← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1260/2019allowed

Kanta Devi And ANR v. Rana Kumar And ANR

2020-09-17Mr. Justice Arun Kumar Tyagi18 pages



       



 ! "#$ 

               %# &'%  (

) %    

  



         !

"



  #

$$



 

  !

%& '

# (((((

) % * " )   % 

 *+

+,   -   * , %.+$ /     

/   

+

0# 



'  ) 0     *      1  ) 02, 

 +

""33"4    %  !

  +,    $ 

-

 !

.)"

 / "

" 12! ")341"

" 1&  

 .+$ /   5     

+ 

  3633"7    $   )    0 %

  

+

 $ 

"88  + $ 

"93

    ":44*  1  2,     3633"7  %.+  $ /       0  % %+  0 $ /+   /     / - $

  

++ $

) +    # 0 933+   #      -) 

$  

# 

  0  /   / 

  !

;%87%4" 

  0#    +    !

" # /   / /   0      #    +  %.+ $ /     +   0 $ /  

       5 .+$ /+  

;

  -) 

 +   0 5 <& !

"67 3733"7+ /    $ 

7: 39%

 &

 '

":43   $

$       )   +  /  0   6  #     +   / 6 333=%  0#+

/       #      )     0 /       /    

    +

       )     

/#  #   +

"  +        9>  /   !

"% + =

   !

%

 5

#  #  ?  

       

  +     0#     & +      !

"

  #

05 

  

       %5



%5

  # +  

 



        0 #       !

%      

 #    

0 / + & +       !



  # 05 

  %  0 #



  !

"% + =



/ 

  

+5+

/        

 0    

   #0#  !

"% + =

    

  

/            / /    

=

  #   !

  

        



 0 # 9 ) ) 0    



 0#  ?       





 0 

 0#   '

        ) 0       .+  $ / 

   5   

 0#  / / 



 0  / / 

!

;%87%4"0#  !

"+ 



  

/   ) ) 0     0    # 

 .+$ / )  ) 0          0  /  6  #      #  6 ":=% 

"6>   +     

 "=   +       @     



  ""    

6 38:=% 

     8 "84=% +   / 

       +#  + 

 # )  0   4 :3"=% ) 0

   93 333=% +     

"6 333=% +  

    @    

"6 333=% +      +



:

:3"+        76>     

  

   A

#0 0#   5

#   #

+6+ 6 <  ///

        / / 

       8 "84=%    

/   

+

 8     /  '

       + + "373300   5 / + /            0  

+   +  0   /  5 / 

  + %    / 7 &   / 

  0#  '

      /   /   4 &#0 

  #      

/  ) 0 .+$ /

 5   

 0#  / / 



  0  /   / 

  !

;%87%4"  0#      !

"

+ =

  !

" + =





  

/         0 /       /    

        

   0 #   !

"  # 

 .+$ /  0  / 0#       0#  /  #        % 05 

  B

 +    0 /0   

    0  0     +  : C  '

    =  +

 0 

  &           '

       =     /    %.+  $ /  +  #       #   )  

+7+    #      #   ;#'



            

-  B #   338*  1;#338 2, @ 



     

 # 0##  #  +     + 0#    #  = !

" /  / 

" 883=%    # 

         0#D%' . .  ?

E      @ 

?0 

 0# ) 0 !

9

5 /  #  #  % .+$ /   @ #  + /  ) 0 + /#

  8 "84=% 

   #0       =   ?0 

    0# ;

20 $  '

      

    

 

 !"# $

# % &' 

0# ) 0+    0    

     )      # 

 +  

  8 "84=%



 #0    =  C  '

    = /   @      

+     

         

  0#    /  "" /  0 

0#  ) 0) ) 0+

 / 

 +

                     +

#

 +      

     C  '

    = 

/##

++     /  +  #  0  

    

+

0# ) 0#0    "3 ?   

     0 / 

   '

        =      

  

'

     !

%& '

# 



       /  

     # 

      

   #

  #   ;#338  F  = 

 / #  

   F = !

"+  #/  / 



   (     +    0 

 @   05 

 

+   /  ;

+   '

     !

%& '

#    #    0 /    '

 

  =  0   ) 0

    +

       

           +    0  0    C   '

           !

  & '

#       /      ) 0  + /#  

+ +  0 /   #      

  #

+  @   +

#0    #   + #0 



/# "" &     %.+$ /+  #

      #     

0# D%' . .  ?

E    %.+ $ /+/  /# 6 ":=%     + 

+$+   # D%' .   0## 

B@9 " .#  5

    ++        + #0    # 0  /  =   # 0  0  



 #    

  ; ''

 + B< -&$ C&'

 %#      0  0  @

 

  #         / #0  )

*+  )         ,       -  ''.# %  //$ 0   

 1  2 )3-

" % &"#

  .

