← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1073/2009disposed of

Baljinder Singh v. State Of Haryana

2015-02-10Bench- 4,Registrar-Judicial9 pages

  

      

   

    



     

     



      

     

 ! "! #$%& ' (!)*$+%, " -*"! %.(! %.& )!/  )   0

1  





0

  

 

 



0     

   





0

  !

 

22$) %3+#.(% ".(&! $),3(%3(%322$) %1$+% - 13$"! '*! ".(+34*5% 2 3) %3), (13$"67*!.532 %! !".3+ , 5*" ! !".3+ *$"!$(% " 2!.*(89:8

 22$) %1$+% - 13$"43)32;$.!! %*5! 23"& $(% " 2!.*(8:89

22$) % 3+#.(% ".(&4*43)2*(<.2! %$(% " 2!.*(8 3)23++ (& % ! #$%& ' (!*52*(<.2!.*(3(%) (! (2 -3)) %,7! !".3+ *$"!



  3".(% "  3+ .(&  43)  !  $(2+  *5  !  % 2 3) % 3), (13$"6 7*!.

 ) ! ! +34 .('*!.*( ,7+*%&.(& ! 5.")! .(5*"'3!.*(  " -*"!  3++ &.(&  !3!  322$) %  3+#.(% "  .(&  4*  '3"". % 3), (13$"67*!.*(  -" ))$".= % "!*,".(&'*( 75"*'

 "-3" (!) ,*$!).>'*(!)-".*"!*! *22$"" (2 322$) %3+#.(% "

 .(&&3< , 3!.(&)!*.)4.5 % 2 3) %3), (13$"67*!.3)3" )$+! *54.2) + 5!5*" "-3" (!)?*$) 3!+43"  322$) %-"*2 % %!* +43"3(%, 3!.)4.5  53! "*5! % 2 3) %+*%& %32*'-+3.(! 4.!03.+303(%3++43"

  " 35! "3), (13$"67*!.43)) (!

,32@!* "'3!".'*(.3+*$) *(! 3))$"3(2 *5! 53! "*5322$) % 3+#.(% ".(& $!322$) %3+#.(% ".(&4 (!*(, 3!.(&.)4.5  (   A " 2 .< %323++5"*'! ( .&,*$"!3!3), (13$"6 7*!.3%%. % 

B"

3' )1$'3"3+*(&4.!"

.( ! $-!32*(%$2! % -*)!'*"! ' >3'.(3!.*(*(! % 3%,*%7*53), (13$"*(  A3!

 (**(3(%5*$(%!3!! " 43)3+.&3!$" '3"@*52')> 2')!*  2'),"*3%.(+ (&!)!3"!.(&5"*'2')5"*'".&!).% *5'.%+.( 3(%  2'), .(%2.( >! (%.(&!*43"%)+ 5!).% *5! ( 2@  (%.)) 2!.*(  5*$(%! $(% "+7.(&!.))$ 43)-3+ 3(%&+.)! (.(&  " 43)(*'3"@ *53(7*! " >! "(3+.(#$"7*(! - ")*(*(! % 3%,*%7 (.)*-.(.*( 3), (13$"%. %%$ !*3)-7>.3*(322*$(!*53(&.(&4.243)3(! '*"! '.((3!$" 3(%)$55.2. (!!*23$) % 3!.(! (*"'3+2*$") *5+.5

(.)2"*)) >3'.(3!.*( 43)% 5.(.! !3!.!43)(*!323) *5% 3!,7 )!"3(&$+3!.*(,$!.!43)323) *5% 3!,73(&.(&

C  "

3)3(!  3+  ."*.43+  3+*(&4.!  "

3+.43+ 2*(%$2! %" -*)!'*"! ' >3'.(3!.*(.(! 35! "'3!*5! 2*'-+3.(! +*%& %,7! 2*'-+3.(3(!*(  A*(! % 3%,*%7*53), (13$"

67*!.3(%5*$(%! 5*++*4.(& >! "(3+3(%.(! "(3+.(#$". ) D 

                

8      

     

        

              

  

  

   !



  " 

        

 #      

                  $         

 

    

    #  

      %      #

 

  

  

     #       

 

    

  

        & '



  

         

 

      (  &%    



 

 

   

 ) '



 *  (% 

        

 %  

       

     +  

   

 

 





 ( '



 (  % 

   

    

  

 ,  - 

 

   

E $ 

  #  

    

 

        .    

