High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/380/2004dismissed

Om Beer v. U.T. Chandigarh

2025-05-01Mr. Justice Gurvinder Singh Gill,Mr. Justice Jasjit Singh Bedi14 pages

!"# $%

& & '

() $* !$%$+%,-%) &'& '

. / &

0 1 0 // . / &

0

0 0

!

!"#$

! #$

#$

%

&

&

%" #$

'''''

0 0 2

&

( )"

#$

$

*+,--.*--/ (0

1"

*

23 ( ,--4*---

$$"5

$ ($ #$ #)"

$ #$

$

*+,--.*--/

)"

$ #$

$& *+-,*--/

$"

&

*60

23

, $$ $

1" 7*+. "

)# 0 $ ,8 9: ;

& 0"

( 7

<# ("

.-.. *+-4*---( $$"

( 5

&

! %" $

( 0 00&"

" $ ="(

0

#

&

!

!( $$" !"$

3

&

$ ( $$"

(

"$! !

( & (0

!

$0

! ( !

( $$"(" ! > " (0

(0 "

!

)"

!

&

($ "

$"

"

(" )"

(

"

(0(0

?

"

!&

( &$

0?

$(0 "# 1"$

3

,--4*---

("

@--

A3"

.8-@*---

0(

$$"

)""

(0 (

"

$ ,-*,-@3 &

$$"$

$"

& )" (0

!

)"0 & $

#"

"(="

0 &

" <" #

& $

$$"("

$$

$$

&

(

$ &

$

&

2 $$ $B (

0$$

?

$

&

$# 2B $# $ 0

$ $ 0 #

$$"& $

"

$ ,-*,-@3 / $

$$" & $ "

$ ,-*,-@3 > "

0

$

6 $"

?

.4 $"

&

#

&

"

:5.<

$ "$ ?

(0 $ 5

0 $

(

"# 13

"

(" )" ="

& (& "!

?

$ "

& (C $ D "

/4E $("

( &

)"& .8 0

& .*"

:5@

<# $

*+,--4*---

("

+-- (5 $$"$ "

"

$

("

#

" 5

9$ ;

$

& ( 5

&

!%" (

(

&

" 5

>

# ( & ( 5

&&

$"> "! " 5

(0$

&

(

"

!

A3

3 $5 ?

$$"&

& (

$ ! ( 5

&

! %" A3 &

$$

(0 "

&

A3 $ "

" $

"$(0

:58% 0 $

$ $

2B$ ,4

$ ! " ? 5*("

$"

( $ ? 5. 5,

5/

:5+< #!

A3 9 $0;

,--4*---& &

A3

0

0

&"!&

(" 3%"

#

$

? A ( &$ $

!

@-613 "# =" ? >

#

? >.

$

!

( &$ ? 5.4& $ ="

&

"

? 5.@ $

$(0

& #

($$ 0

!%" &

3 %"

"(

$

? 1 &$ #

? 1.& $

!

:5.-< ""

.8-@*---

*/-

&&

,--4*---? >

" 0

:5.,<"

,--4*---?

!%"

"

& )"

" )"0& $

#"

$ ,--4*--- =" 3 $5?

B:

$"

($ "(0 (

& ("

$"

($ ""

" $

:5./ "# 1"$

3

,--4*---

$

"(

(03 %"

& & $ "

$

? >*& $

&

!%" "

$ .4/ > $

A3 $

( <#!

&$

$

? 5.43 $5

?

! &=" "

& !

$

$$!

!

& ("

:5.63%"

# *+,--4*--- $ & $ A3

#

$

? A ( &$ $ "

0#

A.$

!

$ !

$

$

$

!%" !

&" # $ $

"# 13

& $

$

$ <" $" #

"

!

("

$

0

$(?

0

$$

(

(& "$(0 :5! >$ &

$

$ A3$

<# $

7

$ $ $ " #

"

$ .@, &

:5.4

!%" " #

,--4*---& & "

0& ( 5

&( "$!

" &$ ($ "

$"

& $ $" &

3 $5?

&

&

5$

:5*3

!

:5,>

) :5/

( > ) :56

( <

( :5 4>

) :5..31

:5.*

( F

&$&

$ #

4

$$"& $"

$ ,., &

$ $ @ & $"

&

0 !

) %" &# " # ( & #(0 $$" &

&?

(0 $$" $<:5.!

