High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/6345/2013disposed of

Jagdev Singh v. Ranjit Singh

2015-03-03Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain16 pages

# $%&

!" # $ '()* +,%'-./ (012( ! %!&'# "!()& ) !$! !!$$!

(012(3 *$!$$!"!+$" !!

&-"! .,)$'(/-" "!)0!'( -"$! 0!(11"+" 1'( !$0

$!$0"

&'! '2!

!!0)

!0!'" !

&' !!$)!

!$0+$1) 0 !)$$! +0$11"'3"

! / ()02"$0)0 !)$$!

! !$ 4) !

"+ 1! "1 ! $!0!! 5! "1 ! $! "'+ !$! !+111+"! 21, +!1 ! 1 1 ! 6 )

)

7. ,

)

7.0!$!+(*1 !! ! 10 -

00+""1 $! 0- ,

&!$ 1 1. ! ! -)" !$'(0( $

!+ !+110 1,

*+0 +$!+ ,,

*+$!+0!"0! 9 ' +$!+)0!0$'(% 52&1) 5")

:!+ +$!+)$!0 $('1+"002 !+! $( !!0! !+"!&"+ )8 )

7.0$ 6

)0! 8)

)

7.0!$" 0 !$

'(+$ ) 1.0 -"'(!$:!+

/ 5 1 !

&"!&)6,8 !!);&;) 0! !+52&1 1:+'! -"'1 1"!+'113" (! 1")$$1!-"$! $ !$! 6 )

)

7. 1 ! 6 )

)

7. +! 0 +$!+' !% 52&1)111. '! !)$! 1-"

& !$0 !) 1"

)11 !+ 11 ,

+$!+ !!

4 1 "

!! ! +"* !$ !+ 1 " + +!0+$!+ ' !52&10!0$

: -")$$1 1'(!$)$! 0! ( !! ,

11"+"0 $1"0$!!+-"01! 1'( !$

5!"1 !$!011 ! !! ,

$'(/-" "!"'+ $!$1$$1'("! !( -"$! 0 $$1'1 !0")!! $! 1-" 0!$ "!'(% 52&10+!$!"11 !0+'1*""1'!-"*

!+1 1'!)!$+!1(1 "+

0! % 52 &1 01 1 " 11 !+ 11 ,

+$!+ !!

)' 00!0$'(% 52 &19"1 0+'1)!03"

( $! -" 1'($! !" 4!1!"1 !$!$!"$$!

'2 8 * '($!)+1()-"

!+ 11 ,

1 1 ! )

)

7.)$(+ !+( 8 )

)

7.+

-" !+11)+$!+!! '0$! ,,

$ 0! '( % 52 &1

!+ "$" $$! ! !$$!

<"!! 1!"1 ! $! 0 '1 $(+

)

7.) $!$ )8 )

7.!$$ 8)

)

7." 0 !$!'(+ :"$$!)$!"!$ )8 )

7.&-"! . &-"! .

."$$! $1 8)

)

7.0! $" 0 !$

= $ )!$ 1 1.! !) $! 1-"

& !!$ 1(1 !'" +!+")!$ 1"

11 !+11,

+$!+ !! ,,

: ! ") !$ + "+ $ 0!'(% 52&1 ' +$!+!! '0$!9!$ -") $$1 0 1 '(!$ !(

$! ! !"" 1'(++ "'#+!)0$!!+)0$ &$ $1

!$)1!"! '10($! -"

, *0!$'(% 52&1

!$!"'10.

><12 "$ % 52 &1&!(

1!( +6

-' (#+/- !+ *$

/- 11'! $! 0! !11!+'"'( + !( $1

/- &! 1( 0!$"! '! "$!

5 1 !

&"!&)6,8 <1' !!!+)5"?

6 *$!

/ 5 1 !

&"!&)0!!1 )!-!'10.

"! 4.(5-.*"!11$!0 !1 ("0+!"1!1( "'11("$! "1("" '0+$!)!'0$!"!0+ (!( +1+1 "!+1 0!""$ +!(!"! : #"! !!1 1+)! ( "! '( 1+ : '1 !

" '( !1 @ !+ 12 #"!)!' ! "$!+"! > 6('2 ')(.782((..,(9 / !(0! !+52&1"! & + ! +! ! !+ 1+ !+11' 1' 11$! !$!1+ "!+ / !(0! !+52&1"! &11'+'! 1"! *0!+'( !+52&1"! &11''(+#!( $!"

