← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5693/2018dismissed

The Punjab State Cooperative Supply And Marketing Federation Ltd v. M/S Rv Rice Mills And Others

2018-08-30Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul3 pages



       

  $%&'(&)*+*,-

   .& /,0$1%$%&2&$%*3& /2245$,("$6&%*,7 &(&$%*,8%(  &%*%*,&    9   ":+ 9 *)&"*44+;./*$,(%.&+ &+2,(&,%+  "-  <8"

  =8

&+&,%- "+&&2$4* /*;(3)$%&;'%.&2&%*%*,&  >>>>>>>  =8; 8# .&  2&+&,%  2&%*%*,  *+  (*&)%&(  $7$*,+%  %.&  (&  ($%&(    ;2$++&(15%.&((*%*,$4*3*4/(7& &,**3*+*,#;./* '  +.%;  %.&  *$4  /%#  %./7.  ?.*).  $,  $224*)$%*,  '*4&(  15  %.& 2&%*%*,&/,(& (& +&&6*,7%.&&*,%$A&,(*%+?*%%&, +%$%&A&,%.$+1&&,(*+A*++&( .&  '$)%+  *,  1*&'  ?.*).  $&  &B/*&(  %  1&  ,%*)&(  ' $(0/(*)$%*,7/2,%.&2&+&,%2&%*%*,$&%.$%, 

 C&+2,(&,% '*4&($+/*%+&&6*,7%.&&*,A$,($%5*,0/,)%*,%(*&)%%.&2&%*%*,& $,(%.&%.&(&'&,($,%+*,%.&+/*%%$44%2$((5'A*44*,7'%.&5&$  C%?$+'/%.&2$5&(%.$%%.&+/&%51,(+$,($''*($3*%+$44&7&(% .$3&1&&,*++/&(15&+2,(&,%,1&.$4''":+71& (&)4$&(,/44$,(3*( 2,,%*)&;%.&2&%*%*,&;?.?$+(&'&,($,% *,%.&+/*%;$22&$&($,('*4&(*%+?*%%&,+%$%&A&,%.&&$'%&%.&*++/&+ ?&&'$A&($,($442$%*&+4&(%.&*&+2&)%*3&&3*(&,)&D.&,%.&A$%%& ?$+4*+%&(''*,$4$7/A&,%+;%.&2&%*%*,&'*4&($,$224*)$%*,/,(& (&  /4&@ +&&6*,7$A&,(A&,%*,*%+?*%%&,+%$%&A&,%%%.&&''&)%



 %.$%*%1&$44?&(%24&$(%.&&*,?*%.&7$(%%.&'*4*,7'%?$''*($3*%+ ,1&.$4''&+2,(&,%?.&&*,*%.$(1&&,/,(&%$6&,,1&.$4'' &+2,(&,%%.$%*'%.&*2&A*+&+$&$44%%&(%$,5%.&'(7$*, $7&,)5'%.&2&*(

 $,(%.&*4&$+&2$%5)AA*%%&($,5(&'$/4%; %.&5+.$44  1& 4*$14&% 2$5%.& ?.4& $A/,%  $,( %.$% %.&2$%,&+ ' &+2,(&,%/,(&%$6&,%%+&44(*+2+&'1*7.$+$,( 1*+?$+'

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

& 2&%*%*,&2&'&&($,$224*)$%*,/,(& (& '$A&,(*,7 *%+?*%%&,+%$%&A&,%%%.&&''&)%%.$%*%1&,?$44?&(%24&$(%.&'*4*,7' %?$''*($3*%+,1&.$4''&+2,(&,%?.&&*,*%.$(1&&,/,(&%$6&, ,1&.$4''&+2,(&,%%.$%*'%.&*2&A*+&+$&$44%%&(%$,5%.& '(7$*,$7&,)5'%.

 $,(%.&*4&$+&2$%5)AA*%%&( $,5(&'$/4%;%.&5+.$441&4*$14&%2$5%.&?.4&$A/,%$,(%.$%%.&



  2$%,&+'&+2,(&,%?/4(,%%+&44(*+2+&'1*7.$+$,(

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

   F =8G +.$A+.&    D.&%.&+2&$6*,7:&$+,&( - &+: D.&%.&&2%$14& -&+: