High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/6758/2015dismissed

Mukhtiar Kaur v. Kulwant Singh And ORS.

2015-10-12Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih4 pages

# $ %&'(" ) !"

*+,-&.(/.+( *+,-&.(/.+( *+,-&.(/.+( *+,-&.(/.+( 0#1 0#1 0#1 0#1 2 # # 2 # # 2 # # 2 # # /+3.&#4- /+3.&#4- /+3.&#4- /+3.&#4- # 0#1 # 0#1 # 0#1 # 0#1 *$ *$ *$ *$ 56* # 56* # 56* # 56* #

(&$ *(##7-)7%.&)(&-8&&( "9-&-( 8(&( %. 38.8( :.; ' .37&&-<+74:&=#> '(((7&&- 8(&((&=#> ?9-&-( &- <+74:& -+7 ' (8(&7 &- 74&=#>

66)0 (.1

66)0 (.1 - 8(& ( 8&& .( +& . .88%.&(..7@&(:<+%&:7';&-8&&(@ 8.&+7( (7(?A) +".7 )7 (%7+( &-&(.%+(&7%7&-<+%&8(.;7()7(7( 7.&7""! !"B)8&&(8(((7..88..4.&&-.7 (7()'+&&-.&&3.7:7)7(7(7.&7 !! !"

--3)8.&'(&-%+(&)&-&.&( 8&& .+&7';&-8.&)-8(.;7(.7%( (<+%&(&(.4&-77.&(:&((4&- 8.%+ (7&. .7 %+&.&4 8 ( .7 :.+(4 ,..) +&-( 7) +& &&. .7 :.+(4A,..B:.(.)'.(4/-3.&??)/-.&.+ B A)/-.(. !0A@B1 .%7(.&&-:.&&( +)&-%%+(%(77';&-&(.%+(&).7.(:7'; &-.88.&%+(&)(.7.&-+$@ C 88%.&-.%.:7-(8(&- 88%.&-.%.:7-(8(&- 88%.&-.%.:7-(8(&- 88%.&-.%.:7-(8(&- +& 8(8(&; '.(4 ,-.(. !

8; +& 8(8(&; '.(4 ,-.(. ! 8; +& 8(8(&; '.(4 ,-.(. ! 8; +& 8(8(&; '.(4 ,-.(. ! 8; <.:.'7-.'8(7+%7(%(7';.88%.& <.:.'7-.'8(7+%7(%(7';.88%.& <.:.'7-.'8(7+%7(%(7';.88%.& <.:.'7-.'8(7+%7(%(7';.88%.& -()3-%- 3($-8%+: 5.'77-5 -()3-%- 3($-8%+: 5.'77-5 -()3-%- 3($-8%+: 5.'77-5 -()3-%- 3($-8%+: 5.'77-5 -. ' :&7 .7 %+&.&4 %+:) -. ' :&7 .7 %+&.&4 %+:) -. ' :&7 .7 %+&.&4 %+:) -. ' :&7 .7 %+&.&4 %+:) D*.,'+<..-7.4.

-D-. ':&7 D*.,'+<..-7.4.-D-. ':&7 D*.,'+<..-7.4.-D-. ':&7 D*.,'+<..-7.4.-D-. ':&7 -,-.(.+:'(%:8(4.7:.+(4 -,-.(.+:'(%:8(4.7:.+(4 -,-.(.+:'(%:8(4.7:.+(4 -,-.(.+:'(%:8(4.7:.+(4 A ,.. B :.(. .7 .88%.& -. %.:7 -( A ,.. B :.(. .7 .88%.& -. %.:7 -( A ,.. B :.(. .7 .88%.& -. %.:7 -( A ,.. B :.(. .7 .88%.& -. %.:7 -( 8 ( &- .7 ,..) (:4 8 ( &- .7 ,..) (:4 8 ( &- .7 ,..) (:4 8 ( &- .7 ,..

