← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-AD/79/2020allowed

Reena v. Sahil And ANR

2023-04-13Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Ms. Justice Harpreet Kaur Jeewan29 pages

     

   

 

!

"#$# %& '( )( '

%

((((((**++

,$( - .#+

%/

.0

((((((((($* %/% $  &  12 ( - (-( -32  12 -( -  4 3  

   

 

 

 

   

 !

  "     #  $ %



" '



   #  $ %

(((((  4 35 ( !







 *  

 +" 

," -. !/ /-!0 



"   '%  !

,"

   2 !3/ /0 !! /-!4 

 35/

5-.

 

 !4.-   

7

 

 

9"

  /-!/   

7

 78



 :  / "  '

"%

4



'" !;*!3 %   "

   "

#   

 %





'" !*! ;-   

  %



 *

 % 



"% 

& "

 "



 &

:

  

  ,"      

'"

  

  



 

"

 & 

% 

$&  "



:



   % 

'"

%

" %  

  / !

 

/5

' /-!4

'" !/--

   

"

    

 * 

 "

 

"

 

 

 



  %



  &" 

%

&"



$



'" ""

 

% '

    ,"



 %

% &  

 / / < %



&    /0 !! /-!4

'

 

 2  ="



 "



 

 !.3





' " !0>;

  

7

  

*

9   " 

 /> !/ /-!4

  

 7



 

/ ;

   7

 "

 /->

 

& " 





35/?5-.



 

  &  



 /0 -! /-!0  

 ;>.

6;8 

 

  

 

"%

  

/ 3 ="

 ' )

"     

  @" @" A  "

+    " +"%

"

 /> -; /-!0

 

 

%

  " % )

/4 -; /-!0 



  @    %  %

"

 9 

 " 





"

 % 

$& !0 -3 /-!0 % '



 "



'



!! -/ /---

  "   =   6A = 8 

 % /; -3 /-!0



&



"

+

+" 



& 

 @" @"



8  /-!5  & " 

)

 '

= @      %

 9 " & / 5    " 9  !;

& "

 

:*/

9 

:*;

$    

 

:*3



"

   :*5  '

!0 -/ /--3 

% '

 6C9 *>8    D



" =

" 

 

:*.





 !.3

 



=

  @  6:*>8 = 

#   #$  6:*48  *

9        = =

" 

$

 

:*!/ 





 

:*!;

 

&    " "





/ .

&

" &  "* 6(

    "

6( 

 /0 !! /-!4  D ?

" 6( '

 /0 !! /-!4    



 !.3

 

6()

      /0 !! /-!4 6( 7 D /0 !! /-!4 6( 8   

"%

 

/0 !! /-!4 6( 

% '



6( 9 A



6(        



   '

 

7 6(  C 

"'

  





  6C9 *08 6(    /0 !! /-!4  



   

   





 !.3

 

6(  

   





 

 !.3

 

E  /. -; /-!0    



  6( '

6( 7 6( 8   /0 !! /-!4  



   

   

 % 

 !.3

 

6(   %     



 !.3

 

6( 9   /4 !/ /-!4  



 '   #$  

 

9  

6( 

' % D

/4 !/ /-!4 6(  =" 

 % "

 "



 /> !/ /-!4 6(  =    

 "

6(    /0 !! /-!4  



 '   #$  

 

9  

6( '

' % D /0 !! /-!4 6( ) 2 

6( 7 C   66( )



   6( 8 "

   "    / .

 "

    

  

 ;!;

 

   !* 





%  "  %

   



9  =:*!  

 #



 %

    "  

  

 

8  /--5 

   &

"* 6(    /> !! /-!4 6(      

"'   *"*AC

  

)  /--5 6( '

%

  

) 6( ) %

  

)  

!;;- -4 !! /-!0 6( 7 %

  

)  

!!>5 -. -/ /-!0 6( 8

% 9 "

   6( 

% 9

      6( 9

    ;





"' "

 "

"  

 '

!0 -/ /--3 '

 '

  C9 *>

*4 '

'

 C9 *> " " "    '%

%



  '

 !/ -; /--3 C9 *4 "F '

 

 '   !0 -/ /--3 

'

 '

 

   C9 *>

*4

% :*5 '



'

!0 -/ /--3 ; !

