High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/6545/2012dismissed

Balwant Singh Narang And ANR v. Saroj Gupta

2017-02-22Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari25 pages

!"#$%&'()*+&,))! "!-!%+!

! "

# !

$ ! " .' % ! !!

" &$ '

( $ )*)+*+)+),+-*+)* ! $ &$ ! &

$ &&.

) !" " !

$ $& " / / " " & "

/ % & "! 012*3/ / ! &!"$ !/2 !!& 2 & !4 5

&$ & " ! / !

& & !

/& &7! $ &! !7&" / !$& &$$ "!

!/ !% " !"&7!$.

/ !&

+)+5)--8 012*3 & / & / ! 1& "

! ! " !/22 &" ! "!!& /!

&!/ & "!!"

/ & ! & " / $ !! &!" " ! !/ " &!/ & " 2! !

" % "

" !" "/ $% !

7 2/ " "

" !/ !! $ &! / $/ !! / $/ & "" "

/ ! % / "

5 &" !! "! & "

& /$ .

2! " / $ / % &!

$ " " $

" ! !

( ' "

/$&/ ! &$ ' & " / ! &/ "

/! & % & +5+**++* " " & ! & ! "! ! " ! & / &" $ ! " "

/ !

" " $ / ! " ! / / " 9 !! &/ " $ / ! " " ! & &$.

" !

/ " $ !

" " " ! & 9

!! &/ /

% " $$" 5$ /" " ! & !" $ !! " ! !

& "&

" 9 !! &/ ! !

! &

"& !! /

!"# $% %! !$ & " " &$ ' & " &#'( (

)( (

&* + &$ &/ ! " & / & 9 $ !

" !! /" 2' '

( , )(,-.

/ "

+ !"#

2## 3( 3(

! &!" $

!" " $ & !

# ( '" / " 2 ' ,( ' 2- "40(

)'#4 5(4

* $$% ,3 # 3( , (

# !"#

&/ " " $ $ & ! & ! !"& " " &$ ' & !! /" ' -

,(#

%$% !! !/ "

! ! ! /"

72/ " " 9&/ ! "! " !/&" $

! !! $& & ' ! / " & ! !/! &/ !

!&" ! !! /" 2' 2 " &#,4" ,#6,#, *

40(# 3(

$ +%&/ ! ! & ! ! ! "

/ $ $ " ' &% !

&! &: );)+)-<) " !

"& / & "$ ! % " $ " "!9 " ! !/

' &

$! " "

&& " " &$ )7$ " < &!

" 8< / *,=2*,=

" / " $ /& 7>97;;8037>97 ?--0 3 ! !

% & &/ 9

" $ / <

)7 / $ " *++@7 " +)+;)-8+ !! &2!& / & &$& " !

$ & "

&$ " ! / / $ " @ 4+)+<)-<) / *,=2*,= &!

" 8<" / " $ ( / $ "5;+@7% / ! " /" );)+)-<)01253 /" ! " < &!

" 8< & &$ & / $ !"

! ?

/ " @ / ! *,+;)-<?" $/"

" 2A);B +*+<)-<-"6 ,)+))-<- " " $ ) " " $ $

" " / !! " 7 !

2 9! " !$ & / * " &! ! " $!

$ $&

" / . " !

$ $& &!/!/ / ." !

/ A);++@7 / : !& % $ !/ "

/"/ &!

: "

/ !! $ !!$ &

C$ " / )7 "! & $ & ! & +)+5)--89" &/ $ & & % / !$ &!

" &!

" &$ $" / & / !! $&$ / / "

7 ! " ! / /"

" /!

" $ &! ! " $9" &!/!/ / 9 " !& $: $ &/"

/ 9 & & +)+5)--8 ! 9

"DD & +)+5)--?.

,)+,)--? * ! +)+5)--8012*39&/ & DD !

$ & !

!/! " / !

* / "& / "!

9 " / " &$ $ !$" +)+5)--8 &!

$!$

& % / ! !:! /!

!/" "!/"& ) !

$ $ & 9"

! /"

! " " ! $D/ 76)" "" $ / / " $ "

) / ! ! & % ! 7 "

! ! 12-)). !!

72/ " /

&?* $ " $ 2! " )8)+)-<- . " +)+5)--? /" 79

! "! &

& ! !

"/ $

/ / && / & " / & / 6*

D/ &/ "" " !" $2/ !/

$ .!

72/ 2

& / " @ $& /" @ . $

& "

/ " &

/$ DD .

/ D/ 6,&/ "" .

@$ ."

"/ $ % ( E

( .

" & .

6) !

