← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/750/2007dismissed

Som Pal v. State Of Haryana

2015-12-15Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik,Mr. Justice S.S. Saron13 pages

     

 !

"

#   "    

"$%& ' '



  

 

  

 &  () *+ '

,-./+ +(/ 0- / () *+ .'

,-./+

, -* 00 11111  

 

   



    



! 



  

#"

$ % 

& "' (

 

% ) ' "

 (

)

'  ***** , -* 00','



  

"   





+,+,,+' '  ("

"





"

 !-. "

 !-+/ "

 1  2  3/0134 

  !-5 /01  " 





 "

 " 6

'

"       

 

  !,,+,,+'       

""

 ",   "

!',,,78 



"

 !-.  "

 !-+/01/  

"



"

   ""

      "    5  

9    "



 

"

    !-5  /01'      

""

" "

.',,,78/ 



"



"

 ""

 ",

 &"

  

  ":

"9 " 2  4'   ";  '

 "



  < 6= '

  

$!,0% ,>,!--51"

&"

20.4'   '

;  "

          

  " ("

" ? &:  "

=#<8 @8,A% "(

   

$,,7$!, %'

 

("

& @  

"  "

' : B" 

 '("



.3-C

>7. ' "

 ; 



 

 "   "

 '"

"

   

 ' "

 ' ( "

  " "

   

 B

"  "



'  :" /

" '     "

'

"   1"

( "

    ":

"9

  "

   

"

    



-7,  " 

.3

2   

  "

 "

: 

"

:  



,7  "  .3  "

  "



 : 



 



-7,  " 

.35C   

 ("

 .3  



 -7,           "

 8"     

     "

'  " "



 "

"

     

     

  

'  

  

"

 ( "

 " ' "'      

'"("

"

' 

B"

!.,,78 

" :

 :

  

   :     ("

     "D      

"

,,78 :

":

   "

 "

 % ' '0' " &" 

' . "

    

  ("

 &   @   1"

 "

    

 (  

"

 ( "  ' 

"("

  



""   

 '" '

  :@ 

 % :

     :" #='"

 

<

 '  "

"

'# "1

'     "



,!--5/

 FB0G7  0 8



 



"

'= # "

3 #  )#  20A4  

  E  FB00     "   '



 ' 

' /  '   

"

FB0F 

:"

"



FB0F7'  

" 

" 

 "";/FB0&   

"

' /  

"

&"

8"

'(""

 ,.,!--5

"

    FB0 &

"

    :

 " ("  FB0 H ,,!--5' '

 "'%   

H

 ' % '  ' "

FB0)'FB0 FB06  "(   ' %

( 

A,,78 "("

"

"9   ( 

A,,78 :

""  0 (  ',,,78'  '

" 8  "

= #<8@8,A  (  "

"

 FB0@'FB0< FB0="



  " ( "

   FB07 FB07!   " "

 (   

 "

H -,!--5'

          



          

" 

""

   @ 204

  :

 " ("  FB0   -,!--5'     &"    

  # "

 "

   ' 

 .,78

  &"

"

8"

    (        :

 "

 " (" (  FB01H

 ' 

"  

 FB  0#7        

    

'

"

" FB0#   "



"

 

   FB0;H



"

( '  

1

 ;"

"

""

 ' 



8

"





"

 !-.

"

 !-+

 !-5/01 

:"

"



("

'



 !!101   ' 





  ""





       

    

("

'

 &" 0

 (  "

      " 

("

 

-,!,,  %    

"   ("

("  

,>,, 

("  

  5,>,,  

    

  "

   "   6

'



 "



" 1 1""

  =!!-8#&,,' 

      " (

"   0

  1 -,,,+  '    

4

("



" "   ( 8"  ("



 "



"  ""

" 

" ("

'

 "

 " 6

'

'

"



 (" 

+,+,,+  



!,,+,,+'

"

 "

  (     

  

     

 





 "  "



  " <



 

8 

 

 



"

8 "



   &"

20.4'   "

"   "

  "

 "

       /  "  "

 " 



"



'

  "

   "

"

   "

 "

       "

'  "

"   '

"

""       

     

   :

 "

  '

"

""  " " :"  %

& "'



 

'"



      



 !

