High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/6661/2015allowed

Jagbir Singh & ORS. v. Charanjit Singh & ORS.

2019-03-29Mr. Justice Arun Palli11 pages

! "!#$%$&'

()

( *+$,-$&*.&" .!,% ! $ $&!,% /!,%0% .,&1$ -$&*.&" .!,% !%2&"!& % '

3 4-4- ,!%!& '

,--$,2.$5.$6"/# !6 , .!2! $ $&!,% ,7$2$&.1&6"/# !6 ,,!%2&"!& &

4-6 ,8

9 .$% 2! $ $&6 .! 2! $ $&!,% #.88!&*! .! ,"!, .! 8!,&!" $/$8 0"*! 0&$, $/$%$&6 86 " !"

#29 &&!;0,!<6+9=.$#.&228$# $& $8!"+9 .!2! $ $&!,% 28$& $ % $& .!%0$ 60&"!,-!# $& .!"! $/$8,#!"0,!6.%+!!& "$%>$%%!" 7$"! .!%$"228$# $&6 .!2! $ $&!,%<28$& $ %%0*. . .!=,$ !&% !>!& $8!"+9 .!,!%2&"!& %<"! !&"& % .!>!&"!" 28$& +!,!1!# !"& .!*,0&" . =$ .0 # 0889>/$&*&228$# $& ,>!&">!& .!=,$ !&% !>!& ,$*$&889 $8!"6&!=#%!=% +!$&*%! 02+9 .!"! !&"& %6 5$&*%.!8 !, .! # . .!228$# $& .!2! $ $&!,%<28$& $ %0&"!,,"!,08!? .!."+!!& 88=!" % 2!, .! $>20*&!" ,"!,6 .! 2! $ $&!,%<28$& $ % ."

>!&"!" .!28$& +9""$&*2,*,2.

!,,&!0%89,! !,,!" % 2,*,2. $& .! $>20*&!" ,"!, &" $&% !" $8$&* =,$ !& % !>!& %$>289,!289$&* . ""$ $&82,*,2.6 .!,!%2&"!& %< "! !&"& %./! $8!"=,$ !&% !>!& 8%8 !,$&* .!% &" 5!&$& .!,2,*,2.%6 .!,!+9%! $&*02&!=#%!

.! 8!,&!" ,$8 0, !, ./$&* #&%$"!,!" .! > !, !/!& 0889,!8$!"02&10"*>!& .$%0, $&.& @2$8 !//% -> ,5%.A $&" .!,%6

:6 .8" . &#!28$& ."+!!&>!&"!"6$ */!#>28! !,$*. .!"! !&"& % $8!&!= =,$ !&% !>!& 6 5$&*=. !/!,28! .!9=$%. 10"*>!& #$ !"&+!.8 .!28$& $ %6$!>2,/!>!& ,0% 6 $8 .,0*.$ %">$&$% , ,B.$,>&/%%=$&"!,@0,&" .!,%6

C )C6=%8%,! !,,!" +9 . 0, +0 =%.!8" +!& 228$#+8!$&/$!= .! # . .!8 !,10"*>!& =% 0&" +9 . 0, .8"$&*%>! .$&* .!#& ,,9 &%!D0!& 896 .!228$# $&=%"$%>$%%!"&"#>28! !89 &!=>!&"!"=,$ !&% !>!& ,!289$&* .!>!&"!"28$& =%88=!" +! $8!" )

! ,! .$%0, 68!,&!"#0&%!8 , .!2! $ $&!,%<28$& $ % $,% ",=% !& $& %0+,08! 08!? ,"!, .!"! $/$8 ,#!"0,!6% 228$#+8! .!- !% 0&1+&",9&&" .&"$*,. .!!& $,!,08!$%+!$&*,!2,"0#!".!,!$&0&"!,'< E

.!0, >9 &9% *! .! 2,#!!"$&*% 88= !$ .!, 2, 9 8 !, , >!&" .$%

) 28!"$&*$&%0#.>&&!,&"&%0#. !,>%%>9+!1!% 6&" 88%0#.>!&">!& %%.88+!>"!%>9+!&!#!%%,9 , .! 20,2%! "! !,>$&$&* .! ,!8 D0!% $&% $& #& ,/!,%9 +! =!!& .!2, $!%'

,/$"!" . &228$# $& ,>!&">!& %.88+! 88=!" !, .! ,$8.%#>>!&#!"60&8!%% .!0, #>!% .!#&#80%$& . $&%2$ ! "0!"$8$*!&#!6 .!2, 9#08" & ./!,$%!" .!> !,+! ,! .!#>>!&#!>!& ,$8

