Rohtash v. State Of Haryana



 
       
 

 

!! "#

$

%&&

!'!  

   


 


 


            !"  #  $    

 

%&   '    (   "   ) "* 
+
, -,,.    -,
, -,,.  (       / "



     .01-,,2 3(    3 " 3         (     2,-   4   #   54#5$  3 

  
 

 
   
         


 



 
   

 
    
 
  


   
   !

 "   
  
   


 #$   
  

 %  & 
  

 '



    
 ( 

%  
     
 &  )   "

 * +

  

- %
 
   

  




 "   %   

 %

, -( . /   

% %

 
 ( 


 
01 2

 




 #$  

$2 3  %

 



  45    /   
 

  (


    
2    
 ( 
%      +  


 &  
, 
   " %      5     




 %  / %  
  
%  
 &
  /  )  

     / %  (  
  


    




 


 
  
) +

  



  
 6
 
(



  
 
    "   %


 



 1 
 7 8$  * 3,  )  
 
   

 
01 8    45   ( 
  / % %   % 



 7 #$   %

 

   45
  /   
 &  )  
  

9 3 



     
 

/ % %   


%        

  

 
   
 /%   6   
 & *2 +  )    :  
 

 #$   / %  %
 


 %

 
 


 (
 4 
  
 

2#2 3 7 ,%     


 




   "
  %
 


 




  
   
      5 
  
 %


   %  (    
 ,%



$  


   ,%     


  * (%

 
 
1


 
   

,%   
(% 


%     
 )   




 

 
    %
    (%& (%

        &





  %

 


 
 
 %


%  7 $$     
  % 
  

 4  ( %

   1  7 9$    
  % 

 (   

 


  ,
   
  ,  




  
 
 
 
 & 
  % 

 4  3    (  

 
% 01 9 + 
,
   





 
& 

 
 ,  "  %
, 
 

 &  &  01 #


  & %

  " &

 % 


 ! %  
 




  
 

 '   6*    *(  3  *     3     2
2 #  #         '   3 

       (     .

!    "  (      

*  "

             "    !    "  (          + 8              "  ") "*  

.

8:
% 4;(  "    :** 6*    (  * < 3      3 "

)     :

  

                  

   

         

  

 

      

         



 

             ! "  

      #      $           



            $ %

           

           

 # %

            &    &      

    %

   $           !       &     

    ' %

$          

    

    ( %

$         

 

   

        ) %

#   !   )    

       

    

      * %

$          &            

 +  +    , %

!              

 

 -       .

 

+     %

$          

       

  ! %

   !       

          

  $ %

#   !       

           

  #   

!            

   

        

!          

  

  



 

    ' /   

 0         

 1  ( /  



 0          )   

#             *           )!   (   

   

 2

+ '     3     )     )   3  **     3  

                    ,.

,= -,,2   *     >6 .  " 3       "

  3   

3 )   

2   (   3     (        3        )   *   :**    (   (   3     >6 7 8:- % <   *  "  6*       3 " )   :

      

   

 $3  3  3  4        

   (       &  5



  4

     4 

     

   !           

  



 

  4          4

     $       

     

 67!     

 1  4 

       2 '    )   3  *  %     )   3 3   .  + 8 3(  = 8:.& *'* ">6 =-,
, 8:7 

*   * < 3  3    ? -.

-,,2  (  7 ,,17
7   3   " 

         * < 3     *  " 3       3 

" 3   * 3    "  " (  -,1--  *           3  ( " 3 *

"     ( ? ;

       *  ' (  *   

"        * (      '  3   : 3 ? -+ -,,2 3  * (

 *  3      * < 3 3 *   3      * < 3 3 *  (       *  -9 -,,2  3  *>6 %


8:+ @*  "    -.

-,,2  3 " "

*    &     *   8     & (  "   * & '

    (  9 ,, 

    3            & '

  " 3   ?  "  " (  -,1--  "   *  "   '     *   '     *      3         6 

(

       "  3 (  "

       #   *3( -9 -,,2
- 8:9       -,,2  3   "

'% ( (      & (  "   * ? -.

-,,2   " 3           *   (3              " " 4 3 ( + ,,  '3  * * ?  * 3  -,1--  "     3  7,   " ' 3 * " 3  (3 '  3 '% ( ' 3  (  -,1--

  " * "     3     (3  3 (  "

*     ' (      *   '      *  3 

8        3  

3         3 *   '  *   

"  *    3    (3 4  :6*        *        *     3    3  " '    *    '     " 3 3 

  * 3  (        *   & (  "  -9 -,,2+ ,,
2 8:0      -.

-,,2   " 3         3            " " '3     "  --      "  7,  3 * " 3   (3              " '% ( '  3    (3     '       "  --  3 * "   *  3     (3    "  3 (  "

     *        *    (3    ( '     3  (3 "    3  3    3 

      *  4  * *      3 *   ' 3  

"         4   :6*        *           *  3 

' 3 

"  *  
.

8:= 4 * #    3       &   -9 -,,2  )   "  3  41?

= @ )   " 4 @ )   "           *  3    (3     ? ,.

,= -,,2          "

  3  &        >6 .  " 3                 3 )   

2 *       (  3    3 '  "      >6 7 4   :

6*    *  (  *  " 3   (  3    3           ' *  ( 
A 
7 8:



     3    (   ( 3 3    ? -.

-,,2  (  + ,,19 ,,   3       @ )    < *       ( = ,,      *   (    ( * < 3 3  "

   (3     "        3  *  3    (3 (    ( 3  " (       (3  3    (3       (   (      *   3          *  "      -.

