"#,'   2%!2 5!5#,' *!< 4# !221#$ " '##"+#=/$0*#(">

 4#,# #,,#$""+#,#5,"#,',("> 3 ? ;+#"+#, "+# =/$0*#(" '+/2$ 4# ,#5,"#$ &( "+# $&0#'"> :::

 77 ,!2 .&$# ,$#, 4#&(0 !''!&2#$8 $!"#$ @



A8 ,#($#,#$ 4< "+# #(" (",22#,8 !"+!(B"8 #9&%"&(  5#"&"&(#, +!$ '&(%# 4##( ,$#,#$ ( !%%/("   5#,'(!2 (#%#''&"< !($ !' +# +!$ #9#( %#!'#$ " %%/5< "+# $#*&'#$ 5,#*&'#' &# ! '+5 3&(%# #9#( !( !55#!2 5,# #,,#$ !0!&('" "+#'!&$,$#, !&2#$!($1!'$&'*&''#$9&$#=/$0*#("$!"#$

 @

8 "#(!(" &' 4# ,# "+&' %/," 9&$# "+&' ,#9&'&( 5#"&"&(

,&# 2<8"+#%!'#'#"/"&("+##9&%"&(5#"&"&(1!' "+!",#'5($#("2!($2,$&#"+# 00!,1!23!4+!8&'!3%&#"<8 ,#0&'"#,#$/($#,"+#3%&#"&#'#0&'",!"&( %"CC  , '+,"8E"+# %"6 ($"+#3!4+!+!$5/,%+!'#$!(&**9#!42#

  5,5#,"<8 9&$# '!2# $##$ $!"#$ A ? DA8 !($ "+# $#*&'#$ 5,#*&'#' 1!' ! 5!," "+#,#   #"&"&(#, 1!' &($/%"#$ !' "#(!("F ?

G5#,*("+!4/"?

<#!,'!0+#5,#*&'#' 1!'2#"/" ,,/((&(0"+#4/'&(#'' %!,5#(",<+#3!4+! +!' 4##( #(0!0#$ &( */2"&52# !%"&9&"&#' %(%#,(&(0 5/42&% 0$ ,## $&'5#('!,< 1!' 4#&(0 ,/( , 5,9&$&(0 *#$&%!2

!%&2&"&#'"!22"+#(##$<!($5,&("+#%&"< ,*!5,"&( "+#5,5#,"<1(#$4<"+#3!4+!3&(%#"+#!%%**$!"&(8 "+!" 1!' 4#&(0 /'#$ " %!,,< /" "+&' !%"&9&"<8 +!$ 4#%*# &('/

&%&#(" 1&"+ #

2/H   "&*#8 "+# $#*&'#$ 5,#*&'#' 1!' ,#I/&,#$ ' "+!" &" %/2$ 4# !*!20!*!"#$ 1&"+ "+# #H&'"&(0 !%%**$!"&( !2,#!$< &( %%/5!"&(   "+# ,#'5($#(" /,"+#,8"+#$#*&'#$5,#*&'#'1!'2<&(0%2'#$ ,<#!,'8!($ "+/'"+#"#(!("+!$%#!'#$"%%/5<"+#'!*# ( $# #(%#8 &" 1!' 52#!$#$8 &("#, !2&!8 "+!" "+# !22#0#$ (##$   "+# ,#'5($#(" 2!%B#$ 4(!

&$#'8 !' "+# #9&%"&( 5#"&"&( 1!' &2#$ =/'" " +!,!'' "+# 5#"&"&(#,  22 "+#, *!"#,&!2 !22#0!"&(' 1#,# $#(&#$ !($ "+# 5#"&"&(#, 5,!<#$ ,$&'*&''!2 "+##9&%"&(5#"&"&( ( ! $/# !($ %*5,#+#('&9# %('&$#,!"&(  *!""#, &( &''/# !($ "+# #9&$#(%# ( ,#%,$ 4"+ "+# !/"+,&"&#'%(%/,,#("2<%(%2/$#$"+!"%(%#$#$2<!(#2#%",&% %((#%"&( 1!' &('"!22#$ &( "+# 5,#*&'#' 4/" "+# #9&$#(%# 4,/0+" ( ,#%,$ 4< "+# ,#'5($#("8 !2(0 1&"+ "+#, $%/*#("!,< 5,    %('/*5"&( $!"! !($ '"!"#*#(" 