/!,9228$# $& ,>!&">!& %%.88+!$&=,$ $&* &"%.88% ! .!%2!#$ $#>!&">!& %=.$#.,!%0*. +! >"!$&"$# $&* .!=,"%,2,*,2.% +!""!"6>$ !" ,%0+% $ 0 !"$& .!,$*$&828!"$&*F ! .!,! !,,!8$!%02&10"*>!& .!-02,!>!0,

,$%$&* ,>10"*>!& 2%%!"+9 .$%0, 6$& 0,"$8-$&*./%1 @0>,&!16

!& (C6 ,>=.$#. .! 2$& % .! 88=$&*2,*,2.%'< E) ! ,! 2, $&* =! !!8 $&#8$&!" >5! #!, $& +%!,/ $&%+0 .!8%!2,# $#!2,!/8!& $&%0+,"$& ! 0, % $& !& !, $&$&* &" "!8$&* =$ . 228$# $&% , >!&">!& 28!"$&*% $%"$% 0,+$&* ! 0,!&"6$ %0#. 2,# $#!#& $&0!%6$ $%8$5!89 .=, .!#0,%! 10% $#! .!228$# $&>/!"+9 .!##02& % ,>!&">!& $& .!$, =,$ !& % !>!& % $8!" !,8$!, "$" & %2!#$ $#889 %! 0 =.$#.2, $&% .!,$*$&828!"$&*%=!,!%0*. +! "!8! !"&"=. =!,! .!/!,>!& %=.$#.=!,!%0*. +!

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

;;

:A.!&&! .!2, $!%6.%+!!&2!,>$ !" >!&".$% 28!"$&*6&22, 0&$ 9.% +!*$/!& .!22%$ !2, 9 >!&".$%28!"$&*.!22%$ !2, 9%.888%./! >5! &228$# $&0&"!,,"!,08!? .!=.$#.6 #0,%!6 =08" ,"$&,$89 &" 8$+!,889 +! 88=!" -0#. >!&">!& %,!5&=&%#&%!D0!& $8>!&">!& %.! 2.,%! G#&%!D0!& $8 >!&">!& G $&"% >!& $& $& .! "!#$%$& .$%0, $&

! #$%& .!

!;2,!%%$&$%10"$#$889,!#*&$H!"A.$8!*,& $&*8!/! >!&"28!"$&* +9=9 #&%!D0!& $8>!&">!& .!

0, %.88%!! . .!28!%0*. +!$& ,"0#!"$%+9=9 &&%=!, .!28!2,!/$0%892!,>$ !" +!$&#,2, !" +9=9 >!&">!& +9 .!22%$ !2, 9&!=28!#&& +! 2!,>$ !" +! ""!" $& .! *,+ #&%!D0!& $8 >!&">!& 6 .0*.$ #&+!228$!"+9=9 &$&"!2!&"!& 2,$>,9>!&">!& F C 4!,&!" #0&%!8 , ,!%2&"!& & & .! .!, .&"

%0+>$ % . &#!28$& .%+!!&88=!" +!>!&"!"6&9=,$ !& % !>!& $8!"$&,!289 .!>!&"!"28$& .% +!88=!"6!%2!#$889 =.!&$ =% .! ,$80, $ %!8 =.$#."$,!# !" .!"! !&"& % $8!& >!&"!"=,$ !&% !>!& ! 0, .!,%0+>$ % . .!,!=%+%80 !89&#0%! $8!& 228$# $&0&"!,,"!,08!?6&#!&>!&">!& .!28$& ."+!!&88=!"

&%022, .$%#& !& $&6.!#$ !% ,>10"*>!&

$/$%$& !&#. .$%0, $& $,".,$88/%@,$%.& 6(

0&1+ ?

6=.!,!$&$ .%+!!&.!8" .! 88=$&*! !# '< E/$&*.!8" .$%6.!22!,%8% ./!+%!,/!" . .! &!= 28!% #& $&!" $& .! ,!%. =,$ !& % !>!& .! >!&"!"28$& =!,!0&0 .,$%!"&""!%!,/!" +!,!1!# !"I , .!20,2%! #>28! $&* .!#%!6.=!/!,6.!#&%$"!,!" $ 2,2!, *$/! $&"$&*%& .!&!=28!%%=!88&+!.8 .!,!%2&"!& 6+%!,/ $&% .!8=!,22!88 !0, ./! +!!&,!2! !"6&" .!0&%!8.%%0+>$ !" . .!&!= =,$ !& % !>!& %.08" & ./! #& $&!" &9 .!,

