High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/313/2004dismissed

State Of Punjab v. Karnail Singh, Etc.

2026-02-2315 pages

4226 P a g e |

"#"

$ !

"#"

$ !

"#"

$ !

"#"

$ !"("

$ !

"#"

$ !

"#"

$ !

"#"

$ !

"#"

$ )* )* )* )* !' *

++ + '!

1# 1# 1# 1# 4226>A)?

4226>A)?

4226>A)? !5& * !5& * !5& * !5& *3+2+4247 3+2+4247 3+2+4247 3+2+4247 0"'" * 0"'" * 0"'" * 0"'" *4 4 4 4+24+4247 +24+4247 +24+4247 +24+4247 && * && * && * && *29+2+4247

:'+ :'+ :'+ :'+ $% &%!' $% &%!' $% &%!' $% &%!' B11## B11## B11## B11## B'1 & '

B'1 & '

B'1 & ' $% $% $% $% :'+ :'+ :'+ :'+ $% &%!' $% &%!' $% &%!' $% &%!' 789 7894226 4226 B11## B11## B11## B11## B'1 & '

B'1 & '

; <)+

+ + =

+ =

+ = +=< +=< +=< +=< )!+)++ .--

!%11## "

4226+ )!+ ! )

-&50 !)!+ / &1 -&5 !%1"" !"

7894 0>("0 ' !"? 4226+ )!+ % 5 :'-&50> !!'1 & '"

%0''+ ("0 ' !"?

= - = - = - = -++++

%"'

&$( '%## &"'1 1' 11#- "++ +- 4226 4226 4226 4226"#&'@ @ @ @

:'+ !

"#"

:'+ !

"#"

:'+ !

"#"

:'+ !

"#"

$% &&&& %!', %!', %!', %!', 789 7894226 4226 4226 4226"#&'@!" @!" @!" @!" ("

$%:'+ !

"#"

$% ("

$%:'+ !

"#"

$% ("

$%:'+ !

"#"

$% ("

$%:'+ !

"#"

$% &&&& %!', %!', %!', %!',-.% !/%

'.# ##'0(1#"

%&0%## $& %0((

"(1 $ &

&$( &&2+ +23+4221''&/% ! - &&"" # ''" ' &$- !

0 0-5"&%"(1 $ &

&$(

P a g e | 2 %!"# !%#&%%1!'0 %&"#&1!5%0' &/ C &"

$% "& -%!'1 & '.!0D "&%0%!$+ 4+

% C+ EF4 "

% 1!' 0' .' !$"'!& % '"'%'( (&/!"("

$%' G%'%"'%"

$%+ % !#5 C!0% "

%1!' 0'%' !1!& 0&#.* @

!"#$$#% &'

&( & ' )& ) &' %&& *'

& '& &) & + & % & ' ) & && '

& ' ' ) & ' '

% && ''

' '

& - & & & ' ' + % & & ) ' %& - &%) & % & &.

- &% - & & %/ ) % % & - % & & &

% % &. ) % +

P a g e | 3

& -

1 '

2 )& 30

- & / ) + - '

& '

+ & '

%& 4- & -

2 5

2670 %2 8 + ! !$"'!" % - % 1#0 00 !! 0 .' '10&/%1#"0 &! $%'"1# .'1!1!&+ +28+4224-

!%&'

(&%!"

!"' &%!&&&/.'' % %'1"#!1'(!(C("

" +!1'(!(C("

" -% &&&/.'% &&5!%#$#!1!' "5'%&0'& % 0

&!0" 24 .'&&&+!1!' " % %0'.'0(("&% !''" '!!"#+ %!"# !

7 0'

&!0" '24-672 &6 $"

'% !'1 & ' &%/.!!&!&0%!$'%&00!&" $#/+##% 00 '&1#&&%%/%& #'#/"

5#5&"

%1!' 0' (/ !"& / % !+ !"

$ % 0 !' !"#- % 1!'0 C("

&=!+ ++ 1-.%0 0&%H!/C("

! I+29+4224 &

&%##."

!"'* @! 97

%' 0

/!%

& # 97 ' 0

/#%

& & ' %& 8

P a g e | 4

%"' 0!''C("

" - % &("& % " 1!' "' !