$ 4

    % %

-

.

% "&'$5 

 6 7 

-

" % /#  31 8   9% )7   -

# % 

. ) ) 0+ G   #

 @  / #            / #0 

  4

     % %

-

. % "&'$ 5 

 6 7

-

" % /#   31 8  9%  )7  -

# % 

.)  

   9 "

884=%  /   # 3"7%"4        @    # 3"7%"4 

 @+#0     333=% 0 

+,+ "

333=%+   0  $ 

43'  &  )@    0   @  33=%   "3> 

@0     333=%+#0 0

+

$ 

47  &  )@  0  6 333=%+  0

  @0   0 / 6 333=%)  

 @+#0   ) 0

   #  

/#

     + @ " )  

0# 

   0 /  6  #                $     +   -    # 

"6>+ G 0   + /#  0# ) 0  

+     

+

 0# ;

20 $  '

 !

8"*

, 5 /  4

 1 



/# % 

'D  

   

    6 ":@"H9 "

884I*"6>,8 63H 9 :"4=% "9 &

+  0     0 / + * +

+  ,

 0#;

20 $  '

 !

"9 5 /      9,     

'" % // "=

  + G 0 

 + /#

0# ) 0 +     @  ?

"=   +     @  

++   #                9 :"4=% *"= ,"

8"

8:=%H  7:=% "6 ;

20 $  '



!

8"*

,  5 /  1 (      / 

  0  0 # /   &

+

  0#;

20 $  '

 !

" 5 /     (          /      0 /  6  # 

  ""+ 0 B  / 0 //

6# +        #   / /  83 # 0

+

 0#;

20 $  '



 1 

 64  

#   %  ##"      0 # 

      7 9       7#        9#    "" 0 

         D    "" 

 #   7:    

  #         7:@""H6 38:=% "8 & 1   (         +   +  /        5$ ;

20  $   '

 

   !

8"*

, 5 /   0  /  

    #             @     0 "6 333=% 93 333=% "6 333=%  

#& 

 ;

20 $  '

  

   

   0      "3> # # &      + 0 #0    

++   

&     



  3633"7     

    0  #/  & )7  

 4 :



     

  

.  #    %  """ ;

20 $   '

  

      /    1   2 

 

 +    1    2 1 

  2    1     2    +

 

93 333=%             

;

+  . 

!

47 5 /    

 0 +

     + 0 /  0#    +

 1C  '

  2

+  1 (      +    73 333=% #0   0

  

  &

+  0 5

 

 ) 0 /#+

  93 333=% +  

    "6 333=%   +      @      "6 333=% +          "7 &#0 

   

#0  +

+

        0    0 

        

#0    /   

 #      / #0   65 

 6  9



"  % '#&+ 8 

 4

  

.# % ."/$ # # @/  

0#   #  +

+ 

0  

#0    /   



++       / #0  )      !36 



." % 1 3+ ;* *7   ' "4 &     ) 0 0#  / ;# 338   #  

 0#;

20 $  '

       (        

   

8 "84=% 

  6 38:=%  /  #+  +    "

76=%+ 0 #0    =   %.+ $ /   @ # )     + 

0# ) 0  

  %  

        

 

 

   

!"

!

 # $  $ !

%  & !

      

 ' $ ()    

 

 *

   

    



       ! ! !     + 

 

)

 ' $ (  ,       (   -



)    !

  !

!

 

   '   $ (        

  !

 

  !

 

     

 ' $ (  

.   

    !

/0+)

 ' $ (  (  ( !  ,)1234

!      

)  

    )    

  



       !

!

!



 ' $ (

    /0+

 

   (  (  )5.34)  

 

 2534   ( 

 2534)

 !

 )6.34 ! 

    

 ' $ (-



)

 

 

   ! 4(  (

  !

 

  

!

 !



1).,534%,1276.&

!  )61)5+34

!%1.,1&)



         

   '   $ (        

     -



)      !  !

   8)8.)18634 %615+.&

 ()   ! 

   

!    6)66)25134%,,8582788.186&

++ 

     9 ": & 

+   0 

      '

        #  + +  #0 

  # 

+

     0    

 !

9

 5 / +  + /     +     + 

 0#  '

    !

%& '

#

   43433  @

     

 

/  ?

      ) 0  +          

 !

9  5 /      

 0 +   +    3 &        43433     

 

/?

 ) 00    @

"93:33         

  %  

   !

 :- 

  ;<

= #  ;! = 

  

( 115516)     !  

 (     

 

 

   

!  "

!

