High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2741/2021disposed of

Rupambir Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And Others

2023-12-2211 pages

CWP No. 2741 of 2021 2023:PHHC:165598 -1-

!"#$$

%& '($)$*+ !+ , !$!$ -% )! !" %. ( !+ , &! )$' &!/ % , !$!$ -% )! !" %. ( !+ , &! &+$0+ * , !$!$ -% )! !" %. ( !+ , &!

!"# !

$%!!

! 1 ) !2 3$ 4)$# !2$!+ 1 $+% . .4# !4"!+&!$!$$ 5 67 879"

1 *! )$*+)$+%4# !"!+&!$!$$ 5 :6 "

/ / &4$!$ 3# ! 34 %. ( ;;;;

+$"'$2$33$&"!+ " $!+2$!&!$!$ #''<%!$"3 2 " #! $3!+$

+&!$!$4$=$%'(4+ &"!+2$!&!$!$2$!+ & >!<% +!+ !$'! 7$%(>!+ %. ( %(3$#)$#

CWP No. 2741 of 2021 2023:PHHC:165598 -2- ''$$!+( $"<%$$!$ !9

!!+=!!"$$!$* &&3$# !$""$33$*%& &!" %. ($$3)$#?=#%!$ #+@(> 2 >"$#!#%$!'!

!$!$ A .!)$*+$5 67"

&!$!$)$' &!/ %$5 :6 "

& B )&! !$!$"$# !42+ !+&!$!$& B)&! !$!$"$# !$%(>!+$#! !")&!4 %. ( !$!+$# !+ ! !+ &!B)! ! 2+$3 $%$* !+ " $ !$'! " $3 ! $#& ! C !$<%$")&!' !*> 3" $3! $#3%!+ # #$%!+)&!' !*>42+$#+2 !(# $%! "'!+ 3$> #%$!'!

+ &!$!$ %('$! !+ ! !+ 3$ !$'! 9 !

2 $%(>!+ %. ( %(3$#)$#''$$ !$$*

&!" %. ($$3)$#?=#%!$ #+@42+$#+2 3 !%& (> !$'! 7 !9

2+$ * $ &!" %. ($$3 )$# ?=#%!$ #+@ 2 !$ 2$!+ "# ! ! &$! "332$*(!2 7B !$! !!+ !!+&!$!$2!$!3!( &&$! !+> + &&3$ 24 3> &! 2 !$ " )#+%3 ! 3'$0$D1 E+ ($)&!&# !*>4 3!+%*+ 3$&! + ' $ # !

!$! !!+ ! &&$!!#$#%3 !(>!+& !'!" 53" ! FF64!+!&$!

47 2 $*" !$ % )&!' !*> %!+ "' !+ ! !+ %. (

#%$!'!")&!' %34F992(%*+!$!"# C !$ <%! 2 &$"!+&!'4) # #$ "'!+!$'" !$"$# !$ "'F99!$33!+#%$!'!>

3>!+# $ !

CWP No. 2741 of 2021 2023:PHHC:165598 -32 &&$! 2+$3 "% &! + ' $ # ! + 2 $!+ !$# $"2

!$"%!+! !!+ !3>"%&!2 !$(!2 !

!+&!" $3! !$"%=$!$*( #0 3* # #$!("$33"')&!' # !*> $! 3>&!%! "!2!>2 "$33"' 3'$0$D1 E+ ($)&!' # !*>

G #%3"!+&!$!$(>2 >"2$!!%('$$ && #+ !"!+!*$! %('$!!!+! %B

+#+ !"!+ ! *$!$ "332

"# $

! ##

$ %

$ & !

" &# '() *

+ ##

$ ,

# !

CWP No. 2741 of 2021 2023:PHHC:165598 -4- *

! !

# $ % !

& '

! ( &) & &

$ '

( &) & &

* ' + , - .

$ !

! ' '

, $ -

/ & & '

!$"%!+%('$!!!+ ! &F99 %3%"$33 # #$2 <%$!(# $"2 "!2#%$!'!> 2+%& 3!+> #%3(B 24$!+&!# 4!+ # #$2$!+ # $"2 !$ +%4!+ !2 3)&!' &! !2)#+%3 !)&!' &!42+$#+ !$333>$* # !!("$33 "' !+ $ # !*> !+ &!$!$ + #3 $' !+'3 " #$ !$%!+ !$'!

#! 43 #%3 && $*"!+)! !41

/ / &4 $!$ 3# ! 34 %. (4 + %('$!! 2$!! %('$$ ! !!+ !!+&!$!$ &&3$3>% !$'! 7 !9

&$!!+ !!+>#%3!+ &&3$3 $ #3 $'" &&$!'! !$ #! $!+ ! &!&$! 73>&!2 ")#+%3 ! 3'$0$D 1 E+ ($ )$0+ )&!&4 +24 )#+%3 !