5!%!(/>"?/!(!G'- '1!&#"#& /"#&"

$ # $%&/!(1!''

!>""?$!J'>"""?5 #'" '+ %!!/ 0$"

'"C&#"((/'!"1#('##"'' '&.

% +

% !&& .

& (/ '$( # ! 0"!0 (! "#- % #! 0(1##/ 0"!0#"

$ !( ! #$+ >"5? % !G' % 5%"0# ! 11#"&-% .%#'."###0G &# $#0!" '!1!& 0&& % '%!"

$0" $ "#!0+ %0(1#(1 " #"( &01"" (/00 !+>5? !

$%'G"

& %%1!& 0&/ '#"&"

$ % &/- &1 0!

'%"

$ "

# !$ '- & # $ &!(""'%&-0%'-!1#5"'+ 6+

% 1!'0 !%! C("

& !+ !'" (- )&"0# "0!-"5"# '1"#- !

#-.%(&"0#$##/C("

& ! I+29+4224 &

&%##."

!"'* @!5 &!$1#1' '

%0-0 & :

% '

2- 97

# & 0 % &'

- 97 8

!"'

(! & 4 .! G1 ! H!/ 1"

" + % 1!#& !" %"

!"'.'."%"

46% !'+##%"

!"'.! 0 '&/#

.1 + %5! $%%!"$"

#!0!&."%(&/"

% !-.%"0%"'"

(/% & &"''"$ &/( &"'0!!0+C%"" "'%0! 01/%)<.%"0%.'1!1!&"

%1!0'' !"$"

#+ C%"" F "' % 1"0!"# &"$!(' '%." $ % '' %

!"'+ ' "

!(" C%"" -++ !

#!$!&"

$% !!"5# % 1" "

% %'1"#+ 1#"0 !D ' C%"" - &0#!& !-1" -

"(G%'( 5"&(/1"

P a g e | 5 C%""F+ 1#"0!D 'C%""- 1"

!"'

(! 4 ( & "

%)< '$!"5 ' "

!- 5"&(/ 1"

" - C%"" F+ )/ %"' 1"

" .' '& % H!/ !1!+ 7+29+4244-

' !- 1" .' !!!& &! '1"#- "#+ % !! 0"

%"'!'10"'( &"

%&%&"0G.%"0% %5 ! $%&/"

% !+C+"''&!

01/%!"$"

# &%&"0G+ I+

%"'0!''C("

" -%&("&%%%& &0#!& %"

!"'& $! '#"-'%'(.! '

"0" 0 ' &%"

!&"

!/0 !' !+ &"& "0%/!(!G' % 1!' % "

!&+ &"& "0 / $!J' % 1!' %

!& 0!

'%"

$(!G' %"

#!$ '%"

!&+ %! .' &!("/%&-0%'!1#5"'+ %!.' !

$'G"

/1!%&/+ 7+

% 1!'0 !%! C("

& = !+ !

&! !- .%0 0&1'(!(C("

" %&&&/ ! &

&%##."

$* @ %

& ;

7 & '

&- '

& &

&0 '

&&'

& < - % & &

#&'

: '

&&'

&(=

P a g e | 6 (

' < &% 7 & < ''

- %& < - '

%1 0

& '%% & %

1 & &

& %

& & ' 5

& '

1 '

- % &&

%%'

1' & & ' & %

& &- 5 - % ' & %

& '

/ &

& & & & & & % '

%& -'

'- '' - &

% %'

% 0

& 7 8

%! 0!''C("

" - '% &("& % 1 #( !/ (#"'(.'(''"5-.%"0%0 '&&%&0'& &-% '-".' '

&& + % &"& &!("

& !" "

!"' % 1!' % &0'&+ 5 1!' - '% 0 #& &!("

% & !" %

!"'( &"

%1'(!(!1!+!0 !' % "

!"' %& ! "

&%"(1'(!(+%&"& %5 /1!5" '%"'!/ ."%!$!&1 #( !/(#"'("

!#" %&0'&+ %#

P a g e | 7 '"&%%!-%!.' %!('"'!(" /##."

