High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRWP/1069/2021dismissed

Rajni Rani And Another v. State Of Punjab And Others

2021-04-28Mr. Justice Manoj Bajaj6 pages

! "

#$%&#'()*&+#,-)%./#$00,1($&.+0#.1.1)&#%++*231.+./$.)& ./)*5/ ./# 0%#+#&. $00,1($.1)& $,)&561./ ./# 3$1& ($+# 6$+ $'7)*%&#' -)% .)'$8 2*. 1& 91#6 )- ./# $'31&1+.%$.19# )%'#% '$.#' :

0$++#'28./1+ )*%.)&,8./#$00,1($.1)&/$+2##&,1+.#'

# 0%$8+./$.$+./#%#,1#-(,$13#'1&./#$00,1($.1)&1++131,$%.)./#%#,1#- (,$13#'1&./#3$1&($+#./#%#-)%#3$1&($+#2#$,+).$;#&*0-)%-1&$, '1+0)+$,

#$%&#' .$.# ()*&+#, /$+ &). %$1+#' $&8 )27#(.1)& .) ./# $-)%#+$1' )%$, %#<*#+. 3$'# 28 ,#$%&#' ()*&+#, -)% ./# $00,1($&.+ 0#.1.1)&#%+

(()%'1&5,8./#3$1&($+#1+$,+).$;#&*0-)%-1&$,'1+0)+$,

/#0#.1.1)&#%+/$9#1&9);#'./#6%1.7*%1+'1(.1)&)-./1+ )*%.

*&'#%%.1(,#= )&+.1.*.1)&)-&'1$$&'+##;$6%1.)-3$&'$3*+286$8 )-'1%#(.1)&+.)%#+0)&'#&.+) .)4.)0%).#(../#1%,1-#$&',12#%.8$+./#8 $00%#/#&''$&5#%-%)30%19$.#%#+0)&'#&.+) !.)6/)$%#)00)+1&5 ./#1%3$.%13)&1$,$,,1$&(#

/#-$(.+ 1& 2%1#- ,#$'1&5 .) ./#6%1.0#.1.1)&$%#./$. ./# 0#.1.1)&#%+ 3#. #$(/ )./#% ./%)*5/ $ ()33)& -%1#&' 6/) '#9#,)0#' 1&.13$(8$&''#(1'#'.)3$%%8 &./1+%#5$%'./#0#.1.1)&#%+$00%)$(/#'

%#+0)&'#&.+) !.)6/))00)+#'./#0%)0)+$,$&'.*%&#'')6&./#1% %#<*#+.)-3$%%1$5#$+0%19$.#%#+0)&'#&.+1&.#&'#'.)3$%%80#.1.1)&#% ) 61./$2)8)-./#1%(/)1(# 1&$,,8)&> ./#0#.1.1)&#%+ +),#3&1?#'3$%%1$5#$. *%*'6$%$/%11&5/$2/$$/121 $+2$ *%;1 @$/$'*%5$%/A1+.%1(.$.1$,$$&'6/#&%#+0)&'#&.+) !.),#$%&.$2)*.

1../#8$,)&561./)./#%(,)+#%#,$.19#++.$%.#'1++*1&5./%#$.+.)#,131&$.# ./#&#6,86#''#'()*0,# /#0#.1.1)&#%+$00%#/#&'1&5./%#$..)./#1%,1-# +*231..#' $ %#0%#+#&.$.1)& @&&#B*%# !A .) ./# % *0#%1&.#&'#&. )- ),1(#$.1$,$)&> 1.+#,-/)6#9#%.1,,'$.#&)0%).#(.1)&/$+2##& 0%)91'#'.)./#0#.1.1)&#%+ #&(#./1+6%1.0#.1.1)&

&).1(#)-./#0#.1.1)&6$+1++*#'.)./#)--1(1$, %#+0)&'#&.+)&,8$&'*0)&$((#0.1&51.1& )*%../#,#$%&#'.$.#()*&+#, /$'+)*5/..13#.)9#%1-8./#-$(.+$&'#B1+.#&(#)-./#$,,#5#'./%#$.

