← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/20/2004dismissed

Pintoo v. State Of Haryana

2017-11-07Mr. Justice S.J. Vazifdar,Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri17 pages



     

 !"#$%&'%  



   

   (  )*( + ,+ +,+(  )*( + ,( ,, ---     





  

 



 + +,+(&+ !

 

 "   

#

 $ %&

   ' (   ) * +

"

$  ,$(     %-%./..0   "

  1$ 2 34

   ($ ,$(   

 

#   

  0./5#    ( $( (         /....67            (           $ 

$ ( (   

!

  (

   +

 +  "  8-



(   $$                   

          

  +

 +   (    /0//..-" 9     %0%%/..: #

      ( (  

  ( "

 

$   



(

   1

 # 

;

4

 + '$<5# )

 

 $  4 " 



  ( (

      !

"

$  

$  + ;

= /&&/... ">.. ( (

     $$  "%/..

  

(  "(+  '  (

( ((   (  $

  +  2"

3!

(

 

   (   + + ;

 '

+ 

+

$   

+ "

 $ (( (



$ $ $   ">0. ("

$  

( "

'  +

 (  

(

'  +   $  "

   $ "%%0. ((    ( +



    +   ($         

 

+   +  +

$ 2

3 '  

(

 "

 8 (+    +  "

$  '





+

 $ 

+ " "

 $

  ((+  

+ + 

(  ;

%.6%?  $ 2(@3 (%-..67+ 



"

$ 

    ;

 

'  (

 ( 

   4



(  ;

 (

 " 

 (

 +      $   ( 51 " $ ! # +'+

$

    ( AB)+

 /&&/... /0.(51 " $

9    ( 

$ #  ,;(

  

;

"

45AB   0./5#+ $ 

 /&&/... /-.("5 

$+ 

  

$  #  

 ;(

 +  

  "   5

 $

 4

    /&&/... C?.( ) $  $ 

 51 " $

   

$  

AB   

   

 ( 

$+ ' $

"

$  +$

$   

'+

'    ( (AB1!



9 

   AB;    (  

  AB<    $ 7(  ( 

    (  +    %:%# #!

+

 />&/...    "     55   $

    0.&/...  +     + "       



  ( ABA

$

 ' +

'  



!   '

A

 =/&&/...

51 " $

'  $   ""

    ( (  AB  =  &>/...   (  

 AB  "      

 =

;  

  4



$  "  +

,  

 " 

 +  (     

,    " 

  " '   

   

 AB +

  "  , ;(

 )

(    /0>/...   

(   $     

   %C0# #

 + ((  #  +

+        0./5#+

 $  

( 

 5        

         B ( 

 +  

 8%   ,  ;(

  )

(       

   /0>/...



 

AB '$5 " $  8/     #    $              AB

$   $    

  4     < "

  80  

,  $    $

      

   /&&/...

'  $

 !

  AB%AB%%+  $  %/// 8-



   (   ( AB<  " ("  51 " $  +

45+

$    

      "    

$     

+  (    ( 

 +  

       "   $    

    (   "  

$

 

 '   



$  $ $ (

 

 "

  

7 B (  ( 8?   $ 



(

 + $ %&

 % 



;

    

    

 /...    +   $      ,"  

(  = 4

 =/&&/... 

  ( $ &=

' 

$ 

  

          (      

  " 





$     (  %%.. (  ('  ($ ( '

  8  + 

 

$ '  $$ + +  ( 

(

;

!

   

(

$

  



$$"

+"( 

+

$

 

      (

  +   

    

(  

 

  (  $$

 5

( 



(

 + 

  

"   8:#  , $     

     AB4 

$   '$   

        

4     < "

  8C  #  

 ;(

     

   /&&/...  #    

  ;

       ( 

 +

  5

 $

  

 8&  5    

$+       

    /&&/...   5   

;



 

45AB

 9 AB# 8>51 " $    " 

  ' " ( $  $ 

  8%.  )   ;  ;

   

 =

  ;

 

  4

       

    />&/...     7(  ( ";

+ 



5+

"+

"  (

$ ( +   



"5+ +

$+     $   

#  +  

" 4

+$, +

7 D% <

 , / (BE (B"  

  

 

$   ( 

   "

  +    $" + 

  / !+

 ,   (

$ 

$

$

$ (  $06- ( 0

  

 

  ' 

( 

 

 +

 "( " ' B

$ 

 /60   $ (' +  !

  "



( - # $  



F 5 

 

, 5,    (  (   

 

    ( " +  7(  (+ 

/-   

  



AB "( "   $   AB6%

, /  "   ' +

,  % -"

  2

3 8%%  (  #

         

 #

    

    /&&/...   +   $ +    (  ;

  !

  +   $  +   (  5  

( $ +'  

!



   

  ( 

$+

+ "

$ $

 "  

" 

 "  '  $ $ $  +



 (

+ ( "

' %?(  

$  "

   

(  



 

(             +

  +  



$ 

(  ( +   " %?.

 (    !

+ $  ' 

    "

(      + !

+

 " +

 

  (#

+   

   +

$  '

  !

  ( 

           

      

     (   (   "        !

 $     

  +  

  '

"  

 !

 $    !

