High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/556/2008allowed

State Of Punjab v. Jasbir Singh And ORS.

2024-10-23Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma40 pages

!"# $ % & '( '(

) *$ &+ ( '(

)

, ,

+ !"#

!"#

"& -./0"(12,3 0,20,4352 -./0",(12,3 0,2003,"

! "#$

% "!& "! "# ' ())*+)),,- . ()/)++0)/),,*

% %

!1 "# . 2 * ()/)++0)/),,*

( "#'3(

- .0()/)++0)/),,*

1 1 "#

14 "# ' ()05),,-

# 6 . + 7777

,20,435261( #"' -&#4 " ' - 4#44 "# 4$ # # #8" ' -4 #44 "# 4 8" ' - # 4 "# 4 ,2,0,, # .9 55* $ 3 &

# #& ## 6 #

# 9* , 9 895 :

( # # ## # "# ) # "# 4$ #

# ,9):

(:4 $ # # #6 4 ## # & " # " # # # )# "# ;#4

# $ !% &

### )# "##4" 4" & "# # "# #4 " 4 # 6 #'- 4 4 #4 4 4 $ # "# ( # # # #4 .())*+) ),,

9 %

&#4 #4 .()/)++0)/),,* #4 "

.()05),, #"$ < # # "# 6 # "#)## #

# ,&# 95 :

(

+ % # ##44 =: &#>; ?588 % #

>; ?88 #& 4 >; ?584$ # "

# :

4 &4 $ 4 $ ## # **55* < & @4

# " " %< " "

# ?5 < ?, ?+ %# ? & "%< & "

# " $

A $ **55* 0,, & # 4 "# ## &4 4 "

<4 "

## 4$ & .4 & 4&1# 14 (

4&#<&

## ?94## "<#& @4

# #?## "4&

& & # ? & 4 # &# @4

# ?9 4## 4## # 4 & < %#

& & #

# < %#

## #4 4&#"& ## # @4

& ("@ 4 "# A # @4

#&# A >; ? 5844 $ # ?5 # 4 =:.05 55* #$>; ?58

# 9* , 9 95 :

(& ## #

4B #:" ?2< " #@ "

>; ?28 # ## #&##4 @ 4 4 &#& # < " C 44 >; / $ # & % ("@ 4 >; ( $ @4

#4$& $!

4 ? #4 #$ 4 " ## &# (

$$%

& ''"%!

( 0 # #

# , :

( &;# "$$( #44 ( # # #444 0,55* # ##44## # ( )%

& ''"%!

( 2 % # # #" # 4 #" $ #4 $4 # 4 $ #&# ## #44 #

# 9* , 9

895 :

(% & #& ## &#$ $ #4 * :

# # ;4 2&

# # # # # # " # # # " # # # &#

# ( ( ##

# # #4 4# @&" $#& #" # *$%((% !( + ,'

'!'"

!('

+ ,'

--'

!(('"

5 % #

"# "#) " ( 4 "# # "# # 6 # 6 #@ " 4

4# )# " #4 # , % #

" $ ( #4 $&

## "# # % 4 4

# # 4 #

#44 =:&#>; ?8588#4 @ 4

&4< 4

# 0( ( # ## # ## &$ 4& #"& @&" & & & ; ?)+ #

## &$ 4&#"& $ 4& & " $44 $4 # # ## # 4<#

# $ 4 & & ; 4< # ## #

4#4 :

# 6 # 4"4# $ ?)+ " $44 & 4"4 44 "" $4 4 & ( 6 $ $ # # #4 < # " #6 "/ ** $

?) 4#$;4

4# #

)## %"

#$ ?)

;# % 3#4 >; 38%# 3 ;#

. ' ( )*

! ! ! !

(! ! )

! + ,* *

!* ! ! ## - *!! " ( ! * ! ) !#"

! !.

!* ! - *!! #( !! ! ) !/

!! ! ! )

- *!!

* ! %

%0 $( !&

?) 4#$;4

.4 4# #

)## %"

#$ ?)

;# % 3#4 >;

8%# 3 ;# ' ( # ' ! !

! *!! ! ! *

* !

( 2 !

! *

($ ! !* " (

* # ' ! !* '"

* ! !

