Bhupinder Singh And ORS v. Kewal Krishan Chabbra

 








   

  

!"#

$#%&'&()






*+,&($#-
.&(/*
!($
"*#-'

0
#"&"&(#-'
1#-'+'
2#3!4
2-&'*!(
**!5-!


0
#',($#("
 )
6 7

.

 77
-#'#(")
-
.
*4+3!4&!8
$9%!"#
-
"*#
,#"&"&(#-'
:::


;*#"*#-
-#,-"#-'

4%!4
,!,#-'
<!=
5#
!443#$
"
'##
"*#
>+$/<#("?



5#
-# #--#$
"
"*#
-#,-"#-'
-
("?
.
@
;*#"*#-
"*#
>+$/<#("
'*+4$
5#
-#,-"#$
&(
"*#
$&/#'"?

:::


 77

-!4
1&$#
-$#-
$!"#$
 A

B8
-#($#-#$
5=
"*#
#("
("-44#-8
7+$*&!(!8
#9&%"&(

"*#
,#"&"&(#-'
-<
"*#
$#<&'#$
,-#<&'#'
*!$
'&(%#
5##(
-$#-#$
'
#9#(
"*#
!,,#!4
,-# #--#$
!/!&('"
"*#
'!&$
-$#-
!&4#$
!($
3!'
$&'<&''#$
(
@  

8
,#"&"&(#-'"#(!("'
!-#
5# -#
"*&'
%+-"
&(
"*&'
-#9&'&(
,#"&"&(


>#%"<#("

"*#
,#"&"&(#-'
3!'
'+/*"
(
"*#
/-+($
"*!"
"*#
,-#<&'#'
&(
C+#'"&(
*!$
5#%<#
+( &"
!($
+('!

-
*+<!(
*!5&"!"&(8
!'
"*#
<!>-
,-"&(
 5+&4$&(/
*!$
!4-#!$=
!44#(
'"

"*#
"#(!("'
&(
"*#
5+&4$&(/
*!$
9!%!"#$
"*#
!%%<<$!"&(
&(
"*#&-
,''#''&(
*#
5+&4$&(/

3*&%*
$#<&'#$
,-#<&'#'
&'
>+'"
!
,!-"
 8
*!,,#(#$
"
5#
<-#
"*!(

=#!-'
4$
+/#
%-!%D'
*!$
!,,#!-#$
&(

 
"*#
3!44'
!($
"*#=
*!$
5#%<#
,4+<5

.
<+%*
'8
#9#(
"*#
+(&%&,!4
-,-!"&(8
7+$*&!(!8
*!$
$#%4!-#$
"*#
,-#<&'#'
+( &"
!($
+('!

-
*+<!(
*!5&"!"&(8
+($#-
.#%"&(
A@
 "*#
+(>!5
+(&%&,!4
-,-!"&(
%"8
EA

9#(8
2!-"!-
.&(/*8
"*#
-&/&(!4
"#(!("8
*!$
!5!($(#$
"*#
,-#<&'#'
$+-&(/
*&'
4& #"&<#
$+#
"
&"'
-+&(+'
%($&"&(
!($
*!$
'"!-"#$
4&9&(/
3&"*
*&'
'(
!"
*!($&/!-*
5# -#
*&'
$#!"*
*!"
5#&(/
'8
"*#
,-#<&'#'
3!'
4=&(/
%4'#$
'&(%#
%"5#-8

EE
#'+4"!("4=8
,#"&"&(#-'"#(!("'
*!$
#9#(
%#!'#$
"
%%+,=
"*#
,-#<&'#'
-
!
%("&(++'
,#-&$
 +-
<("*'
,-#%#$&(/
"*#
&('"&"+"&(

"*#
#9&%"&(
,#"&"&(


(
$# #(%#8
&"
3!'
,4#!$#$8
&("#-
!4&!8
"*!"
"*#
#9&%"&(
,#"&"&(
3!'
&4#$
!'
!
%+("#-54!'"
"
"*#
,#"&"&(