!+52&1 / !(0!+'( !+52&1"!

&11' 111'113" (! 1")$$1!-"$! * !+52&1+(!+(0! +'( 1"! 11#"! " 1"!11-"!! 0!! +'("!?

*+$!

&)+"$ !! ' !4;'1 "$!+"! **+ *+')

1 :0$!0! 52&1+ '! "!))"!11$0!0!$ +!1!$'()01" $0! - + * 1(

! + $ !

! 52&1*'#$" 1 *"!1-$! 0052&1)' ! )" 0! 52&1: 1( 0!$'(52&1110'!()

!('# &0"1' *!1 $!! ! -!'10.

> :"!$)0! 52&1

11(+'! "!! ! "! 11$0!!1! !1!$'(1 *)"!$) 1"$0!-+$$!$!: "!$)0!$'(52&1 "!1 "

!! '(+$1!

+ 1 $! !

"+ "! *

+:) 4 "! 1'(0!0$" $$1!"!!'( 1 '0'!! ! !* 02 '(4 "!)"! 0)01111( '#$"!$ 5 1 !

&"!& !! 52&1+ 1 -- -- -- --

8 =52&1A B*B52&1B1 !+ #" (+ $! 1:C 1(' 20( +!(*0!C52 &1C+C $1"!C*(+' @ !$1: +$ & (+&:"!! !'"!0 '21 ! "1!"!! 1 1 ()-$ "$!"! *"!2(! !1 $( 52&1)! !$! 1! !1"!

!-$"-$ #" :52&1$! !! !

3")")!"! /-$!+ C52&1C1!+

$"1++'$:)

'1)+)

!+1 59D&&5&*!1! E::&5 E *:/*!! ( !1 ! !+1) $-$"#"+++'(0( 1 $")0!$ "!1 )0 (!"!'( ) 1'($ $!" )++ "+$$!$!'1+ $") 0 $11(!-$! %+'! *+ 1!B F E!52&1 *!"! "! 1!($ +"011'! " $"152 &1! !"1

*' "! 52&1!$!"!1

1-'1($(!1 $"*! !$$1 $!"!11012 1 !"! / &01 1+'(52

8 &1 *$!$"!1(!0 " !"

! "1 0 $'1 ! "1!"! 10 *0!'(52&1' $! " ! 1"! .$$1'10"1( 1+ $" 11( : 0 ' 1$! '(C&C 52&1!'1 $"'1( !$"1 ! +'1( &0! 52&1.

*52&111$!$ !! +$!+!1+'( 110 1 1$!$1)3"("!1#"E1+1( 52&1$0!) !("0!11 '+'! 1"!!+( '0 1 &0! 52&111'<1.

, *52&1011$0!0 $!) ! ! ! ! !!!! 0+! ) 0!$'(52&111' 1/ "! 6 B$$1111

!+!$'("!0 $!B*0! 52&1!!'( 52&1"! $!)11' +'! 1"!)! ! $$1111 !+0! 52&1 "! 6 6: -0(,(.((87(81)/1(2 (13 !!!%(215( '(21 !"3 !

)4 "! 1B*$! &11$! 1 +! 1 $$1$$10"11

, "!$! 6 52&1 ""!$+ 0!+'(52&1! $$111'

! '( $! 5 1 !

&"!&0'$ 11('!!"!

! )$$1' 1 0!"! 6 B*"! "!!

B:+(11(' "!! 1 !"! $! ! $$1"! 6 !* 1 !"!1 !$'( 1"! 1(

" 1( ' $!+ ' !() $!"1!1("!5 1 !

&"!&) 0"1+" !(+'# & 00'))01 $$1 1+'1 *4 "! &! !1) ('2'-..1 '.:(81(;(.()

'2< /'3 ')(.3 78 2((.9/-)9 4/'.('53 .'/. 7<( 4'/ -.1'.53 :(81(;(.()(2(.1' !!!# &7 ==)B* 0! !'1! 1:11 "!) "!1($"!!!0 0+2 11+$!! ! "!! 1 ! ( $" *"

0! 52&1!"1 +!#"! "1!"'("!!A ! "1!"'("!! "1!!1)0 !) 3"1$!0!+$!+011 +'

1" #" !$+$!+'11 ! "1!$$1)0! 52&1' 2 +)'11 '((! "1!!+

6 1'1"!101" 2 &!1

" :11 !! 0!( !""1! 0' 2 "0!$11( !"!0! $

*0! 52&1 1$!+ 03" 1!-"'1)+ 1 + $!? +$ "$$1 *+ 00-$!D@ D"(%

#)&:

86 * !