? 4&22'8'+1#$"+!""+#5,#*&'#',#*!&(#$%2'#$ ,!5#,&$ *,#"+!( /,*("+'1&"+/"!(<,#!'(!42#%!/'##(!(" !*#'+ +!($#, ;

 +!$ *!&("!&(#$ "+!" /,(&"/,# 1,B 1!''"&224#&(0%!,,&#$/"&("+#5,#*&'#' ($(# !(8"+,## "/4#2&0+"'8(#%2#,!($!%/""#, ,%/""&(0"+#1$1#,# &('"!22#$&("+#'+59#,<9!,&#"< 1$1!'4#&(0/'#$4< "+#5#"&"&(#,"*!B# /,(&"/,#1#9#,8"+#,#%,$'H  5,9#$"+!"%('/*5"&( #2#%",&%&"< ,*#4,/!,<

" !,%+

 1!' J#, (2< (# /(&" 1!' %('/*#$ &( !<

  ,* /2<

 " !,%+

?8 "+# %('/*5"&(  #(#,0<1!'!0!&(J#,(2<(#/(&"1!'%('/*#$&(!<

?!($"+#( ,* /2<

?"!<

8"+#%('/*5"&( 1!'!0!&(J#,(2<"+,##/(&"'1#,#%('/*#$&(9#*4#,

8 4/" ,* !(/!,<

 " 9#*4#,

%('/*5"&(   #(#,0< 1!' !0!&( J#,  (2< @ /(&"' 1#,# %('/*#$ ,* !(/!,<

@ " /(#

D !($ ,* !<

D " !,%+

8 "+# %('/*5"&(   #(#,0< 1!' (&2 ' "+##9&%"&(5#"&"&(1!' &2#$(





D8!($'&(%#"+#,# 1!'(%('/*5"&( #2#%",&%&"<%("&(//'2< ,!5#,&$

/,*("+'8!"!'",#"%+8&"%/2$("4#*!&("!&(#$"+!"!(< 1,B 1!' 4#&(0 %!,,&#$ /" &( "+# 5,#*&'#' 1&"+ "+# !&$  #2#%",&%&"<8 #2#%",&% !552&!(%#' !($ *!%+&(#,< ' ,#0!,$' 5#,'(!2 (#%#''&"<8 &" 1!' %(%2/$#$ "+!" "+# #9&$#(%# ( ,#%,$5,9#$"+!""+#$#*&'#$5,#*&'#'1!'&($##$,#I/&,#$ 4(!

&$#2< 4< "+# ,#'5($#(" , &"' /'# !($ %%/5!"&(

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

 ( ,#%,$ '+1#$ "+!" "+#,# 1#,# 9#,+#!$ +&0+"#('&( 1&,#' "+!" 1#,# +!(0&(0 9#, "+# '!&$ 2!($ +# 5'&"&( "+!" 1!' ,"& &#$ ,* "+# "#'"&*(<  !,&($#, 3!&(&8 ;?8 1+ 5,#5!,#$ "+# '&"# 52!( H  ('#I/#("2<8#=#%"*#(" "+#5#"&"&(#,1!',$#,#$ +!9#+#!,$2#!,(#$%/('#2 ,"+#5#"&"&(#,!($ 5#,/'#$"+#5!5#,4B

22 1+!" "+# 2#!,(#$%/('#2 , "+# 5#"&"&(#, +!' /,0#$&'"+!"2!($!$=!%#("""+#$#*&'#$5,#*&'#'8"+!"1!' 1(#$ !($ 5''#''#$ 4< "+# ,#'5($#("8 1!' 2<&(0 9!%!("

($ "+/'8 &  !" !228 "+# (##$   "+# ,#'5($#(" 1!' ' 0,!9# !($/,0#("8"+#'!*#%/2$4#*#"4</"&2&J&(0"+#'!&$5&#%#  2!($

 ( ! $/# !($ "+/0+"

