High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/6437/2017disposed of

Joginder Mohan (Deceased) Thru His Lr Vishal Gupta v. Roemsh Kumar Gupta And ORS.

2019-04-03Mr. Justice Amit Rawal4 pages

!"##$%&%'()*%+, - .%'/#*0!' /#$#!&#/ "0*1.02 #"%"%'#* 3#*&1&

4#&0514!*1)"! "0#*& #&)'/#'"&

!" #$%&'" '& !

*#&#'"( *3%6!&0!'1)"!,/7$!"# *"0#)#"%"%'#* *4%"0!1/0!*8,/7$!"#, **#&)'/#'"& , *1*&%4*!'9%":%'.0,/7$!"#, **#&)'/#'" ;;;;;

'& !)# *+ ')1*&1!'$#""0#*/#*/!"#/ -,+#!*'#/$1'&#+* "0#)#"%"%'#*0!&%+#/!%/!7%"3%&0!+1)"!,+#.!+*#)*#&#'"!"%7#"0# )#"%"%'#*,"/!8%'1*"<0%$0%&"!6#''*#$*/ )8.%7#'""0# $1'&#+))&%"# -=> - %/!7%"*#&)'/#'" !&''#?1*# > @=%&"!6#''

*#$*/ &"!'/&/%&)&#/ 0#)*#&#'"*#7%&%')#"%"%'%&/%*#$"#/!.!%'&""0#%4)1.'#/ */#*/!"#/ = ''#?1*# > ,<0#*#A8"0#"*%!+@?#$1"%'.1*"

<0%+##'"#*"!%'%'."0#!))+%$!"%'*)*#)!*!"%'%'!+/#$*##&#)!*!"# )&&#&&%'""0##?"#'" @*/ &0!*#%'*#&)#$"!*#&%/#'"%!+01&# A#!*%'.)*)#*"8>BB>-=4#!&1*%'.C &D8!*/&,&%"1!"#/!" !"#+ !.!*, %7%+ 2%'#&, 21/0%!'!, *#9#$"#/ "0# A9#$"%' "0# )#"%"%'#*> 91/.4#'"/#A"* '"0#)*#4%&#"0!""0#!*#4#'"%'#/01&#%&'" )!*"%A+# *3%6!&0!'1)"!,+#!*'#/$1'&#+*"0#)#"%"%'#* &1A4%""#/ "0!" "0# .#'#&%& "0# %4)1.'#/ */#* %& A!&#/ 1)' "0# &"!"#4#'""0#)#"%"%'#*%')*#7%1&)*$##/%'.&,<0#*#%'0#0!&"!6#' "0#)+#!)*)#*"8"A#%4)!*"%A+#'!$",!""0!""%4#,"0*##)!*"%#& <#*#!&&#*"%'.*%.0",A1"%"%&'+8"0*##&"*#801&#!'/$!'#!&%+8A# )!*"%"%'#/ 0%&1*"' - )!&&#/"0#++<%'.*/#*(>

!"#

%& $ $

)''!'

*# ' '! +& %

', 2#!*'#/$1'&#+*"0#)#"%"%'#*0!&%+#/"0#!%/!7%"0%& $+%#'"!+'.<%"0&%"#)+!'&"$'"#'/"0!""0#)*)#*"8$!'A#)!*"%A+#A8 &0<%'."<)*"%'&%'.*##'!'/8#++<$+1*&'.*1'/!'/%*&"+* "A#.%7#'"'#)#*&'!'/"0#"<+*&""0#*)#*&'!'/"0#)*"%' &0<'%'A+1#$+1*""0#"0%*/)#*&''"0#.*1'/+*,%*&"+*!'/

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

1*#%'%"&<%&/4 0!& )*"#$"#/ "0# %'"#*#&" "0# $>&0!*#*& A8 %'$*)*!"%'. &)#$%%$ )*7%&%'&%'"0# !*"%"%'$" *&0*",E"0#$"F :#$"%'#4)<#*&"0# $>&0!*#*"A18#!$0"0#*&0!*#!"#*"0#!&&#&&4#'"7!+1!"%'"0# &0!*#A8"0#1*""%&!4!""#**#$*/"0!"''#"0#&0!*#0+/#*&0!/ "*!'&#**#/ "0#%* &0!*# " "0# "0%*/ )!*"8 !'/, "0#*#*#, %' &1$0 $%*$14&"!'$#&,)*7%&%'&:#$"%'<1+/'"$4#%'")+!8:#$"%' #4)<#*&"0#1*""*/#*"0#&!+#%'&"#!//%7%&%'"0#)*)#*"8%' )!*"%"%'&&1%"&0#&!4#*#!

'./$

- # + # $#

# #$

$ #

#0 # 1

$ & - # ', 5##)%'.%'7%#<&1$0#'*41&&%"1!"%',%"<1+/A#%'"0# %"'#&&"0%'.&"*#&*"""0#)*7%&%'&!*#4#'"%'#/0#%4)1.'#/ */#*$!''"A#&!%/"A#&1#*%'.*4%++#.!+%"8*%'%*4%"8 #&1+"!'"+8, "0#*#7%&%')#"%"%'&"!'/&/%&4%&&#/ <#7#*, 2%A#*"8 %& .*!'"#/ " "0# )!*"%#& " 47# !' !))*)*%!"#!))+%$!"%'%'"#*4&"0#A&#*7!"%'&!'/"0#)*7%&%'& "0#$"*7%'/%$!"%'"0#%*.*%#7!'$#& 0%&1*"%&&!'.1%'#"0#!$""0!""0#"*%!+1*"&0!++ #?)#/%"#"0#%4)+#4#'"!"%'"0#*/#*<0%$0%&

#7%&%')#"%"%'&"!'/&/%&)&#/

,*)- '& ! *+./ #$01"

(/2/*,+3 45*+ 6 75

(/2/*, *2+8