High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/6104/2012disposed of

Sudesh Kumari v. Dharam Pal And Others

2017-09-08Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh8 pages

!"#$%&'%()$$* )((#

! "# $%% %&'(& ! "# $ ))))) $* )((#+& * && $ + ,( -. - # (/ # ( ,#$% 0%$ ## %1&+ * && $ + ,(-2 - # (/ # ( ,#$% 0%$ ## %1&+ 3 $ $%% & + # &&1 %

,( -4$ /+ %"%&5( 1 5(% 0%"%%!

0(%/+ % 7$&%# % % 6 /+$%% / %6% '( 8(6 % 9 $%% #%"%& (% #& % /% 4 /% % /%1 7 & 6 (%1 -:/% %( 0(%/ % 1% & 2

...;< &$ + 1% & ;:

. ; ,#( /+

21 %1(%$$+%(&& "% 3 $%% & (1 #=(% & &% $% && $6 % (#% %%1

2 6 &% %1! 61 1%1 %$%1 (%$$+% +6 " 3

% $ % 6#%1#& %6 $%%<% 6 /+

! % " &%( /# 6 (%$$+% "6 >% +8(6 !(/ $%% " %%$% (% $$+! ! % $%% " $+%# & $% (%$$+$%%7$& %%

$& %%

"6 % %$% 6 3$%% $&%# ,(- % 6 /+

,(-

2/ % $&

%1 $ %!% & ( 6 %(3$%%, 6% " &%

$6%%1$"?%&&

4 ;. /+ + #

+ "% # /( 6

%6% "%

2 . 3

! $

%1$6%% % %

2 6

% "6 (%

"#! $& %%

6% 6( % .2 #% / % ?%&&

4 ;. ! $#%"&+ (& $%% (/6% % $&%# %7 % /+$%%% 6!% /$#% &&+6% %$ 6%

6!'( 6 % %@ &/# 6 %$% (%$$+1 %1%#6( % .2 #% % 6 '( 6 '( 6 % % @ &! >% +8(6 '( 6/# 6 %$% (% $$+1 %1%#6( % #% %% 6

>% +8(6 '( &% (%$$+"% & 2

...;%

"( $& %%

'( 8(6 %

"$%<% 1( %"6# 6( .2 %

"( '( #% / % ?%&& 8 1%

4 ;. %"% 6,(-2'%6%& &+! '( 6 % %@ &!6( %%$# %7 % 6 (%1:/% #% %

"( >% +8(6 '( 6 / % ?%&& 8 1%

## %1 #(&! $%% &

+ $&

/ 6( % #% %

"( '( + 8(6 6( % #% /+ "( (%% % %# 1 %

%#% & (#%#& &+6 # 6( %/%1 #% / % ?%&&!%# $$ 6% !%(& 6(% (#%1

#<% ( 1( %#%

%( # % 1 %$ $% (%

$$+! %($ ( %#%&%&+/# ( $%%%# %$6% $&%# %7 % $&

?%&&

4 ;. ,#( /+ 6%

"( '(

/+ '( 6 %

"( + 8(6 < /# $%% $#% &&+ $&

%1 ?%&&! 6 + /

(#"% #%1 ?%&&%=(% $$% 1(/ % 6

(#%1#

+ "% #%1

?%&& / %6% /+% & (% ##( (& ( 1( $$ 6 (& %# 1 ( (%&% #& %6 (& $ # ( $ ( %#$ %#+# / #6$ %#3& (/6%%6

/+#(&% (& $# (

6%% % (%# 6 /( #%1# ( (%# 6< ($$ % #%! ( 16 *A/& '($6 (

!"#$!!%& &'()!*+ #,) !"!(-!*+ .+ #*#/#,#+0#1/2+,+#,)%3!*+! 45 4'"'(5 (& #%1$ !# +! ($$ %6$(1 % (/6%% $$