/2 %('&$#,!"&(  *!""#,&(&''/#8!* "+#%('&$#,#$9&#1"+!""+#5#"&"&(&( +!($ &' 1+22< $#9&$   *#,&" !($ &'8 "+/'8 2&!42# " 4# $&'*&''#$ ,"+#,#!'('"+!"!,#4#&(0,#%,$#$+#,#&(! "#, #"&"&(#, !*#'+ +!($#, ;

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

',#0!,$'85#,'(!24(! &$#(##$K%(%#$#$2<8"+# ,#'5($#("2!($2,$ &# "+# 00!,1!2 3!4+!8 &' ! 3%&#"<8 ,#0&'"#,#$/($#,"+# %".&$#!'!2#$##$$!"#$ A ? DA8 ,#'5($#(" +!$ 5/,%+!'#$ !( &**9#!42# 5,5#,"< !($ "+# $#*&'#$5,#*&'#'1!'!5!,""+#,# +#'+5&(I/#'"&(&' 4/($#$ ( "+# (,"+#,( '&$# 4< "+# 4/&2$&(0  ,#'5($#(" 3!4+!8 ( "+# '/"+#,( '&$# 4< ! ,!$8 ( "+#

  #!'"#,('&$#4<!'",##"!($("+#1#'"#,('&$#8!0!&(84<"+# 5,5#,"< "+#3!4+!(%#$#$2<8!$&'5#('!,<&'4#&(0,/( 4< "+# 3!4+! ,* ! 5,"&(   "+# !

,#'!&$ 5,5#,"<8 " 5,9&$# ,##*#$&%!2 !%&2&"&#'"!22"+#(##$<!($5,&("+# %&"< +# %!'# '#" /" 4< "+# ,#'5($#("2!($2,$ &' "+!" "+# !%%**$!"&(&("+#&,5''#''&(89#,!5#,&$ "&*#8+!$ 4#%*#&('/

&%&#(""%!"#,"(/*4#, 5!"&#("'81+1#,# 9&'&"&(0 "+# $&'5#('!,< #9#,<$!< " !9!&2 "+# ,## *#$&%!2

!%&2&"&#'  ($8 "+# ,#'5($#(" #9#( &("#($#$ " '"!," ,## 5#,!"&(' , '/,0#,&#' #'5($#(" 2!($2,$ #H!*&(#$ &"' !(!0#,&# '+BL/*!, ;

81+$/2<5,9#$&"'%2!&* +# '&"# 52!( H 8 5,9#$ ( ,#%,$ 4< "+# $,!

"'*!(8 !=#'+L/*!, ;

,!"+#,,#9#!2#$"+!"!*!20!*!"&( "+# $#*&'#$5,#*&'#'1&"+"+#5,"&(&(1+&%+! ,##$&'5#('!,< 1!'!2,#!$<4#&(0,/(1!'"+#*'"9&!42#!($ #!'&42#5"&( !"+#,8'/00#'"&('5/"" '+BL/*!, ;

4<((#"+#, "+!("+#5#"&"&(#,&(+&'%,''#H!*&(!"&(5,9#$"+!""+# ,#'5($#("3!4+!1!'#(0!0#$&(*/2"&52#!%"&9&"&#''/%+!' %/2"/,!28'%&!2!($%+!,&"!42# ' ,"+#?A,*'"+!"1#,# &( %%/5!"&(   "+# 2!($2,$ &( "+# !$=&(&(0 4/&2$&(08 "+# '!*#1#,#4#&(02#("4<"+#3!4+!""+#&(+!4&"!("' "+# "1( ,5#, ,*&(0*!,,&!0#'!($"+#,%#,#*(&#'"+&(0 1!'4,/0+"(,#%,$"5,9#"+!""+#,#'5($#("1!'#&"+#, &( %%/5!"&(  !("+#, !%%**$!"&(, +!$ 9!%!"#$ !(< 1&"+/"!'/

&%&#("%!/'#&("+#'!*#2%!2/,4!(!,#!+#

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

8

 !=!(  ,/(!22&  /$0#