High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/445/2004disposed of

Suraj Bhan And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2025-04-08Mr. Justice Gurvinder Singh Gill,Mr. Justice Jasjit Singh Bedi16 pages

!

"

#$%

& & '(

#) #$#*$+ , $(% -& &

% ./ & 0 1 0 // ./ & 0 0 0

! "

#

$

%%%%% 0 0 2

&

& ' #

#(

)*)+ ,- .,,-

'

/ # 0 & 1"

$#

.

&

02 ( '#

.3 .,,) & 4 ( '

#(

)*)+ ,- .,,- & #

#(

)) ,3 .,,- &

( ( #

.- #

02 *

.- .,,) 2 # # & (

# (

"

$#

( '

' $

$#

& 2 # # #

"

$#

(

5

$

$#

( 1

(

'

' #

!

' (

!

2# #(

1 #

#

#

4

(1 ( 26 (

'

' '

78 #

#

., ,,,4 9

' .*(

(

( ( ' (

(

1

.- .,,) #

9# ( ( # (' ' '" 9

(' 1

'

:

,,

;

9 5 11 1 / 9<(= (

# ; (

1 ( 9

5 (

/ <(=

(

(

;

;

#1 '

'

'

(

'

#

9#

'

'

#( 5#

'

'

'

&/ "

9 #

1 1'

#

'

'

1

1

(

#

6 '

( (02 '21 2# # #

( (>(

'

'

?

#

& '

( (>(

2# #

#

# '

@A &

# #

'

(

(

1

1

' # ((

(

'2# # 6 .+ .,,) 2# #

#

( '

'

1

'

#((

& '

1

4 # (

4# >(

# (; 9( ( &

&

(

#

#' & 05 '

(

#

(

' ( ., ,.

.,,.

2 '( "

(

9(" 5 # ( "

( ;

.

- 6 '

(

#

)-7 *,.)-8 *,:)-8

"

.3 ( &

# # ( 2 '

A #

#

>( ( )*

&#

(

4 ! ;9(<C)= .3 .,,)

(>(

'

'

#

4

!

"

#

$

% &

!

'

!

&

%

'

( ) * +

,

#

1

( # #

( D> ) ? D> . #

D> ! / <C.= >(

#

# .-.3 .,,)

#

'

# (' 1 (#

# ,) ,) .,,.

&

# ((D> 6 # # .-.3 .,,) ! <C*= >(

)) -,

(

((

D> "

6 .- .,,) ! 9

9(<C-= (

4# >(

# 4 -'

"

.

/

, 0

1&

$,

2

- 5D> !

"

'; 9(<C3=

D> D "

' (( E ( <C+=

D> 0 "

' 2 <C:=

D> $ 2 ( <C).=

(

#

., ,.

.,,.

21 <C)*=

(02D> .

9(<C7=' (

.- .,,) #

' '

# '

:

,, 5 11 1 9 <

1

(= ;

( (

(

5 # ; 1 9

( 2((

; #1 '

'

'

(

'

1 # '

; '

# '

'

9 #

'

#( 5 #

'

'

' 11 1 # ( (

; #1 '

<

C7= & 1 ' #

# ( ' 9'

748( #

# (

., ,,,4 9' ( ( .4*(

;

;

9 (1(

' 6

.- .,,)

' # 9 # ( (

(

., ,,,4 ( # ( (

( (' 1 1 "

( 4 C8 (

., ,,,4 ' ( 9

; # '

1

# ' '

'

(

'

#

" 9#

'

' #(4 5#

'

( '

# '

'

( #

'

C

'

# '11 1

; # ' 1C

( 2(!<C),= 11

1 .7 .,,) # (

(

;

" (<9= *) .,,) # (

1

(( 2# #<C))= &(

#

( D> # #

?

# #

# '

'

#

( (>(

(

#

'

(

(

(

(

+ C >(

*)* "

"

( &

( :

4

( 5

# ( (

9(" '

((

*)8" "

?

4

( 11 1

; F;

(F9 ( '

'"

/ # 0 & 1"

$#

#(

)*)+ ,- .,,- 4 ',

#) (3

++* "

)) $+

40 $( $+

5$

$ "

)'*6( #) 7'8, $( #) )5$

; " (

9 *,.*-2" 25 2(

(

) ,,,4 2,+(

11

1

; " <9= *,:*-2" 2,*

3,,4 2,*(

;

" ( 9 .3 ( 2,*

3,,4 2,*(

> 11 1 ' #

*,:*-2" & (

#(

)*)+ ,- .,,-

'

/ # 0 & 1"

$#

#'

"

! #

4

( 11 1 ; 9 '

"

)3 ,:

.,,3 )* ,3 .,,- .) ,8 .,,: .* ,7 .,,:

), & 4

(

( (

( ( # #

# #

#

(

1

'

' (" (F9 1 (; F;

( ;

'

;

'

' '

#

D> ) C47

9(

4>(

( (

B

" (F9 # '

? >

4>(

" 9

#

D> ) C4)!

;9(

4( (>(

>(

D> )

'

# 2

(

C74

9( C84

' #

11 1

(

' ' #' #

& (

'

(# #( ' '

4

# ' ? # ( #

( )) &

C47

9(

C48

(

'

& ( 6 '

'

&(

(

' ' #

'

'

& #

(

#

#

(

'

4

# '

D

(

# # #

# ( 1 (

(

'

'

'

' ' '

C

)* 0 ( (

9(<C7= <C8=

1 '

# ';

'

# '" 9

'

&

(

'

' # '

'

#

;

;

9 ( ' ' #

( ( # (

4'

;

9(<C7= & ((

(( (

# # ' (

0 '

*-2"

? (

(

?

(

((

(( &( ((

(( ( (

# (

., ,,,4 (" 9 & '

'

( # ((

1 '

#

; 9

((

1 ( # 1

'

1 ; ;

( 9 '

*,.*- 2"

)- & #

(

#

#

(

(

(

' #

' '

'

0

'

'

# (

( D

'

'

( 4 <C8= 4

9(<C7= )3 #

' (

A' ( "

4

'

2

4

'

0

,

"

2 &

"

5

"

,

"

5

2

$

8 9

,

6,':

+))

!#;

:

<

$ = > * 4 33#6 ;

::

6 ;

#%+ ?

33#6;

, 3( ;

?

@336 ;

%3%A

)+ &

(

( ( '' B

C74

9(

C84 #

(

1

C74

9(

):

&

#

C8

( 9 (

., ,,,4'

78(

C (

( '

.*(

' C # (

( (1 (

( 1

& (

'

)7

*,:*-2"

11 1 #

'

( ; #1 '

<C7= D

9

( # ((

' # 0 ! / <C.=

>(

.-.3 .,,)'

) *, (

'

# (

C-4! 9

9( # #

# & '

; " 9

*,:*-2

'

)8

' 11 1

( # #

9(<C7= ; #1 '

'

'#

1

1 # #

&

( ; 9 ' '

'

*,:*-2"

11 1

? ?

., &

(

'

# ;

" 9 .3 ( ;

# 1 D> - 9#

D> * ( 2 ( ! <C),=

?

& ; ( 9

# ((

.3 ( .) 2 (

#

#

4

) * - ( ; F;

(F9

(

'

(

# (

(

&

' /

(

#

., &

#

#

1 0 //

0 0

-& &

1 C 1 #

G ;

C ' G ;