Surjeet Kaur And Others v. Kuldeep Singh And Others









 


 







































!
"#$%$ &
'(()
* (
*


+


 *

((


,,*
- * *
+ ,
*

 *

((( * *


 
  +

 *

((


,,*
- * *


+ ,
*

 *
((( * *


 
 

*
+

 *


((


,,*
- * *
+ ,
*

 ((( * *
 '

 .,

(
 *



 ,










 
 








 ,/
(
 ,

  

 


 

! "
#





 
 

!$




 
!$

#
 

%& ' (()

!$


 
* 
 !#
+ 
, 




'

-1$23& 4./
 

01
'23% '%%'
! 




4#
5
4#
6#
 
!$



 


277%%8
!$
 !#


#


 
 

01
'23

'%%'
! 

 


94 
 

 
!$



 

(():%%8
!$
!#


#


 

 


01

'23'

'%%'
! 

 




9
5


 
!$



 

22''))8
!$
 !#


#


 

' ;
4#
5
4#
6#
94
 


9
5


, 



<=/

 


 #
 
 
"


2%%( ((3

#



 
  
!$


 
  
!#
! 
  
+

% 

7):(
2  




$
#
 
!$







>##

 






 !4 

!$





 

 






 


! 
 


"

! $
7  

#


 
1




#



#

#  
#

$
!

 









$



 (

!

3 
 !#





 





 
 
 
!$




4#
5
4#
6#
?



':%%8



8'


:

 
 

277%%8 , 7%%
@
:
@ '
/
) A
#

 

#



 

 
#
 ● 0##




 
  


 
 $
0##



@
7%B

$



!





':
$




 

 
● A
 !#



$ 

# 

-:.




# 

- &.
" 
 





!
-':.
$

●  
#

 
#


!

#


#
@






 


 #




 
 
!$
+.!
#
*#
&  

#$




"


*#$
#

#
"
+ 



 
!$
@  
C 3
4
6#
D$

#

!$
  
$
  
E@


:
 
$



 


':%%8 


 !#

"




!
':%%8 
 



!

!$


#


 








!$



!#



 $
#

##


"

  
!$

 !#
;


':
$



 

 


 



$ & 4
&%31 &#
 56 &7
, "(
-%(
& 7
* 0$
&"
1%(
'% &
, )/
**
):%
 

 

##

 
# 


$

7%B
 
##



!

;


!

# 
!$


3%B




!
#
 

@
6


 





':
$

# 

- &.
#
!
 !


-:.

 
!$

 !#
 


!
 

3%%%8




 
 


 
 #
&3%%8

 




#
@




$
:  $

 "
 
$!






# ?



':%%8

':%%8 

3%B
,':%%

7%%/ 


7%%8 0##

7%B
, 7%%F3)%/

()%8



&

& 


$

()%@ &@ '

2((:7%8 A



&3%%8

0#
@

&3%%8


 #

* 


G'

3%%%8 @'

2%%%%8 *  
!$
 !#

277%%8 *  



777:7%8 E


777:7%8 ,
 

/

277%%8 ,
 
!$
 !#/

2 %77%8


 (

!

( 
 !#





 

 

 
 
 
!$

 
 


94 
 
?



(273%8 #

82
;#

2  3%8 ,(273%

3%/



)

 
 

(():%%8 , )'2%%
@
)/

% A
#

 

#



 

 
#
 ● 0##




 
  


$
0##



@
7%B

$




!





2:
$




 

 
●  
#

 
#


!

#


#
@






 


 #




 
 
!$
+.!
#
*#

  

#$




 

8
*#$
#

+ 
!$
@  
C

H 
6#

I;*
1 

?
@

C 7



 
?
@
#
E@
 2






(273%8

#
 



!

!$


#












!$


 !#


) 

 $
#
 



2:
$




 

 
# 

- 3.
#
!
 !

 !#



$
 
 


##

 







2:
$



 

7%B
 
##

#
!
 !
?




 


!
 



&3%%8
 
#
@

&3%%8




3%%%8




 
 
 
 #

'  $

 "
 

 

 
J


 



#
?

(273%8

#

(273%8 #

0##


7%B
,(273%F2&2:%/

2%:2%8 

82


, 2%:2% 72) %/

:&''%8



3

3



$

:&''%@ 3

2%:2%%8 A

E


&3%%8 0#
E@


&3%%8 A

 
 #

 
 G'


3%%%8
@
'

2%%%%8 
*  



2322%%8

(():%%8 
*  
!$

!#

E
#



2322%%8 , 

/
J

(():%%8 , 
!$

!#/

23)3%%8

&


 (

!


2 
 !#





 

 

 
 
 
!$

 
 



9
5

?



2 3%%8 #

82



)

 
 

22''))8

7 A
*#

 

#




 
#


• Future prospects were not added while determining loss of dependency. Future prospects to the extent 40% of monthly income needs to be added as the deceased was 37 years of age at the time of accident.

• Appropriate compensation amount needs to be granted under the head loss of consortium, funeral expenses and loss of estate in accordance with law laid down by Hon'ble Supreme Court.

3 ?



 



!

!$


#


 








!$

 !#



 $
#
 



2&
$




 

 
# 

- 3.
#
!
 !

!#



$
 
 


##

 







2&
$



 

7%B
#
!
 !
?




 


!
 



&3%%8
 
#
@

&3%%8




:


3%%%8




 
 
 
 #

)  $

 "
 

 

 
J


 



#
?

2 3%%8

#

2 3%%8 #

0##


7%B
,2 3%%F ')%%/

77 %%8 

82


,77 %%

7&%%/

'(7%%8



3

3



$

'(7%%@ 3

77 %%%8 A

E


&3%%8 0#
E@


&3%%8 A

 
 #

 
 G'


3%%%8
@
'

2%%%%8 
*  



7:)%%%8

22''))8 
*  
!$

!#

E
#



7:)%%%8 , 

/
J

22''))8 , 
!$

!#/


32&278

&


?




 

!
 

&3B



#

 



 

 
 
 
 K 
Apportionment and liability of respondents to pay compensation shall be as per the award.

:




 $
 

!


(

(  #
  ,/

$

,/
 

 $
'% 
$

 

!



 





2%3'%')




 


 ,
4

 
C
"

8


L

C
!

L8