High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/3093/2019allowed

Tanuj Sharma v. State Of Punjab And Another

2022-07-27Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur8 pages

"#" $% & '(( !

#"#"

)* "

+ ++,

!"#$ % &&

"&'

(!)! *

" &!"#$ % $+ ( &

,,,, ++,

/*0 -

& &&

*%&("%.&/0 &/% 1123%14 41-3!/&" (&$ &&#&& 6!&&$

(&$ ++&& 7"

& ! $&&/ & %%$! " $&2-8!241!296!293!29:!23-!-41;%

<= ;4> (/ '& $0 "*0 $"&/! &&/ %+!0

&&'

#&/ "&

/'&

( " $ ! 7"

& %+ / 4116 * ?4119 *$ +(&#"& *#$

$&?!1-

'#!"&/

% &#&/

/!& * .< >!

" $&" ( % -2!81!111@;! &" ! "!! (&/ !& $%( "@ (!+ &/4860

"!($ "& %#&(( /

(! &( "&&$7"

'#!&'

*0(?"$"

/ ! /&"""%

$#?

$! !*$ +=$"& $% &&+/ /"( "!

*? #" %& +$ !! &/ *$ + &+ "! "@! &&/ ! !#" /&"""% $#?

$!'%/"! "!% *&$ "

$0$! %%$ % '

0& *( +/ /! + "! "@! $+% &&( "! !*$ + +/ /"'& * .< >!*? *'< >!& ((?% &/ (&B & % +/ /" +?! * . < >! $$$% &"% (% ?+%( & ((+ ?+!

/ $ +! "! (% /" (@( "! *$+% "! "@! *#$<>*$+&/ + *(%

" & *? * . $$"

%! && *$ + /&" (&$ &&#&& 6!&&$ (&$ ++&& 7"

& ! "! &*$ +$&"%%$"$&2-8!

241!296!293!29:!23-!-41;%

/ +% &&!"%&/!& && ! * & &$( & *$ + "! & % = $"$ &/! $$& %%$$ *&(&? ++& % * .< >! "! %! & +*$ + """! ! $$"

!%&("*? (&$%%&$!*% ( " $$"

CC .7&+&"

#&/ & % ++& " <-4-5 146> +% '

(&/ @ ) &D

&"A '@ (&/

%$&" #+*-8!4116 %$& +*41!41-4 % &/ +*43!41-4 ? % "

&/ "/?

+% '

(&/ @ ) &D

&"A '@ (&/

+&#(#"

45!65!42-@; +*41!41-4 - -- EE EEEEEEE -4

&$& "&/ -4!82!536@; "

-5

$+ %& "@ " $"?

&/& (%&( # &( *( " %(('&/"$+

# &( *(

- &/& ( " + * "&% ? -884;85!-883;-88:

"4114;15

&/& (

&/& ( (""* &/ -:598" 44@--@4116&% # % &"A

( /+ #&/ &"A -2

&(%

&&$ % ( $

F $+

" (&"%( % 1( .

% ( $

$*4-!4116

(&$ '

&% @

/&&/%( -4 ? %&+'

&+ % $&/% "*(!* (( * &/$ '

#&/* .&/( & & '& .%"& "+ & &" $ $$

$ '

$&"#+*13!4116% + % -2 81( .

&*+++" -3@--@4116% -2 81( .

&&/"

*? ?&"! &

/ G-1-518 "

+ ! G-14151

?+'

&$ " ?+' % $+&/ '

"$( " $*1-!

411:

-6

$" ( 7 *#" "&/ $&!

&*+ % %(('; ("&$& &/"*?

( &/ & & % @

/&&/%( --? '# *+&"

*?"D$+ ?"

"#+*6!4116

(/ & && *#$+ ?%+( 6 + <

(& '

"&%-1 ? >

(&$

( . 7% -( $%+ . "

(&"% 7&

$"& &&@ $.$"'

* &"

7 '

* &"& %&(

$ %

/&&/ # &( *(%( ?