          #  

   





   

 / ) #   

   #   

           #    

9    0         #             

      1                     

      #        %"  2 



 

     3 

   #

          



 # 

          

       4                        -     

      #             2

 

    



     





E 

)- "! *-.(.*(*5 C"

3)3(!3+."*.43+3), ( 13$"3%%. %%$ !*2*()!".2! %5*"2 3"*$(%! ( 2@,7! +.&3!$" 4.243)3(! '*"! '3(%" 2 (!.(%$"3!.*( ++! .(#$". )3+)*4 "

3(! '*"! '3(%" 2 (!.(%$"3!.*( 

3&#.!.(&4*43)! ( .&,*$"*5322$) %3+#.(% " .(&% -*) %!3!*(! 53! 5$+%37 5*$(%)*' *( @(*2@.(&3!! %**")*53+#.(% ".(&3!3,*$! 3 '

 2 3) %3), (13$"43) .().% ! "**'

 *-+ 4 " 23++.(& "*$!

 " 35! ")*' ,*%7,"*@ ! +3!2@ 7*(! .(( ").% *5! %**"4.!3,".2@,3!3(%*- ( %! *$)  3+*(&4.!*! "- ")*()2*++ 2! %*< "! " 4.!( )) %3), ( 13$"67*!.3(&.(&5"*'2 .+.(&53(4.!%$--3!!3 

 3"3(#.!.(&43)! ,"*! "*5! % 2 3) %  

 3+)*)-*@ 3,*$!! 2"$ +!" 3!' (!' ! %*$!!*.)).)! "3!! 3(%)*5 ! 322$) %3+#.(% ".(&  )! 322$) %$) % !*&.< , 3!.(&)!* 3), (13$"67*!..)53! "3(%).)! "2*'-+3.( %!*03.+303(%3+ +43" 3)% -*) %

A(#$3"'343)!  *$() +*" *' ( *$() ++.(& 3(%  "*! 2!.*(  (!"  #' "

   )-*@  3,*$!  !  2*'-+3.(!  >

" 2 .< %5"*'3), (13$"3&3.()! "$),3(%3+#.(% ".(& 3+#.(% "

.(&%.%(*!!$"($-5*" (;$."7.()-.! *5! (*!.2 ) 3)% -*) % > 4*$+%%.)2+*) !3!3), (13$"43)$(% "!" ' (%*$)-" ))$" *( 322*$(!*5! , 3!.(&)&.< (,7! 322$) %  3--"  (% %%3(& "!*  "+.5 ) "$),3(%43)3(3(&"72"$ +3(%;$3"" +)*' - ")*( '37 < (@.++ ") 3%3++ & %

(! )!3! ' (!$(% " 2!.*(88 "

322$) %3+#.(% "

.(&2*(! (% %!3! 43).((*2 (!3(%353+) 23) 43)5*.)! %*(.'  +.< %3+*(&4.!.)4.5 3(%2.+%" (*(! 5.")!5+**"*5! *$)  .(&.&+7) ().!.< 3), (13$"5 +!% -" )) %3)) 43)(*!,+ )) % 4.!3(7)*(4 " 3)) 43),+ )) %*(+74.!!4*%3$&! ")   "

-3" (!)&*! "!" 3! %5*"% -" )).*(3!+43"



 !".3+ *$"!3<.(&3%< "! %!*!  <.% (2 *(" 2*"% 2*) !*2*(<.2!322$) %3+#.% ".(&$(% " 2!.*(8



0"

13(43+#.!.(&+ 3"( %) (.*"2*$() +3-- 3".(&5*"! 3-- ++3(!4*$+%<  ' (!+7)$,'.!!3!! " 3" !4*) +52*(!"3%.2!*"7 ' %.23+*-.(.*()*(5.+ G*( " -*"!4*$+%%.)2+*) !3!.!43)323) *5 3(&.(&  4.+  !  *! "  " -*"!  4*$+%  %.)2+*)  !3!  .!  43)  3  23)  *5 )!"3(&$+3!.*(!*% 3!

  " -*"!4.2.), ( 5.2.3+!*! 322$) %.(

B )$22."2$')!3(2 )4.++3< !*, 2*().% " %,7!  *$"!

 5 "".(&!* !  <.% (2 *5 3(%  4*$+%)$,'.!!3!! % 2 3) %43) $(% "% -" )).*(3(%43)!3@.(&!" 3!' (!

 5 "".(&!*!  <.% (2 *5 3&#.!.(& 4*$+%)$,'.!!3!! 3-- ++3(!+.< %4.!.)4.5 3--.+7 23) *5)$.2.% 43)-*"!"37 %3)323) *5)!"3(&$+3!.*(!*% 3!  " 5*" .!.).))$,'.)).*(!3!! 322$) %.) (!.!+ %!*32;$.!!3+



 3"( %    5*"  !  !3!  *5  3"73(3  4*$+%  <  ' (!+7 )$,'.!!3!!  <.% (2 *5 C"

3)3(!3+."*.43+4*$+%&*!* )!3,+.)!3!.!43)323) *5)!"3(&$+3!.*(  5 "".(&!*!  <.% (2 *5 3(% .(! ,32@&"*$(%*5> '3"@ %!"*$& A(#$ ) 4*$+%)$,'.!!3!! 322$) %4*43)3(3(&"7'3($) %!*, 3!.) 4.5 3), (13$"

 ." <.% (2 4*$+%)$--*"!! ' %.23+ <.% (2 !3! ! <.2!.'43))!"3(&$+3! %!*% 3!

