High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2046/2020disposed of

Balinder Singh v. State Of Haryana And Others

2025-02-06Mr. Justice Tribhuvan Dahiya15 pages

!"#$$%

!"# $% !& &

!" '!"#(# #& &! )% "*

&%!"# "!# !&# ++,

% "

&%(#%

&%!" !& &

!"# '!"#(# #& &! )% "*

&%!"# "!# !&# CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TRIBHUVAN DAHIYA -

#./01#0 2.0

031 2 45000++,

6# 1 2.0

"70#081 2 45000

9./$3/1 2.0

# 031 2

%01 2 45::000++,

/20#8.1 2 45(#0

%001

$1%3 TRIBHUVAN DAHIYA

:: ;<0 4 /. 0:0/ 4 0 4 00 0 . 500 : 1 41 =08 0=30&;<001

) =2031 4 =08 > 4: ++,1 .0=40/1

>08.04 008 5 5: 40// <5 2 5 4 0 4 0 :5<#0=04/0:5<<20: ? 1 1=35508.008/0400 4:0 & 0 5%3 <=/0 #20 ::00 20 < 0@32 5 4 0 4 0 :5< #0 20 4:0 20: 5 150055/045< 83%.21 3 </ = :: 4 550: =08 /08/3 /. 0 :0:5/::0A.500 0 < B+ B :>1 :5 / 0 . < B, :> < 83 & 40/ /0

& </1 / +B1 . //8 =3 : 0 =40<1<00:38/0 </=550&3.220C1

@<1550:/.0< %.21 :3 5 :0 2 5 04:0<8<"08 4:0 1D1500 .4<0/04 040:5<#0.70 5 5<< /0 ,CC1 @< . 4< 4 / 0 0 70A 4 .: =/8 831 4< 30//3 %055? 50//3%05583&.45 0//21::0270&500 :5053=08@04 :0</=04550:80255 :01=<00:.>1408:40/0 500 ,

0 =>8<1 / #0 </ 5508 4 5003208=080 254833=/81=04:0 ::00 20 < 0@32 5 4 0 4 0 :5< #01 0 . 0<:= <5 0 :> ::080//5=04:0 0 :05213<<3 :: 0 5 :0 & 5 2 .8/3 /0 0 : 4 550: 5/ 0

' .008 /0 4 0 . </ = :: 80 5 4//08 2 502 4 =08 .008 /01 500 208=0805.0:02 . 2 <50?<:1 :: 0 40/ 70&4154.008/0=:8<3 :::0 <554001/</ 4 /. /0 . =3 0200 20 7<8: 1 0 0/

0 / <=:0 # 40/ 800=3::000:0=3#<5:<20 1+B

</45 131 500 2 08 > 550: 80 3 2 5 0 3 :8 0 :: 4 550: =3 ::00 $0208 550: : 80 2 5 /3 = 0 0 .008 /0 55 =3 ::001 .0 0 .008 /0 . 551 4408550:5001.0//04 <0@320::=3::001/3 :<5508.008/0::0804:

4<=0:4#04%3020/ #20 !@<02 //0 #20 #20 ::?:=0!@:00 1 41E 4F1 0 = 550: 4 0 04 0 : 2 = :: =3 ::00 &41 500 =

% 802 550: <55 4 01 /0 <5 #<5:<7<8:0/!

1 ,#C, 4/=: 7<8: B1 0 B B 0/ #

" 2

1.0<>20. 3>0

D #<=:00:=3/</4502= 0 &5000<0@3 254 040:5<#0.20=3 ::001 80 .0 ::0 4 :3 / 0 . : 20 <: +B &. 4 ::00705:02& 0520045508.008/040451 .355&5005/@=/.:: 01 /0:08 550: 80 2 5 84:050208=::4:=3 ::00&00=<5/./0.=3 0200 0

1 .0 =3 /308 <5 #<5: < 7<8: 0

$ %

& 2

1 ,#B,B10 . / 0 5 4 .0 <0: 5 = <=<:0210.;<0=40//<55:0 4::80../080=/4550:=<</ = :: /3 < 4 =08 /. 0 :0 #< 0<00802054.008/0=<50

