Tara Chand v. State Of Punjab
!""#$%#&# '#$('#)*+"!(%'! &!)!$%# !#"#,#+$)%%'! -.(,!/!$% #))!(01"!#&$!(!))+2$).(,!!&23! .&(#%!(
5+(!6'+7'6#)'!6#)72$5+7%!(.$(!&!7%+2$8 *2&72//+%%+$, %'! /.&(!& 2* #$2- 9./#& #$( )!$%!$7!( %2 .$(!&,2 &+,2&2.) +/ &+)2$/!$%*2&"+*!#$(%2 #1#*+$!2*
:#$(+$(!*#."%%'!&!2* %2.$(!&,2*.&%'!&
*2&2$!1!#&
&+!*"1%'!7#)!2*%'! &2)!7.%+2$.$*2"(!(2$%'!)%#%!/!$% (#%!(
;< =>/#(!01)'6#$+9./#&+)#).$(!& ?
!
"#
$ %
% &'
(
)
*
+ ,-
( (
. ( .
! + /
$ .
)
0121)
%
%
(
! + /
$
!
! +
3(
) ! +
)
) !
(
!
! +
4
. , -)
)
)
! +
4 !
8 +
)
) + * ) ,- ! +
)
5 @
$%'!0#)+)2*%'!#025!)%#%!/!$%#*2&/#" ;< =:> (#%!(
.$(!&!7%+2$8 #$(!7%+2$A:A4:A=2*&/) 7%6#)&!,+)%!&!(#% +%1#3+"B#+)%&+7%!&23! .& #/(22&+$,'2$&!7!+ %2*&.C#*&2/ +5+"2) +%#"#3+"B#&!#7'!( %'!&!#$( &! #&!(%'!+$C.!)%&! 2&%< 42$%'!(!#(02(12*#$29./#& !).0/+%%!(#6&+%%!$&!C.!)%< A%2 +5+"2) +%#" #3+"B# *2& 2)% /2&%!/ !<#/+$#%+2$ 2* %'! (!#( 02(1 6'+7' 6#) 72$(.7%!(2$
#%
# / ;< 8>5+)+%!(%'! "#7!2* 277.&&!$7!#$(&2.,')+%! "#$;< >6#) &! #&!( "22()%#+$!( !#&%'6#)72""!7%!(*&2/%'! "#7!2*277.&&!$7!#$(%#B!$+$%2 2"+7! 2))!))+2$5+(!/!/2< "2%'!)2*%'!(!7!#)!(6!&!%#B!$+$%2 2))!))+2$5+(!/!/2< D 5+#"< =72$%#+$+$,2$!0.""!% 6#) &2(.7!(01 #"B+)'#$%2 #/(22&+$,'6'+7'6#)#")2%#B!$ +$%2 2))!))+2$ 5+(! /!/2 < = #&&!)%!( %'!#77.)!( 2$
'!#77.)!(6#)+$%!&&2,#%!(01#$('!/#(!# (+)7"2).&!)%#%!/!$%;< >2$%'!0#)+)2*6'+7'#77.)!(#&# '#$( ,2%&!725!&!(2$!&!52"5!&#$()+<7#&%&+(,!)#"2$,6+%'%'!"+7!$7!#$( %'!)#/!6!&!%#B!$+$%2 2))!))+2$5+(!/!/2< $8
4 '#&#/ #" &2(.7!(%'!)722%!&6'+7'6#)%#B!$+$%2 2))!))+2$5+(! /!/2< 4
*%!&72/ "!%+2$2*+$5!)%+,#%+2$&! 2&%.$(!&!7%+2$8
&
6#)).0/+%%!( !#&$!(#3+"B#72//+%%!(%'!7#)!%2%'!
2.&%2*!))+2$).(,!!&23! .& 77.)!(6#)7'#&,!)'!!%!(*2&%'!
2**!$7!.$(!&!7%+2$8 01"!#&$!(%&+#" 2.&%%26'+7''! "!#(!( $2%,.+"%1#$(7"#+/!(%&+#"
'! &2)!7.%+2$ +$ ). 2&% 2* +%) 7#)! !<#/+$!( 4 6+%$!))!)
