← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/6124/2014dismissed

Tatvadarshi Bandhu Pvt Ltd v. Municipal Corporation Faridabad And ANR

2015-05-12Mr. Justice J.C. Verma5 pages



     

 !"## $%&'()''*&+'' +, )(-( ...

* / *&,& $,

0'1*0'(  2 '* '3'' ' (+ * ...

(&     44444 *5, 36!"$* '7 &+,0('2)

*(+ 0 * $*+ *'8+'91'2)

*(+ (&    

  &&'1(+ '001

20 *+

, *;;/ < *'00

*'( 2*:&5

&(+ &*  0  + * *9'&'1&&,5+((3

36(+ 20 +

23,((+ &'

90  9'&'1&  <=+ * *<=)

9+

+(+

90  9'& +'&'1&

0* (*  0    - '* , & 1*(+ 0 *+'&  (

(+'(9+

3, '*

&  () &) > ' 50,*2?'*'

@+'9'8' +')  (

:'* '  '&6 (2'00 **

:'* &':

&&'*6( 1'

(+'( *& &, **:

(  "'00*

 '

(,'1:'(* A'&'1&(+ '((

,:&('

& B , & 1*(+ (&2 (+ (+ *+' 2+'&,*5 (+'( (+ &'3&1,( 16 

(6*'00 *'&

&, (2(+ 20 *+

2+'& :

9 (+'&0

01 ' + &('31 &+ 0&&   (+ &, (1' '  &, +'11 &('31 &+

 2'001

 , *;;;; &'  *&

8,   '5'

&(  (+ ' (&2  * (&  +

2  +'  3

   /'1

(6' 1 5'1 (6(+ *& &'&& *(  , & 1*3(+(+ 0'*(

&+') 3

+ '*9+ 0 *,& 5(+

0'0 *37'   &

5(+ '

(,'1:'(* A' '((

5

,:&('

& # , & 1  *  (+  0 *  &

5  &,00*(  *:  

      

   

+'& ,*5 (+'(9+ 9 (+* 5'*(

(61' '&'1&((+

'

(9+ (+ ('11& '0'*(

,1'*@+'&*' ,:3 ** (2(+ '00 - ** &('31 &+ 5

(6(+ 1'  2

&&'*69 *2 0* ( '& 2'

(&'* 16  (+

01'

+' '&, (*&

5'

0 *:'

( 8,   + '11 &('31 &+   0&&    06    01'

(  C A,* "<D  '*16 '1&(+'( 1'

:(+ 20 *+

2 &3'&  0,* +'&  5+'& &9'&C ,7+('D1' & (,'(  ' 50,*9+

0'*(

,1'*@+'&*' ,:3 *'&B=E%% &:

'*'&B' (+

01'

(** '6*

'* '00

'&3 19!

FB  !" #$%"

&'(%) "*$+,$-*%&,./ "% 012!! 3*"(%&,. &.

 &"4 (5 "& ( *$&,

*%*#*,(**"  * #&++.*,,.'(% %3 &%&) ,$", 4"&+,.4& )," %() &,",$-(,$%64++"#&$* %*.&" *%*$"+*$**$$ *$ 7077#&$*$)(3*,  2 %*.&" *%*$4& *

&)* *.&" %%8 *+ &,$4".&#*, '

6"&)+'""*""&,&3&+%+68!" #$%"

&+"'(%) "*$ ,%*3*"(%&,. &.

 &"4 (5 (  / "% 012!!  %3     %('  ",    4"&  #&$*  , *% %*.&" *%*$"+*$**$$ *$ 7077%*.&" *%*$4& *

&)* *.&" %%8 *+ &4& ++)," %() &,"8-(,$%64++",$ 4& '&++%" 4%$"*" *%,"&$*-*%&,.$)(3*,   *'

6"&)+'""*""&,4"$*+&#*%*$  *'(%) "*% )'&*" - *"+*$**$"%**,)+"*$ *%*4& 

  &%&) ,$,$%('- "," 4"& #* -**,  ) 4,*%"8  ) "

%*%"8  -&"*$%"  &,   3+  +,$  

%*#*,(*  *"  *  ,,.'(%  &,  %*"'*)    / *4   1  ++ 3*"(%&,.1 &.

 &"4 (5 "& ( *$&, *%*#*,(* *"  * #&++.*,,.'(%8* "&+,$ &" %&) 9%&$-$

*#*,$%"4*%*&,'

6"&)+'""*""&, / "%012!!

3&,3*"(%&,. :&.