&4#$
5=
,-#$#%#''-&(&("#-#'"

"*#
"#(!("'
+($#-
.#%"&(


"*#
!'"
+(>!5
-5!(
#("
#'"-&%"&(
%"8
EBE
 -
'*-"8
F"*#
%"6
+"8
&"
3!'
!4'
<!&("!&(#$
"*!"
"*#
-#',($#("
3!'
("
"*#
3(#-
!'
!4'
"*#
4!($4-$
 #("&-#
,-,#-"=
*+'8
,#"&"&(#-'
3#-#
("
"#(!("'
+($#-
"*#
-#',($#("

(
!
$+#
!($
%<,-#*#('&9#
%('&$#-!"&(
 <!""#-
&(
&''+#8
!($
"*#
#9&$#(%#
(
-#%-$8
5"*
"*#
!+"*-&"&#'
%(%+--#("4=
%(%4+$#$
"*!"
"*#
5+&4$&(/
#G,#-"
#G!<&(#$
5=
"*#
"#(!("'
%(%#$#$
&(
*&'
%-''#G!<&(!"&(
"*!"
"*#
$#<&'#$
,-#<&'#'
%+4$
("
5#
-#'"-#$
#9#(
! "#-
-#,!&-'
!($
'*!44
*!9#
"
5#
-#%('"-+%"#$
;*#-#!'8
"*#

@
5+&4$&(/
#G,#-"
#G!<&(#$
5=
"*#
4!($4-$
"#'"& &#$
"*!"
"*#
,-,#-"=
!'
!
3*4#
*!$
5#%<#
+( &"
!($
+('!

-
*+<!(
*!5&"!"&(
!($
3!'8
"*+'8
5#=($
-#,!&-'
*"/-!,*'
G A
"
BE8
5-+/*"
(
-#%-$8
5=
((#
"*#-
"*!(
"*#
"#(!("'
"*#<'#49#'8
-#9#!4#$
"*!"
"*#
5+&4$&(/
&(
C+#'"&(
3!'
&(
!(
#G"-#<#4=
$&4!,&$!"#$
%($&"&(

'
-#/!-$'H
3*#"*#-
"*#
,#"&"&(#-'
*!$
%#!'#$
"
%%+,=
"*#
$#<&'#$
,-#<&'#'8
&"
3!'
%(%4+$#$
"*!"
#9&$#(%#
(
-#%-$
,-9#$
"*!"
"*#
"#(!("#$
,-#<&'#'
3!'
("
5#&(/
+'#$
-
"*#
,+-,'#
&"
3!'
4#"
+"

#',($#("4!($4-$
!,,#!-#$
&(
'+,,-"

*&'
%4!&<
!($
,-9#$
"*!"
"*#
,#"&"&(#-'
*!$
%#!'#$
"
%%+,=
"*#
,-#<&'#'
3&"*+"
!(=
-#!'(!54#
%!+'#
#
"#'"& &#$
"*!"
"*#-#
3!'
(
#4#%"-&%
%((#%"&(
&(
"*#
,-#<&'#'
!($
"*#
D&"%*#(
3!'
((

+(%"&(!4

.
<+%*
'8
"#(!("
*+,&($#-
.&(/*
%(%#$#$
&(
*&'
%-''#G!<&(!"&(
"*!"
"*#
,-#<&'#'
&(
C+#'"&(
*!$
("
5##(
+'#$

($
(#&"*#-
"*#
#4#%"-&%&"=
<#"#-
3!'
&(
,#-!"&(
(-
"*#
D&"%*#(
3!'
+(%"&(!4
"*&(/
3!'
5-+/*"
(
-#%-$8
4#!'"
!(=
%/#("
-
%-#$&54#
#9&$#(%#8
"
'*3
"*!"
"*#
"#(!("'
#9#-
-#'&$#$
&(
"*#
,-#<&'#'
&(
C+#'"&(
'&(%#
%"5#-8
EE
!"*#-8
&"
3!'
%(%#$#$
"*!"
*&'
#("&-#
!<&4=
3!'
-#'&$&(/
!"
*!($&/!-*
*!"
5#&(/
'8
&"
3!'
%(%4+$#$
"*!"
"*#
$#<&'#$
,-#<&'#'
*!$
&($##$
5#%<#
+( &"
!($
+('!