& %#0,8 28 6$8 )- $--1'$91. )- $7#+/ *3$%

//122#%#0*.8*0#%1&.#&'#&.)-),1(# 1%(,#$2/$1+.%1(.

$.1$,$6$+-1,#'28,#$%&#'.$.#()*&+#,6/#%#1&1.1+3#&.1)&#'./$../#

4 0%19$.#%#+0)&'#&.+3$'#./#1%%#+0#(.19#+.$.#3#&.+@&&#B*%# C.)

"CA)&> $&'+.$.#'./$.&#1./#%./#85$9#$&8./%#$..)./# 0#.1.1)&#%+&)%61,,./#8($*+#$&8,)++.)./#1%,1-#$&',12#%.8 )6#9#%)& ./#+$1''$.#% &1, *3$%'9)($.#,#$%&#'()*&+#,-)%%#+0)&'#&.+ ) !$&'"/$'+.$.#'./$.$+131,$%0#.1.1)&-1,#'280#.1.1)&#%+2#-)%#./#

)*%. )- #++1)&+ $. $.1$,$ 1+ $,+) ,1+.#' .)'$8 $(#' 61./ ./1+ 1&-)%3$.1)& ,#$%&#' ()*&+#, -)% ./# 0#.1.1)&#%+ +)*5/. .13# .) +##; 1&+.%*(.1)&+

)'$8,#$%&#'.$.#()*&+#,/$+0%)'*(#'$()08)-./#)%'#% '$.#' 0$++#'28./##++1)&+*'5#$.1$,$1&

CC -1,#'28./#0#.1.1)&#%+-)%0%).#(.1)&)-./#1%,1-#$&',12#%.8$&'$+0#%./# )%'#%%#+0)&'#&.+) !$&'"5)../#1%%#+0#(.19#+.$.#3#&.+%#()%'#'1& ./#+$1'0%)(##'1&5+$&'$+./#8'1'&).%$1+#$&8)27#(.1)&.)./#3$%%1$5# ./#0#.1.1)&#%+61./'%#6./#1%0#.1.1)& . ./1+ +.$5# ,#$%&#' ()*&+#, -)% ./# 0#.1.1)&#%+ 0%$8+ -)% 61./'%$6$,)-./#6%1.0#.1.1)&1&91#6)-./#+.$.3#&.+)-./#0%19$.# %#+0)&'#&.+6/)$%#&).)00)+1&5./#$,,#5#'3$%%1$5#)-./#0#.1.1)&#%+

#$%&#'()*&+#,-)%./#0$%.1#+/$9#2##&/#$%'$&'61././#1% $++1+.$&(#./#($+#-1,#/$+2##&0#%*+#'($%#-*,,8

/# +)(1#.8 -)% ./# ,$+. -#6 8#$%+ /$+ 2##& #B0#%1#&(1&5 0%)-)*&' (/$&5#+ 1& +)(1$, 9$,*#+ #+0#(1$,,8 $3)&5+. #B*2#%$&. 8)*&5+.#%+6/)+#,')31&0*%+*1.)-$2+),*.#-%##')3,#$9#./#()30$&8 )-./#1%0$%#&.+#.( .),19#61././#0#%+)&)-./#1%(/)1(#$&'-1,#0#.1.1)&+ $5$1&+../#3-)%0%).#(.1)&)&./#5%)*&')-./%#$..)./#1%,1-#$&',12#%.8

&,$%5#&*32#%)-($+#+6/#%#./#%#+0)&+#)-+*(/%#+0)&'#&.+1+($,,#'

