High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/6012/2018dismissed

Balbir Singh v. Shiromani Panth Akali Budha Dal And Others

2025-05-16Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal12 pages

!"!#$ %&!&! '( "$!) ! &$*+ ! $ , -.

/ +$ &

&$ %0& *# 1 '!- 1"$ ) 2*

&23&$0&!&!

!2"!*

&.!&$

*)0"!#$2*

&23&$0& 444 /$0&!!0&!&!!! & !&&$ & 5 0 1&$&3 !!6# 6,!2/ ! "

2 ! .$!

$ &$ 00!

&! 3! 1 0&!&!3 & 3 0&&!# ,', ! &$ 7 )! &! 3 8

,1 "!#$ &$ .!&.

- & * !& *7 3

&! & &$ 33 & &$ & 0&0 !&!339 "$!) ! &$*+ ! $ , -.

/ +$ & &$ . ! 0! 3 !& & ! '!

# / ! "

2 ,!&!

&$! 31 ! !&$0 !& &$ &&!&&$ & 1 ! &$ 1 .

1 3 )& &! 8! & 5 3 &$ &

& "!#$ ! 3 3 &$ 0&!&!3 & . !# 2 ) !0 & 3# )&2 .

3! 8!&& & &)&

*7.

3!1!#&$ )&) !&$0 !&

/$ & ! 3 &$ )& ) ! &$ 0 !&2 ! &$ .!&&& &)& &3) $ 3&$003 !!3&$ !& &!!0&!&! 2&$32&:!& 3& ; ,!#&$0 13&$!&2 00!

&! *7; ) 1 &$ 0&!&!3 & & 0& ,', ! # !#3&$# &$!# &/ !"

;53 00!&)&3 &$ 0&!&!3 & 00 "

$ < 3 $ ,

& "!#$ &$,', # &$# &$!# 5.$!

$&+0

!&$"0&)07 $ , !

$2 &!

.$0&!&!3 &.

00!& &$;&$< 6 &$ 3 &$"$!) ! &$*+ ! $ , - / +$ & !# &!#! 1

& "!#$ & 8

,1 "!#$ &$ .!& .

) =&.

!&$ 00!

&!&$ &8

,1 "!#$$ & 7 )! !$! 7 )! &!$$ )!&&&$ & 52

-"!#$"

9 ) $ .!&&&$&!3&$ 0 !# ;5 $ )!&&$!!# &&$!#! 0$&& & 01 3 &$ ! 0 !#(&! /$ ! )& $

1 0 >7, =& .

&$ & ;52 )!$ 00 0$&# 0$$ & + /$! 3

& $ )!&& 1 8

,1 "!#$ ! $! 7 )! &! 0$&# 0$& $ ) +?,@=&$ 3&$

)!&& ! $! 7 )! &! &$ & 52 &$ .

# &$!# & &!

2.$!$$!)3.

0&&$ &$-!& 3* "!#$2 $ ! 6 #!$ "!#$2 $ - "!#$ A + A )-!& "!#$ .

03) < )!&& &$ & &$ !

! .2 0$&# 0$.& + !.

00 =&.

&$ &!

!.&$

&#!

)!!2&$,', & !!#&$!00 ;5 5.& 0&&&$ !.!& $$ &

3&.!&$&$ )=&.

&$ &&$ !7 !.

3 -!

&!3&$ &1 &.&$0 &! /$ 00!

&! .

00 1 .

1 3 01 *7 2 .$!0!)! 1 - &! # &$0!!3" &! ;* 3&$ =!

>! &2 5 3 $&&$ B>! &C . & +.$!0

!#!

0&$-#)&3 ! & $3&$! &!&$

" !#$" %& =&.

&$ &&$! !# & )0.!&$ & 1 0!&3&!) &$ &3&$ )!! !!&13&$ &!

2&$ .

!. 1&$!&$ & 3. &$ )&.! 5 '!&$!)0# &5 0 1&$&3 !!6# 6,!2/ !"

2&$ 00!

&!.

