Gurdeep Singh v. Punjab And Sind Bank And ORS.








  
        
  



 

 



 !"!# $ %& '()

* +, 


     

 
 
 
 

 
-

$

 ./ - %

%0 

 



 



 
 
  


!" 

#
 

! $ 

#
 
 

$
$
#
 
 
  
 
 "
%%&'%%(
#
 )   
#
*  
   

""


 


+% +, -.., /

0
'--1
 



  
#
 
 
 
-.

+% -..2
/

0
'-31
$
 
"
#
 
 % 4
" 
#
 

#
  
#
 
 
   
 

 


6## 
7 


%8 +.

-.(2
 #


 
 


 ## 
 * 
$
-.8.


 $ 
 " 

 
 7 

 
 
#


 

 
/

0





'-1



 


"$
 
$

#
*  

  
) "
 " 
)

 

 : 3


 
 "



# 
$
 
)

  $ " 

; 

 
)

 
#


$
 




 "
%%
#
 
) "
 " 
)

 
 "

#""

 "



# <7
=> 
?


"
; 



# 

)) 

)6
#
 
 
 
#


# "




#
##  "
"
$
"
***
"

  

/ 
##  "

"
***


 

" 
$
"
"

 
##

"1 *

#
 " 
  "

$

"

## 

"
*
 
** 
?

#


# "

 







 
 
  ""$
#

) #
 " 
6## 
/# <
@


?
A 
& .-1

""
  
#
7 "  
#
))
 
$
?

 

 
 $
#
4 
 

"
"
$ 
)

 


"



"
# 
" 
 ""$
""
  
#
7 "  #
) #
 " 
6## B
 


#
"
*
 
** ##  "

; 




 
)?
 

# ?  , ; "$

 
9
#
*  


  

%- +( -.82


0
 <7 = "$







 

  



 


## 


  "

$
 $

 
 
#
 
) "
 " 
)

 

> 


# 

"

#
 
))')6








#
7 " 
 
)

 
 
  

 

  

D
""
 

  #


"

#
 
))')6

 



 
  "

$
   



 

  



 "


" 
 
>" #
 
@
#
" 
> 
$ #
  

"  
"
D
""
 
 
 
   
 
 
#
 
))
 "

 #  0
 
 
  
#
 
)

   $
*
$
  
 
  
#
 
 "$




"

; 
## 


"
#

"
# " $

#
 
""
  $
 
 
  
# 


"
  "

$
  $
"
  

"  '

7 
#
 
 
#
 
))
 


"

))B

"

!

"$
 "
 

  

 
 
## 

$
 
#
  " 
> 
 
#
 
?

"
$
"
   "
$
#
 
?

"




 )6

$
 
"$ 
 
#
"$
 
$
 

 
 
 
/

0
'-1

 
: %


 # 





#

 
) #
 " 
6## 
#
 
 




  
 
;
  "
#  

#
 : %


  "

$
  $
 
#

# 



#




( & -..+
/

0
'%1
 


 
    
 



-& -- -..+
/

0
',1


"

$ ; $


 
$
 
) #
 " 
6## 
#
 

 " ? 
#
 
 

@ 
 "
$
#
 ; $
 

" 

 

 $
 
 
 
 
#






 
 





"$
# "

"$

>   
#
 

 
" 
#
 
 " 
#
 
 
 
#









" 


"


 

 
#
$
" @ 

 
 



 
 
E ; $
6## 


-3 +, -..-

#



#
 
#
 

  

"

 

 



 
   


-& +, -..-
/

0
'31

 > 
E ; $
6## 
 
 ; $




 " 

#
$
"

 "  
2
3
&
-+.

-+&/ 1
--
-%
-,
-&
-(

%-
%-

#
 
"
&
#
 
 
 
 
 
6## 
E "$ ?  "


 
"
 " 
-.8-
/#
 
= 
 "  C1

> ; $
6## 
0


  


  

" 
# 
 
 











# $
 
  


""$



 
0


$
 ; $
6## 
 
E ; $
6## 
 


/

0 '&1


"

,

 
/

0
'-+1

"



( -% -..% ( > ; $


 

 
) #
 " 
6## 



% 
 

 '

  

 
#

   
#

 "
%%

 "


@  
$
#
 
   '

  



 
   
 

 



$
 $

 

 
 

 "$

    

  
#
 
 





% , -..,





/

0
'--1

> 
"

"
  
"


"  
#
  


 


0
'-3





  "


0
'--
"$

 









F "



 


   "

$
  $
"
"  

 
7 
 -& , -..-
/

0
'31
 

( -% -..%
/

0
'-+1
#

; $

"
 
#
  "


 
 


-8 , -..,
/

0
'-%1
#
 7 
 
 
 # "

"


$
#
 
 

$
) #
 " )

  ') #
 " 
6## 
 
"
 
 
" 

$ 
E ; $
6## 









# ; $



" 


> 
 
  
 


%.