 " 5*" ! !".3+ *$"!3)".&!+7 2*(<.2! %! 322$) %$(% " 2!.*(8 ) )$,'.!! %5$"! "

8

 5*" < "  !3@.(&  $-  !  %.3' !".23++7  *--*).!  ' %.23+ *-.(.*() >-" )) %,7 B"

3' )1$'3"3(%  C"

3)3(!3+ ."*.43+.(! ."" )- 2!.< -*)!'*"! '" -*"!)+ !$)5.")!% 3+4.!! <.% (2  *5     3&#.!  .(&  4.2  !"*4)  )*'  +.&!  *(  !  532! ).!$3!.*(   43)3( .&,*$"!*322$) %3+#.(% ".(&   5*$(% )*' - *-+ @(*2@.(&3!! %**"*5322$) %3+#.(% ".(&   *-+ )!3"! %23++.(&*$!3), (13$"4*43).().% ! *$) )! " 43)(* -*).!.< " )-*() 5"*'.().% ! *$) )*' *( '3(3& %!**- (! %**" ,7," 3@.(&! +3!2@ 7*(! .(( ").% 4.!3,".2@,3!  " 35! "3++ *5! ' (! " %.(!*! *$) 3(%5*$(%3), (13$"67*!.3(&.(& 5"*'32 .+.(&53(4.!%$--3!3

A 9

!.)!*, (*! %!3!! 3,*< < ").*(*5 !3!3), ( 13$"43)5*$(%3(&.(&5"*'32 .+.(&53(4.!3%$--3!343)(*!3!3++ 23++ (& %,7! -"*) 2$!.*( 3+)*(*! ! )!3(%*5! -"*) 2$!.*( !3!.!43)323) *5)!"3(&$+3!.*(!*% 3!

 (*! "4*"%).!.)(*!!

< ").*(*5! -"*) 2$!.*(!3!3), (13$"43)5.")!)!"3(&$+3! %!*% 3! 3(%! " 35! ") 43)3(& %5"*'! 2 .+.(&53(4.!3%$--3!3



!.)3+)*< "7'$2.'-*"!3(!!*" 5 "!*!  <.% (2 *5 B ()- 2!*"03%3(3+4*3%'.!! %!3!3,".2@> B3(%3**@> A 4 " " 2*< " %5"*'! )2 ( *5! 2".'

 3,*<  <.% (2 4*$+% 23! &*".23++7%.)2+*) !3!! 322$) %43)(*!.().% ! *$) 4 " 3) <.2!.' 3), (  13$"  3<.(&  +*2@ %  !  *$)  5"*' .().%  43)  5*$(% 3(&.(&  5"*'  3  2 .+.(&  53(  4.!  3 %$--3!3    3,*<  $(3))3.+3,+ ! )!.'*(73%%$2 %*(! ).% *5! -"*) 2$!.*(&* )!*5*"!.57! *-.(.*( >-" )) %,7 B"

3' )1$'3"

B

C3%(*! %%*4(2 "!3.(.(#$". )*(! - ")*(*5! % 2 3) % *) .(#$". )'.&!3< , (&.< (,7! 322$) %3+#.(% " .(&*"! )3' '.&!3< , ()$)!3.( %,7! <.2!.'.(! -"*2 ))*5 %"*--.(&! % 3%,*%75"*'! 2 .+.(&53(  C3)2*' !*32*(2+$).*( !3!.!43)323) *5)!"3(&$+3!.*(,73(%*(+7,3) %*(! +.&3!$" '3"@ 5*$(%!"3()< ") +7*< "! ( 2@ < (.(323) *53(&.(&+.&3!$" '3"@ "$((.(&!"3()< ") +723((*!, 2*'-+ ! +7"$+ %*$! $"! ".(323) *5 )!"3(&$+3!.*((3.+.'-" )).*(4*$+%, 5*$(%( 3"! ( 2@3)! <.2!.' 4*$+%3< )!"$&&+ %!*4".&&+ *$!*5! '3($3+)!"3(&$+3!.*(  4*$+%23! &*".23++73%'.!!3!! " 43)(*5.(%.(&&.< (,7.'!3!! " 43)3(75.(& ".'-" )).*(( 3"! ( 2@ >2 -!! +.&3!$" '3"@3(%3

F 2*(!$).*(, +*4! 2.(

A

(<. 4*5! 3,*< 4 3< (* ).!3!.*(!*2*' !*3 2*(2+$).*(  ,3) %  *(  !  <.% (2  *5   B  "

3' )  1$'3"  .(  !