" "$8 I    

     

    

               

           



     

         

    

/   

' "

 "# 

$

 %&'

( )***  !

 +

 "

""

  $8 I           

  

    

             

    

            

       

                                   

                

                  

  

;

"

,   

'

 --)+!**  ./  "



"" 

"

""  2 /04'"  " "

:

 "

'"  

:



"( ("

"

"" 1 



 

" '  :"

("



"



 ""

  " "

 /  "( 1  

1""

   =!!-8#&    ,,'         

     %  )    #'8   

  ("

""

 ;/

5 =5+,.,!--5/   ' "E



"  "  /  "       "

 "  

8     

"

""

 " " 1 / "  "

" "

&"

20.4" 

      ("

      % :

    05  

&"

20.4 "

  "





"(

 "

 " 

'  "

 "H "

'

" 

     '% '0  "         

8   %     "

FB0) "

FB0  <":

"    

:"

"

FB06 

8  ' 

'"



"

 ""

'

( "

  



 ( '&"

20.4 "(

 

;/"



"

 :"

    "

  (   '  :

 

 &"

20.4'"

""

 "(

  " 

8 

"

8  &"

 ""

 

  "("

"

   '&"

20.4

   E

 1"

&"



6

"(

"  " 

'   

 =  "' (

"

0.&"

'"



  "  >       ,,!--5  G  

"  ' 

 8"

"

"" 

 "

"

"

"" / 01230

 4$

5..5(!

** 5-/'  3   1  

"

""   '  

    "  ("

'  

 "    

"(

  ("

" 

("

"(

 1 "" 

"( ("

  '"



"

""  '"  "

"

 

 "     

  

   



8   "  "       "  :   "

"" (  " 1



  "   (" :

  ' ( 

 "   

"

 ""   

 '  "

FB06 ("

"

',,,78



' " "

"" '"

G# 1 '0 "   "  

:





 (    "  E

  :

"

  " '"

  1 '0 "  &":







(     "("

 

  &"

 "

  20.4     % :



 2054  

 

    "

"  

  &  

 "  "

         "

   "

  " "

' 0 "   G# 1   " "

( ',,,78



' "  "

 9" FB0' FB0A 



FB0!

FB0>  " (   0 "  "   (  =#<8@8,A   "   

 (  "  :

 "

 " &  

:

  "    FB0%   "

 

/  ' &" " ' : B"

   

   "D       &"

 "

2"

4  "



"

 .,78



  ( "("

"

"2  4  "

 % " 



'"

"

 ""

((

""   " B "     "  &"

8"

"("

 "

   "  2  4  0:

 "    "   (   / "'    "    "

  "             



   

8     0    (         ' "   "

=#<8@8,A':

 ?: "

 ( "

'"



"

 

"

 ""  <"

 E

'"&"

8 "

"2  4 ""

(

" '

 (   "  0  '"



"   ":"

""

"  (   "  / " 

"

(

 >7.8,!8--5 

8 

 ,,!--5  (  '  "

( 

"   " F(

"8  

 H &"8 

 -,!--5 

"

  (  

"

""

G "  '"



" (   B""





"

"



: 

'  

 ( "

    ' ( 





 

8  

"



" 







8 " "9 " ';/

+$!, 0% ,.,!--5  " 



' 

"$,,7$!, % "

(

>7.8 ,!8--5  ;/ 



   " "



""D  

   "

"

  /   

' "



"# 6$

 7

 -((!**5 ) ( 





 

 0" ("  /  '&"

20.4 

"

 



' "



 :

" "

  :

 "  

   "

 ' " 

" 

  "

" ' :@ 

 % :

    ' 

' :

" #='"

 

=  "'    ""

 "

'# "

1

'     "

 ,!--5

"  '

 "

 " "

 '

"  "  ""

       

 " 

  G  

"  '  (   " "

:(



"

E



;/"

/ 

" '"



"   ":

"

   :

  ""   ""





" "   

"



"

 % :

"

   '"



" ;/ " "  

 " 



"

 ( "  ;    ( '"

"

 "

"  %"



 (" 

+,+,,+

2      

 

  !,,+,,+'  "     "     

"" 

+(/ 0- /

, -* 00 ,-0+ ,-0+ .,.