""$ $&828!!;#!2 .!&!#& $&!"&",!% ,$# !" .! >!&"!"2, $& .!28$& 6=$ .0 .!!;2,!%%2!,>$%%$& .!0, %8$""=&$&,"!,,08!?6"! $/$8 ,#!"0,! >0&+8! 02.8" .$%#& !& $&& .! $,% 28#! .!,!$% &,08! 8=6% 0 ,9, .!,=$%!6=.$#.,!% ,$# %,8$>$ % .!"! &"& =.!&.!$%#88!"02& $8!=,$ !&% !>!& &>!&"!"28$& 6 #& !% .!28$& $ 3%#8$>6 &9 2, $#08, 28!%.! *!&!,8 %#.!>! .! "! $/$8 ,#!"0,!&" .!28$#90&"!,89$&* .!8= 28!"$&*%"!% & %0**!% &9%0#.,!% ,$# $&&" .!#0&%!8.%& +!!& +8! #$ !&92,!#!"& $&%022, .$%#& !& $&8!%$& =,$ !&% !>!& &>!&"!"28$& ,!& !;#80%$/!89 #& ,88!",*/!,&!"+9 .!2,/$%$&% ,"!,,08!? .!"!I .!

2,/$%$&% ,"!,:,!!D0889<$ & >,!< ,!8!/& &"$>2, & $& .$%#&&!# $& &>9/$!= .!D0!% $&"!%& 22!,6% ,$# 89%2!5$&*6 +!&! >!&">!& .! $,% =,$ !&% !>!& =.$#.#08" &89+!! # !"=$ . .!2!,>$%%$& .!0, I$ ,!889 2!, $&%>,! .!,$*. .!"! &"& #& !% .!%0$ % >"!0 $& .!>!&"!"28$& ,!"%=.8!.!8= ,!8 $&* 28!"$&*%%.08"& +!#&% ,0!"&"228$!"=$ . 0&"0!,$*$"$ 9&"% ,$# &!%%$ &2,!10"$#!,!>+,,%%>!& =,"% $, ,$8 .!%0$ $%#0%!" =08" #0,%!+! 2!& .! 0, #&%$"!, =.! , , & 6 +!

!, .0*. 6 .!28!%$&D0!% $&8#5!">!,$ 6+0 .!,$*. .!"! !&"& ,$%! .!&!=28!%#08".,"89+!&!* $/!" +9,! !,!&#! .!2,/$%$&% ,"!,,08!?&89

%$"!%6$ $%& %.=&% =.9#08" .!"! &"& & ,!%$% 6!/!& .!&!=>!&"!",!8$! #8$>!"+9 .!28$& $ 6+9 28!"$&* . .!2,2!, 9."+!!&20,#.%!" ,.$%+!&! $ &"." .0%+!!& .,=&$& .!G#>>&% #5G&& ,!%&+8! *,0&" #08" .! "! &"& +! 2,.$+$ !" , "!+,,!" ,>0,*$&* .!&!=28!$&&%=!, .!&!=,!8$! *$&6$ $& .! ,$80, &%0#.+1!# $&*$&% .!&!= 28!+!$&*0&0 .,$%!"."+!!&2,!%%!"6$ $%"0+ 08$ $ #08"6 , .! $,% $>!6+!,$%!"$& .!0, 22!8 +%!&#! ,>8,"!,0 .,$%$&* .!>!&">!& <$ 88 $ =% &!#!%%,9<=% $& .! 2,!%!& #$,#0>% &#!% >!,! $,,!*08,$ 9& !# $&* .!>!,$ %.!%8"+1!# .! 28!"$&*%$% %!!=.!,! .!2, $!%"$ !,6&" . !#.%$"! >9+! 08898$/! .!D0!% $&% .

,!+0 +!,*0!"6 % . .!9>9""0#!8822,2,$ !!/$"!&#!I&"$ .$% +1!# .% +!!& #.$!/!"6 .!& ,08! 0 .! >!&"!" 28!"$&*%=08" !&" "! 6$&% !" 2,> $&*6 .!#0%! 10% $#!6 ,%!,/$&*=.$#.8&! .!,08!% 2,#!"0,!!;$% ./! .!,! ,!&.!%$ $&$&,!2!88$&* .!#& !& $&,$%!" &+!.8 .!,!%2&"!& F ! 0, .!,,!8$!%02&10"*>!& #,"$& ! !&#. .$% 0, 6%=%,!8$!"02&+9 .! ,$80, 6$& .& @2$8 !

-> ,5%.A $&" .!,%6

:6=.!,!$& !,& $#$&* .!

10"*>!& .!-02,!>!0, $&0,"$8-$&*.%3#%! %02,6$ =%.!8"

% 88=%'< E 0"*>!& $& .!#%! 0,"$8-$&*. %02,#$ !"+9 8!,&!"%!&$,#0&%!8 ,,!%2&"!& %&&" #&& +!