;<080.0::0.:</2=40// <5&.008/0::5/3454.0 <0:5=<12=40//<5 B & /. /0 . =3 0200 0

/308<5

=:8</0: 550: 80 2 5 0 4 4 0 0 =<1<05</31<0:500:05 52004 4A/2#0.4<- 550://=:3520 .00 55/0=3<:=4520

@@@ @@@ @@@ @@@

, & # $2: // = :5 44 550:01.05/0.008/0 ./0:0:/4=0.008/0=04 ::?:=0 !@:001 4 5 4 .0 0 :.::=3::00 20 04 0 = 550 44550:2=22054 3 1 20 4 < 0 // = 05 .0 %.21 // = 0/ = 55020?5104314.00: .080//3::=3::00- 20 4< 23 4 08 /31 :/<: 3 400/ =40 . =3 <0</40550:0@ 42051//=:4:0:=<0 53//=40@0/45.00 4<0/4550:<0

(

& # $2: :3 44 550: 0%3020/#20 !@<02

//0#20 #201:3=1 @ 4 <:= 4 20 5 /3 %.21 0//=44550:2@4 <:=42051040:0:: =3 ::00 04 4</40// /080=0/03 00 /0 . =3 # $2: 4 550: 20?5 =3 .3 4 20 </1 8</0@<020<01:3= +

5</ 4 <=0 , 4 #0 520 $2: 0 :5 44 550: 0 . 0 5/0.008/0/0:0:/4?/4=0.008/0 =04::?:=0@:00454.

0 = :: =3 ::00 #<=0 4< 520 550: = 44 /3 @ 4 <:= 4 5 2010//=44550:280 20 5 0 0 : = :: =3 ::00&50001208=::=3 ::00 4 550:1 /0: :/2 = 0/ 00 80 2 5 <:50 4 =08 0 .008/0?@=/.0:0 20.

4/05</00< :08 550: = :=3 $2: </ 0=::=3::008020 51500208/0:550:802 50.

) 00/:0/08452004 4.0 <05</355/3<0:0;<0 /= 7<8:0

1/0<5=3 02001 = 0 044 4 0<0 & 500 0 5005054/04546<0!80 020/ $

408< 0 40/ :0?/ /0 4 #</ 0 4 / 01&0/> 1 . . 44 550:+:8#</0 701500F:408<@=/.&0/> 5 52/ </1 .008 /0 . 2/0 4 3A :0 /0 4 0 0 0<0 4 44 550: 0< .008/01.</:02/045043&500 0 55 %08 < >08 550: 80 254&0/>%0500=054=3008 55008<03@:0/0:1.0.720 ,+4//.

088<- :5/0 .0 00 0< =3 %08 <20C+0#D 4C1 55// 5 ,+ 3 0 ,+1 /0: 4 5 4 550: 80 5 4 6<0 !

.744//.08- G'( 20. 4 4 .008 /0 0< 0 54<0:</0202/003.3=> 0 3 + 0/41 = 8 550: 0 .0:

* '( 4=20120 =40//=/8H

0<:1 #<5: < / 500 # /F :408<0:0?//04#</01 5@=20:?&0/>1.=44550: +1 0 70 5 .0 :0 2 <8 2 = 44 500?# / 5 :0 4: :8 #</ 0 < 4 .008 /0 <08 0 2/003 5</=3</&<=2<- $

20.44</50000=21 00=355//0/008/0:4 5 # / 4 550: < 4 .008 /0 0 //3 <7<040 .008 /0 .</ 5 /3 4 5 4 .0 <0: 0 <1 2 = :5/ .008 /0 .</ :: 5 .444550:2=0<:808 54:0/0&@04.008/0//. :55008<0340//<520.00 <08 <=0 4 .008 /0 .008 /0 :: 5 4 20 4 .0 <0:5=<2=40//<5 023400<04508 .008/001=<4546<0 !80 020/1 $

4 .0 <0: 5 .<.<//3240//<5) &0/><:81454.0 54<0:.<1:02 &5120400<:48<:>1// 5 4 .0 5 4 /0 . < . </340//<510=05<&0/>.

5005 0 : /0 5 5 01 . 44 550: 80 5 4 6<0 !80 020/1 $

+ & 40 44 .:;<<50/00054 <0:&2/0034.008/010440 1=:0.04+1=< 23.44&0/>+ 0 0 231 4 .0 5 55 %08 < 80 401 0 0 >./8 500=355//00:5<8 ,+ @=21.008/0.2/00//

3+ 4&0/> . 4< /080=/ 4 550: 80230;<0<4:.008/01 5 0 .</ = ;<//3 /080=/ 4 550: 80 0 23 &0 .</ = <;<0=/ /8/5001045230 $ & 4 40/08 4 50 =3 50 ? .0 :5 <03 40//<5230;<0104;< .2&/3/2040084 23 .</ = 044 /8/ 5500 04 55008<03040//<520/=/231 50 20/=0/03 4 0 .