0#!+

% 0 '&%-1!" %1'(!(!1!-'%%&( &"

% %"!&#"

%%!('"'#11#"#5"

-.%"0%.' '&!%%"$% &G !%5"

%!+%&"& "0 /C!

!/ % &&&/+%&"& "01 #( !/(#"'( /1!%&& &/+ #( !/ (#"'( 0 '#.#/ ' .## ' '

&& #/+ % 1!" .'1!!(&"

%"'0'+ 9+

% 1!'0 !%! C("

& +=+6- 1# "

$%- .% %& (&"0##/ 0%0G& %!0!

(! 777 &$5 %"' !1! C+ ++ &("& % % !! /!' % !0! .! &($&+ =I G%&5 "

$%- - %& !!'& ! ' "

$% & 1!1!& %"' 1!' #'!0%((C+ +=7 #"

$%.%.' !

'&% 5'"$" +28+4224+ %& "

""##/ 0 0& % "

5'"$" &1!1!&%"

'!1!C+< &%#'G"

1''''" % # $"

$' % &0'&+ % 1!'0 !%! C("

& =9 $! "

$% 1'& ' F IF9F4224 & %& "

""##/ G % !0! "

1''''" & !0!&& % '( % ." '''+ !!'& !

"#"

$% &%"'1!' #'!0%((.'1!1!&+ #' !0!&& % '( ' 0!"

." '''+ % 1!'0 !%! C("

&!"("

$%'=8-.%%&!"!&%5!( '(&"

% +

%"'0!''C("

" -%'&%%!0!.'! $% % 0 !/!& "

% !5!' $!+ % !0! ! 5! '" ! "

% '(1'"" "

.%"0%'%.'#/"

$+ %!0!! 5!%#$ '" !."0!%!"0+!1''"

$%!0!5!%#$ !-% !0!.' !5!'&+ ! #$.'"

'!"$%(

!.%!'% %!#$.' "

'!"$%(

!- "%& #&&+!#5"

$ %!0!%'1-%00 '&! ./!(%'".%!%.##.'

P a g e | 8 &(#"'%& /! % !0! 1''& 5! '" !+ #' &("&% #/ #$ !%&'

!&"

!"'.%!'%! .' "

!/ %%!#$+ %!"0G'.%"0%## 00

&($& .##&"& %" / + %## $%#$"

0# &"

$%%"$% '" !.' . &%#+ !%!&("&%%/!(!G' %!0!&"& C"' /1#0"

%"!% '+5 - #&%& J&!( /1!%&/ ! &%!.' #& %!%.% %! $%%1#"0%'1- !!#"!%+C01 % # %"$% '" !- %! 1! %! &/ '

& 5 '"

$#!

"'+ !.'#/"

$."%0 1.!&.% %!0!.' 1''&5!%!%"$%+=% %!0!.'1''&5!%%"$% '" !."0 &%!"0-'%!("

&#/"

%'(1'"" + %!0! .'1''&5! #/5!% 11!1!" %"$% !+ %! .' "

!/ % #.! 1! % %"$% '" !+ %! .' C!

!/ %%"$%- % '.!0(1##/!0 !&+ % C!

# "

!/ % 11! 1! % %"$% '" ! .' 5"'"#+

%!.'!

"'(!G+ %'G"

.'!&&"'%"

0# !+ 8+

% 1!'0 !%! C("

& =3 #. "

$%- .% '

11!&%0'%1!'0 +

%"'0!''C("

" -%&("& % #/ .%#!0!1''&5! !+%"(- #$ !.''!"$%+"

0-".'%!&'

!0- /!(!G !0!11!&+ %#&%&J&!("

!"' !+ %/ &"& "0 /5"'"#"

!/ %#$+ !%!'&% 1#'! .'11#"&%!0 !&#$ ! !

#+ #/ &$.' 11#"&+ 1!" !.'0 0&!'%&"&+ % 1!'0 !%!C("

&=2 0%%!"

$%-#!G-.%'&% %!0!.'!$"'!&"

% ((!"