) (:4 +'&.&.8.(&.',-.(.+:'(.88%.& +'&.&.8.(&.',-.(.+:'(.88%.& +'&.&.8.(&.',-.(.+:'(.88%.& +'&.&.8.(&.',-.(.+:'(.88%.& 8&-+&8(8(&;)&-&-.& 8&-+&8(8(&;)&-&-.& 8&-+&8(8(&;)&-&-.& 8&-+&8(8(&;)&-&-.& 'E8.7(%(7&-.&3-;-(.:& 'E8.7(%(7&-.&3-;-(.:& 'E8.7(%(7&-.&3-;-(.:& 'E8.7(%(7&-.&3-;-(.:& (%&7<.:.'7 (%&7<.:.'7 (%&7<.:.'7 (%&7<.:.'

&.&+&-.88%.&'48 &.&+&-.88%.&'48 &.&+&-.88%.&'48 &.&+&-.88%.&'48 -.&'E8.7(%(7';.88%.&8(:.@ -.&'E8.7(%(7';.88%.&8(:.@ -.&'E8.7(%(7';.88%.&8(:.@ -.&'E8.7(%(7';.88%.&8(:.@ .%&-.'%.:7';.88%.&&-.&8(8(&; .%&-.'%.:7';.88%.&&-.&8(8(&; .%&-.'%.:7';.88%.&&-.&8(8(&; .%&-.'%.:7';.88%.&&-.&8(8(&; 3. .&&7 & -+'.7 .88%.& +& 3. .&&7 & -+'.7 .88%.& +& 3. .&&7 & -+'.7 .88%.& +& 3. .&&7 & -+'.7 .88%.

& +& .&:& &&( -. ' 8(7+%7 (%(7 .&:& &&( -. ' 8(7+%7 (%(7 .&:& &&( -. ' 8(7+%7 (%(7 .&:& &&( -. ' 8(7+%7 (%(7 6.(7 %+ ( &- .88%.& -. 8&7 +& 6.(7 %+ ( &- .88%.& -. 8&7 +& 6.(7 %+ ( &- .88%.& -. 8&7 +& 6.(7 %+ ( &- .88%.& -. 8&7 +& %&(%&;'.78-&4(.8-8(7+%7(%(7) %&(%&;'.78-&4(.8-8(7+%7(%(7) %&(%&;'.78-&4(.8-8(7+%7(%(7) %&(%&;'.78-&4(.8-8(7+%7(%(7) 3-%- -. ' .7:&&7 '; (87& &-( 3-%- -. ' .7:&&7 '; (87& &-( 3-%- -. ' .

7:&&7 '; (87& &-( 3-%- -. ' .7:&&7 '; (87& &-( (8; -3 8 .88%.& ( +& (8; -3 8 .88%.& ( +& (8; -3 8 .88%.& ( +& (8; -3 8 .88%.& ( +& 8(8(&;+&(:8(+.&-%&(%&;' 8(8(&;+&(:8(+.&-%&(%&;' 8(8(&;+&(:8(+.&-%&(%&;' 8(8(&;+&(:8(+.&-%&(%&;' .78-&4(.8-&%.'.7&-.&&-.&' .78-&4(.8-&%.'.7&-.&&-.&' .78-&4(.8-&%.'.7&-.&&-.&' .78-&4(.8-&%.'.7&-.&&-.&' E8.7 (%(7 &-.& -3 &- ' .7 E8.7 (%(7 &-.

& -3 &- ' .7 E8.7 (%(7 &-.& -3 &- ' .7 E8.7 (%(7 &-.& -3 &- ' .7 8-&4(.8- (.& & +& 8(8(&; & -. ' 8-&4(.8- (.& & +& 8(8(&; & -. ' 8-&4(.8- (.& & +& 8(8(&; & -. ' 8-&4(.8- (.& & +& 8(8(&; & -.