/ &0!!'( 4;'1 "$!+"!G#" +F!"1 : E :)

1 ) +0!"$19

!"11 !0$$1'$! 0! 52&14;'1 "$!+"!$!

$$1!:!"! "*!1 $!! -!'10.

>*!!! $$1&$$1 10(!"! " $$1$!

! $!($!"1!")'(1 +( !!"""1

./ +2 !(0! !+52&1"!

6,8&!+!!!+ 1+ 1 ' 11 $! ! $! 1+ "! + $$1 $! !+ 0!$'( !+52&1'")"! $) !! +$"

$! ""1 : !$1) ! ! "! $""$$ $"!(1+!1 $"'1"1(!

!1" "$"'( $!"!$!

.,) +$!"$"'!"

!1$!1 "!1( 1()

+!+$!1() 11$!($"

! 0! !+52&1 10($$!4 "!"!"$!

!( -!!!(#"!"!&!1

" :*! +! "'+ 1!"1 !$! "'"! 1 0"1''!"

'24 "! !0!$'( !+52&1+!?+$"$$1 4;'1 "$!+"!

&:66, 6

)01 ! $ 1"!. > $!' "! !+ $! 0!1 ("0+! " 1 !1( "'11( " $! "1( " " $! ! +!1 *0!;!1;

"' !(0+$!$"'( 4 "! : 1 1 $!1 + #"1 -+ !+ " 1 !

!+1 "! '( +$ *!'"1 &! ='!+$! !():!1/) +-+)' !!'"1 #"!) !10 1 " !! !+ " &! !"; "1!( /);!1;1") '( +$ !'"1) 3" " 1 1 $! )0! 1!!+1*"0 0"11"11$! ! !+ " $1 1

1!+'(#" +! "! =!0+ "1' 0! ;!1; ! "1 ' !" !!01( +" !1( $ "$ "! '#

$! -0"?

4;'1 "$!+"! 1 :" %1 41H"! !+0!)

$ "!1( '# $! "!

"!! #"! !++"1"1(!( 0 $!111 " !$ + "'# +! : !! 1

" 0 ! !1( "'11( 1 $! "1(""* "+10! 1 $! " " 0"1 $! "'3" " 1 $!! -!'10.

>,*'#"!1( $! "! "!! #"! !+ +"1"1( !( 0$!111"!$ ++! "*'#"!1( 0 $!111!1+"'(0"! !! 1 " 0 ! !1("'11("$! "1(" " * 1 " "

! !'1"" 1"! $$1($! !"!""!( !"*'# $! "! "!!#"! !++"1"1(!( 0 $!111"'0+$!!$ + +! " * "+1 !

)0! 1' ! $! " ") " 0"1 $! ! #""'3"" $$11( 0!01 "'#+!' "1*2(0! !> +!"!1("'11("? $! "1( " " * 0! >!1( "'11("?!"!. 0!>11(!11!11("?*! !)

0"1$$1(1( !(

+!"'")+ !'() 01 "'# +! ' $! 1?

& +0 +1! " 0 ! '( 5! 4

&:6 5!6 )0!!0$ "! $!(1 ! ! $ !$!$!()00"$1$$1* !1! 1-"9'#0! 1-"'( +! #" +'!1+ "1!!( "$! +$!$!(00++!0 $ ' !4 "! !(! !( $! 0+ "! !0 */-" "!( $! !" 3" $ ' !+$$1$ ' !4 "!:0$'( "!01( -"$! !"1+ '('#!)"!! "-!#"! # 4 "! &: 6, #

)$"!.

> *")011 $! ) 1 !"!!+!(!1 "'3"1(""'"'( ( $!(+2!3"' !"!!( " $! "1(""$ !+!

