Sunder Kumar Yadav v. Mahindra And Mahindra Finance India Ltd And Another




 

 
  

!"# $#%&'&() 

* +,($#-.,/!- !$!0  #"&"&(#- 0#-','

!1&($-!!($!1&($-!&(!(%#($&!2&/&"#$!($"1#-'  #'3($#("'

 ) 4 2+
 2  + -#'#(") -!-,( !$!05 $0%!"#5 - -,6#'1 !$!05 $0%!"#5

-"1#3#"&"&(#- -&"&(1!"!&5 $0%!"#5

--#'3($#("(  - /&"1!(7&5 $0%!"#5 !'
 



2  +5-!8 1,91 -,6#'1 !$!058#!-(#$%,('#8 -"1#3#"&"&(#-5 !33#!-#$("1#3-#0&,'$!"#51#&'("3-#'#(""$!:!($-!-,( !$!05

$0%!"#5!33#!-' -1&/

- /&"1!(7&5 $0%!"#51!0&(9;##(-#<,#'"#$0&$#!(-$#- $!"#$

 

"!''&'""1&'
,-"!'
 

&("1#/!""#-5=1#-# "1#3#"&"&(#-1!'%1!88#(9#$"1#-$#- "1#8#!-(#$ $$&"&(!8&'"-&%"

,$9#5  !-(!,85  $!"#$ 

5  !%%#3"&(9  "1#  !338&%!"&(  &8#$  ;:

-#'3($#("( 1#-#&(,($#--$#->,8# 

53&("'""1#7,$9/#("'  "1#+,3-#/#
,-"5 &-'"8:&(  1!-!" 8,/&(&,/
/3!(:0'.!&'#-

8,/&(&,/  #%1(&%!8  +#-0&%#'  (%5  

  *  +

  
('"&","&(

#(%15!'!8'&(?'+=!'"&%!'#'2&/&"#$0'($&!(&8
-3-!"&( 2&/&"#$5

*+

 !($($,';&8#&'"-&;,"&(-&0!"#2&/&"#$

0'!"!=&($((0!"&('-&0!"#2&/&"#$!($"1#-'

>>+

> 1#7,$9/#("'3-&-""1#8!'"(#!-#(";#&(9-# #--#$"&( $#"!&8;:"1&'
,-"5"1#8!'"7,$9/#("%&"#$1#-#&(!;0#1!0&(9-# #--#$" "1#
('"&","&( #(%17,$9/#("&(  1!-!" 8,/&(&,/
/3!(:'4%!'# ',3-!5!($#0#(",!88:1!0&(91#8$!' 88=')@   1#  !/#($#$  %"5  $#'  ("5  1=#0#-5  %("!&(  "1# !

-#'!&$  !/#($/#("'5  3-#',/!;8:  ;#%!,'#  "1# 

2
 7,$9/#("  &(  (  ,(%#-"!&(  "#-/'  1!'  -# #--#$  "  A38!%#B !'

A7,-&$&%!8'#!"B -"1#3,-3'# +#%"&(   "1# %""

,-"1#-/!$#&"%8#!-"1!"+#%"&(

 !($

 =1#-#"1# =-$A38!%#B&','#$5-# #-'"A7,-&$&%!8'#!"B5=1#-#!'&( +#%"&(

5"1#=-$A38!%#B&'#<,&0!8#(""A0#(,#B1&' ;#&(9"1#'#""8#$8!=5&"=!' ,($,((#%#''!-:"#C3-#''8:

&(%-3-!"#=1!""1#
('"&","&( #(%1 "1#+,3-#/#
,-"

1!'!8-#!$:$(#;:=!: %('"-,%"&( "1# %" * %('3#%",' !88"1#!

-#'!&$3-0&'&(''1='"1!""1# //#("  "1#  '#!"  &'  $#'&9(!"#$5  &"  &'  !6&(  "  !(  #C%8,'&0# 7,-&'$&%"&(%8!,'#("1# !%"' "1#3-#'#("%!'#5&"&'%8#!- "1!""1#'#!" !-;&"-!"&(&',/;!&!($
8!,'# * ,-"1#- /!6#'&"%8#!-"1!"7,-&'$&%"&(#C%8,'&0#8:0#'"'&("1#,/;!& %,-"'($#-"1#2!= -;&"-!"&(5,(8&6#"1#
$# 
&0&8 -%#$,-#=1&%1!338&#'"',&"' &8#$&(%,-"'5!-# #-#(%#" A'#!"B&'!%(%#3";:=1&%1!(#,"-!80#(,#%!(;#%1'#(;: "1#3!-"&#'"!(!-;&"-!"&(%8!,'#1#(#,"-!80#(,#/!:(" &("1#%8!''&%!8'#('#1!0#7,-&'$&%"&(D"1!"&'5(3!-" "1#

 %!,'#  !%"&(  /!:1!0# !-&'#( !"  "1# (#,"-!8  0#(,# !($ (#&"1#-=,8$!(: "1#3-0&'&(' +#%"&(' "  "1#

;#!""-!%"#$(!-;&"-!"&(8!=1=#0#-5!'1!';##(1#8$ !;0#5"1#//#("A'#!"B&'$#"#-/&(#$5"1# !%""1!""1#'#!"&'

!"  ,/;!&  =,8$  0#'"  ,/;!&  %,-"'  =&"1  #C%8,'&0# 7,-&'$&%"&(  -  3,-3'#'    -#9,8!"&(9  !-;&"-!8  3-%##$&(9'

!-&'&(9," "1#!9-##/#(";#"=##("1#3!-"&#'

 "  &'  =#88 '#""8#$  "1!"  =1#-#  /-# "1!(  (# %,-"  1!' 7,-&'$&%"&(5&"&'3#( -"1#3!-"&#'"#C%8,$#!88"1#-%,-"' -!(#C1!,'"&0#!(!8:'&' "1#%!'#8!=5'##+=!'"&6!'#'

2"$0($&!(&8
-3-!"&(2"$1&'=!' 88=#$&(!

