Veer Singh v. Kamal Kumar
!" #$%$&'( ) $&*+ $ $& ) , .,/- %0&" & 1' 231 ,3
% & '
1,
+ 4 5"6# 5! + 0 $ $& 7777777 ,358 39 + 0 % & 0 $ $& $% "$ # " * $&% + " "
: 5 0 %% " ;< + ""$ $& . $6$. /"* 8 &$ $6$%$&95
= 0/8!%+ 5 + > #/ $&*/ 95 +/*+?+$#+ + $& !$. ";< + 0 $ $& % @$&* + $& " #.
$&!" #.
$&*% . " "
; &/.. &"6$"5+ %; &"$%-$%% " + !
# %5 $& ;$ !5 ?+$#+ A/$ " ; & $# " !
"4/"$# $&*/0& + 0 % & 0 $ $& + ?
<;
#@$& + < B + %0&" & !$. " %/$ % @$&* + $&%0 #$!$#0 !- * - & % .."
?$ + * " .
&"- %/$&*( @ & .% &":
.
%"
$. " &"" %#$; "$& + 0.
$& 8!%+ 5 + %/$ 00 <9+ %/$ ?
%" # "&B C %0 ?+$#+ + %0&" & ?
%"$ # " " 0%$ + ;
$&?$ +$&& -& +!- + "
! + " # ?$ + !/ + "$ # $& + 0 $ $& > #/ + % . " "$& !
6/! + %0&" & ?$ +$& 0 $"! ?-& +%5!
$.$&*?+$#+ + %0&" & ?
%+ ." & $ . " * + % . " " > #/ " +/*+ + / + 0 $ $& #+ .. &* " + $"4/"*- & &"" # "
D E B C +/*+ .!$. "; ! + $% $# /"* 5 = 0/8! %+ 5 + 00 ..
/ 9$&?+$#+0# "$&*%5 +/*+4/"*- & &"
" # "
C 5 + $"4/"*- & &"" # ! + $ / "
"B C?
%-"$!$ " + > & + + %0&" & 2%%/$ ?
%" # "&.<A/ + . & .$ !! #6 <!:.
@+% .&*?$ + $& % F G 0 &&/- !- + "
! * - & % .. "
$.. + "
!" # / / $& % FG0 &&/- $.. + .$= $&! + " # . -/& ?
% .%* & " +0 $ %; $&* **$ 6 ";< + $"4/"*- & &"" # ! + 00 ..
/ @&#@ " + "%! +$%/ +/*+% 0
% #&" .%; $&*
: H
I &"
B H
I + + % #&" .% ? "$%0% " ! ;< +$% / +/*+ #--& 4/"*- & "
(5 + #&#./"$&*0 $&!?+$#+ "% %/&" ' H00 . !$. " ;< 0.
$& $!!, . ,/- $% +/%5 ..? " &" + 4/"*- & &"" # !.? 00 ..
/ ?$ + * " !/% .!
.$ !!%0 #$!$#0 !- &# ! + * - & % ..$%% %$" &"
4/"*- & ! + $ ./ + > & $%/0+ ."+ " ! &"
& $% "$ # " > #/ + % . " "?$ +$& 0 $"! + -& +%!- + "
! 0 %%$&* ! +$% " 5 !
$.$&* ?+$#+ 0.
$& $!! ?$.. % @ > #/ $& ! + * - & +/*+ 0# %% ! .
? + . !
" ! &"
& $%"$%-$%% " # %+ ; 0 0 "I %0 + ! A/ "0 $&! + 4/"*- & ! +$%/ 5 + 0 $ $& 2%% #&" .?
%"$%-$%% "?+ % + %0&" & 2% ?
% ..? " ! +."$&* + %0&" & & $ . " + .$ !!%0 #$!$# 0 !- * - & % .."
?$ + !/ + "$ # $& + 0 $ $& > #/ + % . " "?$ +$& 0 $"! + -& +%!- + "
%%$&*! + ! A/ "" !
$.$&*?+$#+ + %0&" & ?
%+ ." & $ . " * + * - & > #/ " +/*+ + 0# %%!.
?
DBE + 0 $ $& #+ .. &* " + $"4/"*- & ! +$%/ ; ! + &2;. 0 >/ +/*+0 #$ .3 6 00 .89
C! (H
I?+$#+?
%"$%0% "!& : +/*+ + !..?$&*" ' H ".
& "#/&% .! + 0 $ % + %0&" & ?$..0 < %/-! %(55J8 % $6 .
@+%9- + 0 $ $& ?$ +$& 0 $"! + -& +%!- "
<&# % +
-/& $%& 0 $"5 + % - ?$..# <$& % + ! G0
! + -& +% + -/& " 0%$ ";< + 0 $ $& - <; !/&" " +$-?$ + + ##/ "$& % &0 <- & ! %(55J8 % $6 .
@+%95 + %0&" & 0.
$& $!!?$..; & $ . " @ 0%% %%$& + %0 #$ ..