! -)%./#8$00#$%2#-)%#./# )*%.$&'%$1+#&))27#(.1)&.)./#'#(1+1)&)- ./#%*&$6$8()*0,#$&'./#0#.1.1)&1+%#&'#%#'1&-%*(.*)*+ /1++/)6+ ./$. ./# -1,1&5 )- ./# 0#.1.1)& 6$+ ,1;# $&8 )./#% )%'1&$%8 %1.*$, $&' *&&#(#++$%82*../#+#;1&'+)-0#.1.1)&+()&+*3#()&+1'#%$2,#.13#)-./#

)*%../$..))$../#()+.)-3$&8)./#%130)%.$&.($+#+6$1.1&51&,1&#-)% /#$%1&5 /1+ (%131&$, 6%1. 0#.1.1)& 1+ $,+) ,1;# 3$&8 )./#% +131,$% 0#.1.1)&+ -1,#' 28 ./# %*&$6$8 ()*0,#+ 2#-)%# ./1+ )*%. 6/) +##;

0%).#(.1)&-)%./#1%,1-#$&',12#%.8$&')%'1&$%1,8+*(/0%$8#%+$%#2$+#')& ./#+),#5%)*&')-$00%#/#&+1)&)-./%#$.0%#'1(.#'$5$1&+../#'1+$00%)91&5 0$%#&.+)%)./#%(,)+#%#,$.19#+)-./#51%,)&,86/))00)+#./#1%$,,1$&(# 6/#%#$+./#+$1''#(1+1)&1+%$%#,8)00)+#'28./#-$31,83#32#%+)-./# 2)8 /# (,$13 1& 3$7)%1.8 )- +*(/ 0#.1.1)&+ 1+ ()%%)2)%$.#' 28 ./# 0/).)5%$0/+ )- ./#1% +*''#& +#(%#.19# $&' +3$,, '#+.1&$.1)& 3$%%1$5# $,)&561./$()08)-2%1#-%#0%#+#&.$.1)&.)./#0),1(#()&.$1&1&5-)%3*,$1( %#<*#+. -)% 0%)91'1&5 +#(*%1.8 61./)*. #9#& 3#&.1)&1&5 ./# %#,#9$&. 0$%.1(*,$%+3*(/,#++./#3$&&#%$&'3)'#)-$,,#5#'./%#$. /)*5/./#$55%1#9#'0#%+)&+($&$,+)$9$1,$,.#%&$.19#%#3#'8 28-1,1&5$0#.1.1)&2#-)%#./# )*%.)-#++1)&+2*.)&,8$-#60#.1.

1)&+$%# -1,#'./#%#$&'$,$%5#&*32#%)-0#.1.1)&+,$&'1&./#,$0)-./1+ )*%. 2#($*+#./#6%1.0#.1.1)&#%+-##,./#$,.#%&$.19#%#3#'8.)2#,#++-#,1(1.)*+ 8&)61.1+$6#,,+#..,#',$6./$../##B.%$)%'1&$%86%1.7*%1+'1(.1)&)- ./1+ )*%.($&2##B#%(1+#')&,81-./#6%1.0#.1.1)&'1+(,)+#+$9$,1'$&' ()&91&(1&5($*+#)-$(.1)&./#%#-)%#1.1+130#%$.19#-)%./#0#.1.1)&#%+.) ,$8$+.%)&5-)*&'$.1)&.)+##;1&.#%9#&.1)&)-./1+ )*%.$.,#$+.

" #+.$2,1+/1&5 ./# D$(.*$,D $&' D%#$,D ./%#$. /*+ ./# 6%1. 0#.1.1)&+ ()&.$1&1&5-)%3$,+832),1($9#%3#&.+5%)*&'+$&'13$51&$%8($*+#)- $(.1)&6)*,'-$,,+/)%.)-./#%#<*1%#'+.$&'$%'+-)%#B#%(1+#)-0)6#%*&'#% %.1(,#= )&+.1.*.1)&)-&'1$

-.#%#B$31&1&5./#-$(.+)-./#($+#1&/$&'./1+ )*%.-1&'+ ./$. ./# 0%#+#&. (%131&$, 6%1. 0#.1.1)& -)% 0%).#(.1)& 6$+ -1,#' 28 ./# 0#.1.1)&#%+)& $&'1.($3#*0-)%*%5#&./#$%1&5)&!

