High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/367/2004dismissed

Raju v. State Of Haryana

2017-10-26Mr. Justice S.J. Vazifdar,Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri10 pages

Sumit Gulati 2017.11.06 11:53 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document chandigarh

" "

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

#$%

$& '!( ) ')** $%

+ ! !

,+ #

,./. 0 0 ,+ # 123 4 0

0 04#

46 !

.9:.#. *

4:7

' 5*

( !+ !

% !

!+ %

% ! +

* *!

! !

+ - * .# $%

.:!

.0 !

!.A

'(-$3&,+,5.(-$&359$,(&($2$'(&.502&% =>7?

/&($/*'/$0$;(+5'6 &( B%&'&+,(0+;(+,&0 :&,0$1+,($0$/"+2%&:$'((5(-$,#5('C*$,(0$#50(=>? :&,#0$#&0$/-$B'+.$=>?%4+'1+'(-$9$0&'&-:&,%+.($/.052(-$ ,#5(&'/:&,(&B$'+'(5#5,,$,,+5'9+/$0$;59$042$25> 7%55/ ,(&+',:$0$%+.($/.052(-$,#5(:+(-(-$-$%#5.;5((5',:&3&'/:$0$

8 (&B$' +'(5 #5,,$,,+5' 9+/$0$;59$042$25 > 5*1- ,+($ #%&'

=>D? :&, #0$#&0$/ +/$ &##%+;&(+5' =>? #5,( 250($2 $>&2+'&(+5'5./$;$&,$/ &) *2&0+$9+:&,15(;5'/*;($/340 +'$,- *2&0"%55/,(&+'$/;%5(-$,5.(-$/$;$&,$/:$0$(&B$' +'(5#5,,$,,+5'9+/$0$;59$042$25> !

=>?5.(-$&;;*,$/ :&,;5%%$;($/.0520'&'( &2&'(&5,#+(&%##%+;&(+5'=>?

:&,259$/(5(-$!$/+;&% ..+;$00$1&0/+'1-+,.+('$,,(50$;50/-+, ,(&($2$'(3*(9+/$5#+'+5'=>7?0*3-&,-$(-+/$;%&0$/(-$ &;;*,$/*'.+((52&B$&,(&($2$'(%55/,(&+'$/;%5(-$,5.(-$&;;*,$/ :$0$(&B$'+'(5#5,,$,,+5'9+/$0$;59$042$25> ' "+2%&&00$,($/(-$&;;*,$/5'-+,/+,;-&01$.052(-$-5,#+(&% .($0;52#%$(+5'5.+'9$,(+&(+5'0$#50(*'/$0,$;(+5'6

0 :&,,*32+(($/;;*,$/:&,;-&01$,-$$($/.50(-$5..$';$*'/$0 $;(+5'6&'/6< 34%$&0'$/(0+&% 5*0((5:-+;--$#%$&/$/'5( 1*+%(4&'/;%&+2$/(0+&% -$ #05,$;*(+5' +' ,*##50( 5. +(, ;&,$ $>&2+'$/ :+('$,,$, -$&;;*,$/,$(*#&#%$&+'-+,,(&($2$'(*'/$0$;(+5'66

0 (-&(-$:&,+''5;$'(3*(&.&%,$;&,$-&,3$$'.5+,($/5'-+2 -$(0+&% 5*0(-&9+'10$%+$/*#5'(-$,(&($2$'(,*..$0$/34 "E$$%&2+'(-$3&;B105*'/5.2$/+;&%$9+/$';$5'0$;50/0$;50/$/ ;5'9+;(+5'&1&+',((-$&;;*,$/ $';$(-$#0$,$'(&##$&% <

$&0'$/ ;5*',$% .50 (-$ &##$%%&'( ;5'($'/$/ (-&( (-$

E 5;;*00$';$:&,'5(#0$2$/+(&($/&'/0&(-$0(-$,&2$-&##$'$/+',#*0 5.&252$'(&/(-$0$3$$'&'4+'($'(+5'(5B+%% &) *2&0$9+-$ :5*%/'5(-&9$;-5,$'(-$(+2$&'/#%&;$:-+;-:5*%/15&1&+',(-+2( :&,5'%4+'&.+(5.0&1$&'/-$&%,5+'.%+;($/+')*0+$,5'-+,#$0,5'(55

$&0'$/;5*',$%.*0(-$0,*32+(($/(-&(B$$#+'1+'9+$:(-$&.50$,&+/ ;+0;*2,(&';$,(-$5..$';$&%%$1$/&1&+',((-$&##$%%&'(+,'5(2&/$5*(

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

$0$'(-5*,$, '&(<6&2:-+%$,-$:&,#0$,$'(+'(-$ -5*,$&1&+'&C*&00$%$',*$/3$(:$$'(-$/$;$&,$/&'/(-$;5'9+;(&'/ -$305*1-(&B'+.$.052(-$0552&'/;&*,$/+')*0+$,5'(-$'$;B&,:$%% &,5'(-$&3/52$'5.(-$/$;$&,$/"-+%$/$;$&,$/ &) *2&0+-&9+'1 .0$$/-$0,$%..052(-$;%*(;-$,5.(-$&;;*,$/(0+$/(50&'&:&4(5:&0/, (-$1&($3*(,-$.$%%/5:'&'//+$/ -$0$&.($0(-$&;;*,$/+'.

