Apeejay Education Society And Another v. Shirin Paul And Others




   
  

   

   !"

#" $" !"#%!"      



 #" &"'()**+ ",-! && . %+, &/!0+, "!" 


 )!   !, %!", 2!"" 3 

4 
,%52+02! % %"  
#
" 2 "0% ! !,240 " )!""

+-!!"%%-! "%
""-!!)!-  

6

,!-"0!4 %%%!07% "!!"42 %!"%
"42"0 "-!!"% ! "%"+ ! % %"7"" %

89 !
 
,%#"" "

"     !  %  )!   "  %  -  ""    4 04 %""  :

)!" "+!    %%"  
#
 "02! !2"!!!40 "

(" 
,%  52  !     !"  %  4   00""%"  
#
+!"% "  7""    % 


#
 %  4  !  %

      !"

% %4 ! "  :"-! 
#
 "%"20 0 " %2-"0(""%
"!!%00!,4"! %"  
#
+-!!!,%" 4" ,""  :

;! "!"4!!  -%4%4" *%%"04% !-" 0+!-,"+!40!,4""  " ;!,!"!%" "
% "!" %2!-!!4%2!"2!!0,%4% ! %(" "
% "!"!40! "2%% +  !    -  %  "        ! 
   
,% #""% "%, %!"  
#
-% %'-,"+-!%2!%"7"" %


#
% %4 !%

 "2" %,"

  
#
+!%

!00!%!4 """

,%+!" "+-!% !40  "4!" !"% 2! "!<%, !"   !
 
,%#"" ""

,%      ;! ! %

!!%

 % 004" ! -!"

6 %

 2!" %

 !" !"-% 004"

! )!%

!%0 %%-2"% +-!% %2! 
                      

  

      

      !

 ""

"



  "

#   

  $  



  !      #  !  ""        "  %  "

"

$ 

 



 &  ""

"

!      ! 

    



! 

 ""

"



'

  ( !         !

!    "

    

!  "!"   ( !

 

       "

       

      "

          

    

         " 





   !



 !  "!"      )   

    " "   *       

 %   

 

   #  "       '     !   

:      !      

  "

"     

  !

  

    " "   *       

 %   

 

  

  $ 

 

      !  #  

 # 

 %"

"  %  

       !

   #

  " 

 

  !    + ,  !

  "

"  "

  " 

 - ;!,!""4 !
"-!%2 %"  
#
 "2" %, !
"7""

%


#
 %4   ""  !%("
"!%"
 "    "  

    !.    "  /     

  

  "   " " %!#!  %"

!       0 %  

   "      !

      " !   "   #         1    #   %           

"

 #  ! "  "      #       "    #     

  '2'2 3  !   "



       % 

    "    "           #  

    4  %    "      "

 "  

  ""  # #  ""

"



 "

 " 0 %           

  !

  "

 # 4  %"

&        

 "      !

!  "     

    (   "

      "      '

   #       #   # "" !#   $"

   "       "   # 

    0# #         %  #     $"

       "  #      !

 !    $

  !

   

 5  

 %            

   #

 "

    

!6 !       #      "    "     ""  

  %                    1  

"      ""     !"  %   #

 "   !    

   !   "  %#   !0  ) "          



3 "     #               "

  '     0 !    *         

$"

!    "      "    

"  " + %   

 

#" ""      !

 "    7!    !%  ""   

 8     &         !     %

        

!

              "   % #  "  "  *    

   % #  $"

"       "

    

   #            +        "             %

    %      "  9 

""  *           

 



 % "

   !   "     1 #  "      "       "   # %    !"  !

     !

 )  " 0" "   "   "     !"  



   

                " !    %1   #    "  

 ""    # " !$"

!

"

    "  

           

          %           "" !" 

   

0""    !   *  "       #    

    7    ""    "  

 !- ="0!"2 !""+%"!!-"   ""

 ,%   #"0 +  ;       0"  ! 40 %"%& !4"-

", %--!!4"! " !
,%
"" ""

,%%02!"% -!!"!" "%  ","   !
 
,%#"">"  !
 
,%#""+!
,%
"! "" %%,%%4""  !
 
,% #""<""

 

      90

  & *       "

            *

  !     $ "    #     :       $"

!     " !



;<$"  1=9  #  "

" !                       % #      ! "   ! 

 (     

;<$"  1194 " "   %

 #   !   

 <$"  1 #   

  "   " =-

 '-,"+0 "+"% % !!42""  
#
+ !" "+!!%40 "!" "%  2! ""<%,!"  
#
 #"89 89-%4%*%%"04%  !0 !"% !!2+-%4""

"!
" %% 00!40!!"%  % 42" %"  
#
%  ""

 +  %+    0    "         !  "  )!    !,  %"  4  "0    %  -"  0  4

%"22!0

 

+!" "+ "!""""?" +!-! "

6+%""%
""?<!"% ! ,0     !


"

#   #$%&$%'()%*+,-./'%*(0-%12 %(/0 #$%&$%''%)0'&*34%2 %(/0