*&/"*? (&/ &

% (&/ '

/ &# '#

+ "&

&%+"

#&/#&%&" %+$+ =" +C ((?H " "#&"

?&""&* %&(

I?'

&"*? & &/( & % ""&$ & (% %&+ (/'& 0&

&%&" ( &/*& *&(&?%( --? "% = ( & ""&& "$(&% "%+ + +&%+ + & '#! (% (&%"* * $ % %&+%J4116 ' $+ $?$(+ % $ +

+ '

*&//&""*? &%'/%( & '

"&/(#'& &% % $&(&?

-9

$" ( 7 *#"% &"

? &? (&. "#$ ! ( $" /$?@ =$&#

1 -3

&( % %

7/ && * &"&% ?

&( $

(&"&$ '

$( '

/&#

$&%&$ *# & ' &"&$ "

( &( '

/&#

-8

("/" '&

(&$@ ?*("/"*? * .

$#? $& . + "&$

*&"4- -1

+&&'

$&#"-3@18@41-1

(& $+ '

$ $ *( $& '

&&& "D+ "&$&"4-@14@4118

"" # %$+ /$? &#&/ & D %$+ +&&$&#"-3 41-1* % $&'

.*? /$?

%&$&$?

& %& #&$ $ &$ ( *+&"*? & &" & < &$ &$D /&>

/&# .$ ?

(" %%&$& (#&%? (+* *% &&/ $

7/ ( /&#*? & ? "

!"#$ <

) D

>" $ ' & % (( ?F&

*'"

*? '%+

-5?

" *"

&% ?

$+#&%&$ & !/&#*? /$? ?

/&# &&# ! "$+ *+&" *? *'! '# #&%&$ & % "$+#&B* $ ! ! . +"& +*41-4*? &# // D 'K/ &#K'

$( (?&"&$

"$+*+&" &+% $& ' %/" " /$? '

"&$(?@&"&$(?&#(#"& ((/"% "

% "( ?

& &/!&% ?

$& "

<$#?@ (/

$& "> - *("/" (&$ "$;

(&$

&#&(&*%&("

%% $$ *&(&?

$++ '&

" + % %%&$ "

? &?

• ( *#" "&/ $ % $& "

"&*+ " ( -6F/(?&"&$ %%&#(#+& &/ % "

$#&$& '& '

0& % $&&/ &? '

""" " &$ & $& +'&

?"$+ ? # ($%&+ = #&'

%(('&/%%&$K&#(#"& "&*+" *% *"

+ < G-14151> • (%$ &$ ( /$? @ & &" & < &$ &$D /&>& ("*%( "' ("";

( # ( "'&&&% ( / "&/ & ((/" &#(#+ & & % % "

$++&"&&+&( $

• (% "$+#&%&$ & /$? ?A

D & &$& " &&#(#+& % "

$ *("

&&'("*$+ #"!%+&$( & (?'

"!.'("/& $% .% (""!

2 #&('

%! /+?*$ +( "! ( ! *'< > &&'

$&&/ &?! "!

&.'("/0 *#*$+ "!(

&& ((?! "! '&((%((? " " %+ (# +! "!

/&"(& &&/ $&&/<>%( ! "@&%

"#&"(?

" & ("&/.'("/ * &+&$&+& ?% $! &&/ .% /&"""%$#?

$! $&"! ! $(" *$+ $ *( * (/ '&

$$"$$"!

&/ ((?&$( *(

"+&&/ *#% $! "&/% (?%& "

&&!*

(%% " -!+ ."&$(0 & *&/

'& *#= $"$ &/! !$ &"& %% $$ *&(&? ++& '# ? " "$! ! % %%$$ *&(&? ++& !%"+&&/ # $&?0 " '&/%&$( ? $&! &&!

'("*$+ ((? & ! $ &/ & % ((&" $% '&

$!% &&! $&( *'$$"! !% & %!

!.'("/ * &+&$&+& ?% $ < >! (

" ? ((? &$( *( '& *'$$"

% &/&/* %&" &&!&

& $&&/ ! *'$$"!%+ % $+

"(&"! % # ( $$"! "!