(5 (  *"&$/ *4  1 *6 $)," %() *$ *-(,$%64++"8%3"8'&++%""

$*'&) *$&, */ "%;&%$4%&4* / %& 772 -&

 *3(  &,, *-"&" - *"+*$**$"4"

",) &,*$&, *,3*  #$%"

&,$ *'""*""&, '+&, &

)3',6 "-**,"

4,&, *"&$/ "%;&%$4%& 4&  )," %() &,"  *%*,   ("8  *  '+&, &

 )3',6  &"

4,*%  &,  '""*""&,    / "%  012!!  3&,  :  &.

(5 "& ( *$&, *%*#*,(**"  * #&++.*,,.'(%8* "&+ ,$ &" %&) 9%&$-$G  (  & 

(  *:  (+  '3)  01 '

5&  (+'(  &('31 &+

&, (1' +'&3

1'

+'& :

(+'&0

01 ' &('31 &+ 0&&  ) *'0'*(

,1'*1' 5 0'*(

,1'*@+'&*' ,:3 *&2'  ( '9+ &0 &:'

'3,(

(6 01 '

5&* '001

 , *;;;; & '  2:'7 5&,3& ('001

 , *;;/ < '9 (+?

 # 2 & (+ 53,('

(,& '5

6(+

,*(*

 

* (+ '5

6(+ ,*( ' (3

,& *

 

*'0'*(6 3& *)'(  &(+ 19 ,*(

*'* *6'0(' 9 (+'00*)'1

** )' ( 0*(  2'* 0*,

'&3 19!

F *"(&  "-**, &+*$ %'*%3,*, &,<(,) &,-6 '+&, &

"  $* *,$, "-*%*" %&,*$ %3&, *% *%&,.&, 

*&%'*)* (+'""*""&,*,<63*, #*% *"(& '%'*% 6,$

*6-* (% *%%*" %&,*$ %3%*3#&,.,$$*3+&"

&,. '&++%"4& *+*) %+) &3,*6"#*% *"(& '%'*% 6,36 '&,&,& &"&3'*% &#*, *'%  ''+&), !'+&, &

  '%#*& ")"*-6+*$&,.)%*$&-+**#&$*,)** " '%#*

*&") (+4,*%&,'""*""&, *"(& '%'*% 6,$

&"%&.

"%* -*'% *) *$ %3&,#"&, $* *,$, " &"

"* +*$+4  - *'% &*"%*'*,  5*'+* '%#*

*&%)+&3% ), %$&)  *%")+&3-(  *"3* " -* "(''% *$  -6  *#&$*,)*  )+  33&""&,  ),  ,+6  -* ''&, *$ ""&"  *)(% ,$,   &+++)(,&,)"*%  )%* **#&$*,)*,'%  *& *%'% 6,36'&,&,&, '%*"*,  )"* *%* &"  ,  %*=(&%*3*,    &"  &3*    )+ 33&""&,-*"*,  $*3%) * *'%'*% 68'%*'%* *"& * '+,4 &) &"'%&3%&+6-+&. %6, *'%  ''+&), !

'+&, &

",#&*4 -#*$&")(""&,8 *''+&) &,&, ,$ " ,$"$&"3&""*$G = ( &,*(+ *(3  (

(+'( &&'( &

9 (+(+ &* *

&&'1+ &'001

 2(+   ( , 9 (++ & ) (,*

)7 58,*

,*(*

 

*+ :'

, ** 36(+ *:'

' '001

 **

9(+ &'

* *+ &'(( :0((+ 9'&&(* 516* &( 36(+

(?

1162(+

90 9'&  <= E

'    (+  01'

  (+'(  3, '*

&    (+  ) &  '*

2 & ('* )' (  &

*'(  '((+ &&('5 9+ +'&

)7 8,*

&,*(:'7 5&0

'&& *(  (+'( (

&0

0*( 1' 0,* +'& *: (&) *& 9+  9  '11 16   0&&   '   (+,&  9 :0 (  ( 

 ( ( < @

5

9(+ (('1 (6'

(&' 

,:&('

&2(+

'001

 :) *'00 *' (+ '( *2 **

9 & (+ 5 1& 3,(') (,* (+ &:

+9*(+ (+ (&

7 *) ,*(*

5

* (*&,&('

' &,00*( 5 (& ',&  ?

1162' *:

5(+ *&C A,* "'

"BD2(+ &*  0  23

5 ) :

(2  

       I'5,((J  K+ (+

0*( *&1 '10'0 *&:'63 '119 (&

8,5:

(L &  K+ (+ *(3 ** ((+

0*( *&* (L B K+ (+ *(+ 8,5:

(&+,13 0*(  &(L &