+')*0+$,(5-+2,$%.&%,5:+(-(-$,&+/B'+.$$0305(-$0 &2&% +,-50$ :&,;&%%$/.052(-$,;-55%&'/-$&%5'1:+(-'$+1-35*0,0$259$/(-$ &;;*,$/(5-5,#+(&% 6 "0+'$,- *2&0 +):&'+!$/+;&% ..+;$0 $'$0&% 5,#+(&%+,&0;5'/*;($/(-$#5,(250($2$>&2+'&(+5'=> ?5'(-$ /$&/ 35/4 5. &) *2&0+ 5' F &'/ .5*'/ (-$ .5%%5:+'1 +')*0+$, @.

8 *

! !

<9 5.

!+%

0 ! * !0!.6 *

!!!0.6

.6 * ! .

5.8 !

***

8 *

! ! !

<=5 ! %

9 !. . > . 6 *

!0. 6

.6 * !

* *

* 5 %%

.8 .

! *

!0.A "5#+'$/(-&((-$/$&(-:&,;&*,$//*$(5$>;$,,+9$3%$$/+'1&'/ ,-5;B/*$(5+')*0+$,/$,;0+3$/&359$:-+;-:$0$&'($250($2+''&(*0$ &'/:$0$,*..+;+$'((5;&*,$/$&(-+'(-$50/+'&04;5*0,$5.'&(*0$"

&%,55#+'$/(-&((-$+')*0+$,/$,;0+3$/&359$:$0$#5,,+3%$:+(-B'+.$ 8 " 0*3-&,- -&02& $'$0&% *01$5''&'( &2 &'(& 5,#+(&% &0:&%& 2$/+;5%$1&%%4 $>&2+'$/ (-$ &;;*,$/ 5' &(&35*(E&2&'/.5*'/(-$.5%%5:+'1+')*0+$,5'-+, #$0,5' @.

8 * *

0! .

:0!*!

* ?*

'2=! 0!@! 7 *.

5* !* !

7 &7 *(.8

: 0!

*! 0 5*

5! 5A! 5.B! .

: *0!*!

00 5*

! 0!!

5A! 5A! A "5#+'$/(-&((-$/*0&(+5'5.+')*0+$,:&,:+(-+'-5*0,-$:$&#5' :&,,-&0#-+,:+('$,,.*0(-$05#+'$/(-&((-$&.50$,&+/+')*0+$,:$0$ #5,,+3%$:+(- (-$(+# 5.B'+.$&'/;5*%/3$,$%.,*..$0$/3$;&*,$5. ,*+;+/&%($'/$';4&'/:$0$,+2#%$+''&(*0$ E -$ 0$#50(>:5*%/15(5.*0(-$0$,(&3%+,-(-&((-$

F B'+.$*,$/&,:$&#5'5.5..$';$:&,.5*'/,(&+'$/:+(--*2&'3%55/5. 105*#&'/(-$;%5(-$,5.(-$/$;$&,$/&,:$%%&,5.(-$&;;*,$/:$0$ &%,5 .5*'/ :+(- -*2&' 3%55/ 5. 105*# 9+/$ ,$05%51+;&% 0$#50( >7 '5(-$0:50/,(-$3%55/,(&+',.5*'/5'(-$B'+.$ 2&(;-$/ :+(-(-$3%55/105*#.5*'/5'(-$;%5(-$,5.(-$/$;$&,$/ "8!$:&+'1-',#$;(5055/G*##%4$#&0(2$'(

B%&'& (-05*1- -+, /$#5,+(+5' #05/*;$/ (-$ &(+5' &0/ =>?

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

5. (-$&;;*,$/&##$%%&'( ' &##%+;&(+5' > :+(- 0$1&0/ (5

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

+02+'1(-$;5'9+;(+5'&'/,$'($';$ #&,,$/34(-$(0+&% 5*0((-$&##$&%,(&'/,/+,2+,,$/ 6 ##$%%&'( &)* &+%&,-+,5'3&+%+,3&+%35'/,(&'/, ;&';$%%$/$,-&%%,*00$'/$0.50(-:+(-3$.50$(-$%$&0'$/ -+$.*/+;+&% !&1+,(0&($+,&0:-5,-&%%,$'/-+2(5)&+%(5*'/$015(-$0$2&+'+'1 #&0(5.(-$,$'($';$.-$.&+%,(5,*00$'/$0(-$%$&0'$/ -+$.*/+;+&% !&1+,(0&($+,&0,-&%%(&B$;5$0;+9$,($#,(5,$;*0$-+,#0$,$';$&'/,$'/ -+2(5)&+%(5*'/$015(-$0$2&+'+'1#&0(5.(-$,$'($';$ !

;(53$0 *%&(+ "-$(-$0 $#50(&3%$ $, "-$(-$0#$&B+'17 $&,5'$/ $,