← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/1667/2024dismissed

Gurdeep Singh v. State Of Punjab And Another

2024-01-25Mr. Justice Jagmohan Bansal6 pages



        

 !"#$# % &' ' 

(      (  



)  *+)'() (+                 ) (+  ,'-.

/0   ! "                #

$$%&$$'   (   

           # # )*+,  - # ./#-(&0(12  3   )*+,  -  #2 $ "    -

#  

      #      3    )*+,  -   #2  " -  4  

    5!6!$6$5     #  #

#$!6$$6$5"  

+-#  !767$6$5" 

 #   #  "

    - #   

# 676!$6$8 9  

  -   3 )*+,  - # ./#-(&0(12 5 :   #    -  



  #3  #  

#        3    )*+,  -

 #2  4     #    )*+,  -   #   ./#-(&0(12

#        *+,  -.14# ##   4     #- 4 #*+,  -

 # 3 8 :      #  -    #   !8     - ##3    #  #3## ## # # ) 32; 9  3

# -#   4   

##  -  #   -



#"

   #3  3*+,  -.

 #1   #   -   3"  #3  - 4##  #   +- <   -   4#

#   #      % "   #3

#    3*+,

 -  .

 #1  #   !8       -   

   #

## .1 #  ##3    #  #3#### #

# ) 32" #  - (  -       #      

# 4      #   4   #  -



#" # 

   #4      

    

     

    

          

 

 !

   

 "   #  #$"  $   



     

   # 

  

%   $     & '

    

$ 

#    "

    " 

  ()"

 

     

    

$  $ #  '  *

    

" 

$ 

   $  

 

 + ' "    #  

#    $!6$$6$5    

4 +-# !767$6$5" 



#   #  "    #  ## 

# 676!$6$8 ( 3" -  -  - (4 4   -   "  #   - (4- 4    -   #

##3 344 -  #       -  3 3# !8  -4# #   4#  # 7 4, / -     

 ! "

!#! # $%&&'(%)

*+

#    - #-        +- 

         

 #- 3

examination claimed benefit of reservation. A single judge of High Court of J & K held that a candidate was not entitled to benefit of reservation, however, a Division Bench extended benefit of reservation. The Apex Court reversed judgment of Division Bench holding that a candidate cannot be permitted to claim benefit of reserved category after last date of submitting application. The relevant extracts of the judgment read as :

3.        

#  

$  # ) 

   , #  -#   (# !  - 

.

          )         

  ,/0 123  1445

             $ 

    )      

  )    $     )  

  

#    $ ) $  6 ,7 & 8 24  2992

      (# !  - 

 .

                # $   #       #$ 

     

      



  $          

 #     # $"  6 )

)

            #$ )     

#

  $  

 , ! 5 6     !    

      #  )  138;8 1444          

 # 

       

   #     #$ * )     

   

 )  $  !

    <

 )   

=

&

      #        )      #   !         

      #       

     )         $ 

      

  

 )   $ )    )      # 

  ,/0 123  1445   298381445

  

    

# ) 

  

  *         

     



       

 

   

 > 7      

 



             

         

     #  (   

$  

# ) 

        

  

     $ 

         

      #   (      $ 



# 



   '   #   

  



   #     )   # #  '   

  #  

     

 ) ) $ #      

  

=

  

         #$  )     "  



 

#   

 =  

    )     # 

  

    '



      

  # )   =      =

  " )    #     

)  

& + = "    9 #3  3 

-      #     +-

           3  "    

     +-     *+,

 -.

 #1 3   

#   3 #- 3 "#-

   !6 In the wake of above discussion and findings, this Court is of the considered opinion that the present petition sans merit and deserves to be dismissed and accordingly dismissed.

 -) (+0  $<6!$6$8  > 

(&   ? &; 7 /

?%&