Punsup And Another v. Gurmukh Singh Rice & General Mills
!"# $#%&'&() *
+(,!-."!"#&/&0.+110&#'212!"&(3&4&"#$!($!("5#2 6#"&"&(#2' 7#2'+' +24+85.&(95&%##(#2!0&00' 6#'1($#(" ) :
3 . 33 2#'#(") 2 4!(5!+$5!2;< $/%!"#< 2"5#1#"&"&(#2' ===
>5#"5#2 2#12"#2' 0%!0 1!1#2' 4!; -# !00?#$ " '##"5#,+$94#("@
-#2# #22#$""5#2#12"#2'2("@ A >5#"5#2 "5# ,+$94#(" '5+0$ -# 2#12"#$ &( "5# $&9#'"@ ===
33 2!0 7&$# 2$#2 -#&(9 !''!&0#$< $!"#$ B
< 2#($#2#$ -; &'"2&%" +$9#< +2$!'1+2< "5# -,#%"&(' '+-4&""#$-;"5#2#'1($#("C,+$94#("$#-"25!$'&(%#-##( !%%#1"#$!($"5##D#%+"&(1#"&"&(?!'$&'4&''#$-#&(9 +00; '!"&'
&#$ ("5#-,#%"&(' &0#$-;"5#2#'1($#("C,+$94#(" $#-"2< &" ?!' 4!&("!&(#$ "5!" "5# 4&00#$ 2&%# ?#2# " -# $#0&/#2#$ -; A EE ?#/#2< "5# 1#"&"&(#2'C$#%2## 50$#2'</&$#&"'0#""#2$!"#$ B B EE<#D"#($#$"5&'1#2&$ +1"A B EE5#2# 2#<&("#2#'"("5#$#0!;#$$#0&/#2; 2&%# ?!' " -# %!0%+0!"#$ ?# E EE !($ (" 24
* EE
( 2#'1('#< &" ?!' 10#!$#$< &("#2 !0&!< "5!" !( -,#%"&(!'2#9!2$'"5#&("#2#'"("5#0!"#$#0&/#2; 2&%#?!' 2!&'#$ -; "5# 2#'1($#("C,+$94#("$#-"2 -# 2# "5#
2-&"2!"2 !' !0' &( 5&' -,#%"&(' &0#$ +($#2 .#%"&( A "5# 2-&"2!"&( (%&0&!"&( %"< EE 5#2# 2#< ( '+%5 -,#%"&( %+0$ -# #("#2"!&(#$ !" "5&' '"!9# !($ "5# %+2" %+0$("9-#5&($"5#$#%2##"#D!4&(#"5#'!4# ( ! %('&$#2!"&( "5# 4!""#2 &( &''+#< "5# #D#%+"&(9%+2"%(%0+$#$!'"5+')
!
"# !
"
$
"%
&
' ("
)
( "# *$
"
"%
"
"%
"%
+
! (" # !
# !
"
, !
# -
#
! #
# #
. , ! "%
"# *$
A
# #
# !
' "
#
"#
!
*$ / "
!
" # 0 "
1
1
2 (%#$#$0;</#2!%&"; "5#0#""#2$!"#$ B B EE< /&$#?5&%5"5#1#2&$"'+110;"5#4&00#$2&%#?!'#D"#($#$ +1"A B EE<&''+#$-;"5#$#%2##50$#2'&'("$&'1+"#$ (%#<"5#1#"&"&(#2'C$#%2##50$#2'5!$"5#4'#0/#'#D"#($#$ "5#1#2&$"'+110;"5#4&00#$2&%#+1"A B EE<&("#2#'" ( "5# $#0!;#$ 1!;4#(" %+0$ (0; -# !?!2$#$ ?#
E EE 5#2# &' ( $&'1+"# "5!" & "5# &("#2#'" &' %!0%+0!"#$ ?# E EE< "5#(< ("5&(9 2#4!&(' $+# "?!2$'"5#1#"&"&(#2'C$#%2##50$#2' 5!" -#&(9 '< ( &("#2 #2#(%# &' ?!22!("#$ &( #D#2%&'# 2#/&'&(!0 ,+2&'$&%"&(< +($#2 2"&%0#
* "5# ('"&"+"&( ($&! #"&"&( -#&(9 $#/&$ 4#2&" &' !%%2$&(90;$&'4&''#$ %"-#2*<
!,!( 2+(!00& +$9#