High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15130/1994allowed

B.B.M.B & ANR v. Vipin Kumar & ANR

2017-01-19Mr. Justice Darshan Singh12 pages

!"#"$% & '

()*+

*% ,-*./

!"#

$% /0 "

# #& & '( )

# *

+ # "' # , , -' )

) . / "' #01 '(

. / 01 ''

$%,& 2

( #3 " # & & &4 &

& 5%%5%678# #

& #

# " # ! 9:,; + #<

%6=>. / 01 #( &

9=5(

" "' #

@& ' &( # '( # & ' #

# :5A ' & 'B

98%5%676 ##

" ''

$%,& &#

#( B

# ""' # #( #

## ! 9.1.''1 '

5%%5%678 ! 9.1.''1 ' ' ' " # '(

=6 %67= & %757%66= ! # ' # #( "

"' # & C& &

' & / &0 /#

0+ & & #

&#' & #'

,& !<D !

!' <

& ) .)1 !'< # !# $

#.!

" 1 $

# "&- !

)

."-!)1 ")&#& 8%58%66% & & . 1+ # %65695%E #'( & C( ' & !' < & & & ##( 5%5:%67% ## & & &, ", 5%56%679 &

## 8556%678 & & & ' '

" # '(

F& !'< )&9(:

+ !<D !".!

" !'<

# (%678!'B

#( G@ G

< & C?"& - !

)

!# & # # & ( %665 & " &

& #

"' #' %66= '(

& '( & H "' # &#

' & / &0 /#

# )#

< ) '( !' < $

# &

'( &+ & & ! 9:,; ' # & # ' # ! 9:, ;;; &

' ) # ! 9:,;;; & # #'#

+&## #

! 9:,;;;

& # ' "' # C& B &

F& &

# # & # ) #'B

#( & ' @ ''( "' # ) &

& #( ## # & &, ", " &#' #(

& '

& & " #( #

'# #& H

& & &&# ' #(

!'< ) &

&& &

) # . 1 & &

# #

! ) &

I + +%675!)%%:4.%6>61=!))==5 & B ## ! ) # "

# #( ) &

( ' . 1 " & ' + #<

%6=>4"

%6EE )

#) #! ." ( ! 1 # %6E: D B &4 & ) & '( &

(@ & &

#( # ' )

# *

! 75 .%1

(

( #& (& ##' '( )

$ '% %6EE"! ) '

I *

& #( )

)

@ ( ,&

& ! ) # ##& 285 '

! 75.!1

&' $ '% %6EE '

& & # # .1 .

1 >6.%1+ (

B'( 75.!1 '

(%:

%6>E &#'

& & ( & #(

" &

' 75.!1 B & '

&& #(

& &# #' #(

+ (

# ' ' ( & #( #( #(

&# ##( +

& #(

(

D ( & & ( & #(

&# ##( ##( & #&

3 "! ) # &, #(& & ##& '# /&0 ('#

', & &, #( # &

# '

+ # < " ) #

#& #

" &, #( '

(

&#'# ' & #(

& ( (' + == &##

& ' #

& ) # ##& 2== " H $=:5: %6>7 &

# #(

& &, #( ( " # J# J # '

#( &#

&, #( + &, #( B # #( '( 9:.%1 + #<

) K-(,

(

( #& #

+ #G #(

%6=E3

#( &, #( ## ! 9:.%1 ) #

2-(,

3 &

(

( #& #

+ # G #(

%6=E " '

# #& '( ! ) H ##&

( & # ##B#( ! 9:,; ! 9.1.''1# #$ (

&C ' &

" (

( ! 9:,.91 &# ' & ) ' & # %55& ! 9:,&#

# ) #

&&#

' '

# B#

! 9:,;

' &## '

! 9:;;;

' # ##( '( &

& ## '# " ( & &

, &

&# <

) # !

D -')

# %668.81-97>#

& & &.H# ! 1 ! 9: ;;; &# ' #'#

! 9:,;C&# #

< !

%66= .81 !)" 75

#( # #(

.1"< # & &, #( D

& ' " #

C& (& &

' " & &

( & && #( #(

&# ! &&#

#& '( "' # ''

F & & &

+ &

@ "' #

& '# #& ' "

#&B #( #"

,& & %678 ' = ( & # # ! 88).91 %85=%67>#

( '& @, # ) "

, & ##( # # ( &, ", ## 8556%678 & & L

@ ,9 &

@,8 #M" #

# '( ( & %% E:5?,

)+ %676

& & # # #( @ ( & & '(

+ # $%>= %676 #/ G@ G

<C?"-!) <

!# .C10 " & & 9759%66= & ) ##

& '#

" # ! %5.%1.)1

' ) # #' & '#

' #( # '

# # & '# "

# #( ' # -' #& L , " $

( .95551 9 !)) =::

G@ G

! #

.95591 %5 !)) %E> !

.95561%8!))>=EM

'# '(*

'( # # #

#( # #( ' &

#(& #(

## #( ' ' '( # #

(

#(+ '

F& # #

" "' # ##

# '

'( (

&# ' &

'(#& " '(

F & ' "' #' &B &&+ & # ' "' # &

&' & &# # &!? !

& # * ) &&

5%5%%678 &# & ##8556%678+ &

#'( ' "' # & #( 8 && # "# (

) 985>95%E##

") B(

' #N '' "

& # # &

##( #

' &

& #N & " & # ' # & ' ' + @ #( %%55

& &&# &'B

#( # ) (%66% & &

' & ( & ' '( ! )

" #

& # " #

&, #( & & 8%58%679"&& #( "-!) #G #(

<& - & (%67>

&" # #

" & # ( #

F & ( ( & #( &, ' !'< ""' # &

#'( &

' '

" &#' '# & '

'( "' #

&' &# ' & + &#

( B & '

# - #( # #'(

"' # & &# ! & # # ! 88,).91 #

('( #

' ' D

F & # # %85=%67> ( &''( # '(D9#9 ))

& & &# %676 & #

& # ( ##(

# ' &

##(

# #& " ' & %678 #

# (

%676&#

F& ''(' # #'( #'( '

# # # # ! 88,).91 %% E:5?, " ' '

(

& &

# ' ##'# ! 88,) .91

& #

&#'

# & &# & &

# & 0 & &

# # # # # ' # & (

# # " &# ##&

F& (

# ! 88,).91

& & # # (+

! 88,).91# ('# #

' &

& & + & ## ( # '#( '((

'( $ #N @

##(

" ( & &#'#

' B '#

& G@ ' ##&

& & ' 1/2 #