High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/6682/2016disposed of

Avtar Singh Khara v. Chandigarh Golf Club Sec 6 Chd & ORS

2017-01-27Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi26 pages

!"#"$% &

&

'(#)#

&*

'(#)#

+%

,-++ . +-/ (#$ % !

" #!

" $

%&&'(()*&

%&+,&()*&

" -

%&+,&()*& %*". /

%&&'(()*& 0 " " %(

%&&'(()*& + . +-/0 1(

2 "

((+ 3 "4

##

"

#

#

! # (*,()*&8

9

3

"

"

" # $# " :

#

"

;

8

"

((+ 3 "

"

# #

! # (*,()*&

< "

"

%&&'(()*& %&+,&()*&"

## "

#

2 "

"

#

%&&'(()*&

"

$ %*

= #

"*'&)"

1 #

##

** ##"

## #

# >

1 "

? #

## #

1#

# ## "

"

? #

## " ()*&$()*+"

$

&

" (+ $0 # 4$ @ ?

##

(/)/()*& A

A

(/)/()*& =

%#

./()*&

%#

&/()*& ?

'/()*& " %(

#

"

/,5 6

;

5B C 6 !

#

%($3

D/()*&5

:$.6E! !

E

##

&/()*&5

: $/6" #

##

## 3

3

#

##

#"

=

$

#

3

"

E

## $ F %.

/" #

!

5

: $*6 **/()*& #

"

:$D" E., * (

*D* 5BC 6" $

#

!

"

7 # $ %*". /

:$& $ %( # "

$

#

!

1 "

#

" #

$

#

!

" ((/()*& 5

: $+6 #

% ,/ (.D()*&

: $' # #

< "

" #

! #

(*,()*&5

:$,6

"

((/()*& "

# 0 " #

$ $

#

!

#

# # $ %( #

# #

"

#

#

"

"

*/ *+ #

! # " /,5 6 " $ %(

A

#

! # (*,()*&

<

"

%&')*()*&53

-

6 "

3

"

"

# #()*&" # "

" " # # $

%&&'(()*&

%&+,&()*&"

#

"0

#

3 " 0

#

#

#

$

%&+,&()*& %*

%&&'(()*&"

# :

< "

"

/,5 6 "

#

!

#

# # 9

$

"

/,5 " #

<

*+ #

! # $ %( "

# %(#

#

"

#

#

%(

"

$"

# "

$

#

"

$

## : $ %(

&

$"

/,5 6 "

< "

#

! # 3

"

! # C #

$)

("8 $ 9(# '#

## : $ 9(#0

153&* +)"2 (#;

- '# 9<9< : 9) $ 9(#0 ***1355

%&&'(()*&" #

#

! # "

#

"

$

%&&'(()*&

%&+,&()*&"

#

"#

"

/,5 6

#

#

#

##

"9 3

#

/,5 6"

/+56 " # ##

## # ! " #

$

E., * (

$

#

!

9

$ : #

#

## "

+*(()*&" # 9

3

"

##

#

0 D( -

$ 0

" :

#

: #

#

## (/*()*+" :*&/()*+ #

%&&'(()*&

%&+,&()*&"

#

"

"

0

#

"

# 9

3

"

"

" #

! #

< "

" 1" #

"

* A

" /&"

/+"/'"/,"D("&+"&'"+) +( ;

# 4$ 5

$ "$=::"

@

## #

## #

?:

1 ## #

## # #

# # ## ## 0 ##

## 1 #

## 4 56 1 ##

##

:

! 56 1

61

##

5&+ $ ="$=::"

56

## "

" ** ## = "

## #

>1 #

561 ##

# ":

()).$())/

? )()/ 5 ##

##

#

## 1

##

##

$ 5*

"! ((# 56 1 #

## #

######

#

-

"

"

"1; 561

#

$ ##

## #! #:

## # > # "

# ##

## #

#

" "

## #3

*(##

**

##

6 %## ##

## #

$ # 16 3 "2"$= ;

!

$!"# (#" $ !

