Ram Asra Singh v. Avtar Singh Dhariwal And ORS

 










 

  



 !

"#$

$%&'&()
*$+#$,-$.
/


",
'."
*&(01  $#&#&($.

2$.'3'

4#".
*&(01
1".&5"6
7
"8&(9$.
*&(01
1".&5"6

#1$.'

 $'+(9$(#'

 

 !"# $%&'(
# (' ) "*$%+,#

 :1$#1$.
$+.#$.'

6%"6
+"+$.'
,";
-$
"665$9
#
'$$
#1$
8390,$(#<  
-$
.$$..$9
#
#1$
$+.#$.'
.
(#<  :1$#1$.
#1$
8390,$(#
'1369
-$
.$+.#$9
&(
#1$
&0$'#<

.$'$(#) .=1"##&/
94%"#$/ .
#1$
+$#&#&($. >>>>>

(' ) "*$ -. 1$
%1"66$(0$
&(
#1$
+.$'$(#
.$4&'&(
+$#&#&(
&'
#
#1$ &,+30($9
.9$.
9"#$9



/
51$.$-;
#1$
"++6&%"#&(
&6$9
-;
+6"&(#&  ?".-&(9$.
="3.
1".&5"6/
51
5"'
'3$9
#1.301
$($."6
5$.
 ##.($;/
51
&'
(($
$6'$
-3#
+$#&#&($.?+6"&(#&
/
1"'
-$$(
"665$9 "(9
'1$
1"'
-$$(
"665$9
#
"-"(9(
1$.
%6"&,
&(
#1$
'3&#
"(9
+$.,&##$9
# -$
"99$9
"'
9$$(9"(#
 
.=1"##&/
6$".($9
%3('$6
"++$".&(0
(
-$1"6

#1$ +$#&#&($.
'3-,&#'
#1"#
"'
+$.
#1$
+.4&'&('


.9$.
/
36$

"(9
?  /
&#
&'
(6;
#1$
9$$(9"(#
51
%"(
-$
#."('+'$9
"'
+6"&(#&
"(9
(#
#1$ +6"&(#&/
5&#13#
#1$
%('$(#

+6"&(#&

1$
"++6&%"#&(
%369
(# 1"4$
-$$(
"665$9
"(9/
#13'/
#1$.$
&'
&66$0"6&#;
"(9
+$.4$.'&#;
&(
#1$

 

&,+30($9
.9$. 
1"4$
1$".9
#1$
6$".($9
%3('$6
.
#1$
+$#&#&($.
"(9 "++."&'$9
#1$
+"+$.
-@ 1$
+$#&#&($.
&6$9
"
'3&#
.
9$%6"."#&(
%1"66$(0&(0
,3#"#&( -$".&(0

4&'?"?4&'
#1$
&(1$.&#"(%$

6"#$
"(91&.
*&(01
1".&5"6/ 13'-"(9

".-&(9$.
="3.
1".&5"6/
51'$
"++6&%"#&(
1"'
-$$(
"665$9 "(9
3.#1$.
%1"66$(0$
&'
#
#1$
'"6$
9$$9'
,$(#&($9
&(
#1$
'3&# 1$
"++6&%"#&(
5"'
&6$9
-;
".-&(9$.
="3.
1".&5"6/
51 1"'
-$$(
"..";$9
"'
+6"&(#&

"(9
#1$
'3&#
5"'
&('#&#3#$9
(#
-;
1$.
&( 1$.
5(
&(9&4&93"6
%"+"%&#;
-3#
#1.301
1$.
"##.($;
",
'."
*&(01?

+6"&(#&

(
#1$
+.$,&'$
#1"#
'1$
1"'
($4$.
0&4$(
"(;
"##.($;
#
1&,
# &6$
'3%1
'3&#
"(9/
#1$.$.$/
'301#
+$.,&''&(

#1$
3.#

#
"-"(9(
1$. %6"&,
&(
#1$
'3&#
"(9
"665$9
1$.
#
-$
&,+6$"9$9
"'
9$$(9"(#
 
#
5"'
'#"#$9
&(
#1$
"++6&%"#&(
#1"#
-;
&6&(0

#1$
'3&#
-;
", '."
*&(01
-$&(0
"##.($;/
1"'
%"3'$9
5.(036
6''
#
1$.
"(9
1$.
",&6; "(9
5.(036
0"&(
#
1&,'$6
&(
#1$
'1"95

"66$0$9
.0$9
+5$.
 "##.($;
"'
'1$
&'
 
"(9
69
6"9;
1$
#.&"6
3.#
"665$9
#1$
"++6&%"#&( "(9
+$.,&##$9
+6"&(#&

#
"-"(9(
1$.
%6"&,
&(
#1$
'3&#
"'
+$.
#1$ +.4&'&('

.9$.

36$

  '
.$0".9'
#1$
%(#$(#&(
#1"#
"'
+$.
36$


.9$.

 / &#
&'
(6;
#1$
9$$(9"(#/
51
%"(
-$
#."('+'$9
"'
+6"&(#&/
&'
(#
#$("-6$/ .
#1$
.$"'(
#1"#
1$"9&(0

#1$
"++6&%"#&(
9$'
(#
+.$'%.&-$
#1$
$A"%# +'&#&(

6"5/
-3#
.9$.

36$

 
+$.,&#'
#1$
3.#
#
$&#1$.
'#.&@$ .
"99
#1$
(",$

#1$
9$$(9"(#

&#'

5(
.
#1.301

#1$

"++6&%"#&( 1$
#.&"6

3.#/
51&6$

$A$.%&'&(0

#1$

83.&'9&%#&(

1"'
+$.,&##$9

 

".-&(9$.
="3.
1"6&5"6
#
"-"(9(
1$.
%6"&,
"(9
"99
1$.
"'
9$$(9"(#  
1$
.9$.
%"((#
-$
'"&9
#
1"4$
-$$(
+"''$9
5&#13#
"(; 83.&'9&%#&(

9
(#
&(9
"(;
&66$0"6&#;
"(9
+$.4$.'&#;
&(
#1$
&,+30($9 .9$.
1$
+$#&#&(
&'
,&'%(%$&4$9
"(9
9$4&9

,$.&#
%%.9&(06;/ #1$
'",$
&'
9&',&''$9 &/012-*  (' ) " -.13 $%+,#