- & !#&&$3!!#3&$0&!!0&!&! D 3&$0 &!.$ E

'!- 1 "$ ) 2 0&!# &$ 0&!&! &1#&$ &&$&!

&$ !!)!!#&$ 00!

&! =&.

)!&&&$ &8

,1 "!#$$ 1 )!&& &&$ &3 ;5 5 2&$ ! )& 2&$.

! 3 &$ &!

& & $ !!& 0 &$ 0 &! 3 &$

&!3!

&" &! 3&$>! &=&.

)!&&&$ &&$ ! &!3!

& 0 & 1 & # 2 0 &!

&!) $ 3!73&$ )=00&3$! &&!2 0

0&$3.!#-#)&

! "#$%#&"$"'( ""

$ "$"')

; "

* * + ( '",-&"$"' ( ".

$, "$"' /

0 ( + !)

1* 2 3/ +&+&'&"$"" ( ", $.

"$"" /

0 ( !) '

4//1 4// "#"#&"$"" ( '

"$". /

0 ( !) ( * 4 +4! "##"&"$"" ( "% $'

"$"./

0 (+ !) *1 +78*+29 (

++!&,-&"$, : + ;<<&'%#6-&"$". ( "% $6 "$"'/

0 (4 !) - 31* 3/ &"$#,&"$""( ", $, "$""/

0 ( !) % ;3 1 1 1 2 "$"$!- ) ,

1* 2 3/ "$"""! !-.%)

2 "

!2 "!0&!# &$0&00&$0 1) 1 3&$0&!&! =&.

)!&&&$ &!&)3&$ .&& 1&$*07& 1&$! &2 &$ ,', & 0& & &$ .!& .!&$& 0 !#

&!3!

&" &! 3&$>! &D "! )!&&&$ & 1 )!!) !#&$ 3&$&!

.& &!&&$0&!&!&0&&$,',.!&$&00 &$&!

&!!

) &" &!;3&$>! & !&.

)!&&&$ &! &$ 0&!&! !& & 3&( & !

& &$ .!&2 &$ &!3!

" &! 3 &$ >! * & .

= 00& 3 $!

&&!2$0

0&$3.!#-#)& 5 *

=5 (> 5 3/"$-!%

#%) "

+** *( "$%! " %$)

1 ( 0

+ *"$,!- ##) '

;

0"$'!$ '-.) <

= 3/"$-! -.' 5 "$6" !%-$

0 ( =$ !&$ )!!) 1 3 &$0 &! $ 0&$0 0 +

3 &!#&&$)!&3&$!0&2!&. 00!& & !317 )!&$& &&10!! &$ .&$ - &" &! 3 &$ >! * & .!&$ )!! !!&1 3 &!

" &!

; .!&$ 3!$!# 3 &!3!

& .$ & &)& ! ! 1!&3&$0!!3" &! 3&$>! &!& #! 6#0 ;* / ( (( ??? ??? ??? '!@ <( *

(/ ( ( (

&! ( (( (

* ( / *

(

<()/!

(< ( (

<( ( ((*/<<< <<

( (( <(/ (*<)(! * ( ( * /&( "! << / / < ((< < / ( < < (* *

( ( <<< ! / ( * ( () << /&( / ( */ / / < F&$2" &!;*0! '#;

A< 8?* 8( (8 ( > <( (* < * * * (*< ( ( ( * < 8?* 8( ( 8 ( ( -,&; @ * ( ;("$$$""$$$! ( B " &! ; .!&$ 7 )! &! & 0! & &)&!.!&!# C'# &?* < *

; * / (&?* < * */ * ( * D ( /

* / < ) / ( ( * / * /

( /< /(< ( /<<( ( * B /$ ." &! 3&$>! &.

!. 1 &$ 6# $ 3 &$ "0) & 3 =!

! ;

0 0 /$0! !0 ! !!# 3&$*07&.