& 9

?)94#$;4

& 4# #

)## %"

#$ ?)9

;# % 3#4 >; .8%# 3 ;#

' (

* #3 ! !4! !

! ! '

! 3 ! $ * !*

5*!!!

)! +,'

* !!4! ! )

! ! ! %6 !4! * * *

!+,"'3 *

!!4! ! !!!

) ! !* +, 7 ! " 5*! * *

)+,8 3

! *

!4! !

)

!* !

!*! !

* !+,'' ! *

)

! ! )!!

* !

* 9"

& +

?)+4#$;4

4# #

)## %"

#$ ?)+

;# % 3#4 >; A8%# 3 ;# ' ( !! 1 *

!* ! ! & 0

?)+4#$;4

4# #

)## %"

#$ ?)+

;# % 3#4 >;

8%# 3 ;#

' ( ! # 3 *

6 !*

)! ) #3

)

! !

! & 2 3 #

4 # 3 ## #4 " #"$ $ ?) )9 ?)+ $

#4# #"

)## # " # 8$ # #4 6 "#

#4 "$## $#4 $ 4 ## "$ 4 '- ;# #4 $ #4 #4 4## ;# " # :

" 4 # "& # #4 # "# ## $ #4 )"#4:

6 ##44$## # " 4# 4#4

# # 4# 4

4 $ ## 6 # "#

# ,9 ): :

( $ $

* $7 * % 4 ( $ #

)## )## & ;# " # )## & $" 5 4$ " 4 4 #)##

## & #4" $ ## #4 # 4<4 $&6

# # ## & 6

#" # ;4 #4 $ 4 #4 $ #4 ";# $ 4 " #@&" #" # #4" #4$## % # " 4 '-' - "## #4 # 4<4

# # #4 $ $ ## ' -" $#4 &

#" D &# $4

"$4## # & #&4 $ 4 4

'- ## #

# #4 ";# $4"))" " # ( $ # ' -$## $$# ## #4" &$$ # '-

)"#4#4 " , .&# & #$ 4 ( )## & ;# " # $ &#" $'- #$" # 4 &#4&" $$ )## 6 # 4" #"

# & #4 $ ) ## 8 $#4 $ 6 4#&

4# ## $ &

4# #4 $ " 6 4 4 " #" #&## &6 $4& #4 $ # $6 4 &## ;# ;#;# " # $ 8 :

4 " #$ " # 4

4# #4 $&+ &

4# ## &*% "

4# ## $

4# #4 $ $ & #4 $ & &4&## $ &&#"$ & & # #$ & 4 #" & & ( # $$& 4 ' - $#4 # #4& #4 $ $& ##4#" #" # $ ##44 #4 $ & $& # $ $ # # #4 #$ 4

4# ## $ "))"

4# #4 $ 4 &#4 $

&4 8 #)6 $ 4 &## $ 4$## $;#

" # $ $:

6 & $

$ #4 $ $#4 $ & 4 $## $ ( # ' -## ;# "$ #4 4$4 4 # # #4 $## "))" # 4 # &$ $ " # $ $ #4;#

$& 4 ' - #

#4 $& $ ## #

& 4 # &4 $;# " # $ 8 %*% 9** $ , 5 7, $ $

$ * 3 #

## & "#4 ## & " 4 ## #4&A## 14 " 4 ## # & 1 %" # ;4 1 & & ;/?):

## 14 4## 4+,*55*,,*55* * :8 %*% 9 @&" $ !#"$< $ ## $## 14 #

## # # $ # " #" A ## 14 " !$ & ;/?) 1 & # 4

4 4+,*55* ,,*55* ## 14 &" /?) :

# # <#0 ,4 # #

## 14 # "#4 4 ## # ##4 # *$%((% !( + ,'

'!'"