(

" (&"! /&" "" % $#?

$! *$ +

""'& "$+$$"!*&"

"(&"! &/ "&/! + " %&(*?%%&$@%%&$& (*"&

&+ *#(& $! &/ "&/! !+ "*? %%&$*"& &+! $"%&(*? +!$ *#&(?*$+$"*'& $&#+ %&"! ! !

%%&$@%%&$& (*"& &&!'("" &! $ "& < >!+ .&/ "'&((%(" %+ ( &&/ = +& &! "! $ &+0 # $&?

% "$+<>$$"! $'("&+ +&&*(?*$+ #"

%+&$( &

#! %%&$ +$

&+ &&/ $&&/%( &0&""/ 0&&* $ &$ $! '

*$+ + "! *? %%&$@%%&$& ( $ *"& $&&/ &?

&$ ? (0&"*

$&/'& +""&$ " &*&(&?! %! $&&/

&?! $ * +" ? "&*(&#&/ +! ( & &/ "&/ %&($$"! ((/"! "! ( # *%/"! "!% *&$ "

&$ *# &*&<> + "!

&&!$ * +"

&/ ? ((?

&$( *( '& $$"$$"

-1

*# $%*(&%! "!(& $*&/+"*? $&&/ &?! &/ "&/! + " %&( $$"! *? & %%&$@%%&$& ( *"& &+! *#&(? $&&/ &?&*$"!* $&/* %&"(?! "! + %&"(?!(%;$#&"$/% !& &%&$ &0

# " &! (#

! $&&/ &? ("&/ .'("/! * % . % ( ""! & $ '

% +/ /( *$+ $$""! &* &/&+&" *# $0&"

.'("/0 &+ &$&+& ?% $

*#/ "! =&#&"$!* *# = $" $ &/! ! ? + " & && *? %% $$ *&(&? ++& ! '#! *# $ &/ $+ ((?&%&+! "!"$ & !&+ ?$"$ < >*$+$+ &"& $+

! *# $ &/!"( &% . &&/ &+

&$&+& ?% $( .'("/& $ %*&/ $0&"!

*? &&!*'

?( (? $++$& ( *&(&?% *&% *'K%&+ %!

*#= $"$ &/! &%&+! '

$&" & $.& "!% *'&/%&+!*'

$&" ?+&"& ((/""& " (""

0(?!'

(&B &% /"+?'

*+ "%+ /"

?!% *'!'

* $(""! /

% .!% /&"""%$#?

$! $ &/& < >! &&/ *&(&?%*&!% *'&/%&+ *&/"*#&%&"*? &&! $" ("

?$0$

-4

%! *#+ "&$( ?$ &/! %%&$& $ = & !$$("

?" ! &+! #&;

;#& & + & $ * &"

4 && (" ?.'("/! * .% (""!& $% ?+&" &! /( '

$$"" *'

-5

#!&#*$ +$+*"! $&&/

&?!#&%? $$% (""! / &#&&&/ ('% $$"! "!*#&(?'

" .'("/ * .% (""$$"! "!'

& *$ +&$+* &&!#&& (0

&$$"!

% (# 0(! "! & "(? '

" .'("/!

! * . % (""

$$"!

"* %&"(? $"! &/ "

&/! + "*?%%&$@%%&$& (*"& &+!& & $&&/ ! ! & #"%+&$( & -2

#!#&% & $ &/!& & 0 & ((? "#&&/ ?&""&* !?'

& +% *#! *#% $+! *#$ &/+ "& & &&!$ *(&" !%+ .&/ ?&$&+& & & &+ &/&%&$ (?!

*#"&"&0&$. + &" "&*+%( !

$$"& ? 4116!+ " ? &

/ "

-6

&+&& &&! "! +& (('"

&& ! (/'& $0! "!*0 $"&/

&&/ %+0 && 0 "! "! &"

/++,

-0

#"#"

%565 ,5%5

7$8( 9:

,5%5

7 %$;6 !