008 /0 & 44:&0/>+=30/4/ 04 23 < 4 .00 50 4 3 0 <08 50 4 2/003 4 .008/05</=3</&44423 &0/>855005=200 4:5/340//<523%0155// .040//<523<4 2100 . 5 . >08 550: 80 23 2 =2 5 4 .0 5 4 /0?<0: .

40041.2000/<08 55// <8 2 550 5 # / 8023.0.44&0/>

0141550

1/3 500?#/.0:0?//01..008/00 5/ .0 2/003 50 4 3 23 . <4&0/>50844101+1 2/003 4 .008 /0 @50 0 1 50020=::4550:103 52004.008/0=:00010/= :>08550:40.2=::=3 <00883 =43520040//<520< 4.008/010.2=::2 08/0:550:80323"<//317<8:0

)120.>0

.00= <54:14438<500/0: /04 #<=;</31 #<5: < 0 !

10:.0:0/4</=>8<@000 1/0=43520045504.008 /010=55084=08@0:0104 0:408<0//0& 47<8:= 054:5851.0<-

00/;<0:=0=30< 0

0001005040//3=2

/200/4550: 2 701 0 = 4 3 <3 </ 31:5/30=<44<40//23 0@=/.000:0/0

0/4</0=4352001 :5/30=<55.008/0000 5/4/055004: .008/0004:5/70 & 40 00 4 0 < = <=;</3 4//. =3 %08 < 0

)

55/308 /. /0 . =3 0 < 0

4 4 008 <3520000"</ 4"</ .0$<0/01.420.55// /0:550:<40//23=08@=/. 0 0 :0 /0 4 <=:00 =/4 4 55//051010.0///520084 5504.008/01.0.005:00=/ 5<=</ D4"</ 4:05:010 10.0//=00853 <3 5200 &41 %08 < ::0304<0855055// 5 .

0 :0 <40// < 4 / 0 0 40/ /0 /0 5508 4 <//08 & 0:5<8 7<8: 5 =3 %08 < 0 =/</3 0 .0 /2 <35200.0.0.8 &20..4//.

2% % 1# /0B 1008 G

& , )H&0/5000/.==> " - "

1 # +1/08<- ($

55<<004%08 <,,CC155//>5440//08<5D 20054 54: 20:,?+ :008D204: 20: ?C &</.040CCC0=& :: : 4 <4</ 0 <

20:,?+ 20: ?C <4 0 / =3 4 550: <

20:,?+ 1+00<<5 0 8000:5"5B55/0 4 550: < 20: ,?+ DC+ 3 ;</0401 =< 3 . 5/ #0/,.008 =21 5/4 0 . 55 4 550: <

20:,?+ "5B4//=3 <44 <:= . 3 <3 <0: </.0;<055//55.008/0 0005/&8<:2=/44 "5B.044.+040/ <<555//.=<4450 0.008/0<</=.<00 8I

08/310:5<87<8:/0855//?<8 2:550:=34<55085/4+25 ./=4//0<=3#<5:< , 0/ 008 !

1 #<5:<40/020.0

208 = 0 0 044 4</ =>8<4044.01.0:= & /. /0. 0

55/3 0<0 . 0 0 = :: 5/ 0 .008 /0 ;</31 0 < 0 <=/ 0 0< 0 0 =3 4//.0820.>0

0=3/308<5

0<0=04//.08//./0.0

0 0 !

08/3100/50001.<<4</ 5/0/?:0/01208>0080 2 5 0 = 4 .008 /01 : . 0 <3=0040::E5/0 .008/0./0:0:/4=0.008/0=04 ::?:=0!@:00F )<1 0 0 #

1 .0/ 008 00/ 0< 5008 2 5 4 0 400/838020:0;<0 ? /308!

.//52004 1 / 0 08 > 550: 805:00820?=::=3 ::00 D

20.4=20<010:005 100:0 Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also stand(s)

% disposed of. B 5340=5/ TRIBHUVAN DAHIYA D .

/ 0 . / 0