High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/6763/2016dismissed

Darshan Lal And ANR v. Manmohan Singh & ANR

2019-01-10Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu3 pages

!" #"$%&%'( ) *&+ ', - '# '!+"* ."!%!%'"*& /"*&0& '1+ '2%'3+ '# '!+"* .."&4'#"'!& ( 5, 2

26, *"&"'!( *20*%'#"*+ 70*8#9$ !" * *1%!/"*1 8#9$ !" *!+"4"!%!%'"*& *2 '#""4 '& -8#9$ !" **"&4'#"'!& :::

+ --"'3"%'!+"*"9%&%'4"!%!%'%&!*#"*# !"# = 4 &&"#>? !+" -" *'"# %9%- 0#3" * %98 &+% *40* ''"@0*" A $-&%'3 !+" 4"!%!%'"*&5B4- %'!%

&5"9%#"'$" ;

< ," *'"# $0'&"-

* !+" 4"!%!%'"*& $'!"'#"# !+ ! !+" 4"!%!%'"*&B4- %'!%

& C '!"# ! "@ 1%'"

%$% - C%!'"&& *1 !+"

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

C"-- &*#"*# !"#== 4 &&"#'!+" 44-%$ !%'>?!+"-" *'"# %9%-0#3" *%98 &+% *40*3* '!%'34"*1%&&%'!#"4&%!&GBA &#%"!1'"?

"*!% %"#$4? & %# 44-%$ !%' &C"-- &*#"*%&! 7"''*"$*# & *7H5 ;E< ," *'"# $0'&"- * !+" *"&4'#"'!& $'!"'#"# !+ ! %&&0"& %' !+" $ &" C"*" * 1"# ' C+"*" !"* !+" 4"!%!%'"*&B4- %'!%

& 9 %-"# '01"*0& 44*!0'%!%"& >0! %-"# ! 4*#0$" '# $'$-0#" "9%#"'$" #"&4%!" - &! '# %' - 44*!0'%!?8>"&%#"&4"*1%&&%'!#"4&%!&GBA#%"!1'"? C &$-" *-?

!+"*"

*"' %-0*"!4*#0$"!+"C%!'"&&8!+"%1403'"#*#"*4 &&"# >? !+" -" *'"# %9%- 0#3" * %98 &+% *40* #"$-%'%'3 !+" *"F0"&! * #D0*'1"'! '#$-&%'3!+""9%#"'$" !+"4"!%!%'"*&B4- %'!%

&C &%110'" *1 $+ --"'3" ;G< 4"*0& - !+"%1403'"#*#"**"9" -&!+ !'"9%#"'$"C &-"#>?!+" 4"!%!%'"*&B4- %'!%

&#"&4%!"- &! '# %' -44*!0'%!? '#!+ !%'!+"$%*$01&! '$"&8 !+"-" *'"# %9%-0#3"*%98 &+% *40**"D"$!"#!+"*"F0"&! * #D0*'1"'!>? >&"*9%'3 !+ ! %&&0"& %' !+" $ &" + # >""' * 1"# ' C+"*" !"* !+" 4"!%!%'"*&B4- %'!%

& + # 9 %-"# '01"*0& 44*!0'%!%"& >0! %-"# ! 4*#0$" '# $'$-0#""9%#"'$"!C &%'!+" *"1"'!%'"#$%*$01&! '$"&!+ !!+""9%#"'$" !+"4"!%!%'"*&B4- %'!%

&C &$-&"#>?*#"* ;< + 9" +" *# -" *'"# $0'&"- * !+" 4 *!%"& &&0"& %' !+" $ &" C"*"

* 1"# ' C+"*"

!"* !+" 4"!%!%'"*&B4- %'!%

& 9 %-"# '01"*0& 44*!0'%!%"& >0! %-"# ! 4*#0$" '# $'$-0#" "9%#"'$" ' !+" $%*$01&! '$"&8 C+"' !+" 4"!%!%'"*& 19"# 44-%$ !%' * 4"*1%&&%' ! #"4&%! #%"! 1'"? * &011'%'3 C%!'"&& !+" & 1" C & --C"# ' == 3* '!%'3 4"*1%&&%' ! #"4&%!&GBA &#%"!1'"?>0!'C'*"&4'&%>%-%!?'!+"$%*$01&! '$"&8%!C & %'$01>"'! 04' !+" 4"!%!%'"* ! 4*#0$" !+" C%!'"&& ' +%& C' *"&4'&%>%-%!? 9%'3 %-"#!#& '# -*" #? '01>"* 44*!0'%!%"&+ 9%'3>""' 9 %-"#!

$'$-0#""9%#"'$"8!+"-" *'"# %9%-0#3"*%98 &+% *40*9%#"*#"*''"@0*" A$-&"#!+"4"!%!%'"*&5B4- %'!%

&5"9%#"'$"'!+"$%*$01&! '$"&' 0-!$ '>"

0'#C%!+!+"%1403'"#*#"* ;< $$*#%'3-?8 %'#%'3 ' 1"*%! %' !+" *"9%&%' 4"!%!%'8 !+" & 1" %& #%&1%&&"# 26 -% 0#3" ) 1%! 6+"!+"*&4" 7%'3B*" &'"# ( "&B 6+"!+"**"4*! >-" ( "&B