, -..,
/

0
'-,1
 # 
"
 
 

0
'-3

$
 
: ,

.

> 




 ""


$
    "$
  
/ 1 
 
$ 
" 
#
  " 


0

5
/ 1
 
 
 
$ 
" 
#  


" 
 5
/ 1
 
 
 

 #
 ; $
## 


" 
 5
/ 1
 
# 
 






5
/1
 
 '

  
#
 
 " ? 



" 5
/ 1
 
 "
$
#
"

$ ; $




" 5
/ 1
 
 ; $
## 
"   
0 
 "
$ 

$
 $
$





; $



 



 
 5
/ 1
 
   "

$
  $
"



 
 



#


 ; $

 "5
/ 01
 
 
  "

$   $







"" "$
"

 
 
#
 
#
 - ++
)5
/01
 
#


  
 
 
  "

$   $

# 
 
 "$
#
 
""   
#

; $
## 

# 


 "$
G


   -+ * 
 
"$
 7 
 
"

$   
 
;
 $



 

#

"#




#
 ; $
 
E ; $
6## 

  
 "
 ; $

 
 
 "  


  
> 




  
 

#
 7  

 $
## 
#
 
 
 
 



""  
#
" # 

 
  

* 
 
#
 $
""  
#


 
" "

#
# 
$
 
)



 
 
$
 
  
  $
> 
 
   
 
 "
%%&'

%%(
#
 
)   
#
*  


0 

# 
 


 

"
$
 



""
  $ > ; $

 

 
 
 " 
*


# 
)

 
 
;$
#
  
"




# ; $
> 


; 
#


 
#
) "
 " )

 

 


"7**
6## 
 


#
## 


"7*
 
"7** 
 

 $

> 



 

 
 
#

#
 
) "
 "

)

  '
) #
 " 
6## 



 "$
 
 
# " 
#
 

#
E ; $
6##  
"
 
 "$
# 
"""
 

-- "
"$

  
*

"

 "#
#
  7 
 

 

 

-% +.

-.8.
/

0 '-1


 "$

 " 
6## 
 

 "  
 "



$

6 "$
#
#


 
$
  " 
6## 
 
""
 
#



  
 


; $



" 

    



 ; $


> 
  
  
$
 
 ""

 
 "

 

E0  7H*** 

; $
> 

"
 
  



 
 
 

#
 
""   
"""
 



  
" 
#
 
 
 

" 

    
$
 


6## 



 ; $


  "

$
 ; $

"

%8 +- -..-
 
" 
#
 
 

" 
$
 


6## 
 
"
 -3 +, -..-
/

0
'21
 
  
 
 

"$
 " 

 

 





 "
 '  


 ; $


#

;  @  "
 $



 
#

0


 
 
 




> 
% 
 
  #
) #
 " 
6## 
#
 
 

 $

 
 



 
  "

$
  $
@  ; $



 

 
) #
 " 
6## 
#
 
 
"

 
  "$ 
 
 
  
#
 
  "

$
  $ 
 $



" 
 
 
  
 
$
    

" -% A 
 
 "
#
 
  

 




 $

#



 
 
E ; $
6## 
  
 
#


 

 
 




 ""
 
  "

$
  $
"
"

"  
 
 
 ; $ 
 

$
I  !  
 
?
%& -- -..%








0
'-- $
 

   #
  -, A 
 
 "
#
 
# 
   

 $
#
 
"" 

 

( & -..+ /

0
'%1



 
 



  "







; $



 
E ; $ 6## 


 # 
#



 
##

 ""


?  "

$

  $

  
 "

 

0
'--

   

 
 




 "$
 $ 
 

E
#
 



 






 
 

#

"
"

E ?  "

$
  $





0
'--

 
 


"


 
 

"

" "$


 
 7 


-2 "
 

# 
 

" 
 
 "

 

 

#  


 7


; $




""

:

" 
#
 
 
 

 " 

 
"


 
 


  
# 7 
"



 


 
"  #
 
 
 

" 


; $


"$

 
 "







( & -..+
 ; $




#
%8 , -..-



-3 

"  

"


 
   
#
 )

1!