# &$ & ) 3 )!! 3 &!

/$ 0!#0 3&$-#)& &!3170 !&$! !!# 3&$ *07& C ( /

( / 4 ( / < < / () < / * / ( 2 (

5 / ( / ( ( * / * < ( < ( > *

* ( (( < ( < ( << B ; /$!0&$ !&3&$G > &!&&$A

D#! &! *) 1 $ ; /$ 0& 3 &$ "0)&3=!

&&> D#! &!*) 1 &!& 1 < .

! & 00& 1 &$ H!& ,) &!

F& /$ 00 & * ' $ && &$ &! !0&

! &2 #1 00& 1 &$ D3& ,) &!

F&/$!7&$0& 3&$"0)&3=! &$ $!3 > &! *#& 3 &$ 3!& 0& /$ 00 & .

!&)3&2.$ &$&3&$&& 3!

! & 1) #! &> &!3&$3!&0&.

$ # 1&$ 00 & $ #$&

&!!$!3 /$<!#$ & $ &$ & &$ &! 0&!&! .

& ) !& ! /$ &$

&&!# ! . # ) )&(& &)& $ !# 0 !$ !&! &!&$&!& 1; # &$ $

& &3&$ 00 &*) 3!!3

&. !/$<!#$&!)!&$ &!0&!&! &3.$!

$ &$) &&

$&$"0)& *0 &3)&$ )& 1! .$!

$$ 3&$<!#$&2&$. &!

.$!

) - &) &&3) - &1 3&$*07& /$ <@ "0) & &$ .& & 7 )! &$ 0!!3&$=3) &!/ $#1* &2 $! 3&3&

&$ B=/* &C &$ >! & 8$! 3!# & &$ "& &)& 3

- & 2&$"0)&3=!

$ C.

;

(* (/ ( (( 8 (;( ( #, 6#;( / < (( ( <( <( / 7 6#0 ( 6#% * / ( ( ( <<< ( ( ( ( (* /(*< @*/

( / (

( 8 (;(

* ( ( (( ( < << ( (< < ( * ( * <( / (*< / * / (* ( * E /&( "! < <( * / ( (* ( (( ( ((*<<< ( ( 76#0"!

<( ( 76#0"!8 (;(F ! ( ( ( (

* / <( / (*< < (* <( * << ( ( < /<

( (*<) ! * ( ( ( ( * ( * (*< ( ( ! 4 * < < (*< < <<

< <<* *// ( (((( ( )

! * ( (/ <( * * (*< ( ( '

7 6#0'! 8 ( ;( * <( <

( (( <* /<

( F ! * / ( ( ( ( (((

* ) /!( (*( /*

( ( (( <() (! ( ( * < ( (

<( () ! ( ( * << (/ ( * 76#0"!8 (;() !( (*/ /< ((< < / ( < < ( # @ ( < ( ( * / / + *< (( (*((*< ( ( ( (*< < *<( 4 ( 4! 5 *<(4 (5 4!< ( <

( * / ( * <( ( ; ( ( ( * <

( ((/ ( 8( ( ( / * (< / *< < ?( ( ( / <( ((( 3 ( 6 A ( (( <( *

( 6#08 (;(D ( / * ( '#;&< ?* ( ( (

- 8 (;( ( *<<* < ( ((/ ( D * 76#0 8 ( ;( (*< @ B 5 /$&$6# $3&$"0)&3=!

! !I 3 !)!

! ! &$

3 ;3 1

0 2.$!&$ !0!&!3 .&$ & &!3!

!&!0 &3&$ )!! !!&13 &!

! .

!& & =&.

$&$ &&$ &!3!

&. 1!3&$!#! )& !&3.

0 F7 )02!3&$.3 0&0 )0&2 )0& & & ) ! 0$ &0 !& &$ .!& 7 0 &$ & &$

.$!

$ &$!#! !3) &!.

& .

(0 & 1$!) /$ 3&2 &$ ) 3 -#)& 1 &$! & &$<!#$&!!!33&0 !3!