(

&

< " ) 0>

( 5

&(

0

! 0 "

& )" #$ & (" (0(

!&

A3

&

>

$ "

& &

! &

!

"

! (0

!

( # # $

$$

$5(?&$# $ ("

$ $

$

&

!

& "(

0 &

#

"

) 0%" <:5*

="

("

.---..-- *+-4*---&

$ $$" $(

!&="

!& 0

"

$"$ >

"

$0 0 (0

!

&

"

.6 $ "

(" $ > 9<:5*; "

(

(0 ?

" 8 # $ $$"5

0 ($ ($ #$

$(0 "

1"

# )"

$ #$

$

*+,--.*--/ "

**%, 30 0%)%,

4% % #*(+5) $* 6(7-%) $* *4% ,-*3

3B3

6---5 $

3-.0 +

)"

$ #$

$

*+,--.*--/ (0

1"

"

$

( " .- <" $0

$

$$"5

(& " (0 " #

-6-/*--@

.. $"

$$"5

$

=" "

5$ & "$

(

&

0 $

0 ($ " & $"

& ( !$"

"

&

0 3 $ & "

(

"&

#

<#9 :5@; $ 5

"(

&

# "$

0 $

( $$

"

$

$

$(0

13 &

$ :5@

<#

)"0& $ & !

(0( (0

!%" & :5@

<#

!%" $# )"(0 & (0(

(

"

(0(0

<#9 :5@; "

<#

(

"

(0

(0$

&

(

"

(0

(0) 0%" & ( ?

$&

$

!%"

)"50&

"

! &

) 0%" &&$ $"

&

"

$ 3 "$

<#9 :5@;$"

(( # " $

$ &

(0 $$"&$&"

# $

$ $

(

$

$

"$

" )"

( ( .* $"

5

0 $

( :5./ " 13 $

( ( # " $

$

$ ( &

$

<# :5@;

$

# $ $ $

$ $

$ & !

#

0 $

"

! %" ( 5

& ( & & #

$

& $ ($ "&$ $& $

> "$

( ( ., : # $"

" $ ./

5$ $"

"&

# $"

# $&

<#9 :5@; $ 5

( (0"(

"$ $$" $3 $$"

$

( (0

$$"

$

(

0

="

$ $$ 0

=" "

# &

" /4E (" )" #

(0 $

$

"$ $

!%"

$

(

"

$

!%" $

$ $"

02 $

$

!

,.6

& $

!

@-6

@/- .6 $

:5+<#!

#

#0

$

0($ "<#!

$$

0

&

0"

(

( # ( 2" :5./ " 13

$ 0

! &=" "

( !

"

(#

"

0" (0 $ 3 $$"

$& # "( &

#

&

0 "

$

$ .4 $

$

(# "$

$

"( $ :$

$

$ "/4E(" )"

&

$ &

# "

( &

!%" $ ( )"&"

$

"(

"(

.@

!%" 5 )" "

!

) 0 %" $"

&

$ &

(0 #

! "

$(

& 0

"

$(

"

$(

(0

:5@

<#!

) 0%"

$$$" $ (0

0( "

!

$ ( &

" $ #

& ="

0

="

0# $

#

.8 " $

$

$

$

$ &"

"

0

& ( #

3 #

$ "$ (0"

(

$

$ $ ("

$$"3 " ?

& "$

#

&

3

$ $" (# 0 $

5$ :5@

<#$

(( # .+ # $ $$" $

!%" &

A3 &$&

(0( $$"

$ # $

A3

$ "

$$"&"

#

$

$

$$

( $$ ( (

$

("

$

$

$

!

#$

# $ =" $3 $$"

$

$$" ( ( 0 !

$

*- "

(# $" ( #

$"

&

$"

0

:5@

<# 0 $

$

$ ?

$ $"

&

# (" " # $$" $

&

$

($ 0($ "

!%" "

!

) 0%" " $

&?

$&

$# ( # (

$

"$ ($ " ( $ !

)"0

!& & #

$

&

"&

# & "(

02 # $

$

# ( &

!

!%" ( 5

&(

"$$$"

$ ( 0$

("

"

( " !

"$ " ( )$ (0 $ *. #&

$" &

"

0

( # $

$$"5

$ " ( 1 "

$ & #"

$ **

$

0

$$ 0

1 0 //

0 0 &'& '

"! : !

F7 :

(

F7