# %!#21 3" %



4#5 (

#6  1)"* +,,7 89 %
  +7:;

#!# 

#6!

#6  1)"

3" %4"1!< 04'

) = "1!"1

#6

# 1)* +, 89 %
 77 -& A 
 
 "
# 
 
 
 
 
$
 
?  "

$
  $
 ""
  $





 



 
 

" "


7 
6 
"  

"




#
@ J"
0
)

)>?

!"1)!"

3  / 6 3" #!# 

#6!

* +,, 8@9 %

+7
 


 #
)7 



#
 
)


0 )'

3!

3" 4#5 (

!# <  #A

#6  1)"* +, 89 %
 +:;

%!#21 3"  )?

#

/ #6  < '

!#

#6 3<&'#

)&)

!# / 6

#6  1)"* +, 89 %
  ++;

%'

 % # "1 % !#!

3" %



 )?

#

#6  1)"* +,:

89 %
  7,;

')!A %!#21 3" %



4#5 (

#6  1)"* +, 8@9 %
  ,:;

 3!#6)  < %!#21 3" %



4#5 (

#6  1)"* +, 89 %
  +  -( * 
 
 
   

 "$






 
 7 
 "$




 
"
 
   "

$




 
 
 ; $



 

 


 

7 
 


"



 

"
 



 
 "



   
 
?  "

$
  $


 



 $

 

 
$
 
E ; $
6## 

 ; $ 






 

 

"
"
   "
#
"
 

 

#




$
 ?  "

$
  $

" "


7 


-8 "
 

#
" 
 
 "
#
  
 
 
?  "

$
  $




 

#
)6 
"
" 
 
 
#
)6


$
#
 
 
'  

" 






 




6 

"  

"
 



 #
@ J"
0
)

)!#

<  #A 

'')

#6  1)"

3" %% %1A #6

#6

# 1)* +,8+9 %
+,;

%

 #A 

#6!

3" 
 22 )B <* @   8%
9 7;

) %1!3 )  )5 2!

3" %?#6!

 #A  

! * - #!& <

#6

# 1)*    8%
9 :,7 -.

"
 

 
 
" 
 "
#
  
  

 

 
)6

 "




 
 

 " 
 
)6







 
 
 


; 


 
 
 







 

#






)6

6 

"  

"
 



#
@ J"  
)

) %1!3 )  )5 2!

=" %?#6!

 #A  

! * - #!& <

#6

# 1)*

89 @ %

+;

%

 #A 

#6!

#6  1)"

=" % ?

<*

8+,, 9

%

+

#6 %

 #A 

#6!

#6  1)"

=" !6?4

04'

) -!

)

#6  1)"*

8+,9 + %

@ E
  
"


#
 

 $
#

 ; $ 






 
  
  
 


  $

  "


 
#
 

#  
 
#

#


"
" 

$
@ J"  
)

-* 
/ =  )4# )*

@ 89 %

7+7 %+


 

 7"$
#
" 
#
 
 
  

" 
 "
#
 7 
  
  
" 
#
 


#
" 

 


; $



"#
 


 " 
-2
 
  "

"" 
$
 
E ; $
6## 


"
$
 


>  $ 
 




 
 
 



  "

$





" "


7 

6 


"  

"

 



#

)7 



#
 
)

0 !

=" %



4#5 (*

89 %/ @:@

#6

 #A 

#6!

=" )"!6!#2 

! )

#6  1)"*

+,,8+9

/ @+ %-


 

 
""



 


$
 ?  "

$
  $
 ""
  $
 








$
 
   
#
"$

 
  



  
 
 



;  
#
"
 
 





   
 "



 "



"



#


6 

"  

"
 



# @ J"
0
)

#) < - # 2) 89* 4#5 ( %!#6  #A

#6  1)"

="  ?

%!#21* +,,89 %

+@@ %% >
 "

" 
 "
#
 
   
#
 

 
 7


  
#
 

  "







  

 



"
 
 



 
)



 


 
# #


$
"


#


#
 
E ; $
6## 

6 


"  

"
 
  
#
@ J"
0
)

%

)!

=" #!# 

#6!