6%#& &+/ /+$"% $$ (&: %"%&# (!. ; %A A3$%%

+, 6% 6 +%/

$&%# %7 % <% ( 1( $"%(&+ $%% $6%% &

+ "% # $" ?%&&

4 ;. 6

%6% /+% &("%

2 . 3

4 $ /+ % & ( %6%%1 $6%% &

+ "% # / # &&1 % $$$% $# %1

% % &%+<% ( 1( %# $%%%

% ! % 6 + (&&% +

2 . ,(-2 6%$6%%/& < " #(& $ %!$( $ $-/ $ %#(& &+"

%( ,( $$ %$%%

"%1(/6%%6

/+#(& $ %!%% $$$% # $%(& &1 &$%% $&

%1 "

$"% (& :

$$ /+ + 6% %+

*A/& '($6(% !"#$!!%&&'()!*+67#+! ($ & # % $%#%$& / $ % "% %& &%1 %

%1&"

, # 6$ : ; ( 16

&&- B: #%%# &&+ &+C%1/ D1&% < # ! 6 / %#$%#%$&61%#(1/ %#% %%&

&&%1 #%1 6

? 6(1%%6$ %" $$

#%"

( % # E

? 6% E

2 3 6(& # ((#$ ( %# % %# # / #6$

=( &+ % 6 6+F

(%1 6(& %

% (%#&

6(&%$&&%%1 %F

4 ? $$ 6 #%(% &&+

(

6 &&+# 1 ( # # # E

1 &(&!#((& #&% 6%

(% #& %6 (& / / /+ &%6% %

;3 6 %6$

#%#6 +/$%6% %& &%1% ( (&:3 &+%&&( %" , (%"G ( &

, #& "6 (/ $"% $$ (& : /+ + 6 # #6$& / % &&%1 6 $&

%1 3 6 $& % # / % % % # 1 ( (% (

6 &&+ #%(% &&+ 6 (& % (# #& %6%#%/ /+&%6% % 6 (& (&%(# $ ( %##%1$ + %##% 6 + < # ! $%% #& %6 / (%$$+/ % & ,#( %

"( /+ ' >% + 8(6 ! (/ < $&%# %! 1%"

##( '(

>% +8(6 /# 6 %$% (%$$+%1 6( .2 #% %

"( '( (>% +8(6 "%1/#6 %$% (%$$+ '( 6%$# %#6( % #% 3 $%% $#% &&+$&

/6( % #% %

"( '( + 8(6 % $ $&%# % 6% ( & 6( % ,(-2 - (& 6 %"% 6( % #% / % ?%&&

4 ;. $#%"&+H #%#(6 #!< % 6% % #% $%% /+ + $$

6!$%% % % (#

#%#

&% &% $&

%1 D=( &&+ ( % $%% %

# 1 ( (%# ( #%6(#& &% #& %6 (#$& / % /+$ $$ 6% #( /+6 &%# %%/

(& $

# +6 %1 (&

1(6 $$ 6(& # ((# $ ( %# $ 7

%# + # / #6$ % #?

# #%#(6 # $# , 6% %&%1 (#% %& % !"#$!!%&&'()!*+67#+! ($ !<

% 6% % #% $%% & + % %&%1

%%& # / % + $%% 6

6% &+ $ # && / #6$ %# & +3% &(

, 6% %%1$$#%" #66% $$

# # /+& %1 6%# + ( #%% # 6

#!%# $%%% $&

?%&&

4 ;. $"?%&&%

#%& !6 +/(## (&% /&%%1$& $"%(&+ (% $$+ /+ '( + 8(6 !$ #%% $%%<"% /"! %6$(1 # / ( % / % I 1%1 ! $%% % 3

$& %% (/ #$ +6 # ! 7- < % #& % %

6 % 7$&%# %!%# $%% %& $"%1 ?%&&/+ + #

+"% #! 6 &&/ #% /+ % &(%# 1 # %!%(/%1% &(# /+ &%

; % % 1 *"! %1 %/ && # ( $ ( %#% $ % (%1% & 8 9 :;5 J0K(& %L ?$ %17 +7 ?$ /& +7