High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/6423/2015dismissed

Ram Kumar & ANR v. Hari Ram & ORS

2019-04-01Mr. Justice Arun Palli4 pages

!"# $#%&'&()

* !+,-+!.!($!("/#.

#"&"&(#.'

0#.'-'

!.&!+!($"/#.'

#'1($#("'

) 2 3 4 3 4 .#'#(") .4//!5.!6 $0%!"#6

."/#1#"&"&(#.' . /!.$7!86 $0%!"#6

..#'1($#("'( 669!($*"

3 46 .!:

; "/&' 1#"&"&(6 "/# 1#"&"&(#.' %/!::#(<# "/# .$#. "/# :#!.(#$".&!:-." $$&"&(!:&0&: -$<#64#(&. &0&'&(6!('!6$!"#$

6 5; 7/&%/6 &.'":;6 !( !11:&%!"&( &:#$ 5; .#'1($#(" ( 1:!&("&

-($#..$#. -:#

"/#/!'5##(!::7#$6"/#.#5;

&+1:#!$&(<"/#'&'"#.' "/#1!."&#'$!-</"#.' $# #($!("( 6 !5- !+6(7$#%#!'#$67/&%/1!." "/#.$#..//!5.!'-5+&"'"/!""/# 1#"&"&(#.'(:(<#.7&'/"%/!::#(<# ('#=-#(":;6 "/# %/!::#(<# " "/!" 1!." "/# .$#. &'

$&'+&''#$!'7&"/$.!7( 7#0#.6!'.#<!.$'"/#"/#.1!." "/#.$#.65;7/&%/!( !11:&%!"&( &:#$5;.#'1($#("(

-($#..$#.-:# "/# 6 /!' 5##( !::7#$6 "/!" .#+!&(' "/# 5(# %("#("&(6 '-%/ !11:&%!"&(/!0&(<5##( &:#$!"!'"!<#7/#("/#'-&"7!'!%"-!::;.#+!($#$ 5;"/#!11#::!"#-."""/#".&!:-."6!8-$<+#("!($$#%.###!.:&#.

/!0&(<5##(1!''#$&( !0-. .#'1($#("(

/!".$#. "/#:#!.(#$!11#::!"#-."&'$!"#$9

6"/# 1#.!"&0#1!." 7/&%/.#!$'!' ::7')> /#8-$<+#("!($$#%.##-($#.!11#!:6!.#'#"!'&$#/#'-&" &'.#+!($#$""/#".&!:-." .$#%&'&(!

.#'/!

"#..#%!'"&(< "/# &''-#' !' 1#. "/# 1:#!$&(<' "/# 1!."&#' !($ <&0&(< 11."-(&";""/#1!."&#'":#!$"/#&..#'1#%"&0##0&$#(%#6&

'$#'&.#$!""#.7-:$5#$#%&$#$!

.#'/!

"#."!?&(<&(" %('&$#.!"&("/##0&$#(%#!:.#!$;(.#%.$!($!(; .#'/ #0&$#(%#6& :#$4&(%#"/#+!""#.&'!:.#!$;=-&"#:$6"/# :#!.(#$ ".&!: -." &' $&.#%"#$ " $#%&$# "/# %!'# !' #@1#$&"&-':;!'1''&5:#61.# #.!5:;7&"/&('&@+("/' .+ "/#$!"# !11#!.!(%# "/#1!."&#'5# .#&"A /-'6"/#'-&"&"'#:

7!'.$#.#$"5#$#%&$#$!

.#'/!

"#.

.#%!'"&(<&''-#'67&"/"/#1!."&#'":#!$"/#&.#0&$#(%#6(!"-.!::;6"/#.#! "#.

$+&""#$:;6"/!".$#.7!'(#0#.%/!::#(<#$5;#&"/#.1!."; /#!11:&%!"&(7/&%//!'(75##(!::7#$%1; ((#@-.# >6&''##("/!0#5##( &:#$5# .#"/#:#!.(#$".&!:-."(

&#!5-""7+("/'!

"#."/#.$#.1!''#$5;"/#:#!.(#$ $$&"&(!:

&'".&%" -$<# " &' " 5# ("&%#$ /#.# "/!" "/# !+#($+#(" '-</" 5; .#'1($#("(

&(/&'1:!&("6&'""/##

#%""/!""/#<& "$##$'5;

7/&%/ !5-!+(!"-.!::;$-.&(</&':& #"&+#<& "#$!1!." "/#'-&"

1.1#.";""/#1#"&"&(#.'/#.#&($# #($!("'(!($9&("/#'-&"6%-:$ ("/!0#5##('<& "#$6&(0&#7 "/# !%""/!""/#1.1#.";&'!%"-!::;

!(%#'".!:6%1!.%#(!.;1.1#."; .//!5.!6:#!.(#$%-('#: .1#"&"&(#.'6'-5+&"'5# .# "/&'-.""/!""/#'-&"/!0&(<5##(&('"&"-"#$( B

6"/#!11:&%!"&( +0#$&("/#;#!.

