High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/164/1986dismissed

Onkar Singh v. Naurang Singh

2015-01-07Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal12 pages

! "#$ %&' $% (

! !

#$"!

%! !

" &&&& )% '"$"( $# )*

+! ,"" #( -.

,#-. $"( $# )+

/-. -0 $! "$" 1 "!" ""

23 $" # # $ )) 4 )) " $ # 4"$ # $ ) 4 + 4"$ 5

* 4 -, "

#" " "4"$ "!,""",-.6%78" "$ "4"$!"

#( " " $

) 4"$ 3 """." ,"" "($"!# $" $"! $"!" 9: $"!,, "!" !" , #-"

" # $ "!.! , # /+

"7 " ""4"$ ", " ( $#)+

/ , $ " .

!,7 ,"## ", # # ;!;%;7 "7 ;" $ $ " '" !"7 $ $ " $ $ .-"" '"7 $ ; ;7! $ /+

+ ' 7 ;!""

#"# -, # $/ *< ) 4+< ""4"$-,"

",""'"=7## -# )

+!>4;+!,"" " # -$ " " )*+)*

-("!,"",#-." 7 '", -.#" -. .", -'" -","$

/ # " " )*+ )* , .

4"$" " :"#"!>4;

". /)%: "" ,,-.

93$"!,", ($"!# $" $"$$-!>4; '" #" " )*+)* , "-.$" #($" )

/ '"

. - "," # $/ *< " ;$"," ( $"!#$" $"!" 93$"!," ,$., "< '"

# ","-.,. $ < "

(- $7##=?$ @! +/# 9, ! "4, -."

","", " " ###

(- $ 7## = ?$ @! +/ 2"""! ""

, $ " *. ,"# $" '"", " #

# "<

"""-#, " #

(-$7##=?$ @ ! +/ '",

#. 7"

A;/@! # :

# $" ?

@! %, ?

A;+@ 0$# ?

A; @

."4> "

.","", " < '"

," $ . " 4 A" " - ! " 7 ;""

,, # $/ *< - "$ 4"$ ;%,-."7 -.

$" " " "-$"-# , "# $

< !,""

,$.$ "

4"$ "-$", - #3"!,",$,

"< "-$", $ $3$#. ,

. # , '" !" 7 " " " , " . $ "

#3"".-#, "# $

< "" 3" 1 ;7,$."-

$ 1 ;;%

, , # $/ *< !" !"" ". "#"$4"$> " $"!

" ' .!

)! ,"" - " 9.! " 4"$ $ ## -. #" **,.-

+ $ .!"4"$>4 A;/B," -#,!"

! 2 ! " , 7 $ ." -( ",. -."7 -( , ",3 $ # '" , 7 " - $ ,.

! ## " " ,$#;

C A"""

, " 4"$ $ D

) A"""

" " D2 / A""" #-"

#D2

A"""

" $" $D2 + A"" " #.D2 E F,$ , #;

C; A"""

"# $/ *< ""- "$ 4"$$-."

D ;%A""" ,, # $

< ""- "$

4"$$-."

D ;7 1 ; ;% "

# ! ,"" " , 4"$ $-."

DE =,7 "-."

,-." ," " '"

-" $ #"$"

#- # $ $ # ,-."$$,!4'"

" # A;/ 7"! ," , $ ,

4"$>4 A;/B# A;

#,!

A;+ %, A; 0$# '" " = 7##>4;+,3"$ "", " #,""# " - ",.!" 9$"7 2 ,$1"(:" #"-!" !G" )*+)* ,", ": %"$! :# .!" !" $

;,3"4 93" -$, " '",7 #"$ # "

# . -.- $,"

1>4;

!".-" !" )*+)* ,",-".

93". /)":%"$! :!

, ",-" '" !" "

-$ ":%"$".

,!,. # '"$- "93$", "$" $"

, 93$" !#.!($"!# $" ,"" $"1",.!" !" )*+)* , -".

93$"'" =7## -'",3-."

"4 -. "# #'"

=7##,,

., " $3"- $ ". /)!" , -4"$ ","$" $ '" !" ,",-# "

#$.# #, > " $"", #-#$" #-- " ,

. -" $ " 4

3-."=7##!" " - -# # # ".< "$ " -# -. " - '"B = 7##,-.",7

#""" "

"." '" "

, -,""#" ;4# 1";4#!

"# """" !,"" ,- /*.$ 9 . ". 9,

#. ," "/+ .,,3$"" " "" .9#""" ," "< 9#,."" ",, "< !,"", # -(# 4"$-."# $)) 4))< $. #" '",7 #" #3$,$F # "-$"!" $- 3!," " "

,H#.!"7 "!"-.#$" "

1 $ ! " # " ,$ -< ,;

CA""" $ "7 -, $

##$ $$ " $ " "

" " ," "4"$D ) A"" = 7## ?>4+@ #- - ", " # . "- . #,3 #" 4D / A"""## ,#, -." 7 ,., "". # ( " D

A"" = 7## ?>4;+@ -$ DE = " $ " "

$ -. " , 7 "

#$ .!"4 4"$

. # ", '".! " = 7## ?>4;+@ . #-, 2< ,"$," "

!"- $ "

(-$7##=?$ @! +/ ! . ", "

-#, "# $/ *< !

-. $ "#"

" $ -."7 ;!", 7 < . "

?"@ -(-(, $" $"

;$" $ ;-.,. . !" !" # $/ *< ,"",$.$ -."

4"$ # $))4))< , $ $ 4"$ " # 4"$ , -. " !" !,$. #- "

4 4"$," ,

," "!4"$ " "

* 2"

, -" $. " # $ / * < ! " ! #

4 .4"$ ."

$ 4"$!,""

#3" = " *+,-% -.+ / ( 01 I.2**.

/0 .34 / I.2**3

3.. / 5 I.223.

/0 ,3. 6 / 6.22+.

/0 .738 09 / 80 0

""4"$ ## -. # " **-

," $ #> " 4"$ < . #- 4 $ ' . $ 4"$ - 9.!

" !4"$$#-'"- . ,"$"$"" ( $#F"-. ( $#!"# -$4"$ "

"# -, ".$ -."#"4"$! " !"-$;< ; "-. !--.

" $ ""- $ $ .B"#

; " $ "

(- $7##=?$ @! +/ !"

.- " =3$". " #

" ! " # ( , $" " -

$4"$ '"4"$, -," ?, @1"- !" 4"$, , $. - = ""

" -"""-. "#"4"$!"( "- .$" '"$ #! # ." 4 - ! F.! , ;4# "

"# ! " "< .!" $ "

"- #" # $ )) 4 )) < - ,

# '" - " $"4"$1# #( ""

" - -. ,$ ,'" "

"# $))4 ))< -.,. .-$ !"$ 3$ " < .,

#'" "4 .. . ".

-. ,

# ! " ! " .

-#$ ","""$ # #.$

) $$ -. ,$ ,!

- ","" $. "

" ! " ! " '"< ," # #-.

=7##-"$ '"= 7##!# ! ," #-

$3"- " $ ". /)'" $ ",", -" $ "$ " '" , " , - # " " $.!

# #, " -"- 9$"7 2"4 # "< , "7 9 $"$ #!"7 " -< ,,"$J " " # $. #! $ " -", % (

% ).2*7 %&:($