" -

#

3

#

-

"

-

"

##

-

# -

F

"

" # 1&3 $( 2+ "$=#

#

#

#

1

13 #

?:

1& 3 56 1

#

4$ GGG GGG GGG GGG GGG

GGG GGG GGG GGG 6 1

## 1& 3 "! $( 2+ "$= % .)

##

" #

"

#

#

#

H

$

;

" #0

"

" 2 >

#

" :

$2 ## "

# # "

3 D( ;

" ##

" -

$ #

"

3

"

#

-

$ "

# " ##

"#

#

:

#

F

$

" "

# " #

"0

"

#

0

#

2 "

#

" "

#

$ %(

"

"

# "

# #

"

# "

#0

$ " #

$ %(" # 3 #

%(

"

"

# #

#

3

#

$

#

$ %( #

" 0

#"

"

#

"

# "

#

"

# # "

# #

! %(

# #

"

#

"

3

1

#

" %

0 "

3

#

"

"

%(3 #"

< "

"

/, 5 6 #

#

$

#

!

1 2

" " "

#

"

$ "

$ %(

E ., * ( *D*"

$

#I

#

"

#

!

#

!

# "

#

#

#

"

$

$

#

!

"

:

!

" ##

#

/,5 6"

" #

< "

"

"

/,5 6 !

" #

"

"

#

! #

# "

#

!

#

! #

" #

"

! # " # "

1

" '( '. ! # J #

+)"2 (#, 5 6" 4$

!

"

#"

#"

#$

! %

&

'

! & '

(

!

&

)

!! (!

* + )

!

,

!

!

'

)

)

-

!

.

!

/

.

/

)

) 1

/

1

1

/

1 ! /

,

!

2

# " # J #

*& ! #

$)

("8 ,# 5 6

#

*& ! #

$)

("8 ,# 5 6 4$ !

/

)

)

.

*!

) ,

- )3445 !

!

&

.

-

(

.

*!

.

.

-

)

!&)

!

.

*!

)

7

.

*!

!

,

- )3445

) .

- !

!)

" ! !

*

"

/

) ! )

/

.8"#$ % &

'!! '( ) 3

#

:#

"

"

! # # #"

#

#0

" J #

:

#)$ (

3'#

:"2 ) $ 9(#0

1436440$"$

$ "

'#:("

- 2+ $!9 $ $ 9(#0

5143&60

("## '#+ 22"< #0

1 3 &6

> # $' $#9"- 20

1 3644 0 "

# C #

** *(

! #

9C 5 6"

0

# 9

C 5 6 3 C 5 6"

" 4$ **@*(K-

,

6

! 1 !

1 9

,

%

) !

: ;<

)

,

1 )

:;<

: ;<

!,

"

! !

! !

;.8 .

=

! .

. =

;,->?@A.@BC< 0 =

!D

D! =

;>??@;@<.BB<,

/

1

, $

E

!F ;>?4><,B?5;F<)6

F ! !

!

!)

/

/ !

/

#

"

# 90 "

#"

#

1 # # 90

# !

# 90

!

E - 3 "5())&6* (+D ('(" *( >3 >5G

= !

6 9 !

/ !

/

!

1

) !

)

/

1

)

:

F * ! D F H

;>?5>,CIC C@><)F D !8;,6->B% D< &

)

)

!

"

)1

, $

!

& >@ =!D

J ;>?C4;3<,

6-

3?B<F - ; ,

6-3?C%<)&F ,

&

)1 . F H . ;(3<;>?C><>"F->4@3 !8;,6- >3CB%<&=

)

)

!

!

-

F1 , $

& , )

! - ;>?C3;3<"F-5IC<F

8;,6- C@>< &

!

)

& >C

/ )

D >5

F D

!

;, K! ),->?@3.@A4 &6

!

) ) ! ; 7<

)

)

!&

&$

)

* +,, #, - .

",/ ,0

1!!(233 324 5 " #

$

# #

1

#

$

# # #

< "

"

*+ #

! #

#

"

0

"

2

"

#

3

# ##

$

%

"

# "

$ %(

$

" #

#

2 "

1 :

!

"

$

" # #

"

#

"

# #

" #

#

"

$ #

# $#

"

#

" "

3 " 9 3

"

## $

!

0 D(" #

-

$ "

= "

## $

"

# $#

#

"

D(" +) +* ;

3

: #

#

(/*()*+"

## $ : *&/()*+ >

#

" " 3 "

2

3

# $# 2

$ $"

/,5 6 D("

" 2

"

#

$

#

"

## 9

3

" 2

#"

9 0 9

$ #

1

## $

" $ % #

#

" # "

$

$

#

" $ #"

" " &

& 1+ . +-/3 :8# 0

F LF% LF%