National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Janki
!
"
#$ $%&& ' ( (
"
)'
* +) , )+ ,
! ! !!
"
#
-. ##
,& /01
!"!
#
$$
%
#%$#! &'#&'()#
*
"! "
$ $
$
" "
*
# "
!
"
" #" # *
# * +
! # $
#
" # " !$
" $ -
$ " #
$ " .
"
# 2 3& /
&452& /&%$26 %-$ 7&%$2 / 012"&''13# 4''4&'((# !
$
$#
"
"
"
$
"
5
# "
!%
#!$ "
# ! # & " $!
! #
" $ # )0(1"&'()#
!" %
#
6 # #
)4&' "&'()# ""
* 6 #5
#
! " . $#%$#/ "
# !$ "
3 7!
" # "
"
#
4 "
#%
% # $" "
5 (108" * #(1)(# * "
# # " : /(3
#!$ 6
"# !" $ ! " ;! "
<#
# "
"
" " "
!
"
" ! #
#
8* "
9 ;= 6 "# # $
"
!
"
! *
"
/3
/!3" 00
$ " $ "
#
!!
8* < >*8?
! " "
@ !
@ @5
@ ! # ! "
"
!
#
$
!!
"
" "
$< ***** ***** *****
"
!8 /(3
8 ***** ***** ***** ;/*3
! "
!
+ /*3
! "
!
"
#
!# $$ $" "
$ " * "" $
9<A ***** ***** **** 0 "
$".
!6$
52& $$8 9
#$.6$3 &
52
%$+# &''1/&'3/32(2 #
$ !" #
$ # : "
A " #"
" * 2'#'''B8# "
*/3"
!8 4"5 (108#
*
"
" *
$".
"
52$6,& /0
#0$26,# #$ 2:
#0$2 &'(0 /0)3 /3 024# / * "
" , , #(C103# # * ! 5 2)"
* # "
2 7 #"
#
$" .
/ ! ! 3#
/
3 # " $
!
, " !"
! !"
:3 - ! %
" ! D "
D " "
; $ $ 3 - "
" "
E 3 -
!
!
! E 3 - $.!
" #
"
E 3 - ! = E 3 - ! % "
EA 6$ # " #
, /3/398 :&1 5 (10/43/*3
" "
" ! !
" - #
#" , " ! ""
!
"
" ! %
"
#
#
#
!A ) - !"
!
# $ " "
# #!
!$$ 5"= ! $
$!
*"
"
*
! 5B $ #
/ 5B ""
3#! *
# !#
" !%
# ! !$
/ 3+ # * !
*"
/*3"
!8 /43"
5 (108" "(1)( F # # # "
"
$"
#
!$ " # *
#!$ / ! 3 C *#
! # !#5 (108 " *
6 G?# !" $
! " / ! "
3# !
*
# ! 6 #
" #!
, " !" #
! *! "
#!$
" # *! /" $ # "
*
"" " *!8" $ C"
$ "
!
"
3
! "
$
$ = #"" 6$
# 5
#
" #
$
!
" 3 --&& $2 %-$ 71 $ / .6,0 3< ..
%$
=
-8
: (14&= (4C + 3
& -2&#>5 26--&& $2 %-$ 71 ? /(10)3H I 2)( + 3 /056
0&)&..+#1 -4 :6--&& $2 %-$ 71 -4 :&#:
/(12&3HH 0C0 + 3 @ 52> - 90:
& ,& /0 -/ 206 --&& $2 %-$ 71 &0 2
2&
(104= (24+ 3 6& %0
2 ) #.
.1 -4 :6--&& $2 %-$ 71 -4 :&#:
(12252C + 3 0$--&& $2 %-$ 71:$2 1 $%%
6)AB C&2,5.#
1 (1215C(0 + 3 &#+ .
6$2&6>>,$ (1)25(4F2 + 3 ,$
&2 - / 2- ..6--&& $2 %-$ 71 -1 (1)(5(2F1 + *3 ,5#0$2.
6--&& $2 .
