Maman Singh And Others v. Manohar Lal Saini (Deceased) Through His Lrs And Others




   
   

 

 !" "# $ # %#&  "#'(  "#&!""' "# )        



 $# 

# *+#!#, - #./," #&0"-./ #") # #$#  !"  -./ #"#)   


 .#!& ,#"# 

"2&! , )# & 3"(# #& # ' (#) ## "#/ ) ! " 2&!   )  45  "  .))((  .&"#5    6 6

 ,"( #/# !"2&! )45" 
 #((### !"/

"#)    #"") "!#&  )5 #  4&( !"/ !4&

 &   #"&

"4 3" (5&,"")#4 #"
&#,(( 4 #".))((.&"#5,""#"##( ")4, ) #( (# "#)  

 8""
&#"/ &## (5 & "")#)#5, )&#"45 &( !"/#!#( 6 99- :;$<6=   /-,   &( !" (&!  &( !"

"4  (5( -,"#45"")( !,""# )#)#5"""#   /3" #&,# /&#   //2&!  # 9 

3" # /&#   /,"(( !45 )",  &( !"

"#&!"
/(  & & 6

,"",



3"( (#) #(""5"/)&#"" )#)#5 #  //#!#(



 3"( (# #)&#" !")#)#5 ()

& #  > "?#5 @#4 
 #(   :/ .-

> >

3"/ ,&!" ,!#& - #(5-"  " ()5"#  

(5 #" )&#" ")#)#545"( (#) #- (5-"")

)&#&

5#( &

 &   #"& "4

4 ! ()  A,)("# ( 0"/#& ,5-)(# #"# ",(( (( !-/#&#0"/ ))# ",(( "# ,((,#"#4& (( 3" # (# "") (4& (( 3"#)    ")    (5", #") "( (#4&("#( ") "( (#  '#     
 #((#-   #  ))# !  "  / - ##"/ 4""!#& -",/#-(# 

> .))((  .&"#5  "  #/#  "  2&!   )  45  "   
 #((# ### ! !""( (##, # )#)#5-",/#-"#( ") ( (#   )#/ -"# #-")    4(A54!

   "" )(""5"/4, #45,5 /# )   ?,/#-  (#   B#  .))(( 
&#  "  #2  " #        "        (#  "  "  ) # ( (##", # ")#)#5 '#   .))((  .&"#5  ,"(  #/# !  "  2&!  )45" 
 #((#"/!/ ((, !# 

/ "4 (45") #)#/,"

 "#'( , &&"45"#/ #  / #45#! (, # "") (5 &( !"3",  )#&  45  "  ( (#) #  &(    (  ,"

 "#'(, &  3"## "& )(
 )#/" "# '(," ")#)#5 )& > #  ##)"4 )#&)#/"#( ")

"( (#  6 3" "4#"# "#  !"  "#'( )#/(&

4 " 3"
&#""#"(# & ( #")# ( !" ,""#4( ! "#&!""2&! )45 4""
&#4(, "## " #)  "
&#-"#/#,"( !

6 / /(4( (,"""4 !

#45".))(( .&"#5## !" "#'(#)  ,

"") 3"#& #  "(;&45  / /&# ") #



# # "#'(  ) )#    /  ,  (#  , #    "  )#    )&  / 2&!  # 9 

:;$

)!  &(

!"-"#! (, #."-") #( (#,#

 )&#3" #2&!  # /&#  &(

!","(( !45 )",  &( !"/
/( &

( 6

A " #&-'0"-( "# !"  4#"#     "#  '(   ))#     ) ((5 " "!#& (# ")#")  "# '(   99A,("" 5#( " ##&

!"") #0 ! (( !", #" )#  .)#& )(##)#&45") # #"5#

,#)#/" &( !", # ")#)#5   ) &4"   "  4 ##4&))# "")  )

  #)   (5)# ,"( !) / ."0*&# #*#"

,",( (# # (# "") "))# """ "# , # (#,"# "#'(,"

9 "!#& (#4&"5/")#") # ( )  ,"")#0)( ,  (  &  (  ,"  "  #   !/  45  "  .))(( .&"#5,"(#/# !"2&! "#(
&# B## ## &") ###//( "(##! ((5""),!/ # ,"# "5# ,"#")# ) ,4 ! ( "5#

? -" , #"( (#&( 4 ) (,"

 "#'(, & 3"  &  " #(/  #")&#)  ")# )#&(#(5,"

"!#&  #/ "/ #(/  #")#  53" .))((.&"#5"(0 /#

#  " )5 # 4 !( #

(5 #"  )&#" -"# #-"# )5 "# " ( (#.)#  "3#  # $#)#5.-

-", # 4 (#/#"# (5 #"""4 , #A ")# -",",(45"( (#3" ) , ( #)# 65#? -"4   ( (#&( 4)& 3" # !

45"
&#""& )( ## )#/" "#'( "")A54

")#"& )(##-#!" "5#

)#/" &( !",, # ")#)#5 "") )      "  #   
 9  )  )#   "  3"  & )(  ##   &

-"# ##!#"")4 !

 # )#/ "#'("("" ) )#)#5", #8""
&#"/(#5#2")(&) 45" """4, # -" 5 "5#

99-#//("(#

4;)4 ) #   ;# !

45".))((.&"#5""   "#  !"-4#"# - ")#/&&  4 ! " &4-"  4 !-",/#-"  "4#"# () / ,""

)#/" "#'( ")#)#5 )&3"  

, )#/&(! ," ") #,# 

)&# (( &#"#- -) # ; ## , ( ! " #*#"

 # (# "") ? )# /")# /&# ") #."0 *&# #*#"

"))# /  ")" " "#," # (#  "#'(,"  "!#& (#.)# #"/ ?&0
" - !"4&#" ))# ()4& "#'(4 ! ) 

"") (( &#"#- # &((5#" + !   "#'(-,""))#< -))# ""  #(4(, .&!! ,!/ ""(#

 

"")    &( !"-? !

 !

# 45 !"" )"# ?/ !" ; 45 !"" 0 ,,""#  /,   &(

!"# ?/  ,"#*#"

 (( &#"#-("&!"-

)#/ (""&  (5#04&"#

!# 4,  "#'( ?# 9

,"# " & #0    /  "  )#    7&  ,"  "#  5#   # "#! !" 5& 
6-

-

= #") & ,""

- 9-

=,#/#  5 /, " #/#,"( !/ -"#  !

45"(# .))((.&"#5,"(#/# !" !

" 
 #((#,#,"((5## &? -"##)45" (# .))((.&"#5 / ) ((, .((") !(( &))( - 5-#) - /, "4/2&!    





   !"#$"#%&'#()*+,-%#(&.+#/0 #&-.

!"#$"#%%#'.%$(12#0 #&-.