'!#77.)!()!%. # "!#+$'+))%#%!/!$%#$(). "!/!$%#&1 )%#%!/!$%.$(!&!7%+2$88 &
%'#%'!6#)+$$27!$%0.%#*#")!7#)!
'#)0!!$*2+)%!(. 2$'+/ !#")2!<#/+$!(#$(+$). 2&% 2*'+)(!*!$7!
'!%&+#" 2.&%#*%!&&!"1+$,. 2$%'!!1!6+%$!))#772.$%2* A#$(E/!(+7#"!5+(!$7!#$(2%'!&/#%!&+#"2$&!72&(&!72&(!( 72$5+7%+2$#,#+$)%%'!#77.)!(
!$7!%'! &!)!$%# !#"
=
!#&$!(72.$)!"*2&%'!# !""#$%72$%!$(!(%'#%%'!#77.)!( '#)0!!$*#")!"1+/ "+7#%!(%#B+$,)'!"%!&2* &!5+2.)!$/+%16+%'%'! (!7!#)!( #%'!&%'!(!7!#)!('#()%&#+$!(&!"#%+2$)6+%'#$,#"+$,' #)'+)6+*!'#("2(,!( #,#+$)%'+/.$(!&!7%+2$8E
%6#) *.&%'!&72$%!$(!(%'#%%'! &2)!7.%+2$'#)*#+"!(%2!<#/+$!#&+9+)'#$ %'!!1!6+%$!))6'26#)%'!0!)%6+%$!))%2&!5!#"%'!%&.%' .&%'!&%'#% %'!/!(+7#"!5+(!$7!(2!)$2%). 2&%%'!27."#&%!)%+/2$1#""!,!("1
A ,+5!$ 01A #$( E #)%"1+% 6#) 72$%!$(!( %'#% %'! 0.""!%) &!725!&!((+($2%%#""16+%'%'!&!52"5!&
!#&$!(72.$)!"*2&%'!%#%!).0/+%%!(%'#%+%+)#*+%7#)!*2& (+)/+))#"2*%'!# !#"#)%'!7#)!2*%'! &2)!7.%+2$+)0#)!(2$27."#& %!)%+/2$1 2*%'!6+%$!))!) 72&&202&#%!( 01 %'!/!(+7#" !5+(!$7!2$ &!72&(%'.)(2!)$2%&!C.+&!#$1+$%!&*!&!$7!
'!7#)!2*%'! &2)!7.%+2$6#).$*2"(!(2$%'!0#)+)2* )%#%!/!$%2*A6'2'#),+5!$#,&# '+7#772.$%2*%'!277.&&!$7! !
6#)5!&1/.7'72$)+)%!$%6+%'%'!(#%!#$(%+/!+$'+))%#%!/!$%6'+"! (! 2)+$,0!*2&!%'!%&+#" 2.&%#))%#%!(+$%'!72/ "#+$% !(! 2)!( %'#%2$
#%#02.%
/ 6'!$'!#"2$,6+%''+)0&2%'!& #$2-;(!7!#)!(>'+/#+$#$( #$0+&'#(72/!2.%2*%'!%!$%#*%!& #%%!$(+$,%'!/#&&+#,!7!&!/2$1#$(&!#7'!(%'!/#+$,#%!%'!$72$5+7% #77.)!(&#+)!(#"#"B#&#*&2/0!'+$(%'#%#$2-9./#&0!$2%"!*%#"+5!
'!$#$2-9./#&;(!7!#)!(>%.&$!(#&2.$(%'!72$5+7%# !""#$%*+&!( 4)'2%)#%'+/6+%''+)&!52"5!&2$&!7!+ %2*6'+7'#$2-9./#& ;(!7!#)!(>*!""(26$#$(%'!72$5+7%# !""#$%!)7# !(*&2/%'!) 2%6+%' '+)&!52"5!&2$'+))722%!& $!"!7%&+7"+,'%6#)#")2%'!&!2$%'! "#7! 2*277.&&!$7!