!('

$- %!! + #

& #

#4 " ( "# # "# # 6 #'-' - #4 4 # "#) &4 6 $ # 4$( ;#

# % $ " $# "#) 4= 4 $" ## ) # "# # #

# 9* , 9 895 :

( 8$$ :

$ $ ;$$$< **

$:*%8$:: ;$$ =$4'6+ 6!4+>

4+ 0 & ' - #"$ 4 #4 #";4 ) )# # ## #4 $ 4 # & & #" #4 $ & # #

# #

# 2 :" "& 4 && $'- ## $ & ## #);4 4 $ & ' - " ## &

< & 4 & $ 4" &#44 $ $& ' -% 4 # $4 ( "))" ## # # "

& $" # 4< # $ ( #< $" $" * 4$ #" &4 $& ## #

E- 4 $4" $4 " $#4 & - 4" # #4" 4" #4 4 &"

4 =: #- 4" # ##

")) "#4" &# 4 $ $

# # $ $ $ & ##

#4 $4"))"#4" #4" $" &$# # $#& ## ( # $ $" $44"4 44 $ & ' - "" $ 4 & 4$4 4$# 6 ;# $ # $ % !'"

"%( ('

('$'!( + ,'

('"

-(! ,'' ' /'%'(

5 / # " 4 =: # "#) 4 #" # 4 &#>; ?08 ?08/ ?08> ?08= ?08!

?08@ ?08 ?08189 #4#"$

, %# 4 ' - #$ # "## # :

# 4 ' - # "# # #

# #&#"& % < 6 < # # #4 $& # " # 4 4< < & # < 4 "& # #"$ #4 $ & " # # # 4# < 4

# $ # " $ $ ## ;' - & $ " " " #$"

" # " #"# " " % ; # # 4" $ #$

# $ #4< # 4 #4 4 $ # "# " # # # # 4 #" #"$44 .>; ?08 ?08/8 ?08>8 ?08=8

?08!8 ?08@8 ?088 ?)0818 # #" & # " ## #

( 6 $ & 4#" $ $ # " # #" $ # "#"&4"))" #4 $& #$# "# " ## # :

6 4< " # 4 $ # "# # '- " #" #4 $& # $# # "# " ## # $ # # #

@&" $ " 4# 4 # 6 4#" #" #& 4 # 4 # 6 4#"% # " #' - #44 . 2

4 $ @ D ; (

%$%!

--'

0 (1

% '"

( 2! 3 4$ !% '

+ ",6 &"'(,7 "'%"'"

" & #4;#

" 5 !*

(

! *!!

! 5 $ %

! & % 4 66 !"

,'( /(1 4%!

8$-'

! ! * * !

! !

;

5$ %

! < 5 !

. !

7: *

! ! )

! )

!!* !*

#5!*

! !

)

8$-'

/(1 9 % ,!

, '*6

:%,!

4$% /(1 '

+ %, %

)

* ! *

< '" ? ! * ! * !

! !

* *

! *

#''

$% %

,%/ 4$ /(1 '

+ ",6 &"'(,

#''

! ! !

) *!

! 5 !

! !!

! ! 5

! !

! !!

* * ! 5

#'' $% 5 ;

*! )

@ .

0 !

) !

&AB!!) .

0 (

7% !

. 1

* ! ! D

! ! . 1 "

E!!(

! ! *

! !!

! *

! !

* B! D

(

. 1 E!!

!! !

! ! *

6B! / ! !!

. 1F

! *GF5 !! / *

$B 3 7 '' '7 * *

* !

$B 3 7 '' '70*

/! !

9 = 4

4 $ @ D ;

( %$%!

--'

0 1 #

% '"

( 2%3'!"'

;

!" '

+ :6!7 "'%"'"

11 " # " #& #4 0 & #4;# 1 B ! ! *

! !

! !H*

! !

* !

! * !

! = %%

! 1

!! ) = %%%

= %/

! 1

= /

% !)

! ! +''< ) (%$ 4! /(1 ),'

'= &!, /(1 '

+ :6!= '

+ 3(,!

/(1 ) '/ !

,$ &($ 4",, /(1 '

+ 4!

+ = 4

4 $ @ D ;( -'%

9'/'

&'%% !

%$%! 0 1 +

% '"

( 2&'$

3 ;

&'$

' '-1 6 >!(-' + & %'7 "'%"'"

1 1 # " # " #& #4 + & #4;#

H* *

6 :

(

! 1

! *

4 1

) *!

! 1

! ! (

! 1

! * * ) *!

*!!

,$'"

>!6

, '

+ ,(,'

6 :

(

* ! !

