← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5875/2018dismissed

Joginder Singh v. Mohinder Singh ( Now Deceased) Through Lrs & Others

2018-10-16Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi4 pages

  



      

     !" #"$%&%'() *%'#"+,%'*- ."!%!%'"+ /"+&0& -%'#"+,%'*- '#!-"+& ."&1'#"'!&   ( 23 , 

,43 +"&"'!( +'#"+5%!,- +6 7#8$ !" +!-"1"!%!%'"+ 999    :; "8%&%' 1"!%!%' - & <""' %="# $- =="'*%'* +#"+ # !"# >''"?0+"@)1 &&"#<A!-"=" +'"###%!%' =%&!+%$!0#*"7

0+# &10+ #%&6%&&%'* 11=%$ !%' 0'#"+ ,"$!%'    !-" 3%6%! !%' $!7 B)C -"+"%'

!"+ +"

"++"# ! & D!-" $!2 + $'#' !%'   #"= A   C A" +&>6'!-&%' $%8%= 11" =0'#"+,"$!%'B)   * %'&!!-" 50#*6"'! '##"$+""# !"#>>''"?0+"@ :; +%"

$!& !-"$ &" +"!- !!-"#"$" &"#-%'#"+,%'*-7 +"&1'#"'!E1= %'!%

%="#$%8%=&0%!F-%$-F &#"$+""#'>> !&!+ '&1%+"&!- ! '+#"+- #<""'1 &&"#%'!-" 11=%$ !%'0'#"++#"+ CB0="&   %'!-"$%8%=&0%!' -"1"!%!%'"+F-F & $'!"&!%'*!-"&0%! &#"

"'# '!!-+0*-'",-,"#%7#8$ !" %="# 6%&$"== '"0& 11" =F-%$-F &#%&1&"#  &- 8%'*<"$6"%'

+0$!00& ' B   "F 6'!-& <"

+" !-" #%&6%&& =   !-" 6%&$"== '"0& 11" ='B &- 8%'*<"$6"%'

+0$!00&7!-"1"!%!%'"+ %="# '

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

%=" ' 11" = * %'&!!-"50#*6"'!# !"#>><0!$0'&"=#%#'! %=" 'A 11" = + +" &'& <"&! G'F ! -%67 !- ! 11"== '! F & ' %==%!"+ !" 1"+&'F-#%#'!G'F!-"!"$-'%$ =%!%"& = F '#''@  11" = F%!-%'!%6" '#!- !% !-"#"= A%' %=%'*!-" 11" =F &'!$'#'"# '# 11" = '! #6%!!"# '# #"$%#"# ' 6"+%!&7 !-"' -" F0=# &0

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

++" &'&<"&!G'F!-%67#"&'!$'&!%!0!"&0

%$%"'!$ 0&"7<"&%#"&7 &

 

+%*-!=A'!%$"#%'!-"%610*'"#+#"+!- !'$61= %'!F &6 #"<A!-" 1"!%!%'"+ * %'&!!-"$0'&"=F-6!-"1"!%!%'"+- # =="*"#=A%'&!+0$!"#!

%=" ' 11" = '#!-"& 6"F"'!!&-F!- !!-"1"!%!%'"+- #$%'"# 

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

%' 1+$""#%'*&7 %! F0=#- 8"<""'' !0+ ='-%&1 +!!10+&0"!-" 11" = +F-%$--"- # &G"# -%& $0'&"= ! %=" '# F & &%!!%'* &%="'! 8"+ !-" 6 !!"+ + A" +& !*"!-"+ ==F"'!!&-F!- !-"- #'! %="#!-" 11" =%'!"'%' ==A '# 'FF &$'$$!%'*  =&"&!

8%'*$'&%#"+"#!-"6 !!"+%'!! =%!A7 6 !-"$'&%#"+"# 8%"F!- !!-"1"!%!%'"+- &6%&"+ <=A %="#!6 G"0!&0

%$%"'!$ 0&" + &""G%'*$'#' !%' #"= A CA" +&>6'!-&%'= !" !-" 11" = #6%!!"#=A7!-"1"!%!%'"+<! %'"# $1A !-"50#*6"'! '##"$+""# !"# >>%'!-"A" +>%!&"=  '#- '#"#8"+!-"& 6"!-%&$0'&"=

+  11" = !"+'" 6'!- '# !-"+"

!"+7 * %' 6"! -%& $0'&"=

!"+  # A& " =& #6%!!"# - 8%'* 1 +!%$%1 !"# %' !-" "?"$0!%' 1+$""#%'*& ' +"$"%1!   '!%$" %& ! G%'* 01 !-" &! '# !- ! -" - # %'&!+0$!"#-%&$0'&"=! %=" 11" =<0!!-"$0'&"=- #'! %="#!-"& 6"

 

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

; $$+#%'*=A7 %'#%'*'6"+%!%'!-"+"8%&%'1"!%!%'7!-"& 6" %&#%&6%&&"#%'=%6%'" ,4 =%  0#*" ) 6%! 4-"!-"+&1" G%'*E+" &'"# ( "&E 4-"!-"++"1+! <=" ( "&E