#$2-9./#&6#)%#B!$%2'2) +%#"0.%6#)(!7"#&!( 0&2.,'%(!#(01%'!27%2& !*.&%'!&(! 2)!(%'#%#)2$#$!#&"+!& 277#)+2$%'!# !""#$%6#)72$5+7%!(*2&+$*"+7%+$,+$-.&+!)%2#$29./#&#$()!$%!$7!(%2.$(!&,2+/ &+)2$/!$%*2&%'&!!1!#&)#"2$,6+%' '+)0&2%'!& /#&B#)'%'!&!*2&!%'!72$5+7%# !""#$%6#)'#5+$,# ,&.(,!#,#+$)%(!7!#)!(#$2-9./#&#$(%22B&!5!$,! "%'2.,'#7#)!
E .$(!&!7%+2$8E 6#)&!,+)%!&!(#%%'!+$)%#$7!2*2$!#/+%&#!5+ 6+*!2*#$,#"+$,'0.%%'!)#/!6#)C.#)'!(01%'!+,' 2.&%
%'!&6+)!#")2+*).7'6#)%'!+)).!%'!&!6#)!5!&1 2))+0+"+%1*2&A #$(E%2&2 !+$#$,#"+$,'0.%%'!17'2)!$2%(2)26'+7' %!)%+*+!)%'!*#7%%'!&!6#)$2*#")!+/ "+7#%+2$01%'! &2)!7.%+2$
E #$0+&#")272&&202&#%!(%'!5!&)+2$#)(! 2)!(01 A)'6#$+9./#& !#")2) !7+*+7#""1(! 2)!(%2%'!!**!7%%'#%2$
6'!$'!#"2$,6+%'(!7!#)!(#$2-9./#&A)'6#$+ 9./#& #$( '+/ #+$ 7#/! 2.% 2* %'! %!$% %'! 72$5+7%# !""#$% !<'2&%!(#"#"B#$'+)0#7B%'#%'!6+""$2%) #&!#$2-9./#& ;(!7!#)!(>#$(6'!$(!7!#)!(#$2-9./#&%.&$!(#&2.$(%'!72$5+7% # !""#$%*+&!()'2%)#%'+/#$(#$2-9./#&*!""(26$2$%'!,&2.$( #$( %'! 72$5+7%# !""#$% !)7# !( *&2/ %'!)7!$!2* 277.&&!$7! !
(! 2)!(%'#%!"!7%&+7"+,'%6#)2$#%%'! "#7!2*277.&&!$7! !%22B #$2-9./#&;(!7!#)!(>%2 +5+"2) +%#"#3+"B#+$'+)-!! 0.%'!6#) (!7"#&!(0&2.,'%(!#(
8
& '#""#$# +5+" 2) +%#" #3+"B# (! 2)!(%'#%2$
#%
# / '!72$(.7%!(%'! 2)%/2&%!/ !<#/+$#%+2$2$%'!(!#(02(12*#$2-9./#&#$(*2.$(%'!*2""26+$, +$-.&+!) 0 5 6 78
) )
6
6
)
*
- 9
)
6 5 )
08 7:8
8
)) 5
) +
)
) )
2 5
6 70 )
7
06 7
)
) )
4 )
)
;6
;2
< 5 )
)
)
068 7 :8
)
) )
8 5 )
0:8 70 )
)
)
;<
;8
= 5 )
08 7 :8
)
<
4 )
)
D
)$%8% +
)
) : 5 )
0 7:8
)
)
) ) @ '+)6+%$!))2 +$!(%'#%+$-.&+!)2 #$(872$%#+$!('2"!) '!&!6#) 7'+ *%.&!2*&+0.$(!&$!#%'+$-.&12 $(!&$!#%'+$-.&+!)2 4#$( A%'!&!6!&!*%.&!#%%'!%2 2*)'2."(!&-2+$%#$(2*"!*%)7# ."# '!
"#&,!+$%!)%+$!#$(%'!2/!$%./6!&!*2.$(%20!+$-.&!(#$("#7!&#%!( 6+%'0"22(7"2%) &!)!$% #&%2*)/#""+$%!)%+$!6#)*2.$(%20!
+$-.&!( '+"!%'!0.""!%6#)*2.$(+$F+$%'!) #7!0!%6!!$ A #$(5!&%!0&#!0.%%'!)#/!72."($2%0!&!725!&!(+$) +%!2*'#&( "#02.&*2.%'2.&) !(! 2)!(%'#%%'!)%2/#7'72$%#+$!(#02.%
772**".+(6+%'*!6.$(+,!)%!(*22( #&%+7"!) !2 +$!(%'#%%'!