CWP No. 2741 of 2021 2023:PHHC:165598 -5- 3'$0$D 1 E+ ($ )$0+ )&!& 2 $3 (34 !+ &! 2 & ''!$ %3 )%(B %3 "!+ %. ( #%$!'!")&!'?

''!@ %34 F?+$ "!" H!+' %3 FI@4!+ &!2+$#+"33 # !2 !("$33"$!"'!+ 3 3" 3'$0$ 1 E+ ($)$0+ $"!+&$! $3 (34!+ '#%3("$333> "')#+%3 !!+!+ 3'$0$D1 E+ ($)$0+ !*> +&!4$"!

"$33"'!+ $# !*>42%3!+("$33"')&!' "') !*>

G #%3"!+&!+ <%!!+' %3

$!%#$''! %3 F !$"%!+! !!+ !!+3#!$ &#$ 3 >#'&3! !+# $ !"') !*> 3'$0$ 1 E+ ($)$0++ 3 >.$ !+&+ !($'&3 & !> +$3#!$+ (#+ 33*

G #%3"!+&!B)! !"%!+%('$!!+ ! !+ &!$!$$! &&3>%!+ 3$ !$'!!+># !+ #3 $' * $!!+ $&!

+ #$!+%('$$

%3 "!+ %. ( #%$!'!")&!' %34F99&$

C !$" # #$!("$33(>$#!#%$!'!"&!'$ 33 !+)! !$$3)$# ! 3&$% %3 )%(B %3 !+ !$" # #>' $%"$33"B $3 ($3$!>"&!' 3$*$(3"#%$!'!4 %#+ # #>' >("$33$!'& $3>"' >!+%#$ ## # 2$!+!+%3*%3 !$*!+#%$!'! !+#$!$"$#"& &&$!!%#+&! $"!+ # #>2 ! + ''!' $ F4+24%(!$!%!!+ " $%(B%3 $#! %B

CWP No. 2741 of 2021 2023:PHHC:165598 -6H - ./

0,++0

0 /) 0 1

/ / 0 2) 3 4 * *

) * / / 0

* /

0 2) - *

78 / 0

) 0

/ 2)

0 $ 5

78 / 9 0

78 / 9

78 / / -

/* 0

/ 1 (

78 / 9 - 0

/* 0

(

* /

0 / / :

78 / 9 -

(

0 * /

/* 0

0 0

/ 1

/ :

CWP No. 2741 of 2021 2023:PHHC:165598 -7- - *

/ :

0 * / /* 0

/ 0

0 / 9 1 / 0 0

78 / 0

/ 1

(

78 / 9 1

78 / 0

/ *

78 / 5 - *

78 / 0

) ;<

G #%3"!+&!$!$%('$!!+ !$"!+&!' !" &!'")#+%3 ! 3'$0$ 1 E+ ($)$0+#%3!("$33%! B $3 ($3$!>4$!+%3!( #0!!+!+&!'# !*> +%3 !("$33"')#+%3 !# !*>

24!+$%!"$!+ ! & %3 ?

@?@? @?$@"!+ %. (

#%$!'!")&!' %34F99?%& @4$!$ && !!+ !$"!+&!$! "$33"')&!' "# !*>$E 3'$0$ 1 E+ ($)$0+!+ !+ '+ 33*!!+ 3 3" 3'$0$ 1 E+ ($)$0+ !+ "! !&!'")#+%3 !"!+# !*> !+"'!+* 3&3 ")#+%3 !# !*>!+!+ 3'$0$ 1 E+ ($)$0+ + %3 3&$!+ !$"!+ '# !("$334$!2$33(# $"2 !!+=!

CWP No. 2741 of 2021 2023:PHHC:165598 -8- #%$!'!4 &!")&!' "'!+)#+%3 ! 3'$0$ 1 E+ ($)$0+ +%4!+ #!$"!+&!$"$33$*%&!+&!" )&!' )#+%3 ! 3'$0$ 1 E+ ($ "' )#+%3 ! " 3'$0$ 1 E+ ($# !( $!(2*"%3%.%!$"$ !$!$#!+ !

!+' %3" F+ !(#+ 33*(>!+&!$!$$!+2$! &!$!$ 2%34!+"4+ &&3$# ($3$!>!!+ !$'! 7 !