! )& E /$! & . 0 & 7 )! &$ )!& 3 &$ !& & !.$!+0!#!)!&$& &&10!! &$ . !. 1 &$*07&.$!!&0&!#&$ !0!! = &$ !& &

2 &$ 0&!&!3 & + & 3& 8

,1 "!#$ &$ .!&2 .$ . 7 )! :&1.!&$&$3 &!$ ;5 5=&!& &$

&$ &&$0 !&!33!0 !#&$ !! 3)$!!2.$! !& $ !&$ &&$ &!3!

& $ 3!$ & 1 & #! 0 &!

& #$ !. &$!10!&!$ &!

! ! -#)& <2 &$ .!& 3 &$ 0 !&!33 ! #$&& 3&.!&$&$!9 &2!&$ 7 )! &! $ )!&&&. $3 &!$ !# $&$ &3& 1 &$0&!&!3 &<.2!&$ !0!!3&$!&2

&!3!

&" &! 3&$>! &!0 2&$

&$&!

!&1 #!3&$ !

& 0 &$

! )& 2 &$ 0 !&!33 $! .!&

& 3& .!&$ &$ !3&$ !3 &!=3 $ &$!#!0)!&&2!&. 03

1 1 1 1& 3& .!&.!&$ &! ) +

33& & ! & # & 3 &$ ) /$ $ & !&! &! # &$0 1 .$) &$ &!

! ! !# 0 &$ & # & .$!

$ !& ! !# 0 /$! ! $ 0!) !1& 0 1&$0&!&!3 & &$.!&3&$ !&!33 1& 3&.!&$!& &&&$#$&$1 )!& $3 &!&$ & +0

=&$ !0!!3&$! &2 $ !

& 0)!&& & 0& & .!& .!&$& 3!$!# &!3!

.!&$&$0!!3" &! 3 &$>! & = $ # &$#$ &$ -#)& ! 0 1 &$

3 &$ 0&!&! In the case of * <! !. .

& + 1 "!# $ 3 &$

1 $ <!#$ &&$ & .!&$&&$0 &! 3 &!3!

& " &! 3&$ >! &2 &

&! & 0 /$ 0 &! 3 &$! .

& 1 1 &$ <@ *07 & ! & ; !"D9 ;=&$ !0!!3&$!&2&$ ! !!#!&$ !-#)&.

!33& !&.

.$ .!& $ 3& .!&$ ) &!

! &$ 7 )! &!/$/ # <!#$&&+ !.&$ & &!3!

& " &! 3&$>! & 3! & 1& #/$! ! !0&.!&$&$ ! &!3 . &!&.& !

.$ .!&!& 3&.!&$ &!

!# 7 )! &!

F &$ ) 2 &$ -#)& 3 &$

<!#$ & ! 5 (

0 .& 3 1 !&&$0&!&!*"!# $3&$,$! <!#$&&+ !.!&$

3*1 0 &$ &3!!#3

&!3!

& " &! 3 &$ >! * & .

0 :!)& !&3!!# &&$&!)33!!#3&$!&.

3 & /$! ! . & 001 & &$ 3

& 3 &$ 0&

.2 &$32 & 1 ! & &$ 0&!&! > &$.!2 &$ -#)& 3 &$ ! & $ 3 &$ <!#$ & $ 1 0 ! $ $1 &1 1 ,!!! $3&$! &! &$

3 < 1 E @ ! '

( '

)2*+,-*+*./ 0

0"*# &$-#)& 3 "!# $3&$!&!&$

3 1*2 0 2&$ !.

3 !

)0 &$ !#.

& 3!$ !&.

&$'!#!

.$$ #$&!

)0* - &!.

! 1 &$

2 .$!

$ .

&$! .

0$ 1

! & $3&$!&$!#&$ &&$:!)&3 &!3!

& " &! 3&$>! &. ! &.$&$ !# 0 !! /$!-#)&. & )&&$ !3 &$0&!&! !&$!

!#0 !! 1!

)0.#$&& & + = !. 3 &$ 3 ! 3

& ! )& 2 &$ !& & !!0&!&!!3& !3)!& !

!#1!)! !# 00!

&! 2!3 12$ & !03 ! "

#./.1/,+*./ 0

0 # Whether speaking/reasoned :

Yes/No 8$&$0& J(9