!1 "!)! !$$1!$$1 ! ! !+$ !F" !1

"'3"1(""$!0"( '#+!+01 !( #" +$!$! ! "!) ) 1 !"!!1 '" 1($!' ;!1 ";

"!! <110 "+ G F) @ $!; &: 68 $"! '#"! ) 1 !"! !1 "'3"1(""02"1

!+ $! "'# +"'+ '0 '($! $+!"'# $$1! " "'3"1("" 8 5!"1 !$!+('! "'+ $! ) 1 !"! ! +!() "! 0 +$ +$ ( 01 ( $! ")'":! ! !+-$! ( $ 3": +( 0)!1 "'3"1("" !'#"!

) 1 !"! '0 !1 )+"1'!'(

!$$11"!?

8 &1"+"$ !!' !D!1 4 "!

6 8, ) 0!3"0;0! " 2 1 !"!(") !" /-" 1'(+-"! "! $! "1( " " $ ; * "! $ ' !3"!+ !$$1 $( 0" 0 $! ! + " " !1( "'11("!"*'# 0 1

#" +9 '$$10!" 011$!!#"!": ()$! "'3""!'(40 !)"1!(' $ ) ! $$1 !"+ 1(0$!"! !( "' ! $! 1 $! #" + -!'10.

1 !"!$! "!11$!0!1 ("0 +!"1!1("'11(" $! "1(""'0+$!)!

'0$!"!0+(!( +1+ 1 "!+10!""$ +!(!"! #"! ! !1 1+*'!3"!+ !$$1

$( 0"0$!! +!$!"!$!1+ 1 "!$!!"*! ) +! " " +" ' !1( "'11( " ! " * '#

1 !"! $! "! "!! #"! !+ +"1"1( ! #" "$0"!$

+"'#+!'0+$!: 1 ' !!'(

!"!9 $$1+!

( "! 1 !"! 0! " 0"1 $! ! #"!":

)$$1( 1 !"! ) "'3"1( " " "1'(*"

$( &$$1 !$! "1(""' !$( ")" 11( $ )!$ !$$1(

1 !"! ( -" $! $! "1("" !" ("'3"") 2 1 !"!:

+!"0 $! "1("")0!$!"1 !( 011!$1 !#""'3"":

"$1'!'(0!$!) 1 ! ! ! 1(0$!"! !"$$!("' ! : $! ) !$ 0! $! 9

, 68 * !$ $1

9 ,

,(! '"'(!9 , 68 0!$!1 1 !( $!$!( 1+'(!$-" !9

, 68 *0!$! !$!'"'($! "1( ""*' ! ! + " !! '1 $! 2

1 !"!*"!'10 0#" + $$1?

, * 1 1 $ -$! '( "! !$! $! $!'"!

!+$! 0!1 ("$! "1("" 1 +"'0+$!:1 1$!1) + 0!;!1;-+!+ "'( "!*!11" $! :0"11" !+ " 1!+'(#" +* '#$! "! "!!#"! !++"1"1( !( 0$!111"!$ +"'#+! !!

1 :$$1"" 1"!*

"+1! 0! 1" "!1!0"1$!!#" 6 :)"$" !"!1!

1'($!)+!01' !52&1&0! 0$0+'!!+

/ &)-" 00"

'($!9" "'3"" 1'(!$3" !+11 1+!! '0$!' !52&1) $! -"0!( !"-"0

1"'3" 1 "*-"'3" 0" !$"!$ $$1 $!$1

!( $! -" !1!($'( "!*$!$10$! "'3""!

(! 1 #" ++"*" $! "1(""1!('

*" !$ !+

1 1" !1 "+ $ 0!'( % 52&1 !!$ 1(!1!'" +"+!<"!!!+

/ &) 0!$'( !+52&1+'! 1 "! -"'1 + +! * + ' 3"'(0( $!")$$1!-"$! = 0 !.!"!+"$! 10) !$'(1 "+ 0!$'(% 52 &1 1"11 !+11+$!+ !! '0$!

*$!$1$$1'(1!"!'10 !(

$! -"$ 1'($!011' $$1'1!0 1"$ 0 ! !+"'#+!)!!-"$ !1!($)0! 1"*! 1!($!

'-"

<!!+' )+$"

&-"! .,$'(1!"!'10 5!/-" "!!$!0-"

*! $$

#F1

" !$!!