!+ #!$"!+&!$.%!$"$ 7

24 !+$ %! "$ !+ ! !+ ( #03* &! " )&!' # !*>42+$#+#%3!("$33"'!+$#&!$"!+ %3F99!$33$%$* " !+ !$'! 74 + ' $ %"$33 '$!!3>4 & !+ %('$$"!+3 $#%3!$#+$ (?%& @ & !+#+ !2+$#++ !($&%!4!+$%!$ !$"$!+ !!+2"% &! $3 (3 ( #03*%&!

!("$33"')&!' !*>$ !2 "')&!' 3 !2"')#+%3 !)&!' +!$ %$*!4 !+"!+%('$$"!+&!$!$!( ##&!!!+=!!!+ ! %!"!+!! 3%'("""$#$ )# !*> 3>!2""$# 20$* * $!!+)&!'# !*>&! &$!%!

(>3 #%3"!+&!4!+&!&!"332$* !!&$! 7(3*$*!)#+%3 ! 3'$0$ 1 E+ ($)$0+ 3#%3! ("$33"'!+&!& 334!+"4!+ "%&!2+$#++ ' $ %"$33 "' &!' # !*> $#3%$* !2 " * 3 &! & !2")#+%3 !&!& %!"!+!! 3# !*!+" &!4::&! ' !"$#!#%$!'!4%!"2+$#+ ' !"&!'# !*>

@):4!+)%&'%!+ $#!!+ !!+&!2+$#+

CWP No. 2741 of 2021 2023:PHHC:165598 -9- "( #03* !("$33& !3>(> & ! !$'! 3 !=! #!

"!+ " $.%*'! %B =" -

0 /

* / * /

* -

0/) / 1 * >* /

* *

1 *

%#? * * @ *

/) 0

* %#? * 0 @ / A 561 ?0? "? * + @

/ @ 0

0 0

/) * )1* /

%#?

* @

* < 8

@ %: 4 %!+(>'4$!2 +3 %B 3! @

/ *

* 1 )1 @ 01

/ / A 05 0 / A 0 1

* 1

/ 0

1/ :

CWP No. 2741 of 2021 2023:PHHC:165598 -10-

* 1 * 0

* / @ 0 *

/6 / * *

/* @ /6 / @ * / /

* ,, /

* /. ) 1 56 * /

< 6

$2"!+' %3 F 233 !+=$!$* %34$!$ && !!+ !!+&!")&!' !(# $"2 $"!"$33 +%4$!

$ & !#3 "&!' !!("$33"'&!' $!+!" B $3 ($3$!> $ !+ ! & !$#%3 3#!$ > 4 !+ ' + ! ( "$33 & !3>$ %(<%!> $2"!+.%*'!?%& @4!+%4!+3> '!+!"$33!+&!2%3(!#3 !+&!& !3> !+( #03* &!$ & ! !$'!

+$%! 3"$!+ !!+&!$! '!$!+=$!$*( #03*&!")&!' # !*>$!+ !$'! $% $

+$ " $3% ! !$ !+ =$!$* ( #03* &! * $! &!'# !*>2%3!&$!+&!$!$"!+$$*+!"%3#3 $'

+ #!$"!+&!$!# >$*"2 !$$* !+&!2+$#+2"$33"'!+# !*$$"%!+ %3!$ $!% !$2+!+ &!& $3 (3$!+# =#&! $2 " ("$$*4!+$%!$ !$"$!+ !!+&!+ !#$ !+#3 $'"!+&!$!$" &&$!'! * $!!+ $"%&!3>$*2$!+ !+'

!+!" $3 ($3$!>")#+%3 !&!&&$!

CWP No. 2741 of 2021 2023:PHHC:165598 -11-

F4$!$($$*%&!+'!+ "$3!+&!$!+>

2+!+> $%!+ !$'! 7 F

!+#$#%'! #2+!+)! !'!+ ! 0 #$$ !"$33 !3 ! C&!"'&!'# !*>4!+ #!$"3> !$$* &! 3 $* $ "% ( #03* &! + ! ( #3 %.%!$"$ + &! 4!+"4$#!!$% & ! !$'!""%&! " 3 )&! & )#+%3 ! )&! & $$! &&3$# !$"!+ $&! +3#!$&# &%3+ 33(# $ %!

+&!$!$2%3(! ! 3$*$(3"& !$#$& !$*$!+3#!$ &# 2$!+%! (.#!$* ! !+$ * !+ 3$*$($3$!> #$!$ " !+ &!$!$ 3#! &!+$'$!4!+ &&$!'!+ 33(""!!+' " ) ?=#%!$ #+@ + 3#!$ 2+$#+ + 3 > ( ' 4 !+"42%3!! $!%(

##$*3>4!+2$!&!$!$ &'(&))*(+,-.&'/0 '!$ (

33&$* &&3$# !$+ 33! $&" ##$*3> #!

$%!! 12 6

> D > 4 / D >