6 0 $ $&$%5 ##"$&*.<5"$%0% "! &"$&* $&8%95$! &<5%+ .. .%% &""$%0% "!I 8 -0+ %$%%/00.$ "9 %0 + ! A/ "" 5 ! + $&*.
& "#/&% .! + $ %5 + &2;. 0 >/ "$ # " + %0&" & 0 < + 0 $ $& 5 6 &" ;6 + * " -/& ; ? & + 0 $ %5 !/ + %/-!( @+%?$ +$& 0 $"! + -& +% ?
%!/ + "$ # " + $&# % +
-/& ?
%& 0 $"?$ +$& + -& +% + % - %+ ..# <$& % F G0 &&/-+ &2;. 0 >/ !/ + + ." + &0 <- & !
+ $" -/& ! (.
@+% + %0&" & %+ ..; & $ . " @ 0%% %%$&! + %/$ 00 < /$&* + 0 $"?+ & + - ?
%0 &"$&*; ! + &2;.
0 >/ 5$& + > #/ $&0# "$&*%% . " ""
?
% * > #/ "; ? & + 0 $ %.
"$&* + !$.$&*! $&;< + 0 $ $& ; ! + > #/ $&*/ % @$&*%/#+% . " " ; " #.
"
&/.. &"6$"&.<& + */&" + + %0&" & + "!
$. " " 0%$ + ;
$&?$ +$&& -& +!- + "
%%$&*! + " # 0 %% ";< + $ ./ ? 6 5; ! + > #/ $&*/
D E #/."0$& & + 0 $ $& 2% $&5 + &2;. 0 >/ "$%0% "
! + 0 $ $& 2% $"0 #$ .3 6 00 .& : +/*+ + " 0"/# " ;6 &" + ! $& + .$*+ ! + ;% 6 $&% " ;< + &2;. 0 >/ 5 + 0 $ $& 2% $&?
%"$%-$%% "
;< + > #/ $&*/ +/*+ + " ?+$#+$% + %/;4 # - !
#+ .. &* $& + 0 % & 0# "$&*% & "#/&% .! + 0 $ $& %/;-$ % + + % . " ""
> #/ "; ? & + 0 $ %$%.$ ;. ; " #.
"&/.. &"6$"
! + %. %& + &B C?+ & + 4/"*- & &"" # ?
% %% ";< + $ ./ 5 + %0&" & ?
%* & "& -& +2% $- " 0%$ + ;
$& &" &# $ $% + "-$ " # % ; ? & + 0 $ % + ?$ +/ &<!/ + > &%$&%* & ";< &< / + " 0%$ ?
%- " ;< + %0&" & ? ..; <&" + 0 $"!& -& +5 + " # 0 %% ";< + $ ./ ; # - $& > #/ ;. + ! %/;-$%%$&%- " ;<.
& "#/&% .! + 0 $ $& " % 6 / $*+ 4 # $& + !$& ." $& + .$ $* $&; ? & + 0 $ %0 $&$&* + %/$ !$. ";< + %0&" & !%0 #$!$#0 !- * - & % ..
?
% + " "
" :50 %% ";< + &2;.
0 >/ +/*+?+$#+5 ! + $&*.
& "#/&% .! + 0 $ %5 + &2;. 0 >/ "$ # " + %0&" & 0 < + 0 $ $& 5?$ +$& + -& +%! + "
%%$&*! + " 5 ""$ $& .%/-! ( @+%?+$#+?
%6 &" ;6 + -/& * "; ? & + - ?
% !/ + "$ # " + $! + 0 <- & ! (.
@+%?
%& - " ?$ +$& +
$"0 $"! + -& +%5 + % - %+ ..# <$& % F G0
&&/- &" & %/#+ " 0%$ + %0&" & ? % + ." & $ . " @
D(E 0%% %%$&! + %/$ 00 < $&# & : + &2;. 0 > / "$ # " &.< <- & ! + ""$ $& . -/& !(.
@+%5$ $%& "$!!$#/. 0 %/- + $ ?
% ?
+ + * " -/& + . "<; &" 0%$ ";< + %0&" & & C& + . %% +/*+$ %" "
" :5 &0 <- & !(.
@+%;< + %0&" & + 0 $ $& 5?+$#+0 <- & + % "-$ ".<; &- " ;<+$-5 + &2;. 0 >/ + ."+$- & $ . " @ 0%% %%$&! + %/$ 00 <+/%5 ! + " 0%$ !(.
@+% + # &; &$-0 "$- & ?+ % 6 ! + %0&" & @ 0%% %%$& ! + %/$ 00 < &" + > #/ $&*/ + %$*+ .<" -.$%+ " ..%/#+ +/". %%/*+ ; # ";< + 0 $ $& &6$ ?! + ;6 !
# %5 + !$.$&*! + 0 % & 0 $ $&# &;
- " %& +$&*;/ !$6./% &" + ! 5 + % - $%"$%-$%% "?$ + #% %?+$#+ A/ & $!$ " (5J ( D ,3E %+ -%+ K+ + %0 @$&*J %& "
'
%J K+ + 0 ;.
' %J