$%' #"

P a g e | 9 "

$%-!'"& '%%1 !-"'!"0< &%" + %1!'0 !%! C("

&=- # ""

$% -.%"

""##/. $%'( !0!&&+ !0!&& % '( !"( "

$% & $ % !$"'!&+ #'!!'&%00 '&"

%1!' 0' &0 0& %"

5'"$" "

""##/+ %1!'0 !%!C("

&=!+ ++ 5'%"-.%! !.'&("& 7+29+4224 &.'&"'0%!$& I+8+4224+ % %& !0 ! '% #$ ( ! ."% '"0%& .

1'!"!'10-#%"$% &!0 !#.!K#"""

#+% .'1!& 1 &"

!#0G"

$ "#"

$#( ! &1#'!& % # #$+ &("& % % 1" .' &"'0%!$& 2I+28+4224 "

'"'0!/0 &"" + %1!'0 !%!C("

&=6(!"

$% .%'&%%!0!.'.

&/%"( & "

$%+ %!0! .''#&1!' 5"##$ ("&"-.%' (%&"& G .+ % !0! .' % && 5! % 1!' + ! % '( ' 5!" ' 1!'0 ." ''' .! !0!&&- % 1 #"0 1!'0 ! 0#'& % 5"& 0+ 3+

%!!- % "! "

0!"("

$ 5"& 0 .' 1 % !'1 & 'F00 '&"

%'%1!+++'( &%/'& %% "!0'.'0 00&"

#'0'+ %/%& 0 0!

."% %##$" '#5##&/%0(1#"

%1!' 0'+ 2+ <!

& 0

'# 11!"

$ %# % 0(1#"

' .## ' #!

& 0

'# %5 5%( #/ !$ & % "

% 1!' 0'- % 00 !! 0 %& G 1#0 2+22 +(+ I+29+4224+ '" !.'C("

&/!+ !'"(=47*I2+(+- I+29+4224+ # ""

$% -. %&0!' &"

"!& %" '' '" !+ .5!- '% .' &0#!&

" ! (G"

$ / '( +

%!!-$"

*42+(+-%

5'"$"

$"0!. %%'1"#

P a g e | 10 .%!!"("

$%.'

&/%"( &%!0!&&%'( + % '- %&#/"

%1!' 0''&C1#"

&/%1!'0 +<!

& 0

'# !%!'

("&%& 1 #( !/(#"'(-%&0'& %&&"& ( %!%00 !! 0+ .5!-".'0 '&/ ."

!"'-1!# $&"(("#"/- &#&$+5 %"

!"' % 1!' !.! (!("

!+"## !%!-%#!

& !"# !"#&11!0"%".'1!1#

&( !&! &##% %! 00 '& 0( % '1 !0!+ !

"# "

$% ! ' "

$%-!'1 & '-C%!&%!!'1 & G"##%(/!

$5! ."%%!0!+"## !%!-%!"# !"#&11!0"%%! .'("5 %1!%!'1 & '0(("%0!"(+ + % %! % &- #!

& 0

'# 11!"

$ %# !'1 & '"

%%0'''

("&%%0'.'1# & %( & %! .' 5"& 0 '%. % '" ! %& &"& & %

!"' '

!& / %! "

% "

0"& + % (&"0# 5"& 0 0#!#/ '

$$'&% !%&'

!&"

!"' %!#$'+ .5!-'% .'&"'0%!$&"

'"'0!/0 &"" 2I+28+4224+5 -'%&"& +28+4224& 1 #( !/(#"'( & "

!"'+ % '-% !'1 & '%& .! $#/"

5#5&"

%1!' 0'+ 4+ =%5%!&#!

'#!%1!"' &1!

'&% !0!&0! ##/+ +

% 1!' 0'- &("&#/- % "

!"' .! 0 '& 2+22 +(+ I+29+4224 / % !'1 & ' / !

$ 5! % !0! !1&#/- .%"0% .' &!"5 / !

"# "

$%+ 5 &("&#/- !"( "

$% #. "

$% .! 1!' % 1#0 % 00 !! 0+ ((&"#/ %!!- '" ! .' G % %'1"# &.'(&"0#$##/C("

&- '

!1!"'"

$#/-'( !