$& 

 ' " 

 



   

"  



    

' " 



   9"

 " " ?



; / 

'





 '

 

  &

"



% '



 



 "

"



 

%





  

%&  

  ' 

'

 " %   

" %

"

  & " "



 " "

"

"   

2

  %   

&

  

 



 &"  "

9 

 

% 

  "   "



' 

"

"  

 7 "

%7 



%   



 " ; ;



'

  "  &

  & * 2%  

 !.3

 





'" "



" "







  "

9 :



 

:*/

  "

'" "    

%





 





"

 

 &

"



 6'8

% :*/

/5 !! /-!4

+"  

"

 "

"

$&  

 !.3

   



"

"

,"



 



'

 

 -/*-3 % 

+" 

"

&  

 

68 ;    

:*/

 

 " 

 





  

 "

   % 

 



" /5 !! /-!4 :

  

 !.3

 

 

 " 

  -4 !! /-!4

+" 

"

 



 





  





" " ; 3 

'

   

"



    %



 $& =:*!

 







 %

  '"

     



      -4--

-/;-  

 % &



 "

&    "

 

"

    

; 5     

    6:*;8

  % 

  ,"

&

% 

" $&   

  6C9 *38 $& 

   6C9 *38

 & % " -4 !! /-!4

 $ 



 " 

"  

 " :

 

:*3

"    

 

  " " ?

 " :

 "

  ) 

"

 "  



'"

; .

:

 " /5 !! /-!4 

'

  



  

 

 

  :*;

&

 :*/ 

 " 

 

"  

     & "







  :

 

:*;

*9  



" 

''%

"  





" :

:*/

 "

"



 



& " :

68

 

& "





  

"     

  

+" 

"  

 





"







" "



% 







; > 



    



 6:*!;8

*9  

 "  "









'" /- %  "

"    



+ &  &



 

'"  &  + 

  " "'

" 

 ,"

  " 

"

"  &

   &

; 4 

'

"



 *

 6*/8

% " "" '"  " 

  "  ""

% " %  9   "

  %



 9 +"% 

'  '% & "

#

  

 ' "' *

,"



D  "

  "'

  

& %   %  '

  %

' :*.

   D



"

 "

/0 !! /-!0 C   "9 '  % "9   $ "

"   "9 "

   $& 

 

," +""

"  '

%

 

" "

 +"   ' 



 





      "  !* "'

% "



% '

'

+

   % "9

 & 

 "

% 9  

  "

 +"   %   



%

," 



% =:*!

   "'





 

"'



% 



% '

'



"

 



"  "

"

"

%

 &"

     %

 % "9 '



   !



%

,"

.

:

 

 "' 2%  '

   ' " 

 

 &   $H'

"



 $*.

- *.%

%/

.0$ ,0$:$ - .

$ ;<

%/

.0$ /-// 

.>-  





 



 

,"

'" 



   



"% 

 

 ;>/

 



 ;>/

 

 "

%  ' 

  

  "'*

 ;>4

 

 



,"   " "   >    "

 

'    ,"   &

* !

:

 "9 !4 % 

  I / :

 *

   9"

 " " "9I   *

  I ;

:

 /5 !! /-!4 

 *



"  





   "

" "9 

 "

 & "%  

 "



" 

 "  & "  I :

 *

    

 

 "

  

% &"  

I -  

 A

 C9 *> 

"   A

= =  $  # $ %



% ' 

'



!0 -/ /--3

%   !/ -; /--3

 % %

 

"

 "



% "  %

1

& '

"9

!0 -/ /--3

 "   -4 !! /-!4

"9 

!3 %  -4 

/0 % "  "

J K

 

 



  - ,  

 

 

 