7 2/ / " "" "

! " " " "/ )-+)*+)+!/$& . / !!/ ' " ! 9!

72/ / "

// & "

!! ! ! )--? $ !/2 " !/2 $ 2 "

/ 9!/ %2 / % /" ! /$

# !/2!

/ / / " /" 5$

! " & 79

9/ "

/" @ " $ *++<7+- &!7

! " /% / " " "

/ & /

! !/2/ *++;7+?9" / &

$!!& " "

/ %

! 2! . $ !& / " 9! !$ " ' 8<*8+5*+++ ! ))))*++5 " & / "/ $ //& & "

! .

" 12)* &/

" " = !% "!/"& !!"

/ ! ' / & " )+$ !)--8 % / $ " 2 / )--8 -/!

/ ! <,+/ " !/ % !!& " "

/ & / &$ / / /"6* 9

/ / & %2E / ! " & !!

! "

/ !! .

" "$ / & ! !! . $ / & / " !! /

! / &$ ! / !

: ! //& //& $/ / "

/ "

/. " $ ! "$& "$ &$ /"

/ "

/ / &!/ .! " " "

" /$

""& ! " /" ) 6, !

72/ / "" $"

! / / % &

2 / % &/&$ /

& / & /&$$"!

:9! " "

"" $6 : " !/2" "

/ /"2 / /

"$!

2" "

" &/ $ . $ $/"2 /

! :/" !/2 $ /!

" $ / !! & ! / " !/ 2 / ! / / /" " !! *,+-)--+ !/ 72/ "6*./ ! " & ! " / ! & ! "

/ / & / /"$

/ "

/% /"!

& " "

/ "

! ! $// ! &$ "

/ & "!!% /" !! / 7 /!! .! " " &$ "

/ !!& ! / $/ ! &$ "

/!&! " .! /!

/ & & /9/ !" &" )+/ 2

& ! &! " / !! .

$ .

"/ $

&$ D & !!

" &

&$ & !" !! / " ' ! & 7 "&

! &$ 2 ' & / ! !

&$$ "!&&

&2! $ &7 !/ ! % "! & !

/ & C/ ! !"

" "! " ! & " $ $!!" "! "

/ "+)+5)--89 &&$ 2' !2! !& &" & ! 9 )(# 4 *

*7 /"#8 ,#6,#, ,7 / $$%

+ 2' " ! "

! $ &$ !! ! " / $ ! !

& ! /$ & / & % / & // !

: $$/& &$""

/ !% ' / " ! " /

F5&7!$ & !/ 2 ! " !!//

$ 2! "%

/!/&& $ /

/ " & / 9 ! !

! !& &!

" !!

! "

! $ / ! / $9 ! $ ! 2! " "

/$ / $ / " $9!

& "" !" &$ ! ! ! !

/ & &79& "" !" &$ ! ! / $ && / $! $/" &$ /" &79/$& ! /$ & / 9/$ & /7/ !! " / & /$ & / & !$ !$/"

/ $! /$ &/!

: !

$/ & &$ ""

/ ! ! / " ! "!" !

! $"2! " / &

;9& D '

'0)-<-3)'')- ! $" $ ! $/"! 9 " 2! & & / / &" ' " ! ! / $! / % ' " & ! "

& " !! $ !

/& &7 !&" ! ! $ !9 & ! ! & "! " / / " " !7!

/ 2! " " /

" ' " ! ! / & " / $! % ! ! & " /$ ! " 2/ G " 9 ' D $ 03(0)--53;''-

$ ! &!&$ H % "" &/" " / % ! " & 4 ,4(, &##

,(#

94( (04(.# !(,4'#

,(#

& ""

" ! " & / % / F*< % / "

/ " ! !&// 0 39 / !

""&

" ! !

&& 03 "

!$ " &$ " "

" 03 !

& !" "!/

0 39! & " &$&$ "/ & .

" "!

&" !! ! "&7

! /$ " " " ! &$ 0 3 % 2 ! " " & &7 & ! $ " / ! "

/ & / !

!/! &$ ! ! &$/"!

72/

/ ! " &7

!$ / &$ " "

0 39" ! $! & ! !$ / / /$& /$& 0 39 & " & &! &&

$ 2! " /

" / " "!! "!

$ 03!

!$ / 0 39 & $ !

&$! /"! "

" "! $ 2! " / / "&7 /$ & /

" & *-% / : "9& / ! .

' " 7

& " "

/ @ % % !! &$ &&$ ( / &$& / &"" &$ ! & "

/I9 / & 9

&7 / @ % % !! / &7 &2! $ & /

! " !$ / & & ( &!