-#%#("7,$9/#("&( +&/#'#E(+"!-!;,-9&#$#("1!80
11!""&'9!-1(0#'"/#("2"$!0&(9-#9!-$""1#!;0#5&"&' %8#!-  "1!"  ,/;!&  %,-"'  !8(#  1!0#  7,-&'$&%"&(  "  "1# #C%8,'&( !88"1#-%,-"'&("1#%,("-:5!'"1#7,-&$&%!8'#!"  !-;&"-!"&(&'!",/;!&1&';#&(9"1#%!'#5"1#&/3,9(#$ 7,$9/#("  &'  '#"  !'&$#  1#  &(7,(%"&(  %( &-/#$  ;:  "1# &/3,9(#$7,$9/#("=&88%("&(,# -!3#-&$ ,-=##6'

-/"1#$!"# 3-(,(%#/#(" "1&'7,$9/#("5'"1!""1# -#'3($#("'/!:"!6#(#%#''!-:'"#3',($#- +#%"&(* &("1# ,/;!&
,-"1#!33#!8'!-#$&'3'#$ !%%-$&(98:B

3#-,'!8 "1#-$#-&/3,9(#$&("1#3-#'#("3#"&"&('1=' "1!""1#8#!-(#$ $$&"&(!8&'"-&%",$9#1!'1#8$"1!"!'"1# -;&"-!8 =!-$ !'=!'%1!88#(9#$&(3-%##$&(9',($#-+#%"&(F "1# -;&"-!"&(!($
(%&8&!"&(  %"5  **5  ;# -#  "1!"  %,-"  !"  !-(!,85  =!'  3!''#$  !"

,/;!&5!($"1#-# -#&("#-/' "1#7,$9/#(" "1#+,3-#/#
,-"&(5 ?'  1!($!-&  $:9  2&/&"#$  0'  ($,'"-&!8  !%&8&"!"&( 
,(%&8  !($ !("1#-5

 F+

 5&"&'(8:"1#%,-"'!",/;!&!'=,8$1!0# 7,-&'$&%"&( -!(:%1!88#(9#""1# =!-$G!($%('#<,#("8:5"1#
,-"!"

!-(!,81!'(7,-&'$&%"&("#("#-"!&("1#'!/# 

""1#"&/#=1#("1&'3#"&"&(1!$&(&"&!88:%/#,3 -1#!-&(95 "1&'
,-"1!$#C3-#''#$!    3&(&("1!"=&"1;7#%"&(',($#- +#%"&(F1!0&(9";# &8#$!"!38!%#=1#-#"1# =!-$=!'!((,(%#$5&"

%,8$  !%",!88:  !/,("  "  !  "-!0#'":    7,'"&%#  ;#%!,'#  8!-9#  &(!(%# %/3!(&#'!-# "#('&",!"#$!"0#-:9-#!"$&'"!(%#' -/"1#-#'&$#(%# !

3#-'("=1//(#:1!$;##(8!(#$;:"1#/5!'&("1#3-#'#("%!'#5 =1#-#"1#-#'3($#("%/3!(:8!(#$!',/ !;,"'F5 5

?@""1# 3#"&"&(#- -"1#3,-%1!'# !"-!%"-5=1-#'&$#'!"!0&88!9#&($&'"-&%" 1&($#-9!-1&(!-:!(!5!($"1#-# -#&"=,8$;#0&-",!88:&/3''&;8# - "1#8!(##"$# #($1&/'#8 ;# -#!( -;&"-!"-&(,/;!&-#0#( &8# ;7#%"&('!"!%,-""1#-# #"5"1#-!"& "1#7,$9/#("'!

-#'!&$;#&(9" "1##

#%""1!"(%#7,-&'$&%"&(1!';##('3#%& &%!88:3-0&$#$ -!"!

3!-"&%,8!-38!%#&("1#8!(!9-##/#("&"'#8 57,-&'$&%"&( !88"1#-%,-"'5 &(%8,$&(9!"38!%#'=1#-#"1#%!,'# !%"&(/!:1!0#3!-"8:-=188:

!-&'#(5=,8$;#;!--#$5"1#-#=,8$;#(9-,($ -"1&'
,-""&("#- #-# =&"1"1#&/3,9(#$-$#-5=&"1&" %,-'#!8'";#;'#-0#$"1!"#0#( "1,91"1# &(#3-&("&(!(:!9-##/#("&'0#-:-!-#8:-#!$;:#0#( ,88:

#$,%!"#$3#-'('=1#("1#:;"!&(!8!( -/!;!(6?

&(!(%#%/3!(:5 !($&("1#3-#'#("%!'#'&(%#"1#3#"&"&(#-&''"!"#$";#!-#'&$#(" !

0&88!9#51#3''&;8:$#'(",($#-'"!($"1#(98&'18!(9,!9#0#-:=#885"1#

!%"-#/!&('"1!"1#1!$#("#-#$&("!(!9-##/#("=&"1"1#-#'3($#(" %/3!(: F
('#<,#("8:5 &($&(9(9-,($"&("#- #-#=&"1"1#&/3,9(#$ -$#-5"1&'3#"&"&(&'$&'/&''#$5=&"1"1&'
,-"#C3-#''&(9&"'!33-#%&!"&(

-"1#0#-:!;8#!''&'"!(%#-#($#-#$;:- /&"1!(7& 

* 












 36?$&(#'1

























  H1#"1#-'3#!6&(9?-#!'(#$

#'? H1#"1#-#3-"!;8#

#'?