.(4+7 '; .(7 %+ ( &- .88%.& &-.& .(4+7 '; .(7 %+ ( &- .88%.& &-.& .(4+7 '; .(7 %+ ( &- .88%.& &-.& .(4+7 '; .(7 %+ ( &- .88%.& &-.& %&(%&; %%& -. ' .7:&&7 '; %&(%&; %%& -. ' .7:&&7 '; %&(%&; %%& -. ' .7:&&7 '; %&(%&; %%& -. ' .7:&&7 '; (87& &-( 3(&& &.&:&>(8;) '+& (87& &-( 3(&& &.&:&>(8;) '+& (87& &-( 3(&& &.&:&>(8;) '+& (87& &-( 3(&& &.&:&>(8;) '+& % &- (+ (%(7 .4.& &- %.: % &- (+ (%(7 .4.& &- %.

: % &- (+ (%(7 .4.& &- %.: % &- (+ (%(7 .4.& &- %.: .88%.&'48(&-+&8(8(&;) .88%.&'48(&-+&8(8(&;) .88%.&'48(&-+&8(8(&;) .88%.&'48(&-+&8(8(&;) &-.7:8.(&(87&&:.&(. &-.7:8.(&(87&&:.&(. &-.7:8.(&(87&&:.&(. &-.7:8.(&(87&&:.&(. #)3.'7%+7%(%+:&.%)%) #)3.'7%+7%(%+:&.%)%) #)3.'7%+7%(%+:&.%)%) #)3.'7%+7%(%+:&.%)%) .88%.&-.'.7&-38(:..%%. .88%.&-.

'.7&-38(:..%%. .88%.&-.'.7&-38(:..%%. .88%.&-.'.7&-38(:..%%. -(.()3-%-%7&8(%7&(4(.&4 -(.()3-%-%7&8(%7&(4(.&4 -(.()3-%-%7&8(%7&(4(.&4 -(.()3-%-%7&8(%7&(4(.&4 &:8(.(;<+%&.7.%%(74;).88%.& &:8(.(;<+%&.7.%%(74;).88%.& &:8(.(;<+%&.7.%%(74;).88%.& &:8(.(;<+%&.7.%%(74;).88%.& 7';.88%.&>8.&-(';7:7F 7';.88%.&>8.&-(';7:7F 7';.88%.&>8.&-(';7:7F 7';.88%.&>8.&-(';7:7F E@.%)8.&8(.;7(.7%((<+%& :8%&(.

&<+%&&-77.&(:%.+4.; &((% -( .%&+. 8.%+ 8 ( .7 :.+(4 ,..)%:8(7/-.(. !&-43. '(+4-&(%(7 & -3&-.&&- 8.&3.) 77) .%&+.8-;%.8&-+&.7&-.&3.%:8(7 &-.7+:'(7+'&)8.&'(+4-&(%(7%(&. 8-&4(.8-.7%&(%&;'&-3-(8(. 8(8(&;)'+&&-43.8(7+%7&+'&.&.&+(&-(&-.& &-.78(8(&;3.)77)%:8(7/-.(. !)G+.

3-%-<+%&3.'4%.:7-+4-)8.&%.:7& ' 8 . &- +& 8(8(&; 3. .&&7 & -( -+'.7)'+&&-4 3.'(+4-&(%(7 &+'&.&.& &-.78.3-.&3.(G+(7&'';&- .(7&(.%+(&.&&-.&&.43..8(:..%%.)3-%- .88.(&;)8.&.7&8( -.& '4 ) &((% 3.((.&7 E(% (. <+(7%& +7( (&% &- &&+& 7. && '4 77 :(& )

.%%(74;)7:7: 7&.(&)&-(7(-.&%&&+&. E8(8:(&&-%.:&-(8.(&; 6.(7&(.%+(&(G+&7&7%7&-+&. E87&+;.8')8((.';3&-;.( " ) !"

" ) !"

661 0

661 /.4 /.4 /.4 /.4