$ 

'

 + '  "   ( (

  AB1



$  

 

 "

         ABG 4 

   < "

   8   B (        0%0  # #  

    



$ ( 

 

  8

  

 +   

 + (    



(

  (5    

 B (       

$

   

   $$

$    





 

#  

        

          

 (   "  !

#

 



 



 

 

 

  





     +    

$  8?  8%% (  #

  +      +        

  9 +

(;

  8? 

  "  $ 

 



      "&.. ( " 

+ '= 4

 8 

 







  (  

" 

 

$     (  

%%.. ( ('  ($ ( '



 8  + 

 

$

'  $$ ++  ( 

(

;

 !

   

(

$

 

$$"

+"( 



(

8 

 

(

$  



 

  ( 5 ( ( 

(



+   

"

 ) $

7 B (    

 '

"%?(  (= 4

 



;

  8   

 

  

     (  

 $ "

 +            (  +  

 

(



 

+

  + 8 

( 



 

  (  

  

 

  

+     ( 



$$   

   

( 

(

" $ +  

 

(           '+  

 

    (       

   

   0..( 

    



 $$ 

     

   

 + 





, 

(

 8%%( #

   

  $ +  ;

       

    1

  #   

;

4

 !

+

 $+ ( =     +'  ( $ 

   (    $$ $

 !

 

" 

 "

(  '  $ $ $  +



  $

+  "%?( "    < 

$ 

  

     +  

  $     

  (   

+  %?.

 (   

 + $ ' 

   "

(   +

  + !



 " + 

 

!

+  +     (;

$  '



  (

            !

 $     

  +  

  '

"  



$      "        

      

  +  

  (    ( " 

   5 

7 B (    

  + '  (   + '   

< , 

) " + 

;

< , 

"" + %?( !

$ $  + 

"%6/' (   (  

 8

     B $ "  

   

$,  

    +  

   "

     +

  

 !

 

+ (

+  !

+  

    

 +  $  !

$

( 

  +  

   "       +  

 

      +   ( AB)

+ 

  

(  

  (   AB)  

  "

  +   $         



     $$ 

$  $ $  + (



 





   "  $    

 

$  ) $  B ( 77

 8%%  

  

  

+ 



    ( +

 8-





"



   

$ 

 

 (( ($ ( "   

(  

$ $

$    8

+        +    +  $      '

  +  

++

!

( 

,  " $ '

  

(    ( AB#"   

   "

($   ( 

(  +    +   

$              

+    

$ $ 

    (   "  

        

 $ $

 ' 

 +

'  

 +    

  

                (

 

9        

7 B (  ( (

 

 = $$$   (+ 

(

 (  (  

(  (   

 

   $   

 8%.  )   ;  ;

  +  

     7(  ( ";

 ( 

 ,  !+ (+

 ,  

 

$   $



 ( (

 $ 



"  " 



 ' 

(



 +

 "(  " ' B

$ 

 /60  $ (' +

   !

 

, !

,  +

 (  (    

   

     

  

, /  "   ' +

5,  % -" 

(  

" , 0+ " 





 "

 !

' 

   +



( " +  (  (+ 

+ 

 = (" 

$  (    +    8?  8%%(#

  

 8%.) ;;

 



  "  

 

    

 

  ,   

  " ' 

"   " +



  



("  

,  !

+  +"

 



$' AB%

 2 3AB/!

 '  

$

   "  

  " 9     ( '$  



  (   !

 

   9  

   '   

  /&&/... "%/..!

(  (+    />&/... %/%.(!

  

(

 " +  (  (+ + /-

    

"

   =$$

$   ( 8?  8%% (  #

     #     

  "     (

 



      (

  "    (     +

 

' 

   (

 



$' AB%  AB/ 



(   + "

+   +  + 



"

   ABG

4      < "

  (   

 "



 "    ' 

"

+ (

  $

   

"

   $         

   $  

       

    

  $      $     +$      (     

    

((

(   5  (   "  +    (  

 

  8> 51 " $

 

/>&/...+ +  "  5

  $

  0.&&/..+   + "     +

8%%( #

  

+

    " + 

 

+  

 "        

 5 

 

 51 " $  $         (

     9  +   "

       

  

  +  

    />&/...  +

  8%%  (  #

 

 

 $

    

+

  



(

8-



   

 

$ $



  ( "

$

 '  

$ (

+ 

$  

 

   (   $ 

   ' !

$ (  $  

   (  ABA 

  ( ( ABA6% " 

$  (  $  + "      5  

 

"%.6%? 

   ( 

$$8%%(#

+      +      

  +   "

$           

 

'  (



   "     +     

  4 $      

    $       

 



  

 

  

$,  + '    

  A   

+     " $ 

    

    

"   

+ ( + "     

  ( ( (    ( 

    



   



 !

 

,  , 

5,  

 " +  (  ( 

 

" + (  (!

 (  (,  +

  

   

     



 "  

 

  ( ( ;

" 



$

  ((      0./5#  5  +   "   

    (             ($   ,$(            "

 

# !

+ 

( 

 (   !

   "

"

"  "

 "  '   +     $   ( (    .+ +,+(/   !"#$%&'%   .( ,, /

(

  

 6 '$ H 6



H 6