P a g e | 11 .' !0!&&-5 % $%'%.'0 '0" ' &.'"(G% '( !%1#"0+1!!(%-%'( '!"("

$% .'!0!&&4*I1+(+-' !.'##$&#/

"(G% '( -%.5!-!(27+22+(+"##4*2+(+-%1#"00 #&5!/ .##%5 !0!&&% '( #. "

$% ! !"( "

$% &- % '-%!"'

C1#"

&&#/"

!$"'!" % "

%1!' 0'+ 5 '" !- ' 1! %! .

(&"0# !0!&- .' 0 '0" ' %! $% - %1#"0"

##/&"& !0!&%!'( "

% 1!' 0'+ 6+ 1!!(%-'1!%0(1#"

-%0(1#"

1!/

'&1#/%1!0!&!5!/%"$%5# ( && %'"& !' -%00 '&%&0 '&"

!"'%(+ .5!-&("&#/-% 1!0!&!.'1#/&5!/%"$%5# (!(%#'42&/'"

% "#&' !%"#&'%00 '&1!/+ .5!- "

!"'.!0 '& /%1!' ' %0(1#"

L''"&"

%"#&'"'#.%!% 1!0!&!.'"

$1#/&5!/%"$%5# (+"## !%!-%! .' &0 '"

!"' ! 2+22+(+ %&/ 00 !! 0+"## !%!-"%!'1 & '%&%"

0((" ( !&! !-%/. #&%5! $%'(.1 'F$!"0 # !# "(1#( '%"(0(("''" %0!"( &%"

!"'. #& %5 0 '&!"("

$% #. "

$% & /%!("#/ %'1+)!5!- !%& 0 0!

."%% "!00 !! 0 ##+%%& 5!0(1#"

&$"

'%1#/"

$1!0!&! 5!/%"$%5# (+ % '-%##$" '#5#&/%0(1#"

% 1!' 0'11!&"(1!#+"## !%!-"

%1!' 0'-% 1!'0 %& !#/"#&1!5%%&%%'00 !!&& %

!"' '

!& / % "

!& "

% ##$& "

0"& +

0- %

P a g e | 12 1!'0 C("

& =4 !+ !'" (- .% %& (&"0#$##/ C("

& ! I+29+4224 &

&%##."

!"'* @!5 &!$1#1' '

%0-0 & :

% '

2- 97

# & 0 % &'

- 97 8

&("&%%%& &0#!&%"

!"'& $! ' #"'%'(.! '

"0" 0 '&%"

%!&"

!/0 !'

!+ &"& "0 //!(!G' %1!' !+ &"& "0 /$!J'!0!

'%"

$(!G' %1!' %"

!&+

%! .' !

$ 'G"

/ 1! % &/ % "

!&+ "("#!#/- % 1!'0 C("

& = !+ ++ 1- .% &("& % " 1!' "' !

5!- %! (/ * >"? /! (!G' >""? $!J' >"""? 5 #'" '>"5?"%!G'%5%"0#!11#"&-% .%#'."###0G &# $#0!" '!1!& 0& &>5? !

$%'G"

& %% 1!& 0& / '#"&"

$ % &/- &1 0!

'%"

$ "

# !$ '- # $&!(""'%&-0%'-!1#5"'+ .5!-"

%1!' 0'-

0% "

!/ .'

& % 1!' '" !+ %!- '% %& '

!&.$!"5 '"

!"' &"

!"'.!

&& $! ' #"+ %1!'0 !%!C("

&=-!+ !

&! !-.%%& 0 0&1'(!(C("

" %&&&/ !+% &("&%%!.!.!0 !' %!1!' - %%"

!"' %&! "

&%"(&%+5 '1!%!- !%&&"&& %(''"51 #( !/(#"'( &".''

"0" 0 '&%"

!&"

!/0 !' !+

%!0!''C("

" -'%&("&%%! .! "

!"' %1!' !'%"

!"'.!&("&#/ %#&+ 5 %"(- !0 !'%% '%&%#& &%

P a g e | 13 '%&! "

&+5 1 #( !/(#"'((/00 !##'

&& &"! !' '+%&"& "0 /C!