(

! ) * ! *!!!!! 5

! * !

!5*G

! F !

! F G ! F G

! FG

)! FD !

* !

*! *!

! ! * * = +, !

) * ! *! ! 5 *!! !*

* !

6 :

(

6 :

(

35 4 !

6 :

(

+: $ "6, * !!

I$!1J$! 3 #

K * * !

L -

$ @ >/ $ ! 1H* 4

L -K

K * *

$ D

! $ 5

6 :

(

! )

! :

* !!

0 .& # # 6 " E - %# 4 # 6 #"$ # #" #"$ # 4 # # 4 4$## " # 4 # #"$ #4 $ #E - % ##"& E - :&$" 4<E "- : 4 4# # ;# "$ & < & ## "- %#"$ 4 #"$44

#4< # 4

# ## #4 $ 4 # #4 6 $ =3# # 4#4 & # # # & & ; " & " #"$ # 44

# "

# 4$ # # "- % #6 4# # 4 & # 4 #"$44$ 4 & 4<< #"&

4 # $4< < $#4 ##$ " ## # 44( # $ ##"$44& 4

### " # #"$( $#"$44'-#4 # # # "- % # # " #; & 44

4< # 4 # 6 #"$ 4 $#"4 #" # #4 " 44$$ " #

2 %

#'-&

$" 4< # 4 $ ## # 6 #"$ # #( # $ & #4 $ < # #4 $" #"#" < "

# $& ##

* 4$ # # $ & ##

$& # # 4" $ 44 " #4 #);4 $

# # # #

## # # ( #4#4$ " ## # # #" $44 & $( & #4 &4 $$& # # 4 " $44 &

" #( "4

#4 &4 $$& # # #4" ( 4$# 6 $&# # #"4 ## 4 4$ ## " $#4$" $$4$ # 4 # 6 4 #" " $ #$% #< # # $ # ## 4 # " # ##%$ " #4" & 4 &4 $$& # # 4" $44 & & " #"4 # ## $" #

# 4 $## ( 6 & # # &" $ #$$ # 4 #"$44 #$ & $#4$" 4" # 8 & 4 $ $ & # # 4" $#4 & >4#$ ;#6 #4" $ 4 9, %4; ## 4###

&#< $ $& ##

; ' - ") )"# # $& ##

6 44

#4 $'- # # 6 " #"& # $ # 4 # 6 #"$ &

4$ #" " $ " & # # " # <& #

##"& 4###

$ # 4 # 6 #"$ 4$" $" >" # $ # ## 4 # #" # "$# 9 @&" # ## 4 " #&

$4 # 4 $## # 6 #"$44 " # $$#6 "" $" #$ & ##"4

9 % 4< # 4 # 6 #" #4 6 4 4 #4 $ < # ## 4 " #:

" # # 4" " # #4 # 4& $ #

# $ " #4 $ < $ # " # #& ## ( 6 $ # $" # #

+ :

>" # # " & #4 ;# $ 4$ 4#8 # 4$ ## # # 4 # & ;#

#4 # 2 :

>" # # " & #4;# % $&

$# 4$# 4$ ## # # $& # 4$ ## # ## # #44 4 ## $ & #4 $ # " $## " ## #"$ #& ;# "$& 4 ;# "< & 1 !+'((% !

- %' ++%'

! *'

- /'"1II-

! !!

2 .1 : ?

$, + %!+ $% !

''%/'"

+ $ ('"

$6 *'

- /'"1II$

& 99 # $ & # &$ 4 # 4 # 6 #"$

" #

# #4 " $ # ( $ # # 4 # 6 #"$ # #"44 " #& $ #4# $ <## &" # $ #4 " #4 $ < " #& ## $ # " #4 $ < 4# &$ # 4 &

#"#4 4$44 # #4$ 9+ .&#4 # ## 4 # 6 #"#4 ## $" $ # " & 4 & 44#46 $4# $ "$ & 44 & " 44 # & " #"' - #"$ # 4 " # $& ;# "< & ## 90 ( # $ & # 4

4## 4 " $ 4< ## #"$'- # ##

. # ## # 92 ( 6 $ & $"" #

# "#' - ( 6 $ # 4 # 6 #" & #4 ## $ " $ 44 " $ #$ 4 $& $# #$& ##

"))" #4" " & 44' - #

4###

$ <' - # & ## #4" 3$* :

