← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/286/2004dismissed

Rajbir Singh v. State Of Pb.Etc.

2025-08-11Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul,Mr. Justice H.S. Grewal17 pages



       

 !

"#$#%&'



  

          

 !

"#$#%&'

  

     



         *&  +,* - -* 

. ,  +,*  -- /,    !!

" #$   

  %&&'()&*&'++, -  "#$   "  "#$  " %  

  %&&./0&*&'++,   1#!#  * 

. ,0 /       %"   

            "   $       +,+.'++,

  

  #" # 

  $ 

 

  #

4    

4 4

#  $    .+'   ., -%#  5 

4!   

  





 1#  "2314%!   $

' 

     ')+,'++'# 

 -6 #7&/'#   !

  %  # " #       

   



 "#7&) 

8   9" " - 6 

"  :-8;<=97&) 

       

 

 5,0&,( >  //++   #  " 

?

  5   

 4  !   8         ? ?9  "

#    " 

      

 7   

  

 >  #

! 5

# 

@

4  8"  9#  $

8"  9    

4 4

8" 9$  . 

#



4 8

  %&&'()&*&'++,9    #A 

    

       

    

  B-""

#

   

4  4

      !  ?

 

4 

       !  #

     

! 

  

 7  7&) 

   "#



 "   $# "   , C   "" #7&( 

    

#   " $    3

(

   # $#"      $  7&) 

     $  8'D+,'++'9   E    

 $  "    

 "#  

  ""       $      #

    

"  < C  " 8;<:9#7&/'-6 "   " 8;<:F'9      #  " :-8;<:F.9   -  

7& /'-6   #

 8;<C9             7&)    

#        

"   

7&( 

#   /)/ %%7&)    

#  #

$   ""

<"  D - $   C 7&/'-6   $  G  #" # "$   8;<*F/9 

"      

 "  " 3     #  $  ;<*#  

                    #     $

"  ) C '0+,'++'#-6   $    

" <"   #  



  $;<   7&0

  #$ ;<F' $     #    0    $                   

 

F

   

4 4

  



  '(+,'++'  H

&

 

4    .++,'++' 

 "

 #     

  ( C  +/+D'++'#     $   "        

"   #7&/'-6   8;<:F,9#   .+' -%#          G  E 8;<19#     &"" 

G%  $ 

 %   

#    

 



 8

;<'#  #;<.  ;<,9 $"";<I# " A6B J  

  $

8 <  E   

 "  E " &%&& ./(&*&'++, 9#   % //+D'++'

          7&/+#  -  =

  

         

  "   "    

   $  

#      $$;<GF'3  

 8;<!9  "G  -

   $    

  $

 $ 

 

  $   

  /+ K       $   #  

            -

E     3 #     

"" %

    

 % "

 

 ● 

  $

 

  

4

'  4



    .+' -%H   ● 



4    .+'  ., -% //

 $ <  

 

     

"  /' -          

 #       <"  " /, 

# "

 

7&/      '0+,'++'G  H 

             "   $  ;<        8F/9#       1"  7&'#           ')+,'++'  "

  "     $;<*      " 

$     &       G%  $   

 7&.# %   



7&,#%   

7&/.

  "   

       $  ;<%#  ;<    ;<  $

7&D#

"# " 

  8;<;9  

       /. 7&) 

#       

#  "     :-# $   

  

    "

 /, 

  7&0#$   " ')+,'++'/'D+  



 #          # 



  "     

#  " #     "       G

      $;<F'3  

     

" +/+D'++' +D/0    

;<! /D 7&(     

#    

#     $   $  7&) 

 /) 7&J

 

4   #                   

     

   $

   #

 ""      " /0 7&/+  -  =

  

    7&/'  -  6   # - $    C  #              

 $   # # $ # $""  " /( !" 7&//     &""    $ ;<5   &""# #

 $      #  "   % 

 "

     5/ '#



           /J 7&/,* "

$ "   8;<39#          '+   <"     7&/,    * "  

#     

$  '/   

   <"         ./.     %%   "   "

    "

)  

 # 

"  # 

 $  '' -  #

<"  < 

7&/ 

 

# $ =8;<9#     

  

 '(+,'++'#



 

  

#       "  

  $ H    " #    

  $ $ '. 7&' 

  

      

 

"!5  $G   ', 7&.        

#         L&

<"  



#   

        'D 7&,"

$ =8;<7,F9

    

   ')+,'++'#     "       # #  #   $   5/J# 

  #

  "         ')  ! 7&D  

    

   "       "

    ')+,'++' 

  .++,'++'" G  

8;<7&DF9 '0 =

#7&)  

 <" #  

  

      

 " A B A

B

 '(    #  

    

  "     

"  -    " #



4



"  #

"    

 <  

$ #        "  

  $

" 

   $  

           :-         $ $"   

 

  

4 4 

     

 "A BA

B#             #     

  

  "   

 $      'J  3 %#    $ #

  "     

7&) 

  7&( 



" $   #       $       ?