   9"

 "



 ;

 

"

'

 

)

 ;



"* J;

  9"

 " *    J  9"

 "K *

 



% 9  

" " 

"

 

   

 

%  L  6'8



% 9

% '+ 

 '% '

  

" 

"  

   

 

%  L  68

" 

%  '%  

"    

"

" 

%  '%  

   

 

%  L  68



"

 

" "  

    "

 

%   K 



" 

   

" "



  

"

% * J"

  * :

 " 



'







%   ; 5 >

 



 "

"



 

' 

  

 "  %  " " '  M 6!8

% "

%   

,"

" '  

"



 " 9 "

 '" 







 "









" 6/8 2 " 



7 %



'  9 '%  ' "'

%  9  ' 

  '

'% C9  M  J" '  K"  

&

'    K  

 /0  "  

% 

 ;

   

 '&

!3 % 



 "

"



  "  % 

  

 ;-  G" '  H "



" "  



!- 1

& " &

 9     !!

   " 

 



 

  *

"9

 %

 

 "



 

  "

"  

   

  /5 !! /-!4 !/ :

  " -4 !! /-!4 "9

 

:*/

 %

" 4

   "'

 @"

 -4 !! /-!4







+ & # $

  %



'" -/ --  % & "







8  %

'

 

 



:

 

    

 6* "8 

"



$ 

"



     

$ 



 



$ 

7%+ 7

" 





"

$



"

& "

$   "

$ "

%  

"   

$



"





 

$





% '  

%

% !;

"9

 

 !.3

 

' @" 

  



C9 *;

!3 "  "9 "

'   

 % = =

" 

$

:*!/

 

  C9 :*!/? 





9  **  "  

9   /0 !! /-!4

 

% 9"

 "

" 9   "

% "9 ""





'% 9"

 " "  " " !5   ," 

6:*/8    "



  





&

 & %

$  

  %  " 

  



 "

:

"



,"

'" 



'" 







"



 '"

% ' 

 !.

  

   "9

/5 !! /-!4 * 

" +"

"







 "



 



 * /0 !! /-!4 !> % "9 " "

' %

$ 

 

:*3

 

 *

4

 

"9 "%



" 



 

 "



 



'" " 

:

 

"

:*3

 &   "9 



%

"

 *

$ %

&  '

"9   



 

 " "9

 "



% & %  " '



 "

" &  

9 " %

  

" % '"

" +

*

 

"



  

 "  &"

&



*

*

"%



'

" 





 "     $

  



'* " 



%





* 9  



     /-!4

'

 " 



 "  

 "  

    

 '"  

"

) "

 "   



 



" 

"



      "   









"  

' " " * & +"

 "

)



%    ' /-!4

 " " "

% 

&









  

 

% @"% /-!4





 '

 /-!4 !4 "' "

"

 ""

%    

  

' '" %   6:*38 

%   

'

   % "9  

!0 :

"9   

 

D



"

 "



 "

 % :*.    D



"

/0 !! /-!4

"





C9 */

C



"

 ' D



" "9





 " 

 %

'%   

"

  9 

" ,"



'" 

&

   

 ," 

&



 "   "9 "

  

"  6C9 */8 /-    

'

% "9 "





& " 

"   

 "

"9

 

J

 :K

 9 

9

"



 "



  

$

  % "

  

"   



 

1

&



9"

 "   9 

 &  

  

$& &   





&

  

 "





"

&



9"

 "

"

  "

"

 9

 

"

"

 



&    

 "

"



   "

% A%



 % "9 

" "% '  

&

%

%





  / &"  "

+" 



," 



   9"

 "

/!