(!#%'6#)7#.)!((.!%2)'27B#$('#!/2&&'#,!#)#&!)."%2*+$-.&+!)%2 %'!".$,)#$(7'!)%6'+7'6!&!).**+7+!$%%27#.)!(!#%'+$%'!2&(+$#&1 72.&)!2*$#%.&!
!*.&%'!&2 +$!(%'#%#""%'!+$-.&+!)6!&!#$%!/2&%!/ +$$#%.&!#$(+$-.&+!)2 %26!&!7#.)!(01*+&!#&/ 772&(+$,%2 '+/%'! &20#0"!%+/!!"# )!(0!%6!!$+$-.&+!)#$((!#%'6#)+//!(+#%! #$(0!%6!!$(!#%'#$( 2)%/2&%!/6#)#02.%%24'2.&) '+) 6+%$!))'#$(!(25!&#)!#"!(5+#"72$%#+$+$,/!%#""+702(1&!725!&!( *&2/+$-.&12
= 4
/ #&B#)' &/) "!&B **+7! 2* ! .%1
2//+))+2$!&!&23! .&0&2.,'%%'!&!72&(5+(!6'+7'#) !&!$%&1#% & 2 8:!7!/0!&:==D:#3+"B# (#%!(
==D %'! 72$5+7% # !""#$%6#)+)).!(#$#&/)"+7!$7!*2&#&!52"5!&: +)%2"#$(%'!)#/! 6#)5#"+(. %2=
A
=
.&(!! +$,'0&2.,'%%'! &!,+)%!&2*
9'.+#$#&6#&#$(#) !&&!,+)%!&!( 2 (#%!( ==E#7#)!
.$(!&!7%+2$)84:88:A E:84 6#)&!,+)%!&!(#,#+$)%%'!72$5+7% # !""#$%#$( /#&B#)'2$%'!)%#%!/!$%2*(!7!#)!(#$2-9./#& #$("#%!&2$!7%+2$)8A:8 6!&!#((!( '!&!#*%!&%'!16!&!
72$5+7%!(.$(!&!7%+2$)8E:8A:84 #$()!$%!$7!(%2.$(!&,2
*2&# !&+2(2*81!#&)
E
#/(22&+$,'(! 2)!(%'#%2$
'!
6#) 2)%!(#) 2"+7!%#%+2$ +%1#3+"B# $%'#%(#1#&.C#*&2/
+5+"2) +%#"#3+"B#6#)&!7!+5!(&!,#&(+$,(!#%'2*#$2-9./#&
!#"2$,6+%'2%'!& 2"+7!2**+7+#")&!#7'!(%'!'2) +%#"&!72&(!(%'! )%#%!/!$%2*A)'6#$+9./#&2$%'!0#)+)2*6'+7'#*2&/#" 6#)&!,+)%!&!( 2)%/2&%!/2*%'!(!#(02(12*#$2-9./#&6#),2% 72$(.7%!( *&2/ +5+" 2) +%#" #3+"B# ! 6!$% %2 %'! "#7! 2* 277.&&!$7!#$( &! #&!(&2.,')+%! "#$ !#&&!)%!(%'!#77.)!(2$
$+$%!&&2,#%+2$%'!72$5+7%# !""#$%/#(!#(+)7"2).&! )%#%!/!$%2$%'!0#)+)2*6'+7'&!52"5!&#$()+<7#&%&+(,!)#"2$,6+%' #&/)"+7!$7!6!&!&!725!&!(#$(%#B!$+$%2 2"+7! 2))!))+2$5+(!/!/2 < "2%'!)6!&!)!$%*2&7'!/+7#"!<#/+$#%+2$%'&2.,' 2$)%#0"!
.&#-#&B#)'
!52"5!&#$(0.""!%6!&!)!$%*2&7'!/+7#"!<#/+$#%+2$ %'&2.,'
)'2B9./#&
8#&+ '#$(72&&202&#%!(%'!(! 2)+%+2$/#(!01 #/(22&+$,'
!*.&%'!&(! 2)!(%'#%2$
%'!