" !&

&"9 & / ! !

&7 &$ / & /$& $!

/ /$!/ " "!% !

&! !

!$% & $ & &$ ! ,+9" "! &$ &" !!

! "& ! ! /$&

: " " " ! &$ !

!/! ! &$ !&

/ !& "9!!

"!/ & !$ !& !& &$ !H D & ! " /

!! &$ " & $9 !/ "" !! $ )--+% ! / " !! . "! " !

& $ & "

" 79

+)+5)--? /$" "$ 6 ""! "

/+)+5)--8012*3 * !/ 2 ! & "

* " "! & " ! " !

" "

/ "

/% "!! !$

& &$ $&$ / ! !:! /!

!/" "!/"& % ! ! & " $ % ! /

/$ 9

2/ 6* &$! "! /!

! ! &

2")@, *8+,)--8012)3 &!

" / ! " !$ !!" "

/ &/ !

& "

$! &$ /. " " "

/ $ " /

/ / "

& 012*3 *&!/ &" " ,+B !< & $"*;++@7 / " ,)+,)--< A,;++@7 / & "

!! & / ! !" "

/= & ! "

/ / "! !

"! & ! "

/ / $ & "!! & !/2 & ! /" $ / $ / !

" " =! !!& " "

/ ! $ !/2 & &

$ 2/ "

/$" %2 9!/%2E / $" ! 2/ "

/ %29!/%2 ! " !$ ! / &

72/ "

/ &/" "/ $ //& &

& 2! "

/ "! $

& &$ ' & 72/ " @&7 "/ $//&

" & 7/ &!

% 7$

!!"$/ & $ " &$& $ ! / "" &/ ! 4 5) *8 '' & " " ( ' / / ! !!"$!

$ & &$ !! & / "

/ & !"

/ ! : $! " !" "

/ / ! "

% " 4 5) *8 '' $ 2 !

! & 9 $

! &&

70 3 % ' "/ !

&/ 0 3!/ ! " 2 ! " ! & !&$ $0 3 "

$ : $!/& !& ! / " $ & !% ( '

$ ),+-*+)* & " ! ! !

& ! " !

& !&" ' 9 &!"$

" & ! / " 4 5)*8''

!! / / "

$ & / !& "! / ! & $ &! $ $ / ! " "

! $"! & / !

/ ! $" "" ! % 2'

,7 "-#

( # !"# &#(, )(

)1 *

$ ++ 2 ' ! !

!&&" ! : &$ ' & ! /% !/ !

2 / !& !&&&

&: / )11 / (

#11 (

% !&" " ! ! ! "! 9 / !

!/!

!/" ! " !$" !$ & ! !9 ""/ $! & & 9"

" ! ! " ! " 2! &$ "

$&"& / ! 9 &!"$/ &

/ !

& " ! & 2! !

"!&" " ' &% " ! & / !"#!!$

& !& ! !$ & !!! $ / / &#'( (

"6#&$ !& &$ ' " !

$ & / / /&7 " ! " &$ & / &$ " / D/

" & " & : / ! $& /! & ! % !$" &

! &$ "" !" E 9! " & & " " : " /& !& "!!

!/!" !

/ ! /" 2' '

( , )(,-.

"6# &$! $ " " !" "

$ & ! $& % & ! !! & / : " & &

"! !

/ " "!!

!/!9 ! !!" &" 2' & !/!!" "! $ !7 " $ ! $ $ !" !/ $ $"

/ !" !/ 9 " !&" % & & $ !7 " $% "

&$ $ ! 7&2 !

& $ $ ! $

!" !/ $ $ $ !

"! /& !& "!!

!/!" ! 9 %!&

2' " ! " ! " /! " / & &!" ""

!!" "! $ !/ "

! " " / "

!! $"& " / " ! !9& " !! "

$! !& ! 2! ! ! ! /

&!"/ $//& & !

$ / "" " "

" 2! ! !

: " " "

/& !& "!!

!/!"

! % / !

" ! $ &!! "

/ $& $&! !

&$ !!! & 7" / ! " !

&/&$ &$ ! !!" $ ! &

!" &! $!!$

& " " &!"$!

/!& ! " ! " !$ $ &$ " / !

& & !!% ( '

# "

" 5 &" ' % $ &!" !!!! / 2 ! ! / &

$ ! "! " !"! &$ " &"

/ ! !" !!" &

&! ! $ $ &$ 7 &7!$ " $ & ! ' " " & &$ ' & " ! !/

& !& % ' & " " !

"& " !

!&" !!

&$ / .

"! !$ / 5;$ & ! ,++-*+)8 J& $** *+)8