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

/$%$& 2! $ $& =.$#. $&/8/!% #>28! 89"$ !,!& $%%0! .!,$%5 ,!2! $ $&6$ >9+! $*.8$*. " . .! #& ,/!,%$8 2, $& .! =,$ !& % !>!& >!&"!"28$& $%&89#&%!D0!& $8>!&">!& &".%+!!&28!"!" #& ,/!, .!>!&"!"2, .! 28$& &" %%!, $ 8! "! &"& &)=.$#.$%"!&$!"$& .!>!&"!"2, .!

( .0%6=. .%+!!&+%!,/!"+9 .!$,4,"%.$2%$& 0,"$8 -$&*.%3#%!=%.!8" +!&89&"& 89$&*"=& .!, $ 2,$&#$28! 8= ,.1& 0, .!,%0+>$ % . .!10"*>!& $&.& @2$8

!/%3#%!=% 5!&+9=9 -4+9 .!,!%2&"!& % .!,!$&+! ,! .! -02,!>!0, 6=$ . . 2! $ $&./$&*+!!&"$%>$%%!"&)?

? /$&*#&%$"!,!" .!> !,6%,!*,"%"$%>$%%8 .!-4 $8!"*$&% .!10"*>!& .$%0, $&.& @2$8 !/%3#%!6$ $% %!!& . .!2! $ $&%!!5$&*-2!#$84!/! 22!8=%"$%>$%%!"+9 .!$,4,"%.$2%=$ .0 >5$&*&9#>>!& =. %!/!,& .!$%%0!% ,$%$&* .!,!$&&" .!,! ,!6& 0,8896 . ,"!,#&& +!.!8" +! +$&"$&*2,!#!"!& /!,,$"$&* .!!,8$!,10"*>!& .!-02,!>!0, $& 0,"$8-$&*.%3#%! %02, %,!*,"% .!+%!,/ $& .$%0, $&.& @2$8 !/%3 #%! .!! !# . =. .%+!!&% !"$&0,"$8-$&*.%3#%!+9 .! -02,!>!0, %,!2,"0#!".!,!$&+/!=%&89+9 6=$ .

.!0 >% ,!%2!# 6=08" $&">9%!8 & $&*,!!>!& =$ . . +%!,/ $&6$&/$!= .! # . $ .%+!!&/!,9#8!,89.!8"+9 .!$, 4,"%.$2%$&2,*,2.%) : . 10"*>!& 6 . !/!& ,%!!5$&*& >!&">!& $& .!=,$ !&% !>!& $8!"$&,!289 &>!&"!"28$& 6$ #&& +! "&! 0&"!, .! *0$%! 3#&%!D0!& $8 >!&">!& 3 &" .!,! ,!6&!#!%%,$896&228$# $&0&"!,,"!,08!? .!.% +! $8!"+9 .!"! !&"& % .0*.$ .% +!!&.!8" . &>!&">!& %0*. $& .! =,$ !&% !>!& $&,!289 &>!&"!"28$& %.08"E,"$&,$89&"

8$+!,889+!88=!"F6 .!,! !,$ .%+!!&%2!#$ $#889% !" . .!0, %.88%!! . .!28!%0*. +!$& ,"0#!"$%+9=9 &&%=!, .! 28!2,!/$0%892!,>$ !" +!$&#,2, !"+9=9 >!&">!& +9 .! 22%$ !2, 9&" . &!=28!#&& +!2!,>$ !" +!""!"$& .! *,+ #&%!D0!& $8>!&">!& .0*.$ #&+!228$!"+9=9 & $&"!2!&"!& 2,$>,9>!&">!& : 0, .!,6 .!#& !& $& 8!,&!"#0&%!8 ,,!%2&"!& &

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

& 6$&>92$&$&6&"#&%!D0!& 896 .! ,$80, =.889!,,!"$& "$%>$%%$&* .!228$# $& $8!"+9 .!2! $ $&!,%<28$& $ % .!,! ,!6 .$%2! $ $&$%88=!"6=$ . .!$>20*&!","!,%! %$"!=!/!,6 .!>!&">!& .!2! $ $&!,%<28$& $ %./$&*+!!& 88=!" % *!!/!&=.!&!/$"!&#!."+!!&8!"6 .!,!%2&"!& %< "! &"& %=08"+! 8$+!, 9!/!&&= >/!&22,2,$ !228$# $& $& !,>% 08!? ,"!, .!6=.$#.=08"+!#&%$"!,!"

$ %=&>!,$ %+9 .! ,$80, &""!#$"!"!;2!"$ $0%8965!!2$&*$&/$!= .!, $ .!10"*>!& .!-02,!>!0, $& *! + #%!

%02,

()

( ,-. //0 0*12 25B/#*,* 34(*5 A.! .!,%2!5$&*B,!%&!"

!%B A.! .!,!2, +8!

!%B