High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1028/2007dismissed

Chhota Singh v. State Of Haryana

2022-09-09Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan12 pages

""## $%& '%( " )%

%* +(,- % ""## %$. %*,#+,'%( //// ""## 0& ! 1 % 2( #% # 3&!, 4 2 45 6 7 % & % 7 6% %&! )( %"&2 , 7 % %%%%8 , )# %,9 -.&!* :; , 1 -% %1 12< %*%% -%(, 1 & %!%!%&*"% * % (% "( ,,0 &# % &% %& %!*"#*"% * %"% (%

%#(, ,"% "%&

-% % 7,5.2% ! ,5 %!"#, 9 % % %%% 5 -! ! %05 *" 2( % "# # 1 %& "%## ! < !%*&(,! !1%-##!4 "&% 1

"#"%(% 2& -##!4 "&%, .2 ! ,=>%" +&%2 ! ,% -##!4 "&% *? 1. 1 "#"%( * 1 #5 %-% %* ! *@#,% 4 "&%1 &#! ! ## !"""( &< 2 & #" # *# -##! %1 &, &#2""% ?& 5 "%"% % !"%(,. !.2 ! ,=>%" %1 "% 1% #"#?1 % !"%( % % 2 A % , &1 ! 2! - ! ?

! "#"%(, &&" %1#< !1( 2%<#(? 1""% 2&" * %"%&#%1% B&%2&,1 #? %1&% 2! " ;

9 5 &" 2! * , %% 5 %- & % 7 =>)=&" & &" 2! "

* , 1 % * & %, % &#2 & "% !%% !C%? &"& &*2*"% %" =>)4, &% % 2! &

"% !C%,& 5 %B& ! , ) %&! *2#" * "?%** ! ,)# !1 %%- %? 5 ""% *2& ? %& ),

% !&

(2!,1 1%& """( &<? &&# "%& (# %"%*%" ? 5 <*"#!%* %* &% !&

(2!, -% ! "%#,1 % %* !"""( &< !&

(2!*&2;D <!? 2! %&"""( &<1%# -% "%#? *"#"%# 1## 2&#<"%#1%#2( 5 1 #2% *"% 8 8?) ! #"& # - ! %"

8 ## "%#?*"##*"% 1%< ?

) ! <" #1 *#,1 % 5 %& -% #5* .? %"%"%(1 < "#" -%-%(** 9 5 -! ! % %&B =>)5 "# , 2%*#45=>)31%%&1 % !#( %% "% %&#, "%"% ! %B& &* 9 5 -! ! %"%"%%&! "# "# %-%(=>)A %%* 1

%&% "# , 5 -! ! % "%& &# !1 "%"%( 1 2% 5 *"# ! , '

)# %, 9 , 1 -% # "%"%( 1 # - %" 8)89 %%, %& 5 " "%"%(1 ' #! & #<&" '"& %* =>) %"%2(5 =>) &% ! &% -! , *"#"%#1%

4@,'%( &2 "%%"%=>)@ %- %%*, 1%& 2"""(%1 %) )"-%* %&*@ % *"# -! % %*#, ## ! &1"%"% # &%3, 9 :

"% ## &%#% 3, 9 , &""#"&* %#&" ## &%"%-& % %) 9 ! & % 7 >#&-#( %2# 2( &% , #% 3, 9 ** &%#% # 3&! 5, 4 2

%" &%, #% # 3&!, 4 2, 2%- ! "%* %! %

& % 7 1#! & %! *% !#(,1 , "# !&#( #*%# &% ! &%- , "%& >* ##1 !1

)E 2#)%< " D7 1 # 11%< !%),9 , (, %-%"%=>) - ! %* =>) "&&" %"%2%),9 ,1 %! ! %&! *"& !

&% % )

)E ' % ! , %*# 1 %

- -=>) 7, 1 "')# %,9 15 %! #< ? (,5.2% ! ,5 %!,"#,9 " "%"%(&#(#1 * -% *"#"%# 2# % ! %" !

4@, &2 ,'%( -6D77? 2# % ! % !#( -%%" * # ! "%"%(%* " , *"% %1 < "# )E; 2# % ! , %%% *"# "%# &*2% !&%4@, &2 ,'%( - - =>) %"&%*"#"%#&#(%-2( *%*' % ! , " 4@, &2 ,'%( %&% -%%"' % ! # ! "%"%(%* &(,

*"% ! %1 < "# )ED5$% ! 7D71 # 1 "'

,)%,9 , *"# -! , "%"% ## ,1 1 # &% )E75* .,1 1**2% "#"%(, 1 ""% & %-%( %* *," %!% )E:) ! , 1 %& 5 % &%2!& " &,1 1%

!"""( &<," %!% )E 5*"#,1 1 #")# %, 9 %!%%*#45 %"%&B 2(5.2% ! 2%1 *5.2% ! "%& "%"%( # !1 1 & 1 !'

"# "%!% ! "% %%2- %#% "% .&!* # )E 5.2% ! ,1 1 ! "#"%(, 1 ""% & %-%(%* * & %&"%- ) ! ," %" 9 )&2#)%&% % - %"% 4@,'%( , &2 =>)@ # "%& - * &1%%& % ;;

%), 1 ## %* !%&* "%&

- ""% !! &1%"& *2& ##! ! 1

%-%(1 %* * 2 ##( -#- &% ! - , &>* .2 ! ,1 2 ##!#(. " 1 2( "#"%( 1 "% %-%(1#(, E'1-%, %" -##!4 "&%

7, &1 =>%" -##!' 7, -%. % !"%("# 2( 5 .2% ! &% % %-%( 1 %* & ! "% ? "# 2 !