6&# ;#!.':!"#.6-1(.#+!($ "/#%!'# .+ "/#!11#::!"#-."6&'/&</:;5#:!"#$!($"/#.# .#("'-'"!&(!5:#&("#.+'

"/#1.0&'"-:# .$#. "/#6!($"/#.# .#"/#&+1-<(#$ .$#.$#'#.0#'"5#=-!'/#$("/!"<.-($!:(#

. /!.$7!86:#!.(#$%-('#: ..#'1($#("'( 669!($* " 6 ( "/# "/#. /!($ '-5+&"' "/!" 0&$# "/# .$#. "/# :#!.(#$

$$&"&(!: &'".&%" -$<#$!"#$9

6"/#".&!:/!0&(<5##(.$#.#$" .#%++#(%#67&"/#0#(&''-#'"5#.#%!'"6!($%('#=-#(":; .#'/#0&$#(%# "5#:#$6"/#".&!:%!(("5#'"!"#$"/!0#%++#(%#$6!($%('#=-#(":; "/#1.0&'""/#!

.#'!&$1.0&'&(7-:$("%+#&("/#7!; "/# .#'1($#(">1:!&("&

!0&(<%('&$#.#$"/#+!""#.6"/-</.//!5.!&'!5':-"#:; %..#%" "/!" 7&"/ "/# 1:#! "/# 1.1#."; !::#<#$:; 5#&(< !(%#'".!: %1!.%#(!.;1.1#.";!:7!;'/!0&(<5##(!0!&:!5:#""/#1:!&("&

!""/# "&+#7/#("/#'-&"7!'.&<&(!::;&('"&"-"#$&("/#;#!.

6!($"/#.# .#

;#!.':!"#./#'/-:$("5#1#.+&""#$""!?#"/!"1:#!6!'&"7-:$("5# !1:#!7/&%/7!'"!?#( ."/# &.'""&+#$#'1&"#$-#$&:&<#(%#/!0&(<5##( #!.:&#.#@#.%&'#$67-:$'&+1:;6#0#((2"#%/(&%!:2<.-($'6("5#!5:#" $&'!<.##7&"/:#!.(#$%-('#: ."/#.#'1($#("'65#%!-'#(%#"/#.$#.

.#+!($&(<"/#'-&"""/#".&!:-.".#+!&(#$-(%/!::#(<#$!($"/#".&!: 7!'"!%"-!::;.#%++#(%#6"/#!11:&%!"&( &:#$-($#..$#. -:# 9 %!((" 5# '"!"#$ " 5# (# "/!" /!' 5##( &:#$ !

"#.

%++#(%#+#(" "/#".&!:6'!'"+!?#"/#5!.%("!&(#$&("/#'!&$.-:# 1#.!"&0# 50&-':;61.!%"&%!::;'1#!?&(<6&"&'!2"#%/(&%!:'&"-!"&(2&(

!0-. "/# .#'1($#(">1:!&("&

6 5-" (# 7/&%/ &( +; 1&(&(6 "/# 1#"&"&(#.'>$# #($!("'%!(("!0&$ 7#0#.6.#'1($#("(

/!0&(<"!?#("/!"1:#!

;#!.'!

"#."/#'-&"7!'!%"-!::;&('"&"-"#$6&("/#1&(&( "/&'-."6"/# %'"' ' 6

C>!7!.$#$""/#1#"&"&(#.'5;"/#".&!:-."67/&:# !::7&(<"/#!11:&%!"&( .#'1($#("(

6&'"1!:".;!'-+!($ "/#.# .#6".#1#!"67&"/"/#1:#!!:7!;'/!0&(<5##(!0!&:!5:#""/# 1:!&("&

#0#(!""/#"&+#7/#(/#.&<&(!::; &:#$"/#'-&"&("/#;#!.

&"&'%('&$#.#$!11.1.&!"#"/!"7/&:#$&'+&''&(<"/&'1#"&"&(6"/#%'"' &+1'#$5;"/#".&!:-."5##(/!(%#$"'

C>67/&%/7-:$5#1!&$ 5; .#'1($#(" (

!' ! 1.#>%($&"&( " /&' !11:&%!"&( .

!+#($+#("5#&(<!::7#$!"-.!::;"/#.# .#6& "/#%'"'!.#("1!&$6"/&'

1#"&"&(7&::&( !%"5#".#!"#$"/!0#5##(!::7#$!($"/#!11:&%!"&( &:#$ -($#..$#.-:# "/#$&'+&''#$ /#!

.#'!&$ %'"' 7-:$ 5#1!&$ "1#"&"&(#.( (:;6 (!+#:;6 !(!?!861#"&"&(#.( 6!+,-+!.6!:.#!$;/!0&(<7&"/$.!7(

.+"/&'1#"&"&(6!'.#%.$#$&("/#.$#.1!''#$5;"/&'-."(9*

D/#"/#.'1#!?&(<C.#!'(#$ #'C D/#"/#.#1."!5:# #'C