Main Pal And Others v. Commissioner Rohtak
! " # "
$%&'
$%&'
" "(() *
* !"#$%&'#
#& (# )*+
, - .
/0 .
12 5* 0
6* +
12 0
2
-
&
& ( / & 7 -
& + , -
. . .
0 2+ )895:
)895) ,);;) & .
(
-
,
,
/,
<
2
< 9
2 - ,
,
10& - / ,"
);86&-
-
<
. 0 -
. 0
, ,
2,
- .
/
-- 2/ & /0
(
-
,
,
/,
8
2
< ):
2 - ,
,
10& - / ,"
);86&-
-
8
. 0 -
. 0
, ,
2,
- .
/
-- 2/ &(
,-
, + )895: ,);;)
2
69);;)0/.
-
0
.
-- 2
- ,
<
9
2 , =/
(2"
, -
> ="0/ 2
,& ;?)*)<=
10 & - / ,"
);86
2 - ,
2
/
7 ,);@) 0);@8
,
?0
*
- 0
.
=
A"
56BB8=9=@5<BB) ):)))CB9B)
8))@ D
A" 27 )CBB9B)?C= @*56BB8?9=))*9?9=))*@?C=)9*5<BB)?9=))*):?@=:*))?@=:*
8))@
2 0
& D
.):B=
-
/
.
,
0
-
.
2
2
/ . 2 ,
2
, 2
' ( --
0/
- 2
- .
/ );@<>
20
2 ,
,
.
'
.
- ,2 -
/ '
-
- ,
.
2- /
/.
.
.
, 2
/
'
.
);@80/ 2- 0
-
/
2
0
"
- ,
/
,
-
- 0
/
.
0
0 &
0/
.
, 0
.
0
,
E -- , ,/ ,
- 0
- - &1 2345
((677((1-82951
);@:"$6<C+812 45+ 1:51
);@:"$))9 7154
((677((1-1:
);;8?)*"68; +5( 154+5+(;5
);98"$86 & ;?)*)<= ,
10& - / ,"
);86
.
= +( < =(9(6(: 9 2 > ?)*
.
2/
2- /
.,
2, .
0 -
F-
-
=
?*
, .
G ?*, /
/.
,,- - G ?*
- -
G ?* , ,.
,,- - -
-
-/
- /
- /.
G ?*
-
-/
,
?* 0
-/
,G
/
-/ 0
0
0 0
/, - G ?* , -
H0/
,
- 0
-/ 0 2- 0/
- ,
0/
.
?@6(> >
,- ?*
0
- -
/ ,
/ ,
0/
.
,
.
,
,
- ,
*
2 /-
,
D +(/< 181 127141: 111
< .
2/
2
-
/- /
. ,
0 2 , 01
,& ;=
?* .
2
/.
2
> ( 2 1 - .
,
, 0= ?5* , ) ,
, 0 ?6* ,
/
- -
2
- -E , --/ 2
,/
10 -/ )@@9 ,,
G ?* .
2
-
,
/.
2
& - (
21 - .
- 0
,,/0 2 , , 2 ,
,-
0 /
,-
,
2
.
-,
+
,
/
, 0= ?5* , ): ,
,
/
.
,
- -
G ?*?*,
, --
F- ,.
, 2
/.
2,
& - ( 21 - ,
,- ?0*
2- -
0/.
E
--
/0 -- - .
2
- /0
.
C:/ ,
D + & ;
- .
-0
/
0/ .
& )<=
- 0
0 ./
-
22
,
,& ;
E 2
.
2 2
/
2 2
,
0
0
/
1 ,- .
. -
2 2
,10& - / ,"
);86
0 ',
/E
2 2
,,
- 2
0
/
2 2.
,
,
I
.
,- 0
-
0 .
2
0/ -2
0
,
2
,
,
,
/.
.
0
0 ,
.
/ ,-
- '
.
2
.
2 ,
2
.
F
,,
7 , );@) 0);@8.
0
- -
0 &
&1 2 3 4 5 ((6 77((1- 829 51
);@:"$6<C
0/
2,
/
/.
,,- - >
,
-
0
.
= A/
/
0
- 0
2 . 2
2 ; ,
0/ 2
/ ;?*?*. - 2 +
,-
2 /
7 ,);C).,,-
/ , 2 0/ ;?*?* ,
2
.
,
/ .
2
-
0
2
./ ,2
2 F -
. 2
.
01
2 .
.
-
2 -
/2
2
-
/.
/ - .
0 2 '
0
,
- .
/
0
/
/ 22
2
2 0/
2
0 2
.
.
0/
&2 $2
!
-
2
- 0
, - 2
,
2
,
0/- ,
2
,
-/
2
/ ,
.
-
,-
.
/
2
.
/
2
2
-, 2 .
-
0- , ; ,
- 0- 0- ?*.
,,
- & ;?)* - ?*?*/0
= +(<=(9(6(: 92>?)* .
2 /
2- /
.,
2, .
0 -
F-
-
= ?*
, .
G ?*, /
/.
,,- - +
2
/
2
. - - - '
, -
/ 0
/,
,
/
, .
.
,,- - & - /
2
-
2
F- 2
2
/.
.
' 2 , -
, -
. /
. - , - 20/
2
- ,
/ F- ,,- F /
2
-
/ .
D '- ,!5;(15 754+ 82951
');8<10)C9>!
-
0
/
,
.
2
, 2
F-
2 ;0
-
2
0
/
0/- ,
2
2
2 0 2,
/
/.
,,- - + - -2
0 &
17 -
? * 0
= A@ -
,
0
2
- /
/ /
, -
.
/ 0
2
-
2 - 0 - ,
-
, ,
A.
,,- - D'
2
- /
,
-
.
.
- /0 - ,,,- - .
. ',
.
--
,
2
.
A,,- - D0 - 0
/
;
-
,
-
,
22
- ?* , ;?)* ,
-
-
- ,- -
.
/0
/ ,
0 - /.
/ F /
2
/ , ,
2
,
- ,
, /
- ,-
/
,
- -
0
/ -
.
-
- ,
2 .
0
; ,
,
/
2
.
'
-
01
22
/
- , ; 0
.
-
2
0 ,
.
2
'
-
,
/
2 /.
,,- -
, .2- = ?)*
,
/
?5*- ,
/
/
/
0 - /-
/.
/0
?6*,
/ 22,
2 .,,- - , -
- , , ;?)*?*D
,
.,
- , . ,
12 ,
);@:"$)99);;8?)*"68;
'- - -
. ,,- - ' ,
.
,
0
0 &
. 0
,- ,
-
2
0 '
0/ $ /:C5:)C ?
#& (#*
$%(#