← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/6731/2017allowed

Sharwan Kumar v. Yash Pal Pahwa And ANR

2018-09-20Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan10 pages



 

    

  !" "#$%$&'

(

)  

    

    '*+ ,---

        

!

  "#    

!  $ %&

-- .

' !  

 (          )* &)%+     ",      -  .    ",        !   ' / "

  0 &) )))'



!

)% )1 &))2 3    (   )4 )2 &)%+ .

    , . 

 (        !

   ",       (    

!  

5 !  !       '    !        %6! 7 8"9"     : !  !

 ;  <=&4 %) &)%1

>(

 ! !   '  "

"



. # 3! ,$ &%1'%

 7?@ 5$(-> .  

( !,

! "! 

, !  $ %$

 ?   

   :  =     , ! ! %A 1))'

!

)% )A &))4!  ("  ! ,"       $  &2 &))4           

 "

     "



     (

   "

   0 %)C! 

,)6,  -   "

!!     , &))20 &) *1)'  "  !   >(,

            !     0   &) *1)'  !  )% )1 &))2   6% &)%%  0 && 4%1'! )% )A &)%%6% &)%*0  &* +1+'! )% )A &)%*

      

      ",  !(      

      !  (       , "8   "



  "

  (  &)%1  >( "

!!

  !

  ?      /   ! ! , &)%4 !  ! "  

     ?        ! 

   -           )* &)%+               0   &) )))'       

!

)% )1 &))2    )% &)%+                      &* %1 6))'    (         !

 * +4 6))' ! %)))'

((

  (          )* &)%+

 !  "

!    , .        )4 )2 &)%+

  , 

  !



   

   !    ,   (  "

!   - &2 )2 &)%+ !(  ", - 5  !-          

     

 

 

 ! 

 "     

#  $          $ 

%&   #   "$'(

  )

   *(

+

 +!  !  "  

       

 #

 ,  !#    "!



 (* 

    

#!



-!

 # 

 ./ $ 

  +0! &

   "   

!        

    $ #  "  

  $ ! 1

    $  !$!



 2   $ $  $   !$  #  -!'"  #  

       $!

           3# '4"

$ 



/ ! 



  ! $  $ # -! ,             $   $     

 $ #+!  

     # $       

 +!!

 '  4 

    

 $

 

#  !"$'( !



     5$#$ 6 ,# "  #  $

%&  #   "$('  # $ #!  

 #    4  $!    "2 #$ #   

$  

 !

7 ?  

               !      "#         (  $ %&' ?          !   -     (    - )* &)%+ (       0   &) )))'       !            

 "

(     ,"  

!

 )% )1 &))2   /  

 !-    !



8  

7B   !     %6  !       !        

   ! .8$  &  + 

$

 !      

 

       $ #0!$  

$ 

$ ###$ +  "   " $   $  # $  0        "        $  

      !

!

  $       #   ! 3.$8

!- 9      +((

 ! :!  # +

  " 2   

     

 $    

$,$

 

   $          

   !$ " !

      

 $;

  

     !#  $!   

 "$$   $ 0 $#$0   #$ " 

   

 $  !  #

 $ #  0  $

"     $  "          <   $ $  $

   $ -# $ !      

$      0    !# !

 " $

   

       

      

# !

    "# $ 

 ========= 4   

  #   # 2                !   

      

  $   !   

 $  

  

 $   

 # 2       -  

  <

    

 #  

    #  $  !   

     

$!   

 #  0 !# 

0 #     7 ? 

2   1 "

      >   ?

 #

,!

 

          

 *  

-  B    ! %6:&=:=     %6:&=:=!    "(  -  >  

!:=  !  :=     :=  !

  / !,",,!           ,   ;!  ! (<!  (!  !; 

< ", - !,  / 

!  

E !  !   ,   /  !

  ! @

!  >   

/ ,  ", - !!,8  (                 !         (  !    (   

(" > !  !   

!  

   !     (           ,     ,! 

      !

 (  )* &)%+ (     !(   ,  ! 

 = ?  

      ((   "  ! ,"         

, !#( ,.  !      ,( 9 # 3!

 

,  " (        !    ' 

,   ((  

"     

, !',

, ?      

 !"           !     !       - !  "  !  

"

  (   B  &: , =    ("

    ! (! 

 " (     (  "            "   "

"



  "

   &))2     

 !1+,  

 , ('  ! !  ?   "

  (     "

!  !                 

  !

  (    

 "

  (      '      ( 

B!  ( B   , !!(

   , &)%1 ( !

,

!  !!

! , &))2

"=?      

)  ! ( !   '",,!

" >('>(

      !

  ' "

       

>(  8      

( (       )1 %) &)%1 -  (

   . 

D           )1 %) &)%1       !(  +    $         $ #  



$$$ # !$   

"  !$  

  $ 

    $     $!       $ #  2    $    $      #     #  

0 $ 7   D

        !   ",       &4 %) &)%1

,)6

>! (!        

  ("    "      ", !(!  8  ",>(    !   ( "

(  ! 

-   !            .

(                     ,   ( &)%1

D     "

"(! "   ( "

( ! 

( ,   &))2      3  !(    "

      

     

   "

    @

      !     (  )* &)%+!  - ,    "

  0 &) )))'   " ",   ! 0 &) )))'   ! ! )A, "

! D   "

      

 

 ,          

, 

    D     , !! (  ! -  

>   

?     !       "

   (    

 !    !

  "

  -  , 

D     0 &) )))'       ! ! ! !  )% )1 &))2)% )2 &)%1  

 - "

   ,

  (              !  )% )2 &)%1  @      0 &) )))'

 "8 ! 

 

     - .  

  ! '  

B  ,,  !    !)A ! ,

3   !  "   

 

"

(

!  



   ! 

(

) --

  F  >('    F  "