-
*+<!(
*!5&"!"&(
!($
"*#
"#(!("'
*!$
!%"+!44=
%#!'#$
"
%%+,=
"*#
'!<#
-
!
%("&(++'
,#-&$
 +-

B
<("*'8
,-#%#$&(/
"*#
$!"#

&('"&"+"&(

"*#
#9&%"&(
,#"&"&(


*!9#
*#!-$
4#!-(#$
%+('#4
-
"*#
,#"&"&(#-'
!($
,#-+'#$
"*#
,!,#-
5D

7#!-(#$
%+('#4
-
"*#
,#"&"&(#-'
'&<,4=
'##D'
"
-#&"#-!"#
"*#
'+5<&''&('
"*!"
3#-#
!$9!(%#$
5# -#
5"*
"*#
!+"*-&"&#'
!($
-#>#%"#$
!

"#-
!
$+#
!($
%<,-#*#('&9#
%('&$#-!"&(
44
3*!"
*#
*!'
+-/#$
&'
"*!"
"*#
#9&$#(%#
(
-#%-$
'*3#$
"*!"
"*#-#
&($##$
3!'
(
-#4!"&('*&,


4!($4-$
!($
"#(!("
5#"3##(
"*#
,!-"&#'
!($8
"*+'8
"*#
-#',($#("4!($4-$
*!$
(
4%+'
"
<!&("!&(
"*#
#9&%"&(
,#"&"&(


"*#-
!-/+<#("
3!'
!$9!(%#$
(
!
$+#
!($
"*+/*"

+4
%('&$#-!"&(
 <!""#-
&(
&''+#8

!<

"*#
%('&$#-#$
9&#3
"*!"
"*#
,#"&"&(
&'
3*44=
$#9&$

<#-&"
!($
&'
"*+'
4&!54#
"
5#
$&'<&''#$
-
"*#
-#!'('
"*!"
!-#
5#&(/
-#%-$#$
*#-#&(!

"#-

(%#$#$4=8
,-#$#%#''-&(&("#-#'"
 "*#
,#"&"&(#-'"#(!("'
*!$
&4#$
!
,#"&"&(
+($#-
.#%"&(


"*#

%"
!/!&('"
"*#
-#',($#("4!($4-$8
'##D&(/
-#,!&-'
&(
"*#
$#<&'#$
,-#<&'#'
($
"*+'8
"*#
,4#!
"*!"
"*#-#
(#9#-
#G&'"#$
!
-#4!"&('*&,

!
4!($4-$
!($
"#(!("
5#"3##(
"*#
,!-"&#'
3!'
3*44=
#--(#+'
!($
<&'%(%#&9#$
+-"*#-8
"#(!("

*+,&($#-
.&(/*
!$<&""#$
&(
*&'
%-''#G!<&(!"&(
"*!"
*#
*!$
,!&$
-#("8
&(
"*#
,-#'#("
,-%##$&(/'8
!'
!''#''#$
5=
"*#
#("
("-44#-
5=
!$<&""&(/
-#',($#("2#3!4
2-&'*!(


**!5-!
"
5#
*&'
4!($4-$
(%#
"*!"
3!'
'8
"*#
!-/+<#("
5#&(/
!$9!(%#$
5=
4#!-(#$
%+('#4
-
"*#
,#"&"&(#-'"#(!("'
,!4#'
&("
&('&/(& &%!(%#
+-"*#-8
#9&$#(%#
(
-#%-$
%(%4+'&9#4=
,-9#$
"*!"
"*#
,-#<&'#'
&(
C+#'"&(
3!'
&($##$
!
,!-"