+$5!)%+,#%+2$6#)'#$(!(25!&%2'+/#$(2$8
2$!'#&#/#"
&2(.7!( %'! )722%!& 2* %'! 72$5+7%# !""#$% 6'+7' 6#) %#B!$ +$%2 2))!))+2$5+(!/!/2< 4 D
4 /#&-+% +$,' "!&B +)%&+7% &#$) 2&% **+7!& !&23! .&0&2.,'%%'!&!,+)%&#%+2$&!,+)%!&2*%'!5!'+7"!)5+(!6'+7''! &25!( %'#% %'! )722%!& 0!#&+$, !,+)%&#%+2$ 2 A48=8 6#) &!,+)%!&!(+$%'!$#/!2*%'!72$5+7%# !""#$%
=
'! +$%'! &!)!$%7#)!6#)&!,+)%!&!(2$%'!)%#%!/!$% 2*A )'6#$+ 9./#&6'26#) %'!0&2%'!&2*%'!(!7!#)!( #$( 6+%$!))!(%'!277.&&!$7!6+%''+)26$!1!) !'#() !7+*+7#""1(! 2)!( %'#%2$
6'+"!'!#"2$,6+%'%'!(!7!#)!('+/#+$#$(
#$0+&'#(,2$!%2#%%!$(#/#&&+#,!7!&!/2$1#$(2$&!%.&$+$,0#7B%'! 72$5+7%# !""#$%&#+)!(#"#"B#&##$(*+&!(4)'2%)2$%'! !&)2$2* #$2-9./#&;(!7!#)!(>2$&!7!+ %2*6'+7'#$2-9./#&;(!7!#)!(> *!""(26$#$(6#)&.)'!(%2'2) +%#"6'!&!'!6#)(!7"#&!(0&2.,'% (!#( E #$0+&#")272&&202&#%!(%'!)%#%!/!$%/#(!01A 2%'
%'!6+%$!))!)'#5!(! 2)!(%'#%!"!7%&+7"+,'%6#)2$#%%'!%+/!2* 277.&&!$7!
2%'A#$(E'#5!,+5!$#,&# '+7#772.$%2*%'! )!C.!$7!2*!5!$%)6'+7''# !$!(2$%'!*#%!*."$+,'% %6!&!A#$( E6'2%22B#$2-9./#&;(!7!#)!(>%2%'!'2) +%#" A)'6#$+
9./#&6#) .%%2)!5!&!7&2))!<#/+$#%+2$0.%'!6#)72$)+)%!$%+$'+) (! 2)+%+2$ '!(!*!$7!*#+"!(%2)'#B!%'!7&!(+0+"+%12*A)'6#$+ 9./#&
)*#&#)/2%+5!+)72$7!&$!(+%'#)72/!+$%'!(! 2)+%+2$ 2*A%'#%#)%'!72$5+7%# !""#$%'#(#%%#7B!(#$2-9./#&2$#$ !#&"+!&277#)+2$2$E ==E6'!&!+$ 2 (#%!( ==E2"+7!
%#%+2$9'.+#$#&6#&6#)&!,+)%!&!(#,#+$)%'+/#$(2$! /#&B#)'
.$(!&!7%+2$)8 :8E:8A:84:84 #$(%'!72$5+7%# !""#$%6#) 72$5+7%!(.$(!&!7%+2$)8E:8A:84 #$()!$%!$7!(*2&81!#&)
#$(%'!&!*2&!%'!72$5+7%# !""#$%6#)$.&)+$,#,&.(,!#,#+$)%%'! (!7!#)!(#$(/.&(!&!('+/ A+$'+)7&2))!<#/+$#%+2$#$(E+$ '+)!<#/+$#%+2$'#5!(! 2)!(%'#%%'!&!6#)#")2#5!&0#"#"%!&7#%+2$ 0!%6!!$%'!(!7!#)!(#$(%'!72$5+7%# !""#$%+$)+(!%'!%!$%(.&+$, /#&&+#,!7!&!/2$1 '!&!*2&!+%7#$0!)#*!"172$7".(!(%'#%%'!&!6#) &!/!(+%#%+2$#$(%'!72$5+7%# !""#$%'#(!5!&1&!#)2$%272//+%%'! 7&+/!+$2&(!&%2%#B!&!5!$,!