$* ;$$$ 9*

?)5 ;4 ) )# # #

< %# ## &$ 4 & #"& @ # 4 $#<

4#< 4 # &4 # ## 4

&$ 4 ;4 ) )# & ' -

# # 4 #4" < # ## " # #4 $

# $& < "4 " # #

#' - #);4 4

4 4"4

#4 4 < 6 & $& " #&

## % # 4 ' - #" # # #4 $ &6 ## ;# " # $%;4 ) )# & ' -#4;# ! !!$ *) * H

1E!!!. *D 'K K 8K!! * ! !!5) D ! * .!) * $BH 1 !!*

!!5)

!( ! * .!) $B 5! * !!

!!$ * 3 #37 D * )* * !

(1 !!

E. !!(B !!

! !

* ) -! * ) 1 * * * ) % * 1 * ) E1 *

)

(

* *

)* !

( !!

* ! H 1 $B ( *

H 1

) !*

H 1 $B !

(

) !* $B

.!) 5! *!

) !*

(

! !

(

( 1 H 1 .!) 5!

* *

( * )

)

*! !

* (

1 * ! ! ! H* !! !!*

* * H 1 *! * ! $$-! !

$! * !! $ 5) $ !!

! * * !

)

:$B 8( $

(1 !!

$1 E! * H 1 ( H 1 * !!

(1 H* !

* *

(

H 1 1 H 1 (1 !

(

( !

* ! * * !

)

/ :$M

$B .

* ! 5 ! !

:$ 6& 95 % & ' - #4 # #) ;4 " & #4;# < &"

# # 4$ ## # # $ # 4 #4" < # #6 # #4 $# # & #);4 #

$ "%< 4" # +)0< 4# ## # " #& ## # 4 # *)5<4 ;#

## #4 $& " #

# #);4 4 ;## $ 4

# $ #4## D#6 # #6 & ' -$& ## #( 6 $ 44 # # # $ & ' - "))" #4 "

" $ $ ## $ 4 #4 $# #4" 44#4 " < # 4

$4 ! !

! !

:$B 8( *

! !

* )

) *! !

* +(

:$B8(

, ! !

!! +

:$B 8(*

,D * *

H 1 *! * !

* * H 1 . * ! H 1

. * ) * *

H 1 .

) !

!! !

) * $*

* ) * $! !) * $* 1 !!$ H !! H*

(

" #

) '3

! * ! "3

# .

( *

0!!5)

'N) !!-!!*

! @*

* ! * ! @*

* !! *

! *

%!H !!

) !

. *!!

* *! * !

%!H !

. *@ >D * !! 0!!$

#)$$ -!

* H*

K 8)B! * $ $$ -!

5) * !!$ $$-! !!5)

K 8) 5 ! !! 5) !! $

3 7 )!! !

K 8 ) -

* !!

* *- ! * ) ) !

!!5* !

1 H 1

) *** * ! * 1 *

%!H !

!( ! * ! !5 !* *

(!! H 1 *

!5 1*

M !* !

1 ! !! M !*

) 1 ! ) * * ! @

!! D

! @ >

! @ !!

! !B

H!4M$*

H* H!4M$

$! ! !

* *)* !

)

! * 1 *

* !

)! " *

! (

E1 ! !! (

1 ! !!E

E ! !!$ (

!!* !

) !! 3 "3 (1 *

* !!!

(1 * !

)! ! (1 $!

)

+ * ,( * *!

)

)!* !!

) !* $B (

) *!

! 5

!! K

H 1 * ! * H!

!!D * )

* !! ! H 1 *

* !

1 @ .1!! * 5 * * ! @

! !

* @

@ *

!! 1

H 1 * M *>

) ** H 1

1 M ) ** H !

H 1 *

)4!*

M* ! 1 H 1 0!

1 !

1 M

* !!

H 1 ) 4!*

! !

H 1

$B ! 1

! 1 !

! !

(1 *

!!! * * !

(1 !!

! ! H 1 !

%!H !

9 !!

!!-!

!!E ) *

1 !

" ! *

1 *) !