   #   $   $ !    

#%518&+5%$&9

 >$ 123  3 3523558       

!

)  

 !

   <  !

 5156558



   

 

 

 !

  

 

?4 ,%1&@  

!

 !

)

!

  !

    

 

 

 ! *  

  

              

  !

   ! 







( 

  !  %& 

 

   !     !

)   !

  !

             (   

4

  %& 





     

!

   





   !  

!

 $

     (    (    

 

+5+

  )   !

  !



   ( 

4

      (  4

(        

 !

       

        /01)

   (  ( ! ,)1234

!    

 )5.34 ) 2534

   

 2534   ( 

 (

)6.34

    

 

    ! 4(  (

 !

 



!

 1).,34



        

 ' $ (   

     

 !

 

      



 

3 (  

 

( 



  

  !

 (!

 9 " J  6*", ;#338      -    #    #   #    

   

     G  #

  +  +0#    #    

 +   /

   # 

 #          /  #%

# F +  #             / /

 

+       #     

   /  #%

# 0   /  #% /# 

 #           

 / /   

+   

 #         /  #% / # J  6*, ;#338    #+ 0 / 0  

  # 

     #    

 /  +      #  

/        

    &  $    (        ;

20  $  '

    



0 0#  

  -    #  ;#338  G

+6+ #   +  +0#  -    # + 0  0  0  @

   

#0      ":44  ;

+     %.+$ /+  #       #   )  

   #      #   ;#338  @ 



            # 0##   G #     +     +  0#      #   &   0   #   = +      # 

     0##   G #   +  +0#   #  #   

D%' . .  ?

E   

    % @ 

 !

"%+

+

%.+$ /+/  /  " 883=%      #   

          #     

    = !

"+

+   # .+$ /  

      0# 

   0           =  # + #  #



        0#     #       =   ) 

    0#  ;

20  $  '

  /

   

          

+    0       ) 

 0# ) 0  !

9 6 5 / =+ +  + /&  + ) 0  + /# 

     8 "84=%     

+7+

      6 38:=%  #0      =  / +      

 / #    0 

  /  

#

 !

9 6

/ + +   0#    

/?

) 0   

 

+ +  

 ;# 0 /;#-    # ? / #  + /    #  5 / 

+ 



  

%$

61,5  <)1

''#  &# &)         0  K / +     #  #  0 0 %$

!

17 <01 

" % '"  <=6>2 ?<< @

"&#&!



 G 0  / #5



0 

   J              /

     @ 

    /

#

 

 #

/  0    #  0 + 0   0# K

?

 %$

6 4 <A -

''   "# 6  1    < A 



'

# &)     



 

   /

 0

 5

#     

 0   

*$    <=6>2 ?<< @

"&#,&           #      +

/+    0##

 @   



  +#   

 #

// 

++    

/?

 ) 0  



 9 &     ) 0

   # 

 +       76>         

   A

 +   & !+AB+

 9 9    - 7 %<

 

" " #.;

20 $  '



 # /     0 /+

0# ) 0 ;

/ '

 ;

20 $  '

         0 5   0 

    

          0 

     

/   



    

 

/  #  #0 /



0#    . &

      + /  

/    5 #    ) 0 

5 / +

 + 1 (     &

+

 0   5

     

/  #

.&2 

/          + 0#!



. @         

 

0#  ) 0 #       76>   0 

0 5=  / 6 &  +   0



    # 

8 8 38:=%+  

     76>        

   A

)   :

:3"=%+

 0# ) 00  0  0 

   0 % 

 ?      8 "84=%  

3 "84=%0 #0   !

"%+

+  

+$+ 8 333=%0 #0   !

    !

%& '

#

  # 0 

   0#  

/                = *  + 0    0# 

    =         !

%& '

#+    #    #

, /)-$ #  

/ 

+                           =   ?    

  =     0   +  +  

  

  8 )   

/# + +    

 0 



  + ""33"4 7 ;

+  0    /  +           #  0

       +      +  0#5



 $ #  /   /

5      =

/   

    0#   =

'

&+ 0     K

 ?

    

#     /          0#  

/    G #

   0#     K

  ?

   )  '

/  K

  #  '

/   

      

#      

/           0#  K

  ?

   0#

0 /     G   

      /    /    / K

 '

      $ 

 K /  

        K

?

 

 / &

=   ) /'

  /  

+,+ +  

  

 /  

  K

?

    

 / # 0   0    0    #0   

+    5 /  '

  

  + 0   '

+       '

 4   #        0            * 

,  '

/  K

   #  '

/   G        K

?

 



 /

  $ 8

) % 9   #    D   

/=   L =!

D    0   L =!