,32@&"*$(%*52*""*,*"3!.<  <.% (2 *5 3&#.!.(&!3!.!43)3

23) *5)$.2.% ,73(&.(&

F

  *$"!4.++3< !*5.(%*$!4 ! "! " 43)3(73, !' (! *(! ).% *5322$) %3+#.(% ".(&%".<.(&! <.2!.'!*2*''.!)$.2.% ,73(&.(&   <.% (2 *5 3(% ! $(2+ 3(%,"*! "*5!

% 2 3) %4*$+%&*!* )!3,+.)!3!322$) %3+#.(% ".(&3%!" 3! %.) 4.5 2"$ ++7  %*2$' (!3"7 <.% (2 >  >.,.! %!"*$& A (#$4*$+%&*!* )!3,+.)!3!! <.2!.'3,*$!B'*(!)-".*"!*! *22$"" (2   +*%& %  3  2*'-+3.(!  !*  !  55.2 "  (23"&  *5  *' (

*$() ++.(&3(%"*! 2!.*( (!" +43"3++ &.(&!3! "$),3(%$) %!* , 3! ".(2+*) %"**'

 43)+ 3%.(&! +.5 4.!&" 3!3"%).-  3--"  (% %%3(& "!* "+.5 3!! 3(%)*5322$) %3+#.(% ".(&4* 43)3(3(&"72"$ +3(%;$3"" +)*' - ")*(

C

  <.% (2  *5     3(%     2*""*,*"3! %  ,7  !

%*2$' (!3"7 <.% (2 > 23((*!, .&(*" %,7!  *$"!

 3,*< <.% (2 4*$+% )!3,+.)4.!*$!3(7-3+ *5%*$,!!3!! 322$) %3% .(532!, 3! (.)4.5 ' "2.+ ))+73(%3, !! % "!*2*''.!)$.2.%



52*$")  < (3)- "! *4(< ").*(*5! <.2!.') 43) $(% "  % -" )).*(  *(  322*$(!  *5  !  %"$&)  3%'.(.)! " %  !*   "  ,7   " $),3(% (*$"<. 4! " .)(* <.% (2 !*)*4!3!! % -" )).*(43) ! 23$) 5*"! )$.2.% 2*''.!! %,7! <.2!.' < (*! "4.) 322$) % 3+#.(% ".(&43)! "**!23$) 5*"! % -" )).*( (2*$(! " %,7!

C <.2!.'

 " 5*"  4  3< (*  ).!3!.*( !*  *+% ,3) %  *(  !  3,*< <.% (2 *(" 2*"%!3!! -"*) 2$!.*(3) )!3,+.) %, 7*(%" 3)*(3,+ %*$,!!3!322$) %3+#.(% ".(&3, !! %.)4.5 3), (13$"!*2*''.! )$.2.%



 2*'-+3.(3(!3%3+)*5.+ %3(355.%3<.!!*!  55 2!!3! 322$) %3%!3@ (23" *52.+%" (+ 5!, .(%,7! % 2 3) %  (*! "

4*"%)  !  2*'-+3.(3(!  3%  )!"$2@  3  2*'-"*'.)  4.!  !  322$) %  " 5*" .(*$"<. 4'.(.'$') (! (2 5*"! *55 (2 $(% " 2!.*(8B  4*$+%' !!  (%)*5#$)!.2 

(<. 4*5! 3,*< ! #$%&' (!*52*(<.2!.*(3(%) (! (2 -3)) %,7! !".3+ *$"!3)3&3.()!! 322$) %3-- ++3(!$(% " 2!.*(8 *5! (%.3( (3+ *% )!3(%)) !3).% ()! 3% .)2*(<.2! %$(% "

 2!.*(8B*5! (%.3( (3+ *% 3(%) (! (2 %!*7 3")F'*(!) 3(%%37)4.2.)! - ".*%3+" 3%7$(% "&*( ,7.'  5.( 3(%!

% 53$+!) (! (2 .'-*) %5*"! *55 (2 $(% " 2!.*(8*5! (%.3(  (3+ *% ,7! !".3+ *$"!.)'3.(!3.( %5*"! *55 (2 $(% " 2!.*( 8B $(% "4.2! 3-- ++3(!3), (2*(<.2! %,7!.) *$"!

 .!

! 3,*< '*%.5.23!.*(.(! '3!! "*52*(<.2!.*(3(%) (! (2 ! 3-- 3+ .)-3"!+73++*4 %  (-37' (!*55.( ! 322$) %, " + 3) %5*"!4.!.5 .)2$)!*%7.)(*!" ;$." %.(2*(( 2!.*(4.!3(7*! "23)

 "  #

   ,"$3"7 "   # $+3!.