6/#%#1& &).1(# )- 3).1)& 6$+ 1++*#' .) ./# )--1(1$, %#+0)&'#&.+ -)% !

'31..#',8 '*%1&5 ./# 0#&'#&(8 )- ./# 6%1. 0#.1.1)& ./# 0#.1.1)&#%+-1,#'$&)./#%0#.1.1)&)&"

-)%+131,$%%#,1#-2#$%1&5

C2#-)%#./# )*%.)-#++1)&+$.$.1$,$$&',#$%&#'()*&+#, -)%./#0#.1.1)&#%+1+*&$2,#.)7*+.1-8./#()&'*(.)-./#0#.1.1)&#%+6/) $')0.#'+13*,.$&#)*+%#3#'1#+2#-)%#'1--#%#&. )*%.+-)%0%).#(.1)& /# 0#.1.1)&#%+'1'&).'1+(,)+#./#-1,1&5)-./#0%#+#&.6%1.0#.1.1)&2#-)%#./# #++1)&+ )*%.$&',1;#61+#./#-1,1&5)-0#.1.1)&2#-)%#./##++1)&+ )*%. $.1$,$6$+&#9#%'1+(,)+#'.)./1+ )*%.

/#$2)9#-$(.+$&'(1%(*3+.$&(#+)-./#($+#(,#$%,8#+.$2,1+/ ./$../#0#.1.1)&#%+/$9#$(.#'*&-$1%,828()&(#$,1&53$.#%1$,1&-)%3$.1)& -%)3./# )*%.+$&'31*+#'./#0%)(#++)-,$6 )&+#<*#&.,8./#0%$8#% -)%61./'%$6$,)-./#0#.1.)&1+'#(,1&#'

../1++.$5#1.1+%#,#9$&..))2+#%9#./$../#2#,,15#%#&.%# #3#%5#&(# )- 0$&'#31(

> /$+ )&(# $5$1& -)%(#' ./# .$.# )9#%&3#&.+)-*&7$2$%8$&$$&'

'31&1+.%$.1)& /$&'15$%/.) 130)+#9$%1)*+%#+.%1(.1)&+.)(,$30')6&./#()&.$51)&$&'1&./#+#.)*5/ ()&'1.1)&+./# )*%.+$%#$,+)6)%;1&561./,).3$&8%#+.%1(.1)&+6/1,#

= /#$%1&5./#($+#+ 00$%#&.,8./#0#.1.1)&#%+/$9#&).)&,8()&(#$,#'./# 3$.#%1$, -$(.+ 2*. /$9# $,+) 6$+.#' ./# 0%#(1)*+ .13# )- ./# )*%.+ ./#%#-)%#./#8'#+#%9#.)2#+$'',#'61./()+.+

#+*,.$&.,8 ./# 6%1. 0#.1.1)& $+ 6#,, $+ ./# $00,1($.1)& 1+ '1+31++#'61./()+.+)- + 4C.)2#2)%&#28./#0#.1.1)&#%+$&'1.1+ )%'#%#'./$../#+$3#2#'#0)+1.#'61././# /$&'15$%/@))% $.1#&.*&'A61./1&$0#%1)')-.6)3)&./+-%)3./#'$.#)-%#(#10.)- (#%.1-1#'()08)-./1+)%'#%

/# /1#-*'1(1$,$51+.%$.#$.1$,$+/$,,#&+*%#./#%#()9#%8 $&''#0)+1.)-./#()+.+ 0%1,

*,$.1

! E/#./#% #0)%.$2,# #+C) E/#./#%0#$;1&5C #$+)&#'

#+C)