$6$ 5$ /(1(C3 (& * )4+ *3 6> 2#0&9$:
(1145 45&&& 1
" #
$"
4 . )#2 ,$26&%$ +#
0$2 6 )> B$.53 -&
#0$2 (1)&5( # *"
I /!
"(1413#
!%
# ! " /
! !" 3 (' 6$ ! , # " !
" :- ,
"
! " ! " A
( "
#
5 (F(" I #(1CC#
" := 2& #$2$#30$2$
:%.
&-& ..3$' - "
#
"
!
"
"$ " ! "A
" #
$" 5
--&& $2 %-$# 71 2& 6 0
0:
-D"
/&''134(2 (
# " ! ! 5 40" , #(C10# "
/" , "3 !
"
"*!
$" 5
# $ #2 .
9 & 6 6& 2
#0$2 &''(/534'12 #
, "
#
$ " *
# 5#&%2& #9 .& 0$-&% .
$2#&.&C$2 +&-&#$ 6 --&& $2 %-$ /(11F3&&F (F&# !
#
" ! $ # #
# !"D
D
! "$ ((
$
!
#
*"5 (108/43/*3# *
!
! *" !
!
"
#
! * 5"= !B .
$J. !
$7"" "
#
!+
:
A !
! * (& "
# #%
# "
#
/
3#".
!6$
# "
#
!# ! *
!
* 2'#'''B8
" 6 "
!
#
/ 3#
/
$
3# "
* 2'#'''B8+ "
/ 3#
# ,
*
!
/ ! " ! !
! 6$
! * #!
"#"
*
2'#'''B8 !
2'#'''B8 !
" " 3
#
$#"
" "
# "" *
!
!
/"* 2'#'''B8" 3# !
$
(4 # " " ! ! .
!6$
# !! ! "
$"
#/ "
! $
$$ !
$ 3 ! "
$ !
/%
4'#&'((3#
/*3"
!8
/43"5 (10" * " / !$
/*3 $398 :
"
!8 /(3
8 ***** ***** ***** /*3
! "
!
"
#
!# $$ $" "
$ " * ""
A
/*3 $ *
!
! " # "
"#" "
! " * 2'#'''B8 $" +/ !
!$ "
$ !%
3 (0 K# ! !.
#"
$$ #
/*3 ! !
! ! #!
!
! "
/*3#
!
"'(')&'(2#
* !
!
/
3#
!%
#"
* 2'#'''B8 $" / $
/*3 ! * "" "
'(')&''43 (2
$ ! $ "" $
# !"
# # # "
$"
/*3 /*3# "" "
'(')&'(2# 2'#'''B8 $" # !%
# *"
"*
+
" $$ $ " *
2'#'''B8#
" " ! ! *
# "" #
/*3 "
"
"*
$
#
"
" #*
2'#'''B8 "# # #
# *
!
#/ "
/*33
!! % K$
= # #
() # !
!
">*
&0"&F'0&'(2/
!
"
)0(1"&'()3# !"!
# (F#&'(4#!"
#
$ "
(('&&'(2
#"
$"
/
3 ! " #
! '(')&'(2# "
/*3 "
/*35 (10/43" * #(1)(# !
!
#"
! 2'#'''B8
6 #
$ "
$"
#* !
!
'(')&'(2#"
* 2'#'''B8 " &'(08(2# '(')&'(2 " &'(28() (F
" #"
'(')&'(2# .5
* #
* 2'#'''B8
" #
! ! ! !
/
3#/ $
#
/*3"
!8
/43 "5 (108" "(1)(# *
!
#
3 !" "
$#
!!
"$
$ "
#" " "
"/!$
3 (C # " "
#
" $
!
%
#%$# "
'(')&'(2# "*
/ "
"
* " #!"$ *
3 6 # #" " '(')&'(2#
" ! 2'#'''B8# !! 8 # *
*.
# !
" 8
#" *
" # $ "
" *
#"
*B "# !!
" !$! *!
" " "
G
!$ "# !
! !" * #"$
! ! # $!
5/5# (1
D )+ ,"
(- $B E K
&- !E K