#6

# 1)*

8+,@9  %

,+ %, @

  
 
   

$
" 
 "

#
 
 
 
 "
#
 
 
)

#
 
    
 

 




 
 

-8
 " #
""   

""

> 
E ; $
6## 
 

 "
7  ; $

4
# " $
#
# 7 
#

' " 

 

$
 
E ; $
6## 

 

#""

<7 <<2

!#


1 )2B!"

# <4"!# 

#D4!)?



! ) - = 
#""$
C % =

4 



"  
 
 


 
 #  

*

"

#  
#
F
 


 
 ""


 
  "




" 
 







 "$ 
  
#
 
   
0 

  



  C
 , 4 




 
;
##




$
 
)6


 
"  " $
#
 
$






> 
 
$

"



$
 

# )6


"#
 

#
#


 
  
#
 
$
$
 
)6 2
/ > 
 
  
#
 - 3
"



"$
#




$

 
 ""
: -+,

%3 -+ 88
#  &+,3(-'7
> 

   

"$




#
 


 
=  "
   C


 
 
  "

   
 
'

E0
 '

 
*  
A & @ 



"

  "
;   

 " 

# 
  
#
6

? (


 
$
F
 





 %% .%
/ 
-%1 
 




 
 
#""

##





 
  > 
)6


"#
 
 
= 
 

 $
#
  
 
#
 

A

  "

 
$

 

 4&  ,, < " .

> 
 

 
 ""


 <
=>  

8&
"
>

A 

# 
" C
*





 
 
# 


0 

 
 
 
#

#
"


  
$
 
 


 
0  
#
 

I
$

 

"  
 
 
 


0 

-+ E0

 

""
$
*
 
"

 
#""$
 
 


 
$
 
$
 



 



#
 
 
# 
"

-- > 
 


#

  $

"

#


  
#


   ""
/F1

  
 
 


%( % 8.

-% > 
 
 
 



#
 
$

   -, 4 
  
#
 
)6 
 




#""$

 
 
   
 
A)

  "
 

#
 
 

 -2 *

 ## "

  

 
  
#


@  A 
"
 
 
#

   " $
#   
 
  " $ 




#
 ""  

"
 -3 4 
 
?EH
HH***
/

0
HHHH
/-7%81
 
 
 

 

 

# 
""  


 -& > 
)6
 "
   
  

* ?

) " --.(





-( 
 
"
#
 "
 
  
 

#
 
)6




 
 
""  
 
 -8 > 
 

 
 
 
 # 4 
 
EH
HH**'-7-(
 
HHH*
 
#   
#
F


 
 ""


""   
"


#""$  %2 > 
?  "

$
  $
"
"

"  
 
 #
 
E ; $
6## 



 <7 = 4 
 
#


#
* ; 

  $




 
#
 
  

#


)6
  
$
 "
 $

 
 # 



*
$

 
#


#
 
* ; 

  $

""
""   



 

""" 



"

, -

, ,
 
, 2
#
 

  
6## 
E "$

/) 1
 "  
-.8-
 

#
 

"$
0


  

 $ #
 

 "
# 

" "$
"
#




6 

 
 
 

 


-& , -..- 
( -% -..%

*

#
 
  
  


#
?  "
G

 ""


 ;" #  
# #
 "$ 
 ""

 
#
 




*

$

 







"

2/ 1
#  

 

 
 
6## 
E "$

/?  "


"1
 "  
-.8-



 


 
/9'1 %3 *#
 

#
E ; $
6## 

 
   


?  "

$
  $

 

  
 
"$



; 

 
 


> 
 
 
 ""
 ?  "

$
  $


  


 

#
 
E ; $
6## 


 

#
#
 ; $

 














 
 
?  "

$
  $
"
#

 ## 
 

 
#



 "



 

 





   

@  
#
 
  

0 
 
 ?  "

$
  $




"
"$

 

# ; $
6## 


"$

#
#
 

 ""
 
#



 
 


 







#
  "




0
# 
?  "

$

  $
"






0
'-- %& *  "

"


  "

$




# @ J"
0
)


 )4# )."

"

8"4&)
 
@ J"

0
)


 




 <7 => 
"
#
 
# 
  
"

 
   "
#
"
 





 " 
( /%1 

"
 #

 
  "

$
  $   
 ; $
  $
 $
 "
#

#




#





 

  
 
#

   
 


 
"

; 
## 

 $

 
#
 

#

> 

#
 ; $
## 
 


#


""



 $
 
"

; 
##  ""


 $


 
  "

$
  $ 

 
#"
 " 
#
 ; $
## 
>   "
#
"
 



"$


; 
 
  $





# "
   




 "$



 $

 
## 
 #
 

# "

  
#
 
  "

$   $


#


 
# 
  
##  K





%( *  "


#
@ J"
0
)

4#5 (

!# <  #A =" 04#5 1 )!