*) * !

! !!

* *

! & +,

" $ # # $ # & #);4 " # " 4< &

" #4 ;# " # $ & 4 " # 4

" ( $ $ &< "4 ## $4 $#4" < # 4 # #4 " $ & # " ;# " # ' - # ## " E - %#4 & - %## " ;# " # 4 #4 $ #4 $## #- %"

4# #4 $&

4# ## - %## " #4 $& & 4$& & &$ ## $ + # ' - # ' -4

# $ ;# #4 $#

$ #

## #4 ## + 3<& 4# ## #);4 $& #4" &#"$ & ; , ? ?)+( 6 $ ##4 & &4" 4 $ ?)5 & "))" # 4$$& ' - + % #

## " " # $& #4"

&#<##4 &6 "#

#4 "$$#4 $## $ # "# 6 4 4 # 4

# # 4# 4

4 # 6 # 4 4 4 # # +9 % 4 " # 4 # 4 ##4 & # # $ & " ## #4 $ # & % " $# $ # "0 /0?0- ' ,3" 30"0 3# ++ % $ $ #@4

& # # 5,*55*$ ?) &/1 / %< ?)" 4 >; $4 $ # +0

" " # # @4

&& 4 #<# $

$. &#& # # $#

&# 44 %" 44

#$ ?) $ #;# ' $

N * !

8 !

! "

* '

! )

! # !*!*

. -' *

N 1 ! ! 5*

!!!

! 5 ) 1 * 1 - & +2 % #4 $& '- #'-'>; -&&

?) # 4< # '- # # :

# < F

## 1#'>; -G% # " #$& ## #);4

&4 # & $ ##

$ ## # 6 44

& # # " $ # & $## ) #"1#( 6 $ $4#" ## $& ##

&#"$44' - @-/ 0

+* % # # 4)#4 # "# # "# $ #

# ,9 ::

( # "# $ #)## #'-

# , :

( & # 4 ## #

# , :

( #4 <## & #44 # 4

& 4$ % # " #4< $ # " ## " $ 4

& 4$ " #&

44 $ $ " &# $ ## & #)## # "

. # ## & 4

& 4$ 4$ "# 6

$#4 # $# 4 #4 # $ $ 4 4 #

$#4 # $# "# & 6 " 4# 6 4 "))" # "# #4 $ #

95 :

(% & "# # 4 4 # 4 ## $ 4

& 4$ $$4 #44 #:

6 & $ #)## # # & & " $ 44

& 4$ #44 # & ### ' - ## & 6 # "# #& #

# , :

( #" # 4

$ #4 # $# 4 #4 # $ $ 4 4 # 4#4 # $## $ $ #6 #4#$ # # "))"## # & #

# ,&# 95 :

( 6 #4 & +5 $$& & #44

# & ### # # ( 6 $ " #)## # &

& $# " 44

& 4$ &" $# #44 # & ### $ # ## & # "# #

# ,&# 95 :

( 0, " # 4 # 4 " 4

& 4$ " $# #44 ## #4 #44 ##

4 # 44

& 4$

4 44

& 4$ & " $ #4" $# 44

& 4$ #" & #<$ $ 4 &6 #4 $ & #4 $ ## "#) 0 # ## & $ #4 " & $" $4 #4 $# #4" $ $ 4#4"# $ # 4 #4#44$ ### 8$ # 4 # $# "# 0 ## $ "& " 8"

& ( 6 $ & 8" #"$$

$#4 ( 4 "# #6 4$ # # & 4 #6 ## & #

# , :

( 4 4; . 0 2 * $

# #

# ,&# 95 :

(% ## # # # $ (

,,5,9 6 4 #: ## # # $$ &< # $ # # & & #44& ##

, ,

+ :

# 6 # 4 "# # "# # 6 & # #4 #"$ # 4 )# "#$ # # 4 $"$ $ 4)# )# " # # :

# 6 # 4 44:

&< # $ # # && #44 & ## 09 ($ $ & ## #&& $ ;$ 4 0+ # & & 00

# # '- $ 8 ,20,4352# 12A0 ,2003,"# 12A0 + ( '(

) 8$ 4 $:9 B $ & C$B-

4 :

8 & C$B-