← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/660/2011allowed

(O&M) Rajnish Kumar v. Raghbir Chopra

2018-08-21Mrs. Justice Anita Chaudhry9 pages



      

 

 

   !"

#"

$"  % &" '" '     

 #" "( )*+( " '" "," +%%"-.*+( " "' //// 

 +"% !-" ") %!-""(0 %! &%". 1."'" "('% ""

'  &2       ".."   "!  &2     +''..  +  "2 !% ' "3%(  "' "

4  5       6  #  &  7"&    "  +* 

" "&" "": +  898;< = - "= "&-":-  " & ' .&2  "!&2 .."'.%"2%" 4 5    +

898*"2 .."- .''"% -&>

! '&  %" 4 5    +

898<;

+'" +  898* ..""= "'. " ..-% 

 ,"= " " - '

 , '2%2 "& .%  "&""

 , (  & .%-     " !!!  +  "&" 4 5    +  898>" "  





    

    

  

 



 

     

       !

    

"



    !

       #      

  

       "

 

  !

 

          #  

"



  "      "  

#  $ %#   

  &  

    





#            #      #       '

  (  "  )*+"  

5



 #      

               

     

     

      

$, ?     '"  *     .."    '.  ..      " "= "!- .&." "! "%  ' "  "%"&!'" 5  '@ . .% "'.2* "'%(."'.2 "! '"

* -("*- ."'.2%'"5*.2"!-  '"5  ''.-"% @   .."  ''"       (*    '   " ' #  #          

'   # 

   $'             

   

  $-"' 

    

  $, ?!2&%  " .."'"

' ..2"  " &  !  "% "!.3%%"..'"    

 " " ' "  '"'"2 88A?!!.2 "' " *

   &  '"!= "%  & 0  '=   "   "'"! .."->'& "= " '"! "

(%'"'"'.2  !  "!0  "  '"!

9  ). ", "' " 1"".." " % "= "!  .."&& *! ' %"   &   .."    '.     "2  %"*  -("*  - . ''"%(*  ..(=  "2 %"0 +''..+  "2. '

. ""&2% %"  >!  ."2&.. " !.3 ?!0> "*'"(  . &   .." . " % '"!"= " ">'  "  " ." . " '" .% -  "&.% " %  %!'&2  "&.- "" 1" . " '".."  &!  ..".2"= "'. %" 4 5     +  898, " " &!  . "'  .  '."'"(  . "-* .." "= " " ".2( "%", " "

 &! B"+''.. " ""- ." "% % &   .." . " %, &! & - . . " .2  .."% '  '"!        '  "  '"'"  '.2       !  &% !  "&2 !, &! &%'  .."""2%!  "%C &" "!%'" '"'"2>' '= -  "2

A

  " *." . " "'

 &! ..".2"= "'.&  . "= "'"( "2%", &! &   (*'.%& (&'"(,*  " ("% .2! '  " .2D "% !  ." .

" '"@ .''.2% "(*..""= " . ' " &(+!.2*  "  (&'.B"   "= " '"! "  -   '  -   &  '.    .  @  "%"   "!%-"= "!*'". &* .."  ' ..2'.  "= "?"'.2*  "'.%

( &?- "'. -"!&2   '.&2 .."*"%""= "! .   &    .     "   ..2  ""  "     .."      ' 2 "& .%  "&""" -      (  & .%  "&""

  '*!".2&  .."(  ' ..2'&   "-"= "!* ' .&2 .." .&!0 .." ."2 '   (2'.'.2 !  "!   ('"'"   !"@ ." >!% .."* %% &%( !    '2% 2 " & .%    "& " " " 

 (  2     & .%  -           "   !!!  +  "&"" 1"   .  "     "'    ".  '  

%!'&2,E&.B ..F    "       

 

!

!,*- . " ""%'"   %!*  &! .."- ."= ".( ''"  '.% '  " " ..2" %!'&2 ,E&.B ..F 0 = - -" ""&2 ."4%. ) % &"'" &2 B ..F    "*-  >" " . 

   #  

  

   

     

    /  0 %

2

3 3  ")*)" 



"$$  

  "  



          

     

  "     

#  

  #    

 



#                   

  

  

 

#     

           ,

 "%   "= *''" ,E&.  B ..  F  -  -"%     =        >   "= "! '.%

G %!'&2  "&" > .("0 %!'&2 1"%"F  =   .-?&" > -"% = 0

%!'&2  "&" ,E&.B .. F -" =  . "2%" ( &'. &*'" *,E&.B ..F  . " 4  

"    

        #   #    $, ,-("*  " &" >  &!0 - .& " "." "!'"

  %! - >" " $'

  "    

          

  #         /

    

  

                        "     # #    "   

5'

#  "    #  

#   "    

  

      #    

   

        

 

 



  #  



 

 " 

  &

        

   #     

&             

     

     

           1   $- 

 #



    

 

 # 

 

            #          #    



"   

6

/"    "

  #    #    





 & #         /

  

$6 #" 

       

  

      /

  

  #        

"    

 

   

    " 

   "    #            

#   /

 " 

 &  $ -    #    

$/  

 

   #   

      #      

  # 

          #  %        $, ?(-   "* .  "2 %" (&'. .' ..2' &2 *' .&2 .."&! %"    "= "! (&(&2 .." '" .".2-    "  ..2"("   '.  - .  '.%     %"  "  .  2 (     ""2  0  %   +''..+  "2- "%" .." .%'"(  . " %& '"("@ " &  . " %"*'!2 "   ( & "= "!  .." &'.

8 '"(*  ""!".2>! -  " "= "! & ",-!  ."2&% !&2 .."  "  -  !   !     "(%  "!    &    .% !>""*- .&".( " '" .".2- !.2 .."""2%!  "% (2-%>' & &2 (%'"'"'. "

'.2 !  "! '%(-  "* '""(' ..-0 ""'&2 +  "&.-" +..     '%  !..   ''.*    2*  " ' *(-  &( %! 





 %

  !"#$"#%&'#()*+,-%#(&.+#/0 #&-.

!"#$"#%%#'.%$(12#0 #&-.