-!") *

 8@9 %
@@  "
  
"

$
@ J"
?   


#
 
)


#!# 

#6!

#6  1)"

="  ?

# #6  #6)

#6

# 1)*

+,8@9 %/ 77

#6 4)'< %!#21 ="
# ) < 6'!#!"

)

!3

)!(4# <*
1 #6!2 )1 # 1

#6  1)"*

+,8+9 %
+ %8 >


#
#
 


)

#
  
 
 

 


 


  #
 




 


?  "

$

  $


 

#
 
E ; $
6## 
$
 

#



#"



9 "
 # 

#

 

"""
 

 "$




 " L


@



 
#





; $

6



 "
 


$
 
)7 


#
 
)

2!#6) %!#21 ="

(!#6 4)

&)

!3 2)! 4< 4) < %)3!

% !

?

/ 6

#6  1)"*

+,89 / @

#6  26!"1 04'

)* ""!"

#

6 %4&&<!"



! ) =" %



4#5 (*

8 9 %/ 7 %.


#  
 ; $








"$

" 
#
 
 
" 
#
 
  "$

" 

 
"


 "
#


 
## "$
# 


 


 

$
@ J"
?   



#
 
)


1!

# %!#21

#6 %4"1!< 04'

) = "1!"1 ."

""

8"4&)



$
 

#
 7 






#
" 
#
 
 
" 
#
 
"


0"  
 '

7 
 
7#

#


" 


 " 
#   "
#
"
  ,+

"$ 



#
)6


 
 
 


" 



*  "


# @
J"
0
)



%% %1A #6."

"

8"4&) 
@ J"
0 )


 <7 =-(

*

; 
 "

$
 
 
 


 
 


  



  "$


"
 







#
  
#
 
))


 
 
 





 
 
))






$
 
# 
  #
 




 





#

 
#
*  
/1 $
 
 
?  "

$
  $




#



 



  



 
#

))




"


 
 
 
   "

 "




#
 
   


F






 ""



  ## "

"

 
  

 
   



 


$
 "



    


 

 "$



 


*
 
#
 





# ?  "

$
  $7 7 "
 
/1   
#
 
 
"



  

  
 





#
: 
  !
/1
 

 
#
*  
/1
"$
 ;  


  

#
#
 

""


 


# 
 
 


$ 
"


#
 



#
 
@





)
#

 



""


   ,- *  "
 


$
@ J"
0
)


 22 )B <."

"

8"4&)

#6

) %1!3 )  )5 2!."

"

8"4&)





$
@ J"
0
)
 

#
 
#
)6')) 


 
$
#
 
 

; 


" 

 "

; 
## 

' 


 
 
"


 7 




 
"
 


 

#

)6


 

 
"
#
 
   

 6  


 

#
  "
#
"
 
 
""


 "

# 
 
 
#
  "

$



 
 
#    


; 


" 

 
"

; 
##  "
 ""
 
  "

$
  $




 
 
#
 "



" 


,% :"

  
 
?  "

$
  $


""
  $


; 

"$
  
  


 
"


  
 "
 ""

#
 
 "$




/1


"


#
 

  

 
?  "

$
  $ 
""

 ""
  $


7


 
 


#"
 




#
"  
#
  


 ; $


 
 
 

#
 

0

#
"
"

"


7

#
# 
  

 ""
 
?  "

$
  $
 


 $ 




#
 ; $


 









/

0
'--1
$
 
   

  
 

"

""
  $
  

"

,, > 
)
"
  
 


 
 
?  "

$
  $

 
E ; $
6## 





 ; $ # 
# 



#





 
 
#
  
  "

$




 
"

7

( & -..+ /

0
'%1
 
 




#
  "




% , -..,
/

0
'--1



" 


 
 
#


 
 


 
 
"
  "

 ;  "
 # 
 



"
#
;

#




 ,2 *
 
#
 
 
 
 
  


 





0
'--
 
'-3

7 

>    
 ""


  "

 ;  "
 # 
 

#

8%0 

 %& '() *

+, 

   


' M
< D
 
"M < D