"*#
5+&4$&(/
  A
!($
"*#
<!>-
,-"&(
"*#-#
*!$
!4-#!$=
!44#(
'
!
-#'+4"8
<'"

"*#
"#(!("'
*!$
!4-#!$=
!5!($(#$
,''#''&(
!($
4# "
.
<+%*
'8
-
 (#

"*#
-<'
&(
%%+,!"&(

"*#
,#"&"&(#-'
*!$
!4'

!44#(
$+#
"
&"'
$&4!,&$!"#$
%($&"&(
#,-"
'+5<&""#$
5=
"*#
5+&4$&(/
#G,#-"
-#9#!4#$
"*!"
"*#
5+&4$&(/
*!$
$#9#4,#$
*+/#
%-!%D'
!($
"*#
3!44'
*!$
5#%<#
,4+<5
(#
"*#-
"*!(
"*#
#G,#-"
#G!<&(#$
5=
"*#
"#(!("'
"#'"& &#$
"*!"
"*#
$#<&'#$
,-#<&'#'
3!'
5#=($
-#,!&-'
!($
%+4$
(4=
5#
-#%('"-+%"#$
&'
-#,-"
G $+4=
'+5'"!("&!"#$
"*&'
,'&"&(
*"/-!,*'8
G

8
G 8
G A8
G 8
G@

G@ 8
%4#!-4=
$#,&%"#$
"*#
$&4!,&$!"#$
%($&"&(
 5+&4$&(/
'
-#/!-$'H
3*#"*#-
,#"&"&(#-'
*!$
%#!'#$
"
%%+,=
"*#
$#<&'#$
,-#<&'#'8
("*&(/
3!'
5-+/*"
(
-#%-$
"
'*3
"*!"
"*#
,#"&"&(#-'
*!$
%%+,&#$
-
+'#$
"*#
$#<&'#$
,-#<&'#'
-
=#!-'8
&<<#$&!"#4=
,-#%#$&(/
"*#
&('"&"+"&(
 "*#
#9&%"&(
,#"&"&(
(
"*#
%("-!-=8
((#
"*!(
"#(!("

*+,&($#-
.&(/*
%(%#$#$
&(
*&'
%-''#G!<&(!"&(
"*!"
*#
3!'
-#'&$&(/
3&"*
*&'
#("&-#
!<&4=
!"
*!($&/!-*
*#
D&"%*#(
3!'
(( +(%"&(!4
'&(%#



4#%"-&%&"=
<#"#-
&(
"*#
,-#<&'#'
3!'
4=&(/
$#!$

#&"*#-
!(=
3!"#-
(-
!(=
#4#%"-&%&"=


5&44
3!'
5-+/*"
(
-#%-$
"
'*3
"*!"
"*#
"#(!("'
#9#-
-#<!&(#$
&(
+'#
!($
%%+,!"&(

"*#
,-#<&'#'
&(
"*#
-#%#("
,!'"
*#
5+&4$&(/
#G,#-"
#G!<&(#$
5=
"*#
"#(!("'
"*#<'#49#'
"#'"& &#$
"*&'
,'&"&(
7#!-(#$
%+('#4
-
"*#
,#"&"&(#-'
%+4$
("
,&("
+"
!'
"
*3
"*#
%(%4+'&('
"*!"
*!$
%(%+--#("4=
5##(
!--&9#$
!"
5=
5"*
"*#
!+"*-&"&#'
3#-#
#&"*#-
%("-!-=
"
"*#
,'&"&(
(
-#%-$
-
'+

#-#$
-<
!(=
<!"#-&!4
&44#/!4&"=

(
"*#
3!D#

"*#
,'&"&(
!'
'#"
+"
!59#8
(
&("#- #-#(%#
&'
3!--!("#$
&(
#G#-%&'#

-#9&'&(!4
>+-&'$&%"&(8
+($#-
.#%"&(


"*#
%"
#"&"&(
5#&(/
$#9&$

<#-&"
&'
!%%-$&(/4=
$&'<&''#$
%"5#-
8



!>!(














-+(
!44&




















+$/#