 

$   3   3 %  $ 

    " 

 &  

""4$ !

%"

7$8 4%!

- "

#%

1#! $ %

%"

#%

#69$ !

1#! $ %

%"

#%!

4:

 ;6 %   #%

  

4 .+'     -% -"  "     /#+++F& -+)" 

   

4     4 

.+'     -% -"  "     /#+++F& -+)" 

$

.+'

     ., -% -"  "     /#+++F& -+)" 

-4<6#$$#%$% :  99 ::

% 

=<#1-#%35>5:

.+ =         

  

   "    "         

     #       

?

 $          "     

      3

"

 "    

  ./ -        #     

 ')+,'++'//++ # 

"  "  

?

 #5 

4! 

8 9#      "  

       

       &

  "    $      

 

  

   

"  

    

     "   E 

#  &

 $ F

   

4 4

$      

 

 

$        

=     

"   

" # 

    $ "      $  

     $  "     .' -        # 

  "E     'D+,'++'  "   "" C  "   ""   

 #   E  

 

             

 7&) 

-         # 

    ')+,'++'# $# :-  

+/++     .+0 ., -%H  +/+D'++' 

       .+' -%= 

"   #    

   

     

 &  

    $  H  " $   # " ',     

 



                    



 -   

  

     



        <  

$  .. =   "            " 

 <    

3    

#  " 

 $ <   

    

 3 "



     

     

      "   -                  :-#  

  

"  

 

        

  G$#     

&<" #      "      



   3

   #   



  

    $  -

   $ 

$  

    :- $ "

          :-    

"         

 $

 -4<6#$$#%$% :  99 ::

%  3=#@ %$5#>-%4>

"2;

., =   

 

  

   3 %#     "  "     "     "        "

$   3 "

 "   

""  



.D - "  

   $  

" A BA

B#       -  #        %;<G@  



  :-5/'0 .++('+++#  $  #" #   .'.# .',#.'DF.,-%@ ;<GF/@    :-  @ 



 A B     

"  

#  !  #   

     -  # #

  

   

"          "" 

   .) =     7&)  

  " 

        

" A BA

B#

      

   $ "

   

  E  -        $   

          3  %     

  "  "  .0  < "       

 7&) 

#   -   7&)



      

# $

  G  " #  "  



$ 

   %3  3 %#

$#   

 .( = 

    %

 "$"  #

 ""  "

    G         "

"         

   $       #    3 %8MM97      % " $ #     $    " H  & ""$      # 

   A#"

      

 3   #   

 $        .J -

   



    ')+,'++'#          

"        +/+D'++'@  $

3 " # 

  #



          #  "   

      .'D -%  .+,F.+, -%#     .+' -% ,+ -

      " 

 <    

 #



(

    3   

   "

      "   $   #$ 

7&/

 

 

# 7&,"

 $  &

 #

 ',    

   # 

     $ "    

#  

$  $



           $      



           

      -4<6#$$#%$% :   -

,/ =         &#    

 # "   $   

    

   "  $        3 % # #

 $  

  3   $   " "   

7&) 

 7&( 

$ $      " $   !" 87&//9 ,' =  "            

 7&) 

  7&( 

#   

    7     

<#   



 

  " E   "" 

 " @  # 

 

   $          "H   

 " ""

  "#  $ #  

        

    3   

  $  "      

        

     

       # $# $ "

#

     "             

#%!#%3$  41

,. G$       # <"  "  " # 

  $      "     #  

          "

 

#           $          " # $  #  "              

    3 % ,,   " "  

 

4   #       <  

$ 3  #  $# 

   "

 #   



&<"     

   $ #     

  ,D -   

$ "    $    #

  "

 $  

  # ""    #    

   3 

  $  "   



    <       3

'



&<"     

# 

   

#  7&)    

    7&(     

#  

 

  

  



   -                     

 

 "

   

   

# 

 "   ,) : #    

   

    &<      

       3   

       



   

# $ 

  

#7&/

 

 7&,"

G$#  

      <     

    $

 # 

  $   

"   

   #   #     $             ,0 -" "    <  

   

     # <  #    $     G# $ 7&)   

    7&(     

 $      <   @ 

   

         

 @          "

   $    "    #"

 

           

      

&<"   

       <     $  

  

 ,( $#"   8     



  



   $    

  

9 <     "

 #   "         3         3 %      "



  "           #   #  E      ,J       

    " 7&) 

 7&( 

 =   

  $ " 

   7&)  

   #      

 G$#  "   

      ! " #        

    $   "    

 

  $ $ "

""3      $ 

 #   

  

&<"  @

     #  D+ &

  "$"      "

     

"     

        $     3 " $  

    " #  "  " 





    

          8 



    9   "     D/   



 



 

    3  # " 

)

#  

 

#  

#         $    # " $

 &  

     3   3 % 

 $ 



 

  

   

   .+' -% 

  



 D' - $   

 # 



  "

 8* 

. ,9   8- /,9   '

     F   6 F5   6 F5