'!/!(+7#"!5+(!$7!#")272&&202&#%!)%'! &2)!7.%+2$)%2&1 %'#%0.""!%)6!&!)'2%*&2/#*+&!#&/#$(#$2-9./#&(+!((.!%2*+&! #&/+$-.&+!)&!7!+5!(2$".$,)#$('!#&% +(! &! 2&%< A%'!
0"22()%#+$!(!#&%'%'!B2%+ B#/!!3#$( 0#$1#$2*%'!(!7!#)!(6!&! *2.$()%#+$!(6+%''./#$0"22( ) !&&! 2&%< D&!7!+5!(*&2/ .$-#0+%6#)2 +$!(%'#% 8+$7' !52"5!&6#).)!(*2& *+&+$, "%'2.,'%'!"#)%(#%!2**+&+$,72."($2%0!#)7!&%#+$!(0.%%'#% (2!)$G%/#B!#$1(+**!&!$7!+$5+!62*%'!!1!6+%$!))#772.$%#$(
/!(+7#"!5+(!$7!
) !& &! 2&%< +%'#)0!!$2 +$!(%'#%(.!
%2"#7B2*+$(+5+(.#"7'#%!&+)%+7)$2(!*+$+%!2 +$+2$6+%'&!,#&(%2 8 +$7'/.%+"#%!("!#(0.""!%*&2/%'!6!# 2$2*2**!$7!+ !
!52"5!&72."( 0!,+5!$
%'#)#")272/!+$!5+(!$7!2*& '#""#$#%'#% %'!)%2/#7'2*%'!(!7!#)!(72$%#+$!(8
772**".+(#$(*!6.$(+,!)%!( *22( #&%+7"!)6'+7'*.&%'!&%!)%+*+!)%'!*#7%%'#%%'!(!7!#)!(#"2$,6+%' A)'6#$+9./#&'#(#%%!$(!(%'!/#&&+#,!7!&!/2$12$%'!*#%!*." $+,'%
8
'!277.&&!$7!+$%'! &!)!$%7#)!%22B "#7!2$
#%
/ $%+/#%+2$6+%'&!,#&(%2(!#%'2*#$2-9./#&6#))!$% %22"+7!%#%+2$ +%1#3+"B#01!$+2&!(+7#" **+7!& +5+"2) +%#"#%
4A / +%'+$$2%+/!%'! 2"+7!)6.$,+$%2#7%+2$#$(+$+%+#%!(+%) &27!!(+$,)#% # / #$(%'!) !7+#"&! 2&%6#)&!7!+5!(01%'!
.(+7+#"#,+)%&#%!)% "#))#%8
# / '! &2)!7.%+2$6#) &2/ %+$ +%)#7%+2$) 4
9!! +$,+$5+!6%'!27."#&%!)%+/2$12*A#$(E 72&&202&#%!(01%'!/!(+7#"!5+(!$7!6!#&!2*%'!5+!6%'#%%'!%&+#"
2.&%'#)&+,'%"172$5+7%!(#$()!$%!$7!(%'!72$5+7%# !""#$%*2&%'! 2**!$7!.$(!&!7%+2$8
!*+$($2/!&+%+$%'!# !#"#$( %'!&!*2&!%'!)#/!)%#$()(+)/+))!(
A
'!#77.)!(# !""#$%#&# '#$(+)2$0#+"
+)0#+"02$() )%#$(7#$7!""!( !)'#"").&&!$(!&*2&%'6+%'0!*2&!%'! '+!*.(+7+#"
#,+)%&#%! !&23! .& 6'2 )'#"" )!$( '+/ %2 -#+" %2 .$(!&,2 %'!
8 &!/#+$+$, #&%2*%'!)!$%!$7!
*'!*#+")%2).&&!$(!&%'!"!#&$!( '+!* .(+7+#"#,+)%&#%!!&23! .&)'#""%#B!72!&7+5!)%! )%2)!7.&!'+) &!)!$7!#$( )!$( '+/%2-#+" %2.$(!&,2%'!&!/#+$+$, #&% 2*%'! )!$%!$7!
25!/0!& ."#%+:+$!)'
'!%'!& ! 2&%#0"!
!):2 '!%'!& !#B+$,:
!#)2$!( !):2