%

  

 

 "

"9

  

"

"  "

9"



 " "



"

 '"

 % 

 %

  " &  "

 '"    



"

 

" ' %

 

9"

 "

'"

'"

 " "

  

&   '

9  **  6:*/8





% '  &" 

%

%

"   

%



 %

 

  

*9  

"  

," 

 

" 

  

  



" ' 

"  %  



/-*;- " 

" 





 





 

// " % &

 



  /

  9"

 "    "%  '%

& "'  "

" 

 /0 ;- 

 

 &



 %





'



" " "

"

'

  -4 !! /-!4 



  % '" & 

% &" "  

 %

&"  



% 

"  

 "

 !3 %  

"%

* &"



 

   

 '" 





"   

 

 /5 !! /-!4



% 

'



'  " "

  



 # :*!;

    +%

%

     

% &





'"

 %

 &

 %

-4 !! /-!4   &



 & &

   

% &



"

 " 



/;

" 





& .

 

 ;53 



% 

 



 

  % ' "

% "" &"

&



 ' " 

 "

   %

 





'

   " 

   " 

'"





&

%  



  

"  .*!/  



   

   / ;- 

"   " 

"*





  "

   &"

 & &

  % 

 '

"

 



 

  



"

'  

"%

  "'

 @ "+ "



 #



  &"



)

& +" 



  

/3 C  &   

 

&  

 %  

&" 

," 



"



 

 

  6C9 *38 



$ 

 

%  

"



  "



 '

"

"





'"



'"

%

" 

"





,"

," 

"



 %



 

"

7 

"

," 



'" 

="   ;

 /5  & "''  "     

" "   9"

 " 

)

"  



" 

 ' "'



 

"   /5 !! /-!4 "

'

 35/

)   

 5-.



 

/5 !! /-!4

!/ 



"

 

 

 " 

"





&" 

&"



%'% 

$



""

&"     /0 !! /-!4

2

 %  

 

 





  '

" %  





 

 



  

"  

2

 

)

" %  

 "''

"

  -4 !! /-!4 

"  

 

  C  '

  



%  " 

   &

"

'   "'    "',"

' &

   

 

 

% ' " *

"   & " 



 &" +"   

" "% 

 "

% ' " & "

  '

 %   



 &"

 

"   !

&

"



%

7 

&" 

" "



/.

"

"

 



" "9 

/5 !! /-!4 "9

 







    



 

/>  "  :*;

&"

&

% &" 

" 0 ;- 

"

 



% ' 



&

 " 





" 

''%

"





"



"

 ," "'

'" 

 



"



 

"





 

"

" 

"





 

 '    D

** "

"

  

 6C9 */8 

"% 







9 

   & 

" /5 !! /-!4

 "

" 

 %     %  *

" "

  * 

 

8 

  

'" '" * &

+ 



 

'

'

 



 % &" %  

&  

'"  '& 

 ' 

 &

/4 "

"  &

 

)

"

 '" 

   



"  





" "

"

   

 "

 &"

'" "



 &



%'% &"  &"



" 

% '" 



9 J " " " '"K

 ' "

 ='

  "9



  

" '   &  &

 

)

& %  

  "''

'

 

  

 

   

/0 " &

 

%   )





 35/

5-.



"  



"

" % &



  '  

2



 /5 !! /-!4

   ;

 



   !

    "% 

;-  % 

 %

&

+"  )

-. !/ /-!0 

  !



"%

 

 35/ 5-.



,"

 

   " 

(-( -32

 4 3 

 '( )( '

?  ? 

:

 

N :

  ' N

9   ,=- -2   *



  

   

 

      !

  "    # $ %



" '



 # $ %

(((( !

 9 !; -; /-/;

   !







," +"  )

-. !/ /-!0

  "

 '

@ 

 /; -/ /-/ " % !; -; /-/; *'

 '   & "

 

"  "

 & 9"

'"



'



"

 ,"

" 

$   



&  ""

 

*'

 '   " 9"





'  %





  

 # "  

 $ = *   /

 %



 



&

  !4 % 



" &

 

 &"   +"  & 

  % 

 35/ 5-.





%  5---?*



 " %

& "  / 

A

 

 " "%



+"



 %  "



;

@ 



  "

 

"

 %  

 "

 



(-( -32

 *0#+ '5  '

 4 3

!