*""% )# %,9 &&##(- "# %!% !"& -##!' ! -% &#! ## !"""(%1 % % !%!&* ,#% %#&% - &* 2-,1 # *!!%- # "% ""#,1 1< &"

,1 1*%%!&#% % ! %-%( 1(&% " ( ""#

""# & % ;

%) - !2 #2( ""## 0&%&" *"% * &% ! " (""#, *1##1 -%%:

%* ! ""## 1 &" &% ! " ( ""# 1*2# &% !2 , #% 30&(!%, 4 2 ;

61 ""# *&"% # % ! D 5 - %#% & #% ""## F& -,#% #-+ %#% '%( 2 ! ! %&! %% 7 '% 1 %-%( *#()E75* ., )E:) ! )E 5.2% ! -&##(&""% "%& %( 1 %!% & - ! 2 &

&" 9 (1%%>* # ! 2 # &2& (&< %!& &# 2 % (*%#" 6"%-& *(21 * &F - 2 ##!%"%-"%*"2(1 (

*! - -#- & 1% !#( "! *##(&% - 9 & !- 2( )E *&21% (%# :

4%* * )E' % ! ,)E;

2# % ! , &#("%- "%"%( %* &( *"# "%# % 4@, '%( , &2 , "%%*4@=>)@# ! 1 1 *"#"%# % % #1% ##1 "* #"%%1% & %(#% #(, *"#1%& 2 """(%1 %)

@% & #% ""## 1-%< *"&!

.&!* -%&!%& 9 %&2* *2( * %!%1 %!%%" * #1 , *#(,)E75* .,)E:) )E 5.2% ! 1 %!%*1 "#"%( 2%- &? *1 ) %%- "? * " 2( "#"%( " *%&% "#"%( # !1 & "%"%("# &% % %!% ! "#%-%(%* "# ># "#%-%(% ! #% & #% ""## ,& %" *< "%& %( &2&# '1-%,5* - 2( &2* 5 2 <" * %-%( < "# 7,1 %

* 1 %-%(1%%%% %2# * %5* . ;7,%"% * ,) ! 5.2% ! :,% "%*% (%1* % % %* ! %*% %2& &%& % "1%"%" ,2%- % - -%&"% #&#"**%( & "! *

9 > "&%1%2(#% & #% ""## 1 " 1 -2 . 1 "#"%(, *#(,.2 ! ,=>%" 1 >* 2( "%& ,% % ""%1 - . "#"%(% (%-%( - !2 %* & "% ,1 %%& "%&

%( & ! % 2# &2 * 2& %& &# 9 %%, 2 &2 &# 2 !- & %-2B& %!%*! * ! 5* *"%2( 5 2<" * * (* &* 2 !! #& 2(-%& % #< # "%>*( 1 "% , & , % #< , % %#! % #< "% , &2# ! ! *-##!%1 ,1 *< * "< %& % %"% !1% !-% #" &%#( 2& " 1 &""% "%& %(, "%& %( !-%#(

% % #%(2%-, #1 - (*- -#- & 1% !#(% "! *&% - 9 % ! %% 1 & # 1 %-%( >* 2( "%& ("%-&%#1 &9 %%, % * % 2 < "% 1 " 1 " 1 1 ! # (1% "%& , "

2< 2!"#%& % -#&* & %* ! - & 2( "%& 2 %#1##&* %(,1 & 2 ! , - ! %#2# !# &% .&!*

!" # #"

$% & '

()

* 2%- * # 1 %%( * - %(-#& ( %1 %*

2%*"#( & %#!

- &% +

, !" # #"

$% & '

(

*1 " 1 2 . &% ! % %-%( ' ""%1 % ! !

&%1% "%&% 2# < ""% 1 - "#

%& < , 2%- & 1 "2# # !

22#- &*%&!

&% -%& ""% - !% 1% *%#&#2!

2(1

2# <""%9 * ( 1 1 #2& %#2# 1 % 5 -%( .&!* , %2#( #0"#

1 1 % 12%- 1 % ##! ( *(! "####(*"# ""## %1 % % *"! ""## , %#&% %! #( #& >* " 1 % %-%( 2 ! 1 -% 2( & % (&2 "%& @% & # % ""## &% % "% ) "&2&#,<" ! -1 %"#(!-

2( * %>* "#%-%(D7<*%* 4 2,1 % *& *% ;

'1-%, 5 *(# !%* 1 9 "% " ) #2% ! B&#(2# %* %%## "%#2% # %* !1 %-%(#"2&) - !%%- " 5 - !% 2!& % %& D 9 "%& "%- %!! & #&-#( %*-#( 9 & &# % % ( % 2#%"#&2#>"# % ##!#*"# % &# & %" 1 & (# % "%* %2( 1 ! 1 & " 7 %!% "%, &1 & %! %!%&*"% * % (%,1 * *&* "%%2 % " **%# B& (

=- %1, ""## 0&%"& %(2 ""#(1 #- # ""# %2(*< ! * < !%&!9 %&!"#% -&&##(%( #2%&%( #(& 1% !&#" & (" "% 2#1 %*#( % #( (*" (

2 1 *# &#"%-2& %"%&- %&# %%&!%< !9 %%, 1% ""## 0& & 2 -%( ! ## % (%&

9 *"&!

.&!* - %% "2( %#&%%1## % ,2&" "%"% ""%# ""% - %% %"% #1 9 % ##!#(% %*( % 9 .&!* -

%% %&" #1 % ""#& 2 1 & (*% **% !#(

""## ! 2 2#!% * 2( &%'2# ## 3&#!%,4 2 %&%%1%% ! *%%*< * & %! %* !

# $%&'

()%* $+!', &) % # *& $-.

&) %