Narinder Pal Singh v. Dharam Pal Singh Grewal
! "#$ %&' ( ")
*+ ",- .
/! - 0
*+ ",-( .
$# 34$ +$$+ 55
#5 $( 6 ") (+ ",-&)6
(
( $( 6 "!-7 "&)6
55
!2( (( - !( 6 ! "2
"7") (+
"' 8'9 (;
" - ", ",
)7,7!
&2
%( (! ", ()
(;%6 ( 1- -
) !0 !!
" *
(& "
(5 ,(7")2
02 (0
")*()- )!7,-
(0 1!-2!"
" 72
"
( " 72
0
!7( ", 22(< 0
*%3<3=!
) "+7"
0
> (&
& * 0 ",
) ; !-2!
6 ",(
)(0") "(0% !*"
*"2( *&@@!- ) !
& - "
") !
- ! ;7! "
!! " !-2! " ) !27
" ! , " % (0 ") ") - ) ;
0
-( > ) )
+ 7( 1 ") !
%* B ""
, " %3 - 1
) ) 2( !
- !
(* 70 ;7! "
!! *
"
") 0
(* 70 (2(
" % ! ;
", 0 ) ;% - 0 (0 - ! ! ) )7 %6
!-2( 00 *2*
( !!27(2!
! * - 7") (,"
1%
(* 70 7(!
"0 *
(%!
?7
A"1* ), 2
(* 70 2()7 ") , ) "!
(70 ! ) ) ! *!
) " - !
) )2( ! 1 !2 ;7 *) ", ;
( ", $CD!
) "!
)+7"
0
> (;7 *
"
;7 *) ",1 !C' E'%
(!!722(
);%;
")"
;7 *) ", 1 ! " ;
) ") " 1
;7 *) ", ( ( "!
(7 "(!
",72;7! "
!!(2 *7!
") 72
"
"
( - ) ) !0 !!
" " **1 ",,(7")!#5 ) !-2 ") !27
2(6 )"
2()7 "% ) 70
(% 6 ) () ",
** " %
+ 7(F ) *!
) - ! ;7! "
!! " %
( "
**-
-F ",C%
(! 17*)" 2!! ;* (- 0" **-
")*)
!!- ) %C%
(! " * ",
((
"2( *&@@ 22
7 % - ! ( (!
") ", 7( ")- *)
!-2!
("
) 7"!
* (
( - ! 6 *% "
")
%-
) ** **% "-*) ",
)
")*() !;"
(,7
(;% !! ",
!"
;* ( - ) ( ,- *% ) !0 !!
" (
,(7")
**-
")) % " * ",
"&
;* !- )-
%) ) 22(
!7 !!7**%2*
2(6
(% ",( !+
"898 9
(;
" &(!-( B 3 !- ! * 1!
"! "!
1 ):
!-2! ") 2(6
)0 "%2* (7" !!
(* 702()7 !"
;!
"%2(
"( !!&
;"
1(",*%;
7( !2 "!2
- ")
)2( !
"- 7*)!
- !;7! "
!
! " 72
" !
)6
!!7 --
A
"!
52
(
%- !0 "7
*% "! ) ** !2
2
")2
() ("
!"#$% !%" !
!&$ '(!) *#%& @@E 89 8
9 '& 2 < 7( ! - *)
! " (
)
(0! -1 *!
):7!
- 0!
*1 -7 ,
",2!!
!! "
)2( !G-
!- !;7 *) ",( - !1" 72
"&
( !" 2(
)" !702
! " ;"
G- * ")*() !-1! 2( 0
!2
)( 1 2( !702
* ")*() ! ;"
- !
) :7),0 1 **1 ") (% ,-7( "+ #( ), '
", '&89 8 6 *9E -
() *
("
) 7"!
* (
! 1 ** 7"!
*( 7**% "! ) "
";
! ! 0 *
" * ) ;%
-;;
( + ",- "
):
!-2 - ! ;
" ) !0 !!
) ;% - ! 7( 6 ) ( " )
-*) ",
2( ! ") !27
2
:7),0 "-;;
(+ ",-3! ! !**1!#5 H - "! ) "
" 7"!
* (
(D
")*()- 0 *) !!7 -- !
* A *%
!!() "
" - - !7( " .!%$ ,.&@89 8
'C- !;!
&" ,(7")!
)6 ( "!7 " %7")!( A <2 & !"
( ! !
* 0*
,
- ! 2( ! 6
) ! )0
)
( !
)*"
* - ",-
";(7,- () ;%
5 2
" ", - ! **"
!! ( "!7 " %( "
; * (7" *)( 1- - - -*)! <2 1 ** " ;
22(2(
( - ! 7( < 0 "
1-
;7! "
!! ;
!
72 ;% ")*() 17*) ;
!7 !!7* "
! ( 2(2!
) ;7! "
!! ! 0 !2 7*
" - ")*() ! *1 %! "! ) ;
;
:7), - ! "
)! 7"* !! ") 7"
2*
2 * "
;
;!7() "
( ! *% 02!! ;* - ;"
"" )7;
), **%"/ $'* 0"#' , &'89 8
9'&
;!
")*() !" 2( 2(:
2(
() ", !!1- --
")!
*
"- !-0 1" ")- !
)( !-2
!! "" )7;
)",$. ," ! '"1"!2&89 8
9&
;!
" ")*()) <2 ;7! "
!!& 17*) " *
* A ;"
")*() ! "
(% ( * ")
7( ;7! "
) ",!- !
")*()"
-(2
)7") (+
"898 98 9 ;
;
) 7"* !!
) 2*
) ;% ")*() 7*) ;
7"7") ") " 7* " - ! "
< *! ;
0 :7),0 " '# !1 " , ."!%$ "!2 !% #$ & 89
= " 6 1 ;6 ( 70!
!& ) " ") "% ,(7")
( "
) ;% 22
7 % /$ $3" "!($#"#"!" %" '" $% 7"!
*(
!!7;0
;
" "2!!
!! " !-2 ") !27
( 0( "%
!7 ,(
- 0 6
2( ! -(
0"
-! !,(
6
2( !!7;:
")
( 1 ** 2 ((
(! ( D 0 !"
2( !1 - " ( )"
0"
- 1 **- ")6 (6
2!!
!! "
")*()" <2 (%2 ( ) -(
0"
-! $ %&' 8$$+9 !
":