-,,2  (  + ,,  '          3    3  "      *   3                 -.

-,,2 3  "        *  -+ -,,2 @*  "      *   3  ;

  *     4   :6*  *    -.

-,,2  3     = 2,  '  (    (    * 3  "     3     (3  *     " 3     * " "     ;

  *     (

, * < 3  -.

-,,2    "   * "      * 

3

+ 8:
- 4       -.

-,,2  

     *" * "         3 

( "

"      3           

"  3   '  ( 3  "     3 

< 3     * 3 

 >6 27     (    ;

  '  ( 3     (  * < 3 (  (   *  )  * ! :** 3 "   ? -= -,,2 4 @ )   " "     "      " 3                  4   :6*  *      3          '      3 -,,  *  & '

 

(  *  & '

         )  "     *   "    *  
9 8:
2 3  "             &   &    ? -2 -,,2  ( + ,,    "   --  " *   *     *   3  ( " 3 *

"  ? ;

      *  '  *    (3     & (  "   *     3     '   3      (3 '        

  (3     *      *

"  (

*  3    (3  *  3 (    ( 

8  ( 3      3     (  *

     ?  "   * (

'   3 3 & '

 719  *  * ?  " *   3 *   4   :6*  *     

* (       3   *      *   * (   
0 8:
. 4 @ )   "   



* "    * >6 2.

'   * 3      *  3    ?    # 3               3   -0 -,,2  3 " *   6*  ? -= -,,2    3 "   *     *  "                       >6 .2   >6 .9 4   :6*  *     *  (       &  3      * 

"        *     * 3             "    3 *    * <  *    3 )     " '      3      -,,  *  & '

 '    (*& '


= 8:
7 < #      3    (   #3

? -.

-,,2  (  0 ,,10
7  @ )    < *         *    (  * < 3 3  "    (3      3       (  *< 3    *    

" "   * < 3 3   ( 3      

-   .7 *    *     *   (   3      "   4   :6*    3  3         -.

-,,2  (  * < 3 3       *  3 

'

"    (*< 3   3 * -, ' B!   >6 72 ' (  3   6 ( :- (    $ 6 ( :.  $  6 ( :7 $ >6 ( :


$

6 ( :
( )*$

6 ( :

3$  6 ( :
 @ $3 3 (  -
'       8:
% 4;(  " 3    

)     )   3  **     3  

            8:
% 4;(  "    * 
= )      ( 8:- % <   6*    -- '         3 3     ? -.

-,,2      3   (        * 3   (3 '  3

   3* -2 '     (   *  

 4       (   *  

       (*  "     **    3  "

    4    (  3    6* 

 ( -.

8:7 

*         3     -.

-,,2 * < 3  3           3      -.

-,,2 '  (

2 3    -.

-,,2 3            *   * < 3 '   6   "

 (  * " "     "  *     3     "  : 3  * (  -+ -,,2 '    *     * 3   -9 -,,2         * >6 %
 "  : 3 -7 8:+ @*  "         *     3         *     :

6*   & '

 3     3 " "          ' 3               "    *3  -+ 8:9      " 3            "    "            

     '% ( '3  * * ?  * 3 -,1--   " '  * 3   (3 3 

  3 '% ( ' 3  (  -,1--   " * "     3     (3 ' (      *        *  3 

@   *  

"  *    4  :6*  *     3  * '   *  *        3    * " *  3 

 *  *   8:0  

                ( *  3   "          *  3    (3 4  ( 8:9   8:0        3           *          *  3 

'  (

    * "   

.

   "   * 3 '       (

-9 8:



  (     "   *

@ ) *  *   (    ( 3  "    (3      3       (  3   ( 

  3         *  "      -.

-,,2  (  + ,,  3  "      *  

3                -.

-,,2 @*  "      *   3  ;

  *     3  3     & '

      * 4  3  "   @*    * (    3    -2 -,,2  -.

-,,2

 3          

3   B4 3 "  -9 -,,2 * 



* >6 2. 3   -9 -,,2 4   * >6 2.

   3   

 (       ( *  8:
2 3  "     (  (      -2 -,,2  (  + ,,   (  "  --   *         3   *  (3    3  3

   (  (      4   :6*                *       -0 8:
- 4    *         3 -,,  *  & '

 4 3

(  *  & '

 ' 4  " " ?         )    "   *  3* (  (  33 -= 8:
. @ )   "   *        

7   (  * & '

 4 3      -,,  *  & '

 '      3  3  

::

  & '

    *    3   *             "   3 *    * '      3    (    ' " & '

 3 (     3      *   "    '            (

'    (  *     & '

 <  3  3   ' 4  " " ?  *      * 3   3  3    (    !       3        (    3  3 )  ' " 8:
7 < #     ( 3       ( 

" (      3  *  

"    *        3

(  *  & '

 4 3  (        <  * (   * 3      *    8:
7 < #    6* :

:     -.

-,,2  (  0 ,,10
7  @ )    < *           ( 3  "   (3  3        (    )      '    3 3         * *< 3 3  * 8:
7< #    * >6 27 "        

( *< 3 2, '  "      

 4   

 *  

  *

    *   ' "              3    3 

+       (   "

  *  3  "

3       3  ( ( (     ( (       *  3     (     -2 -,,2 '    8:+ @*  "  (     *     3              * 

  3  3              

*  (     -.

-,,2 (   *  *  -+ -,,2 '           "    ((  ( 2
 "      3 ' ) "* 
+
, -,,.    -,
, -,,.     '   ;

   "    (

  ( (    (   "

( ) *+,



(

 *

 * ,

 +"%- .

!

8  .

 8

"1 C1< 8(  C1<