!/ %1!' %&0'&+ % '-""'11! %(&"0#5"& 00#!#/'

$$'& % %&!

5!%&0'& &'%.'#' 0 '&"

!"' /!5!'"

$%!0!+5 /!(!G'.!

%% '% 0(1#"

'"&#'+ % '-% "!5!'" %0(1#"

11!' %"$%#/"(1!# &%"$%#/

#"5#+"## !%!-".''&/ 0(1#"

%%!0!%&1''&5!%##$ !4F "('- %.5!- %! .' %! "

!/ % !"$% '"&+ "' %"$%#/

#"5#%"

!"'%& 0 '& #/ %##$ % %! #$+ 5 - %! .' "

!/ % 1!' '" !+ "## !%!- 5 " % 00 '& %& "

0 ' % "

!"'- % %

!"'0 #&'"#/0 '&!"("

$% &%"'' '"

%"#&'+

.5!- '

0% 00 !! 0 %& G 1#0 & % 5!'" "' %"$%#/ "(1!#+5 %!."'-"!0!"'!5!'& &"

!"'.!0 '& %(

!''

$$'&/%1!'0 -%!. #&%5 ( / (!"

!"' %1!' %&0'&+ !%!-%!0!.'G 1''''" /%1#"0 I+29+4224+ .5!-%!"' %"

$ !0!&'

$$'%%!0!# $&%00 '&"

%1!' 0'+ =2 0%%!"

$%0#!#/'&%%!0!.'.

&/(! "

$% /%00 '&"

%1!' 0'+5 %!.' %"

$ '

$$' % % 00 '& %& / 0

0" ."% % !0! "

D '" +

% '-%1!'0 %&!"&' 10'$"

'%!'1 & '/ ( "1 #"

$%5"& 0+5 %!."'-.%50! ##/1!

'&% "

$!0!&&/%!"# ! &."

!' '&5"!( % '(+ % !"# ! %& 0!!0#/ '!5& % %! .' &#/ " #&$"

$% !&"& '

!%"

!"'"

%##$&

P a g e | 14 0"& &%." '''.!0!!0#/&"'#"5&+1!!(%-%&

! !

5!/%!0!-% %!'% #&%5 /! (!G'-$!J' &#&'% #&%5## %$!

&+5 %!0! .'&("&#/G 5!%&/%&0'&!1&#/-%.5!- %!.' 0!

'%"

!"' &5 '%&"& '

!"' %! 1!' % &/+ 5 % '" ! "

!& .' &"'0%!$& 2I+28+4224"

'"'0!/0 &"" !%!!( &'%&"& +28+4224 & 1 #( !/ (#"'(+ 'D #/- % '!/ % 1!'0 &"& "

'1"!0 "& 0 &%!'1 & '%5 !"$%#/ 0D "&/%!"# !+ I+ ' 1'% 5 &"'0 ''" - . "

(!"' "

% 11#'.##'!5"'" &%'(!!&!&&"'("''&+' 0 'D 0-%"(1 $ &

&$( &&2+23+4221''&/% ! &&"" #''" ' &$- !

#"' 1%#&+ 7+

%)!+ / &1 -#!

&("0 ' !"-.% ''"'&% ! %#%1"" !"

7894226"'''''& '+42-222F+ !%!-%)!+ % 5 :'-&50-.%''"'& % ! %# % !'1 & ' "

+ 789 4226 & 4226-"'#'''''&'+42-222F" 0%0'+ % !'"& '%## 1"& / % 0!!/- "$% ! <$# !5"0' (("+ 9+ ##1 &"

$11#"0" '-" /-!&"'1'&-00!&"

$#/+ 8+

%0'1!1!/-" /-(/&#."%'1!%!

#'+ 3+ 0!&'% !#.' 0G+ 42+ 1%01/ %"'

&$( #' 1#0& % "# 0

0&0'+

P a g e | 15 > ++ = ?

> ++ = ?

> ++ = ? > ++=<?

> ++=<?

> ++=<? 4+24+4247 4+24+4247 4+24+4247 4+24+4247 =